Off-Brand Challenge - ETHEREALICER - Böker City Tool / SWIZA D04
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171323#msg1171323 date=1445795008]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171241#msg1171241 date=1445785477]
It looks like the scales gave up some material when erasing the pencil lines. That doesn't bode well for long time wear from hands/pockets IMOThat's how erasers work :D
I like the idea but you would need scales that are easily available and easily replaced.
Sorry Beat, I wasn't referring to it specifically in the function of an eraser (though in that sense it would beat the Business Tool to top spot for overpriced office consumables) ;) but more in respect of general durability. I can see those scales wearing alarmingly quickly if carried/used regularly just from hands and pockets and whatever else happens to be in the pockets....
It doesn't seem to hold much promise for a long working life to me :-\
I'm doing accelerated aging, by keeping it with my keys and whenever my hand is idle, fiddle with the keys and the knife in my pockets... Did that to the Böker and it held up nicely, now lets see the Swiza...
Yeah, yeah ::) we believe you :P
"No Officer, I wasn't doing that at all, I was just checking if my new pocket knife is wear resistant...."
Probably not going to get away with that one mate ;)
[/quote]

[/quote]I have honest eyes
-
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171332#msg1171332 date=1445795658]
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171323#msg1171323 date=1445795008]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171241#msg1171241 date=1445785477]
It looks like the scales gave up some material when erasing the pencil lines. That doesn't bode well for long time wear from hands/pockets IMOThat's how erasers work :D
I like the idea but you would need scales that are easily available and easily replaced.
Sorry Beat, I wasn't referring to it specifically in the function of an eraser (though in that sense it would beat the Business Tool to top spot for overpriced office consumables) ;) but more in respect of general durability. I can see those scales wearing alarmingly quickly if carried/used regularly just from hands and pockets and whatever else happens to be in the pockets....
It doesn't seem to hold much promise for a long working life to me :-\
I'm doing accelerated aging, by keeping it with my keys and whenever my hand is idle, fiddle with the keys and the knife in my pockets... Did that to the Böker and it held up nicely, now lets see the Swiza...
Yeah, yeah ::) we believe you :P
"No Officer, I wasn't doing that at all, I was just checking if my new pocket knife is wear resistant...."
Probably not going to get away with that one mate ;)
[/quote]

[/quote]I have honest eyes
[/quote]Just a pity about the rest of your face ;)

-
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171335#msg1171335 date=1445796027]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171332#msg1171332 date=1445795658]
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171323#msg1171323 date=1445795008]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171241#msg1171241 date=1445785477]
It looks like the scales gave up some material when erasing the pencil lines. That doesn't bode well for long time wear from hands/pockets IMOThat's how erasers work :D
I like the idea but you would need scales that are easily available and easily replaced.
Sorry Beat, I wasn't referring to it specifically in the function of an eraser (though in that sense it would beat the Business Tool to top spot for overpriced office consumables) ;) but more in respect of general durability. I can see those scales wearing alarmingly quickly if carried/used regularly just from hands and pockets and whatever else happens to be in the pockets....
It doesn't seem to hold much promise for a long working life to me :-\
I'm doing accelerated aging, by keeping it with my keys and whenever my hand is idle, fiddle with the keys and the knife in my pockets... Did that to the Böker and it held up nicely, now lets see the Swiza...
Yeah, yeah ::) we believe you :P
"No Officer, I wasn't doing that at all, I was just checking if my new pocket knife is wear resistant...."
Probably not going to get away with that one mate ;)
[/quote]

[/quote]I have honest eyes
[/quote]Just a pity about the rest of your face ;)

[/quote]At least people are certain I'm a deuterostome as it is easy to tell the two ends apart by sight / smell AND sound... -
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171332#msg1171332 date=1445795658]
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171323#msg1171323 date=1445795008]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171241#msg1171241 date=1445785477]
It looks like the scales gave up some material when erasing the pencil lines. That doesn't bode well for long time wear from hands/pockets IMOThat's how erasers work :D
I like the idea but you would need scales that are easily available and easily replaced.
Sorry Beat, I wasn't referring to it specifically in the function of an eraser (though in that sense it would beat the Business Tool to top spot for overpriced office consumables) ;) but more in respect of general durability. I can see those scales wearing alarmingly quickly if carried/used regularly just from hands and pockets and whatever else happens to be in the pockets....
It doesn't seem to hold much promise for a long working life to me :-\
I'm doing accelerated aging, by keeping it with my keys and whenever my hand is idle, fiddle with the keys and the knife in my pockets... Did that to the Böker and it held up nicely, now lets see the Swiza...
Yeah, yeah ::) we believe you :P
"No Officer, I wasn't doing that at all, I was just checking if my new pocket knife is wear resistant...."
Probably not going to get away with that one mate ;)
[/quote]

[/quote]I have honest eyes
[/quote]It's not your eyes they're going to be paying attention to :ahhh :ahhh
-
@50ft-trad said:
@50ft-trad said:
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171335#msg1171335 date=1445796027]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171332#msg1171332 date=1445795658]
[quote author=Etherealicer link=topic=62284.msg1171323#msg1171323 date=1445795008]
[quote author=50ft-trad link=topic=62284.msg1171241#msg1171241 date=1445785477]
It looks like the scales gave up some material when erasing the pencil lines. That doesn't bode well for long time wear from hands/pockets IMOThat's how erasers work :D
I like the idea but you would need scales that are easily available and easily replaced.
Sorry Beat, I wasn't referring to it specifically in the function of an eraser (though in that sense it would beat the Business Tool to top spot for overpriced office consumables) ;) but more in respect of general durability. I can see those scales wearing alarmingly quickly if carried/used regularly just from hands and pockets and whatever else happens to be in the pockets....
It doesn't seem to hold much promise for a long working life to me :-\
I'm doing accelerated aging, by keeping it with my keys and whenever my hand is idle, fiddle with the keys and the knife in my pockets... Did that to the Böker and it held up nicely, now lets see the Swiza...
Yeah, yeah ::) we believe you :P
"No Officer, I wasn't doing that at all, I was just checking if my new pocket knife is wear resistant...."
Probably not going to get away with that one mate ;)
[/quote]

[/quote]I have honest eyes
[/quote]It's not your eyes they're going to be paying attention to :ahhh :ahhh
[/quote]Yes, that Spirit RT is an eye-catcher
-
**Wisdom of the Day: **Those scales have a great feel to them... I find myself liking them :ahhh
-
@Etherealicer said:
**Wisdom of the Day: **Those scales have a great feel to them... I find myself liking them :ahhhMaybe when Vic buys these guys out too, they'll use the scale materials on the 91 line.
>:DOn a serious note, the scales seem cool (even though they are obviously not dishwasher safe - Vic's softgrip were kind of sucky), the locking system is cool (if it holds in time), I like replacing the short blade with an inline awl (even if a bit shoddy in design), the longer Philips and the tweezers design (even if they have the awful-awful Wenger grip). So a handful of nice ideas - I'd like to see put in something that oozes quality... be it Swiza or something else...
And yes there are also a zillion bad ideas in it, but I complained a lot about this without even handling one so I won't say anything bad until I actually hold one... anyone feel like donating one for... science?

-
Under Construction
Here you can see how the scales are attached. The white part has knobs going into the liners (see arrows).
The scales came off easily and were easy to re-attach. Apparently, we have a 4-pin construction. You can also spot the scale attachment points. The white plastic is stiffer and harder, whereas the blue part is rubbery.
So, if the lock button breaks, you can easily replace the scales. Its also super easy, because everything is ONE part, so no fiddling with bits and pieces.
Looking at the construction, I noticed a gap on either side of the blade-spring. The gap is wide enough to push a piece of paper through without problems. :ahhh
I find the tools sticking out of the frame problematic as it leads to a very uncomfortable grip. Still that might just be me. What I find unforgiving is how badly they use the space...



-
**Wisdom of the Day: **Those scales have a great feel to them... I find myself liking them :ahhh
Maybe when Vic buys these guys out too, they'll use the scale materials on the 91 line.
>:DOn a serious note, the scales seem cool (even though they are obviously not dishwasher safe - Vic's softgrip were kind of sucky), the locking system is cool (if it holds in time), I like replacing the short blade with an inline awl (even if a bit shoddy in design), the longer Philips and the tweezers design (even if they have the awful-awful Wenger grip). So a handful of nice ideas - I'd like to see put in something that oozes quality... be it Swiza or something else...
And yes there are also a zillion bad ideas in it, but I complained a lot about this without even handling one so I won't say anything bad until I actually hold one... anyone feel like donating one for... science?

Pros
The lock system is cool and scales are easy to replace, I was worried in the beginning but now I think it will hold up and once broken it's easily fixed.
I do like the scales and the frame shape, but wished the tools would not stick out that much.Cons
That hole in the blade is stupid, you cannot just wipe your blade after food preparation and the like.
The blade did not come sharp.
The back-layer Phillips is very pointy and does not work well on PH2 screws (it is advertised as PH1, but a bit of versatility would be desirable).
Back-spring on the can-opener is too weak -
@Etherealicer said:
Under Construction
Here you can see how the scales are attached. The white part has knobs going into the liners (see arrows).
The scales came off easily and were easy to re-attach. Apparently, we have a 4-pin construction. You can also spot the scale attachment points. The white plastic is stiffer and harder, whereas the blue part is rubbery.
So, if the lock button breaks, you can easily replace the scales. Its also super easy, because everything is ONE part, so no fiddling with bits and pieces.
Looking at the construction, I noticed a gap on either side of the blade-spring. The gap is wide enough to push a piece of paper through without problems. :ahhh
I find the tools sticking out of the frame problematic as it leads to a very uncomfortable grip. Still that might just be me. What I find unforgiving is how badly they use the space...The ergonomics is a big issue for me. How bad is it when the blade is open? Does the openers cause discomfort? With the blade closed it doesn´t matter much but of course open is a biggie.
About the paper going through I find thats possible on Victorinox as well.

-
Under Construction
Here you can see how the scales are attached. The white part has knobs going into the liners (see arrows).
The scales came off easily and were easy to re-attach. Apparently, we have a 4-pin construction. You can also spot the scale attachment points. The white plastic is stiffer and harder, whereas the blue part is rubbery.
So, if the lock button breaks, you can easily replace the scales. Its also super easy, because everything is ONE part, so no fiddling with bits and pieces.
Looking at the construction, I noticed a gap on either side of the blade-spring. The gap is wide enough to push a piece of paper through without problems. :ahhh
I find the tools sticking out of the frame problematic as it leads to a very uncomfortable grip. Still that might just be me. What I find unforgiving is how badly they use the space...The ergonomics is a big issue for me. How bad is it when the blade is open? Does the openers cause discomfort? With the blade closed it doesn´t matter much but of course open is a biggie.
About the paper going through I find thats possible on Victorinox as well.

I have only a CT41 with me (stored in my office desk), I cannot push paper through at any layers. Anyway, I put the paper in for visualization, because I'm unsure how well one can see the gap on a picture. Please note, that I can push paper through on both sides of the knife-backspring, so the wider gap is really wide! Because of its width, I noticed it in the first place. Its also something that might be unique to my Swiza and not general.
As for the comfort, for me it's the middle finger that lies uncomfortably on the cap-lifter, when using the blade.

-
I actually can get 3 layers of regular printing paper in (in the large gap). The folded piece is ripped to show that it is double.
I should probably point out that the blade is a liner-lock it technically does not need a back-spring!
So, this is cosmetic and probably a bit of quality/precision point.
-
@Etherealicer said:
I actually can get 3 layers of regular printing paper in (in the large gap). The folded piece is ripped to show that it is double.Wow, Thats a differnt story than Victorinox. You can barely squeeze a paper in on some layers but that is like ventilation vent. That could accumulate a lot of nasty stuff.
-
I actually can get 3 layers of regular printing paper in (in the large gap). The folded piece is ripped to show that it is double.
Wow, Thats a differnt story than Victorinox. You can barely squeeze a paper in on some layers but that is like ventilation vent. That could accumulate a lot of nasty stuff.
I should have made a new post instead of editing my previous :D
We should not forget that the blade is a liner-lock, so the spring is not essential, just reporting what I see

But you are probably right, good space for dirt to get comfortable -
Thanks for the pictures, Etherealicer! Frankly, I don't worry too much about those huge gaps. It means water has a way to get out when washing the knife in a dishwasher, which is one of the more unique features they advertise. Also, it is a good guarantee the backspring isn't so wide it causes bladeplay (which I have seen a couple of times in even rather expensive knives). I'm looking forward to testing a Swiza myself, there are several parts of the design I'm a little skeptical about, but I'll hold off judgement till I have a knife I can fiddle around with.
-
@Steinar said:
Thanks for the pictures, Etherealicer! Frankly, I don't worry too much about those huge gaps. It means water has a way to get out when washing the knife in a dishwasher, which is one of the more unique features they advertise. Also, it is a good guarantee the backspring isn't so wide it causes bladeplay (which I have seen a couple of times in even rather expensive knives). I'm looking forward to testing a Swiza myself, there are several parts of the design I'm a little skeptical about, but I'll hold off judgement till I have a knife I can fiddle around with.Yeah, it will also be interesting to hear an other perspective and have a larger sample group (one knife is statistically irrelevant).
I'm a bit torn. Dislike the way they market themselves (kinda playing at the underdog trying to get free of evil Victorinox) but I do like the scales.
Fun fact: It's the only MT I'm aware off where you can OHO the can-opener, but not the blade :D -
The back-layer Phillips is very pointy and does not work well on PH2 screws (it is advertised as PH1, but a bit of versatility would be desirable).
[/quote]


-
Thank you for doing this review Etherealicer!

-
A very thurough review!
Keep up the good work!Sent from a device made from star dust using tapatalk
-
Thanks guys, you are the best

I have it from a reliable source that soon a Swiza model with saw should be available.

Anyway, tonight the Swiza will have to face the dreaded can, afterwards it will be time to sharpen.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login