Official Main Site Review Format
-
There have been a number of changes around here lately- perhaps you've noticed?

What makes you think we've forgotten the Encyclopedia?
We have plans to update it as well, but there's only so much we can do at any one time.Def
-
Changes? Where? You must have a real funny idea of progress up there in the land of maple leaves, cause' I aint seen a smurfin' thing change around here in long while

-
The general guidelines posted above are meant to simplify the review process for readers who may want to compare various tools. In this segment, I’ll make a few suggestions on what you can do to help make a review even more helpful to readers.
First and foremost, please remember that Multitool.org is ultimately my site and I’m responsible for everything that’s said on the main site. Things here may have been built with the contributions of over 2,000 members, but if there’s a lawsuit or a black mark on anyone’s name for the information that is provided, I will stand alone in the penalty box. For that reason I’m pretty picky about what goes there.That having been said, here are a few pointers that should help whenever writing any review, whether you want it published on the main site here, in a magazine, on the forum, or anywhere else.1- Use the item. I don’t mean abuse it, but push it a little bit at least. Find out what it’s limits are, and, staying within them, use the item to it’s fullest potential. This way, others won’t have to risk pushing one that far and breaking theirs. This will also let them know where the breaking point is, in case they feel they need something stronger, or more suited to their needs.
2- Don’t be a fanboy. People need the facts, not your idea of why SOG is better than Gerber, Victorinox is better than Leatherman or this is better than that unless you have an actual reason for saying it. You are more than welcome to have your preferences, but assume that the person reading it has a legitimate need for a quality tool, and they don’t care about the brand. Ranking a tool higher than another based on a name doesn’t help anyone. In short, make a legitimate, provable point. If you have a feeling about something, make sure to mention it, but say that it’s a feeling, not a fact.
3- Compare the tool to other tools. This works on two points- first and foremost, it suggests alternatives to the reader that they may not have thought of or been aware of before. If someone needs a good pair of scissors, and they are reading a review of Tool A, and the review says something about how the scissors are almost as good as Tool B, it may get the reader to look in another direction, which could be beneficial. The second reason is that a website like Multitool.org thrives on traffic and by posting links to other internal reviews helps the site out. Helping the publisher helps the publishee.
4- Know what you are saying. With the number of spell checkers on the market, it shouldn’t be too hard to get at least reasonably accurate spelling, but the other issue is phrasing- some folks use phrases incorrectly, either in wording or in meaning. Using a phrase wrong simply makes the reviewer sound like they don’t know what they are talking about, and to some people, that will invalidate the entire review. Yes it sounds lame, yes it is lame, but that’s the way it is, and whether you agree with the way some people see your review or not, your review is there to help them judge a tool, not for you to judge eachother.
That’s about all I can think of at the moment- write your review, wait a few days, then re-read it as if you didn’t write it, and ask yourself if what you have just read answers all the questions you would have when researching the tool. And, if there are any drawbacks, point them out, because let’s face it, if we here at Multitool.org don’t paint a realistic picture of each tool, who else will?Def
-
Hey Boss, thanks for this info!
While I know it's not something for the main site, I'm planning on doing a review of my new Condor Tavian. I'll certainly use these guidelines for that, and anything else I'll do.
I'm ordering a Zebra H502D from Travis, and when I get it, I'll write a review for it too. I'll see if there's anything else I can think of that I might be able to contribute for the main site as well.
-
No problem buddy. I know we all get into what each of us likes and doesn't like here and I am all for that. The thing about reviews on the Main Site is that the info is static, with no option for a point/counterpoint type discussion like there is here on the forum.
Because of that the info has to be as impartial as possible.
Def
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk 2
-
-
-
-
We had a few test versions backstage but Micah is still working on those.
-
-
This
is Awesome , i build alot mod from here . learn from other like Kam , DrZ , Dmac , SteveC , Nate , Chako ,Sak, Def ..soon many more .. Thank you for oppotunity..
1000 Thank You.. 
-
[quote author=Obi1shinobee link=topic=24001.msg1072092#msg1072092 date=1428863635]
This
is Awesome -
I am looking for new reviewers for www.Multitool.org
I am looking for regular reviews of old or new tools for the main site.
We will be offering some freebies a little later on that are ONLY available to main-site reviewers.<u>Are you in?</u>
-
-
@Corwyn said:
So... how do you post stuff? Do we PM you or...? What tools are accepted? Is there a list of what we have and is missing?
If I'm bored, I might draft a couple of those reviews... I always liked to hear myself talk
Post them in the forum. I'll whip you up a list soon of what has already been done.

-
Do note what Grant says about duplicate reviews; he doesn't care.
Seriously, just because someone has done the Wave, it doesn't mean we don't want to hear your thoughts. You might agree with the other review, you might not. You might think they left something out, you might think they weren't clear enough etc etc. -
I would love duplicate reviews.
Please don't assume we won't take them.
If you want to follow the format please and send them directly to me VIA pm I can post them after reviewing on multitool.org. -
@Megan said:
I would love duplicate reviews.
Please don't assume we won't take them.
If you want to follow the format please and send them directly to me VIA pm I can post them after reviewing on multitool.org.We'd normally post them in the forum section for commenting on first, and then the mods/admin have cherry picked from them. Gives the forum the chance to catch any errors, query comments etc. Sure you want to skip that part and have them go straight to your inbox? I know I've had to get a mod to edit one of my reviews before due to something I'd gotten wrong

-
What Al said.

-
@50ft-trad said:
I would love duplicate reviews.
Please don't assume we won't take them.
If you want to follow the format please and send them directly to me VIA pm I can post them after reviewing on multitool.org.We'd normally post them in the forum section for commenting on first, and then the mods/admin have cherry picked from them. Gives the forum the chance to catch any errors, query comments etc. Sure you want to skip that part and have them go straight to your inbox? I know I've had to get a mod to edit one of my reviews before due to something I'd gotten wrong

Between Grant and I we intended on editing and posting them.
But if people want to start posting them for review and letting us know- that's fine too. Just want to make it easy so we can start getting more to share.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login