Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
This just shows that mice is valid food.
Being given extra items is bs if you ask me. That way you're entering the situation with additional items. On the other hand Alan did make a really fine choice with that kukri.
I wonder if my idea of carrying a saw would work. I have a large round tin that fits my hobo fishing kit and in theory it could fit a buck saw blade (gotta try it) so you'd get a metal container that is roughly the size of a smaller cup that people tend to use for backpacking (a bit above 200ml)
-
@styx said:
This just shows that mice is valid food.Being given extra items is bs if you ask me. That way you're entering the situation with additional items. On the other hand Alan did make a really fine choice with that kukri.
I wonder if my idea of carrying a saw would work. I have a large round tin that fits my hobo fishing kit and in theory it could fit a buck saw blade (gotta try it) so you'd get a metal container that is roughly the size of a smaller cup that people tend to use for backpacking (a bit above 200ml)
To a certain extent I agree. ie when it comes to not counting certain containers (like the tin for the hooks) but not allowing them to come in the small plastic baggie? Also, considering the environment, I think every contestant would have picked a tarp if they weren't already being given one. It's just too wet to have to rely solely on being able to build shelter out of the local resources.
I guess it comes down to the producers to decide what does and doesn't count as an item. I think they were trying to get some variety in the items the contestant's brought with them, but where do you draw the line? If you gave everyone the same kit list (besides clothes on their backs) then you could prevent the 'extras' from sneaking in. Otherwise, it looks like Mitch got a good tip from another contestant and was able to act on it. Can't fault him for it really. I would want every possible edge going into a situation like that and wouldn't turn down a char tin.
-
I don't mind the tin as much as the tarps. Some guys used the 1 or 2 of the 10 times to bring a tarp while others still got to have a tarp even though they didn't choose it. Perhaps if you were to give everyone a 10x10 tarp from the get go and then have them choose from the 40 item list where they can bring 1 or 2 additional tarps it would be perfectly fine with me since they are all going in with the same provided equipment.
The environment really requires an axe but you could probably get by with a large chopper. So how would they feel if it had a piggyback knife on the sheath? The tin thing is more to exploit the holes in the system thing.
As to bringing the same equipment, there isn't much diversity anyway. Look at this:Axe (all 10) Sleeping Bag (all 10) 2 Qt Pot (all 10) Ferro Rod (all 10) 25 piece Fishing Kit with Line (all 10) Knife (9 / Josh Chevez had no knife) 12×12 Tarp (Only 6 carried) Saw (6 chose this tool) Paracord (5 chose this item) Bow & 6 Arrows (4 chose this item) Gill Net (4 chose this item) Emergency Rations (3 chose this item) Canteen/Waterbottle (3 chose this item) Leathermen Multi-Tool (2 chose this item) Bivy Bag (2 chose this item) Sling Shot (2 chose this item) Sharpening Stone (2 chose this item) Wire (Only 1) Extra Tarp (Only 1)The same Site also says that all were given the following items:
Pack Flare Bear Spray Life Jacket 12×12 tarp 5×7 tarpYou can read more here:
http://morethanjustsurviving.com/alone-season-1-survival-gear/ -
Wow with winter setting in I am very curious as to how this will play out. This will most likely be the game changer. Sam will need to get his shelter buttoned up and while we haven't got a good look at Lucas' shelter he's moving camp so we'll see what he constructs. Alan does seem the most "settled" however at this point the voices are getting louder in his head.
I really liked hearing Sam speak about his attitude towards getting frustrated and his take on things in general. He really seems like a solid young man not to mention funny. Winning small battles and not letting the mishaps and disappointments get you down is important.
Mitch appears to be hearing the voices in his head pretty loudly now too. It's hard to gauge him since he's not terribly emotional. He's had some successes and does seem very skilled but man those voices.
Lucas is a trip, one moment I feel he's gonna tap the next he's planning to move camp. That boat of his came into play which is so cool. He seems very emotional besides this show so hopefully he'll be able to get a handle on that. It doesn't seem to break him tho so..... He very well may be the surprise in this show.
I swear Alan is chewing something every time we see him, what the heck can it be? I am digging this guy's approach. Day by day and evolving to meet the challenges of the environment. I also am interested in his dialogue with the camera. He is within himself and his thoughts which seems to fuel him. His shelter appears to be the most secure and stable. He has a decent hold on resources limited as they are and his mindset is one that should sustain him.
I was wonderring when it does finally come down to two and one taps out when will they tell the last man standing he's won? I wondered how long their "rations" lasted? Bravo to these men at this point.
-
@styx said:
I don't mind the tin as much as the tarps. Some guys used the 1 or 2 of the 10 times to bring a tarp while others still got to have a tarp even though they didn't choose it. Perhaps if you were to give everyone a 10x10 tarp from the get go and then have them choose from the 40 item list where they can bring 1 or 2 additional tarps it would be perfectly fine with me since they are all going in with the same provided equipment.The environment really requires an axe but you could probably get by with a large chopper. So how would they feel if it had a piggyback knife on the sheath? The tin thing is more to exploit the holes in the system thing.
As to bringing the same equipment, there isn't much diversity anyway. Look at this:Axe (all 10) Sleeping Bag (all 10) 2 Qt Pot (all 10) Ferro Rod (all 10) 25 piece Fishing Kit with Line (all 10) Knife (9 / Josh Chevez had no knife) 12×12 Tarp (Only 6 carried) Saw (6 chose this tool) Paracord (5 chose this item) Bow & 6 Arrows (4 chose this item) Gill Net (4 chose this item) Emergency Rations (3 chose this item) Canteen/Waterbottle (3 chose this item) Leathermen Multi-Tool (2 chose this item) Bivy Bag (2 chose this item) Sling Shot (2 chose this item) Sharpening Stone (2 chose this item) Wire (Only 1) Extra Tarp (Only 1)The same Site also says that all were given the following items:
Pack Flare Bear Spray Life Jacket 12×12 tarp 5×7 tarpYou can read more here:
http://morethanjustsurviving.com/alone-season-1-survival-gear/Regarding the tarp, I see no problem with it if they knew up front that they would be given the tarps and that the one in their 10 item kit was extra. That seems perfectly reasonable. If it was a last minute 'here have 2 tarps' then I would have a problem with it as the people who chose a tarp would in essence be losing out on an extra item.
As to the knife with a piggyback blade, that one seems pretty clear cut as it is 2 knives of different sizes and styles and would count as 2 if they were even allowed to double up (don't think this was the case though).
I found it interesting that they banned the small plastic bags and some of the packaging material that things came in. Reference the small plastic bag that the fish hooks would have been purchased in (at least locally that's how they come packaged). They didn't allow the cheap plastic bag but allowed a metal tin. That one makes no sense to me.
-
@Aloha007 said:
Wow with winter setting in I am very curious as to how this will play out. This will most likely be the game changer. Sam will need to get his shelter buttoned up and while we haven't got a good look at Lucas' shelter he's moving camp so we'll see what he constructs. Alan does seem the most "settled" however at this point the voices are getting louder in his head.I really liked hearing Sam speak about his attitude towards getting frustrated and his take on things in general. He really seems like a solid young man not to mention funny. Winning small battles and not letting the mishaps and disappointments get you down is important.
Mitch appears to be hearing the voices in his head pretty loudly now too. It's hard to gauge him since he's not terribly emotional. He's had some successes and does seem very skilled but man those voices.
Lucas is a trip, one moment I feel he's gonna tap the next he's planning to move camp. That boat of his came into play which is so cool. He seems very emotional besides this show so hopefully he'll be able to get a handle on that. It doesn't seem to break him tho so..... He very well may be the surprise in this show.
I swear Alan is chewing something every time we see him, what the heck can it be? I am digging this guy's approach. Day by day and evolving to meet the challenges of the environment. I also am interested in his dialogue with the camera. He is within himself and his thoughts which seems to fuel him. His shelter appears to be the most secure and stable. He has a decent hold on resources limited as they are and his mindset is one that should sustain him.
I was wonderring when it does finally come down to two and one taps out when will they tell the last man standing he's won? I wondered how long their "rations" lasted? Bravo to these men at this point.
I'm with you on Lucas. That guy seems to be all over the place emotionally and I keep expecting him to tap out. Yet he is still there.
Alan has really embraced the mental dialog and I think that talking it out to the camera is helping keep him sane.
Sam may end up in trouble if he doesn't improve his shelter situation. He also mentioned in the previous episode that he's started thinking about family and that could start messing with his head.
I'm still pulling for Mitch but think that at this point, there's no predicting who's going next.
-
Lucas is tuff and resourceful. I don't think he give himself enough credit. The breakdowns IMO are fine since it seems he's purging any doubts about himself thru these cries. Afterwards he seems to regroup and forge on with more determination.
Sam, this young man is a trip. Is he winging it? I believe he has skills but I'm not seeing it apart from the trap. I can't tell if he close to tapping or he's just lamenting.
Mitch has skills but I really cannot gauge him emotionally. Last night he seemed really bummed but I dont know where his head is at.
Alan definitely has been using this time to sort out stuff from his past. Introspection can be a $@&%h.
It really is hard to call at this point. Anyone can tap coming into winter tho I see Mitch going next then Sam then between Alan and Lucas I really cannot call it. If no one on taps next weeks airing my feelings may change.
-
They've got to start tapping soon (episode-wise anyway). The season is only so long.
-
It will be interesting to hear the guys who have left the show talk about their experiences and their reasons for tapping out. I'm routing for Lucas while Alan seems more experienced. I'm liking all the guys at this point honestly. Bravo to all.
-
Slinger, that is exactly what I mean when it comes to the tarps.
As far as those who tapped the summary for Joe is that he lost the firesteel and couldn't find it. Without it he couldn't start a fire and it was getting miserable.
For Wayne it was the feeling of becoming dinner. He felt stalked and trapped by that black bear and it got to him since he was worried for his safety -
@Aloha007 said:
It will be interesting to hear the guys who have left the show talk about their experiences and their reasons for tapping out. I'm routing for Lucas while Alan seems more experienced. I'm liking all the guys at this point honestly. Bravo to all.I wonder what the NDA time line is like? I would imagine they'd be able to be reasonably open about it after the show ends but I can see the producers wanting to keep a gag on some things for future seasons.
-
Interesting about the tarps, was wondering about that.
I had a bit of a Peter Pan moment, I was telling my cousin (a year younger than me @39) about the show, mentioned "this older guy".......only to remember I'm the same age :-\

I'm hope Alan takes it, I have to suspect that he skimped on the filming in the beginning, but he seemed get settled with the least fuss, and a lot of what he says resonates with me.
-
Alan does seem like he could go on and on. I do have to wonder with winter approaching tho how he and the other will cope with even more limited resources.
-
Odd that there is not a lot of info on Alan. Or to be more precise, I can't find him on social media to share at least some of his philosophy on here
-
Watched the new episode last night.......now I rate Alan even more for going small.
Lots of tiny fish will fill you up as well!
There's a reason why I tasted what bugs are like, and I know it's a more likely option to keep me alive than most things...
-
I think Alan's age has some to do with his ability to maintain a better attitude. He has been around longer and tries not to over think the situation. When people are young time takes forever, when older time flies by. So age my be a benefit in the Alone show. Most of the younger contestants seem to miss family and home more.
-
as I've stated in the beginning, not having little kids might be the big game changer later on
-
:whistle:
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
We hear Alan dealing with some voices however what he seems to have is the right attitude about being there. Lucas for example appears to forget he chose to be there and can tap any time he wants. Longing for home is one thing but the appearance from some was like they were forced in this.
I wonder how many of these guys wives or moms do everything for them. If they've been married for a while and live like most men I see then everything is done for them. Heck I'd miss home too if that were the case.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
