Gerber Crucial SC review
-
@Yadda said:
The pliers are the most disappointing and distressing part of this tool.Without a doubt, they don't inspire any sort of confidence. In the shootout I did, they did manage to get the job done though. But due to the fact that they can be had at 10 bucks now, if you break it you won't be too concerned
-
Nice review mate.

-
Nice one Higgins

I think you've highlighted the failings of this tool quite well, and congratulations of finding a few plus points too :D I only have a Ltd Ed Crucial with corkscrew and bottle opener (instead of the strap cutter) which is a bit different, but it still suffers everything you mentioned with the unnecessary bulk and puny pliers. It's hard for this to fall into a mimimalist tool catergory when it's as bulky as other tools which carry more capability. Unlike you, I really don't like the ergonomics either, but then I tend to feel this way about everything that has assymetrical handles.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Nice one Higgins
I think you've highlighted the failings of this tool quite well, and congratulations of finding a few plus points too :D I only have a Ltd Ed Crucial with corkscrew and bottle opener (instead of the strap cutter) which is a bit different, but it still suffers everything you mentioned with the unnecessary bulk and puny pliers. It's hard for this to fall into a mimimalist tool catergory when it's as bulky as other tools which carry more capability. Unlike you, I really don't like the ergonomics either, but then I tend to feel this way about everything that has assymetrical handles.
Don't mistake that for liking, I was trying hard to be unbiased and said it wasn't too bad if you hold it the right way
. That right there is a problem in itself, you shouldn't have to think twice about how you hold the thing.It's an okay tool with no market. Too big to be minimalist, too minimal to compete with full sized, too half-smurfed to really draw any attention. One that will likely just drift into the pages of MT history as some footnote somewhere

Thank you for the response too, I like writing reviews if it'll get people talking :D
-
Nice review. I have a crucial fast (red) on the way and hope to give a similar review. How is the tool's weight?
-
@Higgins617 said:
It's an okay tool with no market. Too big to be minimalist, too minimal to compete with full sized, too half-smurfed to really draw any attention. One that will likely just drift into the pages of MT history as some footnote somewhere
That is a damn fine summary for the Crucial

-
It says 5 oz, but if you're anything like me that's merely just a number. It's light, but not impressively so. You won't really forget that it's there, but it is the same weight as the skeletool, which I can assume was the intended competition.
-
@50ft-trad said:
It's an okay tool with no market. Too big to be minimalist, too minimal to compete with full sized, too half-smurfed to really draw any attention. One that will likely just drift into the pages of MT history as some footnote somewhere

That is a damn fine summary for the Crucial

I crack myself up :D
-
Nice review of a tool that leaves you wanting for more, unfortunately.
So it's really a $30 strap cutter, although a decent one?

Keep it up, looking forward to more of your reviews

-
@babola said:
Nice review of a tool that leaves you wanting for more, unfortunately.So it's really a $30 strap cutter, although a decent one?

Keep it up, looking forward to more of your reviews

Ahhh but wait! If you act right now I hear it can be all yours for a mere 10 bucks!!! For around that price it's not the worst thing you could pick up. But for 30? You'd use that money better if you tossed it out the window.
I appreciate the complement. I've been trying to only do tools that no everyone has, because what's the point of me reviewing the Sidekick when umpteen people already have and just about everyone has their minds made up about it.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
