firearms
-
The Franchi is gas operated and the Benelli,as you know,is recoil operated.The only resemblance is purely cosmetic.
Franchi started manufacturing guns around 1868 and Benelli wasn't created until 1967.Two distinctly different companies but both purchased by Beretta.
-
So you're saying the Franchi and Benellis share no common parts (of significance)?
That was not my understanding. I'll have to look into that

-
Sorry,I had to join my wife in watching the TV show Grimm.
The model that you showed the 720 & 712 used the rotating bolt,licensed from Benelli but it was gas operated.It is no longer manufactured.The earlier Franchi guns the 48AL series were recoil operated and these are still being manufactured.
-
@toolguy said:
Sorry,I had to join my wife in watching the TV show Grimm.The model that you showed the 720 & 712 used the rotating bolt,licensed from Benelli but it was gas operated.It is no longer manufactured.The earlier Franchi guns the 48AL series were recoil operated and these are still being manufactured.
Very interesting. My info came from the gun guy at the local Gander Mountain. He led me to believe that Franchi and Benelli were internally very similar (Not that I was ever really looking at Franchi). He implied he could order a Franchi from his Benelli distributor. They stock Benelli.
-
The Franchi 48-AL series is a long recoil operated system,similar to John M.Browning's A-5 shotgun that he patented at the turn of the 20TH century.The Franchi 48-AL and the Benellis have no parts in common.The only guns that had any similarity were the 720/712 series that have been discontinued.
Benelli is factory direct and has no distribution network.The same is true for most of the Berettas with the exception of their semi-auto shotguns,the Sako and Tikka rifles.
-
@toolguy said:
The Franchi 48-AL series is a long recoil operated system,similar to John M.Browning's A-5 shotgun that he patented at the turn of the 20TH century.The Franchi 48-AL and the Benellis have no parts in common.The only guns that had any similarity were the 720/712 series that have been discontinued.Benelli is factory direct and has no distribution network.The same is true for most of the Berettas with the exception of their semi-auto shotguns,the Sako and Tikka rifles.
That is not what the folks at Gander Mountain tell me. When I asked about other Benellis, he told me he would have to check with his distributor about availability. On that I am sure. I wanted to look at a non camo Nova and they didn't have one
-
Believe me when I tell you Mr.Whippy.The counter guy at Gander mountain is mistaken or he is using the term distributor inappropriately. I have access to many websites of the largest firearms distributors on the east coast and they can't carry Benellis because Benelli is factory direct.
-
I think I know what's going on with the counter guys at Gander Mountain.Gander Mountain is direct with Benelli and the counetr man is probably referring to his warehouse as the distributor.
Benelli sells directly to the retailers and has no wholesale network.
-
@toolguy said:
Believe me when I tell you Mr.Whippy.The counter guy at Gander mountain is mistaken or he is using the term distributor inappropriately. I have access to many websites of the largest firearms distributors on the east coast and they can't carry Benellis because Benelli is factory direct.You sound like you know what you're talking about. It makes me wonder about some of the other stuff I've heard at gunshops too.
-
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
-
@toolguy said:
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.+1000! I hear ya, used to own my own shop.....

-
@toolguy said:
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.Don't get me started. I have heard so much bull crap pertaining to firearms and firearm laws from people in the shooting sports. The most BS I have heard comes from people who actually work at firearms stores, but are very much uninformed on what they are talking about, but act like they know exactly what they are talking about. I can't help myself, but to correct people when I hear this because they are spreading false information to other people which will then be passed along to who knows how many people.
This post has nothing to do with your conversation with Mr. Whippy.
-
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
+1000! I hear ya, used to own my own shop.....

LOL.
I bet you've heard some real winners.
-
@captain spaulding said:
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
Don't get me started. I have heard so much bull crap pertaining to firearms and firearm laws from people in the shooting sports. The most BS I have heard comes from people who actually work at firearms stores, but are very much uninformed on what they are talking about, but act like they know exactly what they are talking about. I can't help myself, but to correct people when I hear this because they are spreading false information to other people which will then be passed along to who knows how many people.
This post has nothing to do with your conversation with Mr. Whippy.
It occurs in every endeavor and every sport but some misinformation in the shooting sports can lead to dire consequences.
If it's a harmless rumor that won't affect anyone's safety I usually let it go.
-
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
+1000! I hear ya, used to own my own shop.....

LOL.
I bet you've heard some real winners.
Oh yeah..... ;)
-
@captain spaulding said:
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
Don't get me started. I have heard so much bull crap pertaining to firearms and firearm laws from people in the shooting sports. The most BS I have heard comes from people who actually work at firearms stores, but are very much uninformed on what they are talking about, but act like they know exactly what they are talking about. I can't help myself, but to correct people when I hear this because they are spreading false information to other people which will then be passed along to who knows how many people. **
This post has nothing to do with your conversation with Mr. Whippy.**
From his posts, Mr Whippy is the kind of well spoken, intelligent customer I was always glad to see in my store.

-
As someone new to the shooting sports, I have caught quite a few BS things from the fine folks at the local gun shop. Funny thing is that no matter how much I research things, I did fall into that trap twice...to my regret. Now I am a far more informed buyer, and won't be easily mislead by a few tall tellers behind the counter.

-
@captain spaulding said:
You would not believe some of the tales I'e heard coming from people who claim to have knowledge about guns.Most of it I don't take the time to correct but everyone here has been really nice and I would like to offer the knowledge I've gained from 40 years of dealing with firearms.
Don't get me started. I have heard so much bull crap pertaining to firearms and firearm laws from people in the shooting sports. The most BS I have heard comes from people who actually work at firearms stores, but are very much uninformed on what they are talking about, but act like they know exactly what they are talking about. I can't help myself, but to correct people when I hear this because they are spreading false information to other people which will then be passed along to who knows how many people. **
This post has nothing to do with your conversation with Mr. Whippy.**
From his posts, Mr Whippy is the kind of well spoken, intelligent customer I was always glad to see in my store.

Agreed.
-
@Chako said:
As someone new to the shooting sports, I have caught quite a few BS things from the fine folks at the local gun shop. Funny thing is that no matter how much I research things, I did fall into that trap twice...to my regret. Now I am a far more informed buyer, and won't be easily mislead by a few tall tellers behind the counter.
Its the natural progression of things. I'm sure your good to go now.

-
Continuing, from a few posts above, it is a shame how many shotgun makers have disappeared, even in the past ten years. Just looking at the Spanish makers, most of them, even the well known ones have merged, merged again and disappeared.
If you look at the number of French, German and Italian makers that were producing good shotguns 40, 50, 80 years ago you will be surprised by the fact that now there are just a few large companies owning most of the brands still left...
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login