Thoughts on Bit-Holders and Extender (Vic & LM)
-
-
@jzmtl said:
Never handled a Vic one, but it seems to me that they are completely stand alone, and other than bearing their logo has nothing to do with the actual multitools, no?Exactly. The bits that come with this kit I don't imagine are Vic produced nor of any special quality. It is a stand alone kit which is fine but for the cost not worth it IMO.
-
I did only mention price peripheral, as this can be very different, depending on where you live...
Here, I pay more than 20 USD for the LM extender another 40+ USD for the LM bits (Prices on the images are CHF). I break one LM bit, replacing it costs another 40 USD (prices from today from my primary supplier, also mostly the cheapest source in Switzerland). I have ruined bits, never the holder so far. Of course after paying 60 USD they are still useless unless I also buy a LM tool...
Pricing for Victorinox is 30 USD for the holder + couple of bits. Replacing bits will cost me as little as 1 USD.There are cheaper alternatives (not here in Switzerland, but there are :'(), but there are good reasons for the Vic too... If you buy a Spirit with bit-kit, it will fit nicely into the pouch (will take pictures tonight). As you can see in my first picture, the bits will nicely clip onto the holder. And last but not least, its very slim and will fit into places many cheap versions won't.
That said, if the cheaper fits your need, its by far the most economical solution.

-
So it again comes down to if you are in Europe, European stuff is cheaper, whereas if you are in NA American stuff is cheaper.

I have the leatherman kit but never used it. I won't carry it if I have no plan to use them, but if I do I might as well just carry a ratcheting screwdriver or a power screwdriver.
-
@jzmtl said:
So it again comes down to if you are in Europe, European stuff is cheaper, whereas if you are in NA American stuff is cheaper.
I think the Vic products are similar in prices all over the globe. Its LM/Gerber/Sog (but also Spyderco and all others) that are much more expensive in Europe. Sadly because of high shipping cost and custom fees its mostly not worth to import. I also have to say that prices are coming down (local importer have tough competition with the internet). So, on a good day I get the Surge for 100 USD on a bad day I get the LM bit-kit + Extender for that price. Mostly, its the small stuff (USB-cable, T-shank blade, replacement bits, batteries) that is incredibly overpriced because: A) you want it now and B) Relative to shipping cost its cheap.
Victorinox bit-set might be pricey, but its only the initial investment, replacing bits is cheap.
LM-bit set is cheaper initially, but if you have to replace bits its going to cost (and using standard 1/4" bits the LM-kit looses a lot of its compactness). It would therefore be super-awesome if you could buy LM-bits individually.@jzmtl said:
I have the leatherman kit but never used it. I won't carry it if I have no plan to use them, but if I do I might as well just carry a ratcheting screwdriver or a power screwdriver.Yeah, I think MT carry is always a balance of
- What you need / might need
- How much you can/are willing to carry
- How close is your tool-box
-
I do agree LM should sell the bits individually and not make us buy a whole set just to replace one bit. I have not ruined a bit yet so far so good. I will not replace a bit if this happens I'll just add a 1/4 bit to my kit.
The Vic bits that came with my Spirit and Swisstool plus tools seem standard run of the mill 1/4in bits. The L wrench while fine just doesn't warrant the asking price IMO. I have both Vic sheaths Swisstool/Spirit that very nicely hold the kits and tool.
The way I see it is the Vic set at $30 for an L wrench and 4-5 bit is steep. For around $30 I can get a better stand alone bit set of higher quality. YMMV
It's tough when we all come from different part of the world. Price aside tho I still feel the LM set is better in terms of versatility with regards to the different bits supplied and the compactness.
-
While I like the sheer number of bits you can carry easily with the Leatherman set, I don't feel that they're good for very hard use or precision stuff. The smaller metric hex keys in particular seem a bit soft and don't fit so well in screws. At least with the Victorinox (or any other 1/4" hex) but driver you can get some good quality bits to suit.
-
@Etherealicer said:
Mostly, its the small stuff (USB-cable, T-shank blade, replacement bits, batteries) that is incredibly overpriced because: A) you want it now and B) Relative to shipping cost its cheap.That's interesting, consider Bosch blades are swiss made.
-
If I know I'll be using lots of different bits, or have to battle lots of screws I mostly opt for the Chapman midget ratchet. Great bit of kit.
And you can use the standard 1/4 extender with it for extra reach.

-
-
This one?

I don't own one. Recently passt one up, new for 5 bucks. Why?
WARNING: As a non-owner this is of course just theoretical!Con:
- Requires tool it fits (no universal compatibility)
- Weirdly shaped and bulky (I think for packing elongated shapes are better)
Pro:
- Takes standard 1/4" bits
So personally I see no advantage, only drawbacks compared to a normal bit-holder (Vic or cheapo)
-
@Etherealicer said:
This one?

I don't own one. Recently passt one up, new for 5 bucks. Why?
WARNING: As a non-owner this is of course just theoretical!Con:
- Requires tool it fits (no universal compatibility)
- Weirdly shaped and bulky (I think for packing elongated shapes are better)
Pro:
- Takes standard 1/4" bits
So personally I see no advantage, only drawbacks compared to a normal bit-holder (Vic or cheapo)
That's actually the "Universal" version, which fits most folding MTs (the previous version only fitted skinny MTs like PSTs and Sideclips).
The big advantage of this particular driver is that it can fold to 90 degrees and is considerably more robust than the LM bit driver found on Waves/Charges/Surges, so if you need to use a brutal amount of force to loosen something you (probably) won't damage your MT (either bit driver or other driver component).
-
This one?

I don't own one. Recently passt one up, new for 5 bucks. Why?
WARNING: As a non-owner this is of course just theoretical!Con:
- Requires tool it fits (no universal compatibility)
- Weirdly shaped and bulky (I think for packing elongated shapes are better)
Pro:
- Takes standard 1/4" bits
So personally I see no advantage, only drawbacks compared to a normal bit-holder (Vic or cheapo)
That's actually the "Universal" version, which fits most folding MTs (the previous version only fitted skinny MTs like PSTs and Sideclips).
The big advantage of this particular driver is that it can fold to 90 degrees and is considerably more robust than the LM bit driver found on Waves/Charges/Surges, so if you need to use a brutal amount of force to loosen something you (probably) won't damage your MT (either bit driver or other driver component).
Interesting, how do I tell the Universal apart from the previous skinny fitted one?
For more torque you could also Extend your ratchet like Metropolicity has done here or maybe use a long bit for elongated handle (will report back, when I have tried this)
-
This one?

I don't own one. Recently passt one up, new for 5 bucks. Why?
WARNING: As a non-owner this is of course just theoretical!Con:
- Requires tool it fits (no universal compatibility)
- Weirdly shaped and bulky (I think for packing elongated shapes are better)
Pro:
- Takes standard 1/4" bits
So personally I see no advantage, only drawbacks compared to a normal bit-holder (Vic or cheapo)
That's actually the "Universal" version, which fits most folding MTs (the previous version only fitted skinny MTs like PSTs and Sideclips).
The big advantage of this particular driver is that it can fold to 90 degrees and is considerably more robust than the LM bit driver found on Waves/Charges/Surges, so if you need to use a brutal amount of force to loosen something you (probably) won't damage your MT (either bit driver or other driver component).
Interesting, how do I tell the Universal apart from the previous skinny fitted one?
For more torque you could also Extend your ratchet like Metropolicity has done here or maybe use a long bit for elongated handle (will report back, when I have tried this)

-
I had a Wave adapter I gave it to a friend. I did like it. It worked good. I now have the standard adapter fits my PST, PST II and Super Tool 300 really good and solid. It feels very much like a good screwdriver when you use it not off centered like the multitools that come with a bit driver.
-
-
-
@Kampfer said:
I like to add one advantage for the Leatherman flat bits: If the screws are not too tight (especially the small ones), you can actually use the bits by itself without any tools.Me too. There are many disadvantages to specialized bits, but often you don't care. All that matters is that they are so small and easily carried.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login