firearms
-
@ColoSwiss said:
Going with a pistol round in a carbine is basically a waste of capacity. If you're toting a larger, heavier gun you should make the effort worthwhile by going to a more powerful and capable cartridge.Also ditto on scaling back the purchasing until you get more shooting experience.
.... a waste of capacity? I don't follow you. Shooting a carbine is not like shooting .308 or 30.06..... it's a carbine. Totally makes sense to me to carry ammo that is compatible with your handgun carry if you are range target shooting or similar. Perhaps I'm just slow and don't get what you are saying (which tends to happen as I'm not a smart man).
-
You can get a carbine in .44 Mag, 9mm or .45. For basically the same size and weight you can also get a carbine in 5.56mm, .30-30, or 7.62x39. The payoff is greater range, accuracy, and power. If ammo compatibility is an issue, or you just plain want a certain item to play around with, then go for the pistol cartridge. If you think you may need to use the carbine for hunting or defense, then go with the more capable round.
-
I think the topic of more capable round can be debated to death because there are clearly sweet spots for shooters in all the above mentioned rounds. I own multiple carbines in a range of flavors, and favor my .357 because I reload. I also find it to be a superior carbine load based on personal shooting preferences. I'd challenge the concept of of another round being a more capable load. As a life long hunter and shooting enthusiast I've had superior performance on both the range and in the field with the .357 round. I would not consider the .30-30 to be a more capable round as I don't quantify capability with only range/trajectory.
-
What ever works for you, go with it.

-
@ColoSwiss said:
What ever works for you, go with it.
This is code for I do not agree with you but value the friends we have here and do not want to get into a my round is more better then yours contest.
I love .357, had a Model 19 Smith for years. To say .357 Magnum gives up nothing to 30-30 in ballistics is something I do not agree with. To a certain range there is a lot that can be done with a .357.
-
<---does not hunt, nor will he ever. No need for long distance ranges as the local range isn't really equipped for it..as far as I know.
What I do know is that I have a handgun and carbine in .22LR. It makes perfect sense to me to have the same for 9mm. I am thinking purely about competition...and if a 9mm carbine is allowed in something like 3 gun competitions, then yes, there is a definite advantage in that I can have 10 rounds as pistol magazines max out at 10 here in Canada. Any center fire rifle or carbine will only be allowed 5 rounds max here in Canada.
From what I have read about the High Point 995 is great. It is the cheapest, and heaviest...but weight can be a good thing in stability. Life time warranty that is transferable to any current owner. Built tough and dependable. Very accurate from what I have seen as well. Somewhat difficult to take apart to clean...and due to its simple blow-back design...cleaning it often is the key. Some might dislike the looks...but I am not one of them. The nearest priced 9mm carbine at the local gun shop cost in excess of 1100 dollars.
If you haven't noticed, firearms are a lot more expensive here in Canada overall than in the US.
With that said, I am willing to wait until I can get my RPAL.
-
Can I offer a word of advise on this one?
Although this is something I apply to Airguns,it should rollover to live ammo! Don't buy anything more til you can get range time. When your there look at what all everyone else is shooting. If you see something you like the look of,ask the owner about it. At my club,9/10 times the gun will be put into your hands to try out. Try lots of stuff,even if you don't fancy it!
The more guns you get to shoot,the better idea you'll have of what you actually need!
The thing I've noticed(and I'm guilty of it too!) is that if you buy before trying,you'll end up with a lot of stuff you'll never use.
Oh,and always beware the man with one gun!
-
I have 3 already with no actual shooting experience other than one 12 gauge shot and 3-30-30 rounds from a lever action rifle back in the summer of 2009.
-
With that said, plenty of airsoft, BB, and pellet experience.

-
Oh and this was one of the videos that got me to consider it...and yes...it is from NutnFancy. :facepalm:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
I had to take the day off due to illness, and figured as I was feeling miserable, I could compile a list of items I bought at the local gun shop...seeing that I was somewhat forgetting what I already had...having bought all of this last month. Yeah, I know you guys are right in slowing down in my buying. I should wait till I get these items in my hands, join a gun club, and try other pieces before I buy. Besides, I am tired of researching shotguns....and I still have my eye on that Hi-Point 995.
So here is a list of things I now have waiting for the day I can get my licence. Any suggestions on what I may or may not need in the future, are always welcome.
- Browning Buckmark Hunter .22LR. This has the 7 1/4" blued bull barrel, cocobolo target grips, and fiber optic front sights.
- Bushnell 1X28 Trophy red/green dot sight.
- 2 extra magazines still on order.
- Winchester M22 LR 40 grain ~ 1000 rounds.
- Ruger 10/22R-TS. This features an adjustable Tac Star stock with 2 extra 10 round rotary magazines that fit in the butt stock. The Ruger also features the 50 year anniversary marking prominent on all 2014 Ruger 10/22s.
- Bushnell AR 1-4x24 30mm BDC reticle. I know it is designed for an AR, but the sight picture was very nice and bright. Besides, I may get an AR down the road...who knows.

- GSG 110 round rotary magazine.
- Weaver rings 30mm.
- Fore-grip.
- S&W M&P 9mm Range and Carry Kit. Comes with 3 magazines, a Blade-Tech Kydex holster and dual magazine pouch, and a Maglula Uplula speed loader.
- 4X10 round 9mm magazines.
- 500 rounds of Remington 115 grain UMC 9mm Luger.
- Tuff 8 in line dual stack magazine pouch.
- Snap cap 5 rounds of 9mm Luger.
I imagine I should buy a shooting belt at some time...either that or make one to my specifications. I haven't done any leather work in a few years...it just might be time to get back into it. Hmmm....come to think of it, I do have some old Western gun belt patterns somewhere with matching holster. That could make a nice summer project...maybe with a revolver down the road for some Western action.

-
Chako,
I've only stopped by this thread a little but it seems to me, you're a bit unfocused in this.
What is it you want to DO with the guns? That will focus your purchases, caliber, etc.Why a shotgun? Only 3 good reasons to buy a shotgun:
- Home security (but messy)
- Hunting (you've already ruled that out)
- Shooting clays (launched targets).
If you don't fall into one of those groups, shotguns aren't really what you're after. Shooting paper targets at a range with a shotgun is kinda silly.
If you're mainly shooting paper, TRY the calibers you're interested in, with the GUN you're interested in. Large caliber in lightweight guns (sliding scale here) starts to become NOT fun because of kick. I would much prefer to shoot my target .22 rather than my LCP in 38 BECAUSE:
A) It's more accurate
B) It's much cheaper
C) It's less tiring.My suggestion would be: Spend some time at the range with the weapons you have. Decide what you like and don't like about each of them and go from there.
And definitely figure out what kind of shooting you enjoy. Select weapons that work well for those types of shooting.
-
Well the original thought was to practice target shooting with a .22LR pistol. I wasn't going to buy a 9mm pistol but my friend who ownes the gun shop told me that the lowest and cheapest round to compete was 9mm. I then bought the pistol as that was what I was eventually aiming for. At the time, there was a good sale so I bought the pistol with the thought that I would upgrade to it later after practicing with the 22 Buckmark Hunter.
Because I also wanted to do some target practice with a rifle, I did my research and bought the Ruger 10/22 with tactical mods because that is what I wanted. Remember also that the sale was still in effect. I figured these type of sales don't come often...may as well get while the getting was good.
So that is how I ended up with a 22 pistol and rifle, and a 9mm pistol.
My plan is to practice with the 22s at first and then jump into the 9mm at a later date. I have found out that once I join the local gun club, they do offer the black badge course in May. I was told that if I wanted to go that route, and I do mostly for the fun of it, I would need at least7 mags and around 400 rounds of 9mm. So technically, I am sitting here waiting not so patiently for my RPAL (restricted Possession and aquisition licence) so that I can join the club and start practicing. I was told this will be sometime in March...I hope so, as that won't give me much time to practice before taking the course....which means I guess I am jumping right into 9mm from the start due to the compacted time frame. Once I get the course I can then start to take it easy.
The shotgun comes from the notion that the local gun clubs also do tactical shotgun competitions. I was looking for something that can hold 9 rounds (max for IPSC competitions) so that I could eventually join into that as well.
The 9mm Hi-point, I was looking into possibly 3 gun competitions down the road. Because it uses pistol magazines, I can have a max of 10 rounds as opposed to 5 rounds with anything else. Just thinking down the road here. The big pull is the price. AR type rifles are a mint up here, and I would find it hard to spent upwards of 1500 dollars on one just to have fun in some friendly local competitions.
So not exactly unfocused. I do have an end game plan in mind. Seeing that I am not interested in hunting, but mostly in having good fun in local competitions...that is my focus.
I haven't tried shooting clays yet. Heck, I have only shot 1 12 gauge shell from a shotgun, and 3 30-30 rounds from a lever action rifle a few years ago. I do tinker a lot with my air pistols and rifles however. You know, I originally wanted to get my PAL in order to buy a non neutered air rifle...but getting into firearms was always on my bucket list.
-
My point is, guns are an expensive (and serious-risk wise) hobby.
Rather than buy guns because you might be interested in this activity or that activity, spend a fraction of that money and try the activities for several weeks. Many clubs have intro courses to help foster interest. Often you can rent or borrow a weapon to see whether you like the sport, and/or the people participating in it.
I think you'll find that some of these activities will not be to your liking. That's ok, that's what you want to find out. If it isn't for you, then you won't feel the need to put out ~$1,000 for a competition shotgun or AR or whatever.
If you think 9mm is the round for you, TRY some 9mm weapons at the range. Shooting 22's won't "break you in" for 9mm. Shooting 9mm will. Your gunshop guy is a bit full of it. .22's are ABSOLUTELY used in competition target shooting. Hell, it's the only allowed caliber for Biathlon (My nephew was US Junior silver medalist in the late 1990's).
I'm assuming we're not going to delve into personal defense arguments here, cuz that's just a crazy world of caliber bravado (most of which has been debunked at least for handguns).
-
Well, I bought the 22's because it has cheap ammunition and I thought it would teach me some things that I just can't learn on pellet or bb pistols. I have done extensive reading online on the topic...and all my shooting friends suggested I start off with a 22.
I have friends who are in the gun club I will be joining, and they have told me plenty on IPSC black badge competitions, and I am certain that is what I am wanting to do for fun. Thankfully, I have a pistol to get me started so that I can get my feet wet. The 9mm is the lowest round they will accept in IPSC competitions. I haven't tried action shooting but all the videos and what my friends tell me, sounds like something I would most definitely like to try.
And here is a video to give you an idea of IPSC competitions.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
I forgot to add...personal defense does not come into play in Canada. You have your firearm locked up separate from your ammunition. By the time those two come together, you may as well club them over the head with a chair or something. Besides, in Canada, you can only use justifiable force, and shooting dead intruders is seriously frowned upon here.
I understand what you are saying...but I do have a game plan and a direct goal in sight. I know what I want to do, and am taking steps towards that goal. Besides, I am joining a gun club called the Algoma Practical Shooters. They like tactical stuff and are big IPSC black badge competitors. Heck, the local police force train at the gun range and most of them are members also.
-
@Chako said:
Well, I bought the 22's because it has cheap ammunition and I thought it would teach me some things that I just can't learn on pellet or bb pistols. I have done extensive reading online on the topic...and all my shooting friends suggested I start off with a 22.I have friends who are in the gun club I will be joining, and they have told me plenty on IPSC black badge competitions, and I am certain that is what I am wanting to do for fun. Thankfully, I have a pistol to get me started so that I can get my feet wet. The 9mm is the lowest round they will accept in IPSC competitions. I haven't tried action shooting but all the videos and what my friends tell me, sounds like something I would most definitely like to try.
And here is a video to give you an idea of IPSC competitions.
The 22 will allow you to shoot without much/any kick, so it helps aid in preventing flinching when firing. However, you will have to retrain yourself when you switch to 9mm because you will tend to flinch, anticipating the kick. That's the only thing the 22 will show you: How much you're flinching subconciously.
The reason for not allowing 22 in the IPSC (imo) is that 1) It's not generally considered a defensive round (a little silly) and 2) it would give you an unfair advantage because it is so much easier to be accurate with a 22. (a pretty good reason, otherwise every serious competitor would exclusively use a 22)
-
If nothing else...a day at the range with a 22 won't hurt as much as with anything else.

-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Chako,I've only stopped by this thread a little but it seems to me, you're a bit unfocused in this.
What is it you want to DO with the guns? That will focus your purchases, caliber, etc.Why a shotgun? Only 3 good reasons to buy a shotgun:
- Home security (but messy)
- Hunting (you've already ruled that out)
- Shooting clays (launched targets).
If you don't fall into one of those groups, shotguns aren't really what you're after. Shooting paper targets at a range with a shotgun is kinda silly.
If you're mainly shooting paper, TRY the calibers you're interested in, with the GUN you're interested in. Large caliber in lightweight guns (sliding scale here) starts to become NOT fun because of kick. I would much prefer to shoot my target .22 rather than my LCP in 38 BECAUSE:
A) It's more accurate
B) It's much cheaper
C) It's less tiring.My suggestion would be: Spend some time at the range with the weapons you have. Decide what you like and don't like about each of them and go from there.
And definitely figure out what kind of shooting you enjoy. Select weapons that work well for those types of shooting.
My first time with a shot gun was at the range shooting the paper target and it is so silly. Of course you hit the target. You just aim for an area and boom- yea got it. Not exactly exciting and you'd get so sore doing that over and over and over again. I can't imagine.
I'd like to try bird hunting this year so it sounds like I will end up with one.So far my favourite is a 9mm. The 22 wasn't that much fun to shoot I guess.
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
Chako,
I've only stopped by this thread a little but it seems to me, you're a bit unfocused in this.
What is it you want to DO with the guns? That will focus your purchases, caliber, etc.Why a shotgun? Only 3 good reasons to buy a shotgun:
- Home security (but messy)
- Hunting (you've already ruled that out)
- Shooting clays (launched targets).
If you don't fall into one of those groups, shotguns aren't really what you're after. Shooting paper targets at a range with a shotgun is kinda silly.
If you're mainly shooting paper, TRY the calibers you're interested in, with the GUN you're interested in. Large caliber in lightweight guns (sliding scale here) starts to become NOT fun because of kick. I would much prefer to shoot my target .22 rather than my LCP in 38 BECAUSE:
A) It's more accurate
B) It's much cheaper
C) It's less tiring.My suggestion would be: Spend some time at the range with the weapons you have. Decide what you like and don't like about each of them and go from there.
And definitely figure out what kind of shooting you enjoy. Select weapons that work well for those types of shooting.
My first time with a shot gun was at the range shooting the paper target and it is so silly. Of course you hit the target. You just aim for an area and boom- yea got it. Not exactly exciting and you'd get so sore doing that over and over and over again. I can't imagine.
I'd like to try bird hunting this year so it sounds like I will end up with one.So far my favourite is a 9mm. The 22 wasn't that much fun to shoot I guess.
22's are a little like BB guns. Personally, I like a bit of feedback. My 40S&W M&P is my favorite to shoot. Because it's so natural in my hand, I actually shoot as accurate as with a 22 and can acquire a target much faster with it. Just not for as many magazines. :)
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login