Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
I watched the first episode last night! Will be interesting to see how long they last!
Ture, but somehow it was easy to tell who'll be the first guy to tap out
Yeah, I could see it from the start, It's pretty annoying that somebody else missed out on a chance because that guy was way under prepared for the challenge.
I agree. On the other hand maybe we can tell from the get go but can the producers tell that as well? And why can we say that - is it because we are observing something that has been carefully edited, is it some sense developed trough experience or perhaps an instinct that goes back to more primal times of human history, or simply our own arrogance? How hard is it to tell and what are the realistic qualifications that people were expected to meet?
For instance there are some online "courses" that have a very preachy crowd behind it but when you really look at it in it's core, you don't have to leave your back yard to advance to the intermediate level. So while the idea is great, it's lack or refinement leaves room for simply faking it.On the other hand I've found 3 of the contestants on Youtube and they have very sensible content on there. But again, can your run of the mill producer really tell that considering the vast number of reality wilderness and or redneck shows that are on today?
In other regards here is Wayne Russell's explanation of his 10 items:
- 12×12 ground sheet
- 550 paracord – 20m
- Saw
- Axe
- Sleeping bag
- large 2 quart pot
- Ferro rod
- 300 yards of single filament fishing line and 25 assorted hooks
- knife
- Leatherman multi tool
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
When the dude found the bear den 30 yards away from his camp and didn't move camp farther away, that is when I said to my wife "this guy is not gonna last it very long"
I agree the editing has everything to do with how the contestants are portrayed, and I don't claim to be an expert woodsman, but really, some common sense and fore thought wouldn't have gone a stray there...
-
I'm beginning to think these shows might be hazardous to common sense and society. I was talking to a guy who's really into Bear Grylls. Convincing him that he shouldn't be drinking his urine in case of emergency shouldn't be this hard.
-
@Henry said:
I encountered black bears on an almost daily basis in the summer months. A lot of people who don't live in bear country don't seem to understand the huge differences in behaviour between black bears and grizzlys, and from the first episode my fears of sensationalisation were definitely confirmed! Announce yourself and don't surprise them and they will back off.I know there was a black bear death last year up in the oil fields, but it was the first in 20 or so years.
I think I'll watch it, but it's definitely going to be frustrating. For example the 'I work in law enforcement so I'm used to humans acting like wild animals, this will be no problem' attitude.
Id also be interested to see the list they chose their 10items from (from the similarities, it looks like it was fairly limited). Would be fun to pick your own 10.
This tends to be the prevailing thought when in bear country, even grizzly.
I'm with Daz on the choice on the shelter the guy chose. He clearly saw an active bear den. I certain these guys all had some kind of pre drop off "talk" with a local about the wild life in the area.
TV editing is great at showing what the producers want to get the ratings. I'll say however the guy was clearly overwhelmed by his own admission IIRC. He also had a look of deer in head lights and seemed very emotional. I don't think it was good timing on his part to have a pregnant wife and young kid at home.
No knock against him at all. It certainly is one thing to practice these skills in a class or back yard setting or even a familiar setting vs being dropped off in un familiar area.
-
I haven't really seen much of this show, but I have looked in the mirror and been "Naked and Afraid"
-
[quote author=DazMechanical link=topic=60285.msg1109584#msg1109584 date=1435221256]
I watched the first episode last night! Will be interesting to see how long they last!Ture, but somehow it was easy to tell who'll be the first guy to tap out
Yeah, I could see it from the start, It's pretty annoying that somebody else missed out on a chance because that guy was way under prepared for the challenge.
I agree. On the other hand maybe we can tell from the get go but can the producers tell that as well? And why can we say that - is it because we are observing something that has been carefully edited, is it some sense developed trough experience or perhaps an instinct that goes back to more primal times of human history, or simply our own arrogance? How hard is it to tell and what are the realistic qualifications that people were expected to meet?
For instance there are some online "courses" that have a very preachy crowd behind it but when you really look at it in it's core, you don't have to leave your back yard to advance to the intermediate level. So while the idea is great, it's lack or refinement leaves room for simply faking it.On the other hand I've found 3 of the contestants on Youtube and they have very sensible content on there. But again, can your run of the mill producer really tell that considering the vast number of reality wilderness and or redneck shows that are on today?
In other regards here is Wayne Russell's explanation of his 10 items:
- 12×12 ground sheet
- 550 paracord – 20m
- Saw
- Axe
- Sleeping bag
- large 2 quart pot
- Ferro rod
- 300 yards of single filament fishing line and 25 assorted hooks
- knife
- Leatherman multi tool
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
When the dude found the bear den 30 yards away from his camp and didn't move camp farther away, that is when I said to my wife "this guy is not gonna last it very long"
I agree the editing has everything to do with how the contestants are portrayed, and I don't claim to be an expert woodsman, but really, some common sense and fore thought wouldn't have gone a stray there...
[/quote]common sense is so uncommon these days it's counted as a superpower
-
[quote author=styx link=topic=60285.msg1109599#msg1109599 date=1435222617]
[quote author=DazMechanical link=topic=60285.msg1109584#msg1109584 date=1435221256]
I watched the first episode last night! Will be interesting to see how long they last!Ture, but somehow it was easy to tell who'll be the first guy to tap out
Yeah, I could see it from the start, It's pretty annoying that somebody else missed out on a chance because that guy was way under prepared for the challenge.
I agree. On the other hand maybe we can tell from the get go but can the producers tell that as well? And why can we say that - is it because we are observing something that has been carefully edited, is it some sense developed trough experience or perhaps an instinct that goes back to more primal times of human history, or simply our own arrogance? How hard is it to tell and what are the realistic qualifications that people were expected to meet?
For instance there are some online "courses" that have a very preachy crowd behind it but when you really look at it in it's core, you don't have to leave your back yard to advance to the intermediate level. So while the idea is great, it's lack or refinement leaves room for simply faking it.On the other hand I've found 3 of the contestants on Youtube and they have very sensible content on there. But again, can your run of the mill producer really tell that considering the vast number of reality wilderness and or redneck shows that are on today?
In other regards here is Wayne Russell's explanation of his 10 items:
- 12×12 ground sheet
- 550 paracord – 20m
- Saw
- Axe
- Sleeping bag
- large 2 quart pot
- Ferro rod
8****) 300 yards of single filament fishing line and 25 assorted hooks - knife
- Leatherman multi tool
When the dude found the bear den 30 yards away from his camp and didn't move camp farther away, that is when I said to my wife "this guy is not gonna last it very long"
I agree the editing has everything to do with how the contestants are portrayed, and I don't claim to be an expert woodsman, but really, some common sense and fore thought wouldn't have gone a stray there...
[/quote]common sense is so uncommon these days it's counted as a superpower
[/quote]That's true, you know?

-
I began watching it but some parts were frightening. I stopped watching the show Alone, now I always watch it with company...

-
I just watched episode 2, it seems that the wheat is getting separated from the chaff quickly, so it will become less frustrating. I believe programs like these become most interesting when you can put yourself in the contestant's shoes, and you're naturally thinking what you would do in each situation, then you get to see one option pan out. This definitely looks like it might be where its headed, so I think I'm going to stick with it.
Also its winter here, so I'm not getting out as much as I'd like to, this helps distract me!
-
The latest man off was a bit of a surprise to me
-
Spoiler alert :-
Spoiler:
Phobia of dogs, living around wolves is never going to work! -
@Henry said:
I just watched episode 2, it seems that the wheat is getting separated from the chaff quickly, so it will become less frustrating. I believe programs like these become most interesting when you can put yourself in the contestant's shoes, and you're naturally thinking what you would do in each situation, then you get to see one option pan out. This definitely looks like it might be where its headed, so I think I'm going to stick with it.Also its winter here, so I'm not getting out as much as I'd like to, this helps distract me!
Are you watching it online? Or has the second episode already aired in NZ?
-
I've been watching it online.
-
@styx said:
The latest man off was a bit of a surprise to meI was also quite surprised
. I can put myself in his shoes however I'm beginning to wonder what gives? These guys all knew in a fair amount of time what type dangers would be involved. They each have bear spray and I'm certain each were given details about how to avoid conflict with predators.If in fact he has a dog phobia then what made him think this was the time to try to get over it? I looking at this from the standpoint of other guys not getting an opportunity to be on the show.
I don't know how far in advance they knew where and what they'd encounter tho it's hard to believe with all the waivers they had to sign they didn't know full well.
No bad on him for leaving but yeah very surprised.
-
Phobia or not, it's hard to imagine that when you sign up for such a show you'd be far removed from canine predators no matter where you get left
-
I gotta wait 1 more night to see what you guys are on about, but by the sounds of it some of these guys are in way over their heads! Being alone in the wild isn't the best time to face your fears

-
@DazMechanical said:
I gotta wait 1 more night to see what you guys are on about, but by the sounds of it some of these guys are in way over their heads! Being alone in the wild isn't the best time to face your fears
Exactly nor is it the time to practice skills IMO. This to me is a place to test skill sets learned and honed over time and in various situations. If the only surviving done was in a back yard or campsite then this was most certainly the wrong place to be.
-
So do they need a 1 week competition to qualify for the chance? I wonder if they'd even have enough people entering...
Bit of a risk to quit your job indefinitely!
-
I gotta wait 1 more night to see what you guys are on about, but by the sounds of it some of these guys are in way over their heads! Being alone in the wild isn't the best time to face your fears

Exactly nor is it the time to practice skills IMO. This to me is a place to test skill sets learned and honed over time and in various situations. If the only surviving done was in a back yard or campsite then this was most certainly the wrong place to be.
Agreed!

@Henry said:
So do they need a 1 week competition to qualify for the chance? I wonder if they'd even have enough people entering...Bit of a risk to quit your job indefinitely!
I really have no idea how they would choose their contestants, probably an interview and some practical tests maybe?
-
Hey, if they do another season, maybe some of us could go. We can represent MTO.
Nate
That's us mobile
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login