Buck X-Tract 730 Realtree
-
I have 2 X-tracts, can't remember the model numbers. But I do remember when I got the first one. On taking it out of the bland generic white box, then seeing "China" stamped on the blade and then seeing the awful lateral movement on the blade I scoffed at my own stupidity for buying it. I sat down and began to type a review (Amazon) it was while I was doing this that I noticed the torx head screws - fearing I had absolutely nothing to lose I tightened them up and at the same time applied some thin oil (sewing machine oil) I couldn't believe the transformation. The tool suddenly became completely OHO on ALL tools, the lateral movement was gone - not even the slightest trace remained.
Needless to say I didn't leave the bad review, instead came away thinking it was actually a very useful OHO MT, quite possibly the only true OHO MT out there.
-
@tosh said:
I have 2 X-tracts, can't remember the model numbers. But I do remember when I got the first one. On taking it out of the bland generic white box, then seeing "China" stamped on the blade and then seeing the awful lateral movement on the blade I scoffed at my own stupidity for buying it. I sat down and began to type a review (Amazon) it was while I was doing this that I noticed the torx head screws - fearing I had absolutely nothing to lose I tightened them up and at the same time applied some thin oil (sewing machine oil) I couldn't believe the transformation. The tool suddenly became completely OHO on ALL tools, the lateral movement was gone - not even the slightest trace remained.Needless to say I didn't leave the bad review, instead came away thinking it was actually a very useful OHO MT, quite possibly the only true OHO MT out there.
They are a pretty good indication that China doesn't mean bad quality in all cases. I'm glad you gave it a chance, sort of a shame it came that loose though.
-
@tosh said:
I have 2 X-tracts, can't remember the model numbers. But I do remember when I got the first one. On taking it out of the bland generic white box, then seeing "China" stamped on the blade and then seeing the awful lateral movement on the blade I scoffed at my own stupidity for buying it. I sat down and began to type a review (Amazon) it was while I was doing this that I noticed the torx head screws - fearing I had absolutely nothing to lose I tightened them up and at the same time applied some thin oil (sewing machine oil) I couldn't believe the transformation. The tool suddenly became completely OHO on ALL tools, the lateral movement was gone - not even the slightest trace remained.Needless to say I didn't leave the bad review, instead came away thinking it was actually a very useful OHO MT, quite possibly the only true OHO MT out there.
There are counterfeit X-Tracts all over the internet. After Buck discontinued the X-Tract China has continued manufacturing them. It sounds like if it was in a white box it most likely was not sold trough Buck.
-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I have 2 X-tracts, can't remember the model numbers. But I do remember when I got the first one. On taking it out of the bland generic white box, then seeing "China" stamped on the blade and then seeing the awful lateral movement on the blade I scoffed at my own stupidity for buying it. I sat down and began to type a review (Amazon) it was while I was doing this that I noticed the torx head screws - fearing I had absolutely nothing to lose I tightened them up and at the same time applied some thin oil (sewing machine oil) I couldn't believe the transformation. The tool suddenly became completely OHO on ALL tools, the lateral movement was gone - not even the slightest trace remained.
Needless to say I didn't leave the bad review, instead came away thinking it was actually a very useful OHO MT, quite possibly the only true OHO MT out there.
There are counterfeit X-Tracts all over the internet. After Buck discontinued the X-Tract China has continued manufacturing them. It sounds like if it was in a white box it most likely was not sold trough Buck.
Interestin' As I assumed ALL X-Tracts had been built in China. If it's a counterfeit then it's a very good one. I have 2 X-Tracts although different models the build quality is identical - so I'm guessing either they're both counterfeit or originals.
Maybe you could give me a link to yours so I can compare.
-

-
They're not exactly counterfeits ... they are the original tools ... it's just that they are unofficial. As Longbow pointed out, what appears to have happened is that Buck contracted production from overseas, but even after the contract ceased, the production continued. Instead of these tools being sold through the correct channels and Buck getting their mark up etc, these tools are now readily available to the end user without proper packaging or warranty, but at what appears to be the original quality level, and at much lower prices.
They are still naughty in as much as they are not official tools and should not be bearing the Buck company details, if indeed produced at all. They do however appear to be identical to the original/oficial tool rather than a cheap replica
-
Great write up!
I too have one of those, and since someone threw out this "original/counterfeit" issue, i would really like to know which one is mine! -
-
-
Mine came in a Buck yellow box, so I assume mine is an original. If not, oh well, doesn't bother me really as it's good quality (other than those pliers of course ;)).
Good quality?
You plan to stick with that story?
Yes I do
I'm not experienced with folders and how they all compare in quality, so take that for what it is. The thing seems quality to me with the exception of the pliers as I mentioned. Sure, I would expect some brand name folder to be higher quality, especially if I paid $50-$100 or more for it, but none of them offer any functionality other than the blade itself. -
-
-
@50ft-trad said:
They're not exactly counterfeits ... they are the original tools ... it's just that they are unofficial. As Longbow pointed out, what appears to have happened is that Buck contracted production from overseas, but even after the contract ceased, the production continued. Instead of these tools being sold through the correct channels and Buck getting their mark up etc, these tools are now readily available to the end user without proper packaging or warranty, but at what appears to be the original quality level, and at much lower prices.They are still naughty in as much as they are not official tools and should not be bearing the Buck company details, if indeed produced at all. They do however appear to be identical to the original/oficial tool rather than a cheap replica
Very good explanation. As stated the X-Tract has always been produced in China. I do not have one produced after Buck discontinued them. I would be curious to compare quality. I would just be cautious of any sold directly from China.
-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I would be curious to compare quality.There both junk.

-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I would be curious to compare quality.
There both junk.

Come on, no love for Buck?
-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I would be curious to compare quality.
There both junk.

Come on, no love for Buck?
Meh just busting chops mostly.
Seems like a big tool for what you get is prolly my only real issue with it. Well that and the lame pliers.
-
@THE_LONGBOW said:
I would be curious to compare quality.
There both junk.

Come on, no love for Buck?
Meh just busting chops mostly.
Seems like a big tool for what you get is prolly my only real issue with it. Well that and the lame pliers.
Ditch the pliers and I'd actually like it more! It's not annoyingly large, not small either though. Quality isn't lacking though, even the plier head seems pretty damn well made, just the handle is too small. I'd trust this plier head more than the one on the Crucial
-
[quote author=THE_LONGBOW link=topic=56926.msg1023359#msg1023359 date=1421085633]
I would be curious to compare quality.There both junk.

Come on, no love for Buck?
Meh just busting chops mostly.
Seems like a big tool for what you get is prolly my only real issue with it. Well that and the lame pliers.
Ditch the pliers and I'd actually like it more! It's not annoyingly large, not small either though. Quality isn't lacking though, even the plier head seems pretty damn well made, just the handle is too small. I'd trust this plier head more than the one on the Crucial
[/quote]The Crucial is now the standard we use for pliers?
I would trust the pliers more then using a rock also.

From all the pics I have seen it seems like it is well made.
-
[quote author=HarleyXJGuy link=topic=56926.msg1023558#msg1023558 date=1421115321]
[quote author=THE_LONGBOW link=topic=56926.msg1023359#msg1023359 date=1421085633]
I would be curious to compare quality.There both junk.

Come on, no love for Buck?
Meh just busting chops mostly.
Seems like a big tool for what you get is prolly my only real issue with it. Well that and the lame pliers.
Ditch the pliers and I'd actually like it more! It's not annoyingly large, not small either though. Quality isn't lacking though, even the plier head seems pretty damn well made, just the handle is too small. I'd trust this plier head more than the one on the Crucial
[/quote]The Crucial is now the standard we use for pliers?
I would trust the pliers more then using a rock also.

From all the pics I have seen it seems like it is well made.
[/quote]Anyone ever call you a punka**? Just saying they aren't the weakest plierhead I've come across, and I'm not sure what sort of rocks you found in the sandbox, but American rocks tend not to grip things too well

-
@Higgins617 said:
Anyone ever call you a punka**?Oh yes.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login