Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
@styx said:
Sure does. Although I am surprised that he didn't go for a tarpScreenshot from 3minutes in on episode 5
Spoiler:
when Mitch is being stalked by a cougarThat definitely looks like a tarp to me... even though its not on his list. He is using his bivvy bag too.

Edit:
A better image from later in the show.

-
I'm sure there are some pretty bad arse women survivalist that could make a go of it. I don't know any in particular but I'm certain there are.
-
Aloha, I concur. The sad part is that it's really hard to get that diversity
Henry, see this is what I couldn't put my finger on. Somehow makes not a whole lotta sense
-
if someone wants to apply
-
After watching last night I question if in fact these guys are alone. One camera shot looked rather Les Stroudesque. I know Les painstakingly set up his camera then hiked back up or down to his starting position so he could get a shot of the hike or whatever he was doing.
I also wonder about some of the conversations these guys are having with themselves. I was saying to my roommate the one guy last night seemed prompted. I'm sure they were told to film or make a video diary otherwise watching guy in the woods would be rather boring.
Good episode tho.
-
am I the only one who found it strange that they had a week's jump forward? And I am quite sure one of the remaining guys had a Tom Brown Tracker, but didn't catch it this episode
-
It says they were trained in changing and filming. Though I'm sure I saw a panned shot, and I doubt they have electric sliders to remotely do that. In 'alone in the wild' he had a set drop point, which he canoed too and left pelican box of tapes in exchange for battery's. They haven't mentioned it but a drop solution might be good.
I also don't like being in trees when the wind picks up, that would be a scarier night sleep that the predators!
-
I also find some of the footage strange or confusing. As Henry pointed out, Mitch didn't bring a tarp in his 10 items but the footage clearly shows him using one. This kind of stuff just ruins all credibility of the show to me. Somebody also mentioned 'Naked and afraid' now I realise there are 2 people surviving together on that show, but they literally have 1 item each, and some of them do really well in 21 days. The new season seems to have allowed an extra item in some instances, a total of 3 items per episode. I find it amusing that half of the cast on 'Alone' have tapped out after a week or so with all their gear when the cast on 'Naked and afraid' last much longer with less...
-
While Naked and Alone know they only have 3 weeks, so have a definite date to aim for, it really seems strange how quickly these guys are losing the mental game.
Sam broke down this week, I thought attitude was his strongest card so I wonder how long he will survive. Especially after he admitted that once he thought of home it was only a matter of time.
Has there ever been a Naked And Alone on Vancouver Island? I've only watched a few episodes, be interested to see!
-
I don't think they have done 'Naked and Afraid' on Vancouver Island, but, they have done some places with similar conditions and some in worse conditions. I can't really compare the two shows as they have different rules etc. But, I think it's worth noting that we're not even 21 days into 'Alone' and half the cast has already tapped out with much more gear and resources than those on 'Naked and Afraid'
-
It's hard to compare and hard not to compare these type shows. There were some pretty harsh conditions on naked and while I dont know if theres any real credibility on that show either it does make one wonder. These are outfitted with 10 seemingly decent items which would have have us believe they could last 21 days.
Ok so am I wrong in feeling like in this environment shelter is of the UTMOST importance not a flipping boat? Next would be water and with the amount of rain that shouldn't be insanely difficult. There were "rations" available so next would be security from predators which also is part of shelter.
I found some of the camera angles to be questionable and the tarp thing now is really questionable. I agree that the trees blowing as hard as they were is very scary and dangerous. The animals would make anyone edgy but a secure shelter with fire does wonders for the psych.
I sure hate to be questioning this show so early but somethings just aren't adding up.
-
If you watch Mitch's video, there were loop holes. Like the Altoid tin for fishing hooks. That certainly gives you an extra item.
So is anyone applying for next season?
-
@Aloha007 said:
Ok so am I wrong in feeling like in this environment shelter is of the UTMOST importance not a flipping boat?My thoughts exactly. I don't get why he put so much emphasis on the canoe. Might have built a decent small cabin in this timespan, and with all the felled wood he had. But maybe he built the foundation where he built the frame to now become the foundation of a cabin? If not, that was a lot of construction for one canoe.
-
I believe (from other ramblings on the 'net), they were giving one tarp for free (outside the 10 pieces) and then they were given another specifically to protect their camera equipment. Similar to how their clothes and back pack weren't included in their 10 pieces. The tarp on the list would have been in addition to that so you could have had 3 tarps.
Again, the above is just internet rumour, but helps explain why everyone didn't select a tarp as part of their gear.
-
I'm sure we aren't seeing some things due to the editing as well. I've always been on the skeptical side especially with so called "reality" tv.
When I saw Mitch use the tin to make char I thought whoa that wasn't on his list. I'm sure there are some things that weren't counted like the bear spray and flares. I was thinking about myself on this show, the producers would be pissed at me for sure. I am terrible at operating a camera regardless of "training". I'd be so focused on settling in and either I'd forger or every video would be after the fact.
-
Yea but you'd only take a BO Surge and that's it
-
He talks about the tin in his video though (got tipped off by a fellow competitor that the producers allowed it for hook storage), however no mention of a tarp.
-
So I've read that all contestants got 2 tarps that weren't in their 10 items. This is how Sam has 3 tarps used for his shelter, I think it would definitely change my choices, as in I wouldn't include a tarp in my 10 items and be happy with 2.
Contestants have been out there for over a month now, so the comparison to naked and afraid has kind of passed. Especially considering most NF contestants barely eat and lose 30lbs and struggle to make it out. These guys may be hungry, but they're living comfortably.
I'm enjoying it more now that they're all past the initial stages, so their different styles are coming out more.
I'm definitely thinking Alan is a pretty safe bet for the win. Though the preview for next week made it look like winter is properly setting in so that might be a gamechanger. Especially as they're all relying on fishing/water for their main food source.
-
This just shows that mice is valid food.
Being given extra items is bs if you ask me. That way you're entering the situation with additional items. On the other hand Alan did make a really fine choice with that kukri.
I wonder if my idea of carrying a saw would work. I have a large round tin that fits my hobo fishing kit and in theory it could fit a buck saw blade (gotta try it) so you'd get a metal container that is roughly the size of a smaller cup that people tend to use for backpacking (a bit above 200ml)
-
@styx said:
This just shows that mice is valid food.Being given extra items is bs if you ask me. That way you're entering the situation with additional items. On the other hand Alan did make a really fine choice with that kukri.
I wonder if my idea of carrying a saw would work. I have a large round tin that fits my hobo fishing kit and in theory it could fit a buck saw blade (gotta try it) so you'd get a metal container that is roughly the size of a smaller cup that people tend to use for backpacking (a bit above 200ml)
To a certain extent I agree. ie when it comes to not counting certain containers (like the tin for the hooks) but not allowing them to come in the small plastic baggie? Also, considering the environment, I think every contestant would have picked a tarp if they weren't already being given one. It's just too wet to have to rely solely on being able to build shelter out of the local resources.
I guess it comes down to the producers to decide what does and doesn't count as an item. I think they were trying to get some variety in the items the contestant's brought with them, but where do you draw the line? If you gave everyone the same kit list (besides clothes on their backs) then you could prevent the 'extras' from sneaking in. Otherwise, it looks like Mitch got a good tip from another contestant and was able to act on it. Can't fault him for it really. I would want every possible edge going into a situation like that and wouldn't turn down a char tin.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login