Off Grid Challenge
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Originally they produced the Basecamp for export to Africa only and didn't plan to sell them here. The sales of the smaller standard Bio Lite stove was just to help fund sending the Basecamp version to developing nations. Due to customer demand they decided to offer it here as well, and I very much want one too.I'm very fond of my little Bio Lite stove, although it isn't as effective in a Canadian winter, as Megan and I proved. Megan is largely sold on the Mini Trangia though, but I still hate taking fuel with me, or else I'd be perfectly happy with the Svea Optima 123. And, neither of those also charge phones, flashlights, cameras or GPS.
They want you to use your electronic devices, just not use the power outlet. There is even a car in the "Go pictures".
Also it says you can use your mobile, so you are allowed to use devices that use power from the grid (your mobile is pretty useless if the cell phone towers have no power).If you have a powerbank your mobile phone, ebook reader with backlight, flashlight, tablet and even your laptop are easily covered for 48h.
Cooking: You either make a wood fire, eat cold food (Salad, sandwiches) or order in (cell phone tower paradox).
That makes having no cold beer from the fridge the hardest part. But even that can easily be remedied, just order it with your pizza 8)Basically, I see not much of a challenge or did I miss something?
Absolutely correct, although I suppose this could be as much or as little of a challenge as you want to make it. Yes the cell towers are powered by the Grid and so you are cheating if you use them. It also says something about oil companies, so I suppose your car could be included as well.
I think the idea is to get people thinking about going off grid, as opposed to actually being off grid if you know what I mean. Very likely the challenge was left vague so that more people would participate as they are able to participate (for example, I need my car for work, and I'm technically on call 24/7 so being without it is impossible for me) while promoting the idea of being less dependent on centralized power.
This is (I think anyway) a great idea as it can also get people into a position where they are better able to deal with power outages due to natural disasters and the like. 48 hours may not be a long time to go without plugging in for many of us, but a lot of people don't realize the extent of what that means, and a challenge like this one could be an eye opener for them.
Def
I don't think its an useless challenge (just an easy one), as it should make you think about it and maybe then you are hopefully a bit better prepared.
I see 2 major differences between the challenge and a power outage (for whatever reason)- You are not prepared, so your devices won't all be charged and ready
- More importantly, no cell-tower-paradox. Its quite likely that in case of a power outage the cell towers don't have power either, so no matter how well your phone is charged you won't be making any calls and the Pizza courier won't bake etc. In fact, its likely that all the shops will be closed.
The danger of this challenge is, that people think its easy and therefore believe they are prepared for a power outage. I think the Challenge should be that you DO NOT prepare, go about your life as usual, but when the challenge starts, get off grid. That would show how useful it is, if you can generate power with a stove.
I will be off grid that weekend and cooking on a fire anyway, as I will be at a renaissance fair :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
Interesting, but I've already done it ;)I lived off grid (apart from at work) for two and a half weeks in temps down to -17C. I was stranded at my unfinished boat in mid winter, using a hand operated tombola style washing machine, with battery and oil lighting, hand crank to charge the phone, solar/crank powered radio, and wood burning stove for cooking, cleaning, hot water, and even melting snow when the water supply failed. Work also was without water for that time, but did have electricity. Thankfully an adjacent building still had their water working so we could use their facilities. 48 hours was a doddle, but 18 days just got tougher and tougher as the woodpile diminished, water supply got harder, and the snow became less pure.
No that is a challenge

That sounds long past being entertaining :o
-
@Etherealicer said:
I will be off grid that weekend and cooking on a fire anyway, as I will be at a renaissance fair :DWill you be unplugging your fridge/freezer before you go?

-
I will be off grid that weekend and cooking on a fire anyway, as I will be at a renaissance fair :D
Will you be unplugging your fridge/freezer before you go?

No, but I won't open it and or use anything that is stored inside. I think the only thing with electrical power I'll be using that weekend is probably my flashlight... and of course the fridge in one of the many bars where I will be getting my cold beer :D
-
I will be off grid that weekend and cooking on a fire anyway, as I will be at a renaissance fair :D
Will you be unplugging your fridge/freezer before you go?

No, but I won't open it and or use anything that is stored inside. I think the only thing with electrical power I'll be using that weekend is probably my flashlight... and of course the fridge in one of the many bars where I will be getting my cold beer :D
Storing things is using it. :P
-
I read an article some time ago about a woman whose house was setup to be a zero/neutral carbon footprint. She had a septic system, solar panels, rainwater collection system etc etc. She was fighting with the local town council as they were obliging her to be connected to the city plumbing and electrical, even if she didn't use it (which obviously costs money to install and yearly/monthly fees). Somewhat defeating the point of her setup (which was nowhere urban I might add).
I think it'd be really difficult to achieve this at home, since in reality you're still going to need some items powered on such as your fridge, regardless if you bbq/camp stove cook or eat cold foods. I also feel to a degree that if you go offsite and use someone else's power it's not really complying with the challenge (IE restaurants/bars/etc)... in which case you mind as well turn of the electrics in your house and run an extension cable from the neighbours.

While other items such as TV and computers are pretty easy to power off and yes with power packs you can probably do internet for a few days on mobile for some entertainment... or just read some comics/books.
48h is probably quite easy to achieve, whereas a week might actually be a real challenge.
-
I will be off grid that weekend and cooking on a fire anyway, as I will be at a renaissance fair :D
Will you be unplugging your fridge/freezer before you go?

No, but I won't open it and or use anything that is stored inside. I think the only thing with electrical power I'll be using that weekend is probably my flashlight... and of course the fridge in one of the many bars where I will be getting my cold beer :D
Storing things is using it. :P
I think the challenge is a bit vague on this but I agree...
-
@Whoey said:
I think it'd be really difficult to achieve this at home, since in reality you're still going to need some items powered on such as your fridge, regardless if you bbq/camp stove cook or eat cold foods. I also feel to a degree that if you go offsite and use someone else's power it's not really complying with the challenge (IE restaurants/bars/etc)... in which case you mind as well turn of the electrics in your house and run an extension cable from the neighbours.
When I was in America, this is exactly how it went. In one village there was a central house, that was connected to the grid, its where everybody went to charge his electronics and it was where the freezer and the fridge for the whole village was. Would you say these people lived off the grid or not?
So where do you draw the line? I mean sure, the pizza delivery guy needs power, but so does the cell-phone tower. Why one and not the other?
Of course there is also the big question on where you live. Can I buy and store the wood for fire-making? If yes, why not gas? If no, wood won't work for me.Lastly and most important, what about water? I mean you can eat cold food, you can switch off your laptop but you need water. I think that would affect me much quicker, no more showers, no flushing the toilet, no drinking water...
-
As I said, I think this is why they didn't post specific rules but instead left it open to interpretation.
Def
-
So, anyone do it?
Not saying I did, but:
Delicious Bunny Stew
And some "Multi-Tools"



-
I was out kayaking much of this weekend and forgot all about it. :P
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I was out kayaking much of this weekend and forgot all about it. :PDef
So you probably did it without noticing...
-
Except for the air conditioner running most of the night, yes. .... :PS
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login