Wingman vs. MP400?
-
Let's go ahead and say I'm 'budget minded'.
Cheap as Smurf... whatever. :D
It has been my position for a LONG time, that the Wingman/Sidekick is the best low budget MT out there in its price range. (I'm setting my thoughts on the Rev aside until I get one, and can do an honest appraisal)
However, it's been brought to my attention recently, first by Smaug in his video, but by others, that the MP 400 Compact Sport is running under $30 on Amazon.
So, which is the better MT, if cost is about the same?
The TLDR answer (obviously my opinion here)... It depends. For hard use, the MP400. For convenience, the Wingman. However, as an overall, I have to concede that dollar for dollar, I think you get more MT with the MP400.
Point for point comparison here.
Speed to access pliers? Point to MP400
Needle Nose? Wingman
Wire cutter? MP400
Ergo of handles? MP400
Spring load? Wingman
Handle Splay? MP400
Max Bolt size? MP400Scissors
Access?: Wingman
Cutting? MP400Blade
Access? Wingman
Location for cutting? Wingman
Blade design? TiePhilips
Locking? MP400
Reach? Tie
(in some instances one design may be better than the other)
Full 3d? MP400Large flathead
Locking? MP400
Reach? Wingman
Use as Pry Tool? TieCan Opener? Tie
(Both work, neither are great)Bottle Opener? Tie
Non-Comparables
One more flathead: MP400
Package Opener: Wingman
File: Wingman
Wire Stripper: Wingman
Pocket Clip: Wingman
Sheath: MP400Weight? Tie
While these two tools are comparable for price, and have very similar features, I think their ROLE is not exactly the same. The MP400 comes from a more robust lineage, and that shows. It is more solidly, and simply, built. The Wingman is designed with some elements intended for convenience. OHO blade and outside access scissors, along with a pocket clip, and sprung pliers make the tool more 'convenient'. The blade location alone may sway the Wingman into the winner position for some. In addition, it has more varied functions. While the file is put down for being too short, it works, and is pretty aggressive, and a short file beats no file if you NEED a file. Taking away the convenience factor and a few niceties, though, functionally, in almost all cases, the MP400 will handle more. More options for sizes of flat drivers, more robust philips, all locking tools.
I expect a pack of rabid death threats for even suggesting that the Wingman and MP400 are in the same league, but... Meh. I like to live dangerously. Well that, and it's a topic of conversation.
-
My totally biased opinion is that the MP400 is the clear winner over the Wingman. Wingman isnt even competition for the MP400. I dont need to compare or consider cost. I dislike the Wingman and have great respect for the MP400. :D :D
-
I too would agree with MP400 as the winner, but I probably would award ergo towards wingman. The MP400 handles with sliding pliers buttons are definitely not comfortable for prolong use.
In my mind, I always think of MP400 as the same class as Leatherman regular mid size tool, such as Wave/Rebar. But price wise, it does make more sense to compare it to entry level LM.
-
@comis said:
I too would agree with MP400 as the winner, but I probably would award ergo towards wingman. The MP400 handles with sliding pliers buttons are definitely not comfortable for prolong use.In my mind,** I always think of MP400 as the same class as Leatherman regular mid size tool, such as Wave/Rebar.** But price wise, it does make more sense to compare it to entry level LM.
I personally think of the MP400 in the same class as the Fuse, but comparing it to the Wingman is a great comparison in my opinion.
-
I'd put the MP400 clear above the Wingman outside of aesthetics. The Wingman clip and rounded shape is a big improvement over the MP400 and works great for pocket carry.
But for actual real use, give me an MP400 any day.
-
@Dem said:
I'd put the MP400 clear above the Wingman outside of aesthetics. The Wingman clip and rounded shape is a big improvement over the MP400 and works great for pocket carry.But for actual real use, give me an MP400 any day.
In my opinion the Wingman clip would be a improvement if it actually had any retention at all. Basically how all Leathermans with clips are. I have never had a Leatherman with a clip that has left me feeling confident the tool will not just slip right out of my pocket. The Sideclip is the closest though.
-
No? I've found I end up carrying the Charge a whole bunch just for the clip, even with my keys attached to the lanyard ring being at the top of my pockets hardly being ideal. I thought the Wingman was even better feeling, in the pocket, on its own.
I'm still hunting for a sideclip, sadly (and I thought buying a pulse was expensive...) I've found out of all the LM tools I've used, that the skeletool probably had the best clip setup (with lanyard holding a key ring at the bottom) but I only use that for a light duty carry.
-
@Dem said:
No? I've found I end up carrying the Charge a whole bunch just for the clip, even with my keys attached to the lanyard ring being at the top of my pockets hardly being ideal. I thought the Wingman was even better feeling, in the pocket, on its own.I'm still hunting for a sideclip, sadly (and I thought buying a pulse was expensive...) I've found out of all the LM tools I've used, that the skeletool probably had the best clip setup (with lanyard holding a key ring at the bottom) but I only use that for a light duty carry.
We are worlds apart on what we want in a pocket clip. I think the Skeletool clip is about as bad as it gets when speaking of retention. I have been carrying my Wave with clip lately. The deep carry design and the screw underneath the clip actually traps the top (fat) portion of the pocket holding it more securely which is nice. If the fabric did not lock itself in like this the Wave clip would be terrible like the others. I personally want extremely tight retention. The more the better. I have never come across a clip (on any knife or MT) that was to tight. When you combine the weight of a multitool, the slick surface of a multitool, and a clip with even decent retention (which most leathermans do not even have) its still a recipe for the tool jumping out of your pocket. For me at least.
-
great write up Lynn!
Like you said, MP400 would be a better to to work but Wingman's OHO blade and pocket clip won me over in a second. -
And for the record, any MT with OHO blade and pocket clip scores high point in my book, because that is how I carry them. Wave, Skeletool, SK/WM.
-
I was surprised to see these two pitched against each other. I'd agree with the comparisons though. My preference would certainly ge for the Mp400, or more specifically, my knifeless version (though I'd choose the MP400 if limited to stock models too)
I can understand why the Wingman might be preferred by some, but for me the pliers ergonomics negate any benefits from pocket clip and OHO blade. It's a shame, as I find everything else on the Wingman quite usable apart from the pliers :-\ (though I'd still prefer the drivers to lock and the blade to be a slippie :D)
-
-
Spirit is probably the finest MT ever made up to this day, but I never carry it, so it doesn't help me at all.

-
Interesting comparison Lynn. Like everyone else I'd keep my MP400 over a Wingman in a heartbeat. Not, I hasten to add, that I hate the Wingman and Sidekick as mush as some folks do, like you I really do think they have their own merits.
-
@Kampfer said:
Spirit is probably the finest MT ever made up to this day, but I never carry it, so it doesn't help me at all.
Yeah, left at home is never a great feature :D
Have you considered a Nite-ize clip? I think a few people have done this (don't know how much it would screw up the ergos though).
@Gareth said:
Interesting comparison Lynn. Like everyone else I'd keep my MP400 over a Wingman in a heartbeat. Not, I hasten to add, that I hate the Wingman and Sidekick as mush as some folks do, like you I really do think they have their own merits.The first time I saw the Wingman and Sidekick in the flesh, I was actually quite pleasantly surprised. It was only when I actually tried using the pliers rather than just holding the tool that I realised how uncomfortable (highly splayed with pokey corners) the pliers were. If they'd have only fixed that one thing, my views on it could have been quite different
-
Wingman by an edge. But drop the pocket clip and its mp400. Ease of carry plays a big part. The 400 sheath is terrible. The 400 scissors cut much better. Drivers are easier to use on the wingman but you get more assortment on the 400. Wingmans pliers are more robust but that doesnt mean the 400's are a push over. They are just smaller. Overall it is close. Great thread

-
@Demel said:
Wingman by an edge. But drop the pocket clip and its mp400. Ease of carry plays a big part. The 400 sheath is terrible. The 400 scissors cut much better. Drivers are easier to use on the wingman but you get more assortment on the 400. Wingmans pliers are more robust but that doesnt mean the 400's are a push over. They are just smaller. Overall it is close. Great thread
Interesting viewpoints.
What makes you say the Wingman pliers are more robust? In my eyes they are less durable than the MP400 's due to the hollow construction around the pivot to get the spring in. Are you referring more to the tips, or overall build?
Similarly on the drivers, what makes you feel the Wingman's are more usable? Better fit on the screws you encounter, or something else? I do like knowing the MP400 ones lock and I can use a bit adapter.
I'm not trying to pull you up on these issues, just trying to better understand your thoughts, as they contrast with mine somewhat. It's always nice to understand why someone thinks differently.
-
@50ft-trad said:
Wingman by an edge. But drop the pocket clip and its mp400. Ease of carry plays a big part. The 400 sheath is terrible. The 400 scissors cut much better. Drivers are easier to use on the wingman but you get more assortment on the 400. Wingmans pliers are more robust but that doesnt mean the 400's are a push over. They are just smaller. Overall it is close. Great thread

Interesting viewpoints.
What makes you say the Wingman pliers are more robust? In my eyes they are less durable than the MP400 's due to the hollow construction around the pivot to get the spring in. Are you referring more to the tips, or overall build?
Similarly on the drivers, what makes you feel the Wingman's are more usable? Better fit on the screws you encounter, or something else? I do like knowing the MP400 ones lock and I can use a bit adapter.
I'm not trying to pull you up on these issues, just trying to better understand your thoughts, as they contrast with mine somewhat. It's always nice to understand why someone thinks differently.
No problem. As far as pliers go overall build is more robust. Larger gripping area, the tips are a bit more precise, the cutters are stronger than they appear. They dont do as well with stranded wire but i cut down some spring nuts with ease. Very shocking to me.
With the drivers they are more comfortable in hand to use. You can seperate the handles on the wingman if need be, but with the 400 you are stuck with the box. Not bad, just inherent in the design.
Like I said it is very close. Ask me next week and I may say the 400 all the way. Tough call. Hope that helps
-
I think you know my thoughts on the matter. MP400/600 are the best multipliers hands down

-
@50ft-trad said:
Wingman by an edge. But drop the pocket clip and its mp400. Ease of carry plays a big part. The 400 sheath is terrible. The 400 scissors cut much better. Drivers are easier to use on the wingman but you get more assortment on the 400. Wingmans pliers are more robust but that doesnt mean the 400's are a push over. They are just smaller. Overall it is close. Great thread

Interesting viewpoints.
What makes you say the Wingman pliers are more robust? In my eyes they are less durable than the MP400 's due to the hollow construction around the pivot to get the spring in. Are you referring more to the tips, or overall build?
Similarly on the drivers, what makes you feel the Wingman's are more usable? Better fit on the screws you encounter, or something else? I do like knowing the MP400 ones lock and I can use a bit adapter.
I'm not trying to pull you up on these issues, just trying to better understand your thoughts, as they contrast with mine somewhat. It's always nice to understand why someone thinks differently.
No problem. As far as pliers go overall build is more robust. Larger gripping area, the tips are a bit more precise, the cutters are stronger than they appear. They dont do as well with stranded wire but i cut down some spring nuts with ease. Very shocking to me.
With the drivers they are more comfortable in hand to use. You can seperate the handles on the wingman if need be, but with the 400 you are stuck with the box. Not bad, just inherent in the design.
Like I said it is very close. Ask me next week and I may say the 400 all the way. Tough call. Hope that helps
Thanks for the additional info. I'll have to dig mine out to understand your perspectives I think.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login