Leatherman Signal - A Bittersweet Offering?
-
Excellent write up Comis

There's nothing in there to change my mind about it, so my opinions thus far remain the same (probably reinforced actually). You did however do an excellent job of achieving as balanced a review as is possible

Could you clarify one point for me please? You say the pocket clip is convenient for carry though others may argue it's convenient to lose it. Is it due to a weak spring, lack of traction beneath it, ride height, or something else? I don't feel the Wave "grips" a pocket well, but on balance I still find it an enhancement to the tool, and it does make the tool more convenient at times. How does this one compare to such as a Wave?
-
Good review , thanks

-
-
[rant] Where to begin?
Ah, the knife blade. Not only has the knife blade a combo edge on it (and one with the wrong kind of pattern IMO), it seems it's akward to sharpen. Just what you need in a survival situation, in other words. By the way, I see some dark spots on the knife blade?
Pliers poking at you if you lose the whistle. Something's wrong there.
Awl comes blunt! A blunt awl always comes in handy!
No pry tool, but it has bit holder and hex driver and a hammer thingy of little use (to be honest it looks like it makes using the saw uncomfortable). Perfect for your everyday survival situation, all of this.
It has geographic coordinates stamped on it so you know where to dump it in Oregon?
Good thing they didn't paint the detachable bells and whistles in tactikool black. [/rant]

-
Thank you everyone reading and supporting this!
@dks It does look good, no question about it. That's probably what convinces me initially.
@NKlamerus Don't forget to put a link here!

@Zed Paul, I would then love to see you using it in your next camping trip, and keep us updated!
@kirk13 Personally, I love to see reviews that's subjective and real, than just lope sided praises or bashes. I hope I am doing it right.
@firiki Brother, do send them over to these gents. I love to see what they can do with them. >:D
@leatherman-shop.de Thanks for reading!
@50ft-trad Yikes, Bro, you got me there, and I just went to make a quick correction. What I meant is the carabiner clip is convenient, but also prone to losing gear. Just plain old Murphy's law, so as long it is not a locking biner, getting caught with something and losing the tool is just a matter of time. But you brought up the good point about the tool clip, and I just put my extra 2 cents in.

-
-
-
Thanks for the clarification comis
I may have partially misread it first time round 
-
-
Thank you,a proper review,and a damn good one at that

Oddly enough,it's done more to convince me that it's not a tool I want than all the other sabre rattling in the other threads.
+1
I kinda like the whole idea of the Signal. Its a bit sad that the plastic inserts are of inferior quality (leaking whistle on a new tool :ahhh).What I have learned from the Signal though is that I really, really want a MUT

-

Thank you,a proper review,and a damn good one at that

Oddly enough,it's done more to convince me that it's not a tool I want than all the other sabre rattling in the other threads.
+1
I kinda like the whole idea of the Signal. Its a bit sad that the plastic inserts are of inferior quality (leaking whistle on a new tool :ahhh).What I have learned from the Signal though is that I really, really want a MUT

Yes, the whistle does leak a little, and I have to fiddle with it to blow it 'loud'. Definitely not the same grade as my 4sevens 100db whistle, or our fellow MTO member Tofty's whistles(which is really well made in one-piece).
I don't have a MUT, and am not into firearm...still struggle on the fence about that one. Maybe I should start a thread to ask people to convince me not to have one... >:D

-
-

Thank you,a proper review,and a damn good one at that

Oddly enough,it's done more to convince me that it's not a tool I want than all the other sabre rattling in the other threads.
+1
I kinda like the whole idea of the Signal. Its a bit sad that the plastic inserts are of inferior quality (leaking whistle on a new tool :ahhh).What I have learned from the Signal though is that I really, really want a MUT

Yes, the whistle does leak a little, and I have to fiddle with it to blow it 'loud'. Definitely not the same grade as my 4sevens 100db whistle, or our fellow MTO member Tofty's whistles(which is really well made in one-piece).
I don't have a MUT, and am not into firearm...still struggle on the fence about that one. Maybe I should start a thread to ask people to convince me not to have one... >:D

Me neither, but if I can put something more useful (like a long awl) in place of the two firearm-specific tools, this could be an excellent tool... I was hoping for a civilian version of the Mut, but in lights of the Signal I'm worried that this is not going to happen.
-

Thank you,a proper review,and a damn good one at that

Oddly enough,it's done more to convince me that it's not a tool I want than all the other sabre rattling in the other threads.
+1
I kinda like the whole idea of the Signal. Its a bit sad that the plastic inserts are of inferior quality (leaking whistle on a new tool :ahhh).What I have learned from the Signal though is that I really, really want a MUT

Yes, the whistle does leak a little, and I have to fiddle with it to blow it 'loud'. Definitely not the same grade as my 4sevens 100db whistle, or our fellow MTO member Tofty's whistles(which is really well made in one-piece).
I don't have a MUT, and am not into firearm...still struggle on the fence about that one. Maybe I should start a thread to ask people to convince me not to have one... >:D

Me neither, but if I can put something more useful (like a long awl) in place of the two firearm-specific tools, this could be an excellent tool... I was hoping for a civilian version of the Mut, but in lights of the Signal I'm worried that this is not going to happen.
Wouldn't you think the bronze 'carbon scrapper' is already kinda a long awl? Or you want something shorter?
After re-seeing the MUT vid, I tend to think MUT is a much better designed tool suited for firearm maintenance(such as using the 'hammer' on the punch) than Signal for outdoor/camping. -
Comis thank you for this review. It's nice to see a balanced well thought out write up regardless of the outcome. It sure is a lovely looking tool however with the noted issues I do hope LM is listening. -
I have to mirror the feelings of many in this thread; I'm glad to have an impartial and reasonably detailed review of the Signal, but it has also further convinced me I don't really want one.
At this price point you could buy the fantastic Surge or a Victorinox MT, which I think have a much higher value.If someone gave me one, I'd probably play around with it while car/cabin camping and enjoy it well enough. And if the price comes down, significantly, it might not be a bad gift for the weekend outdoorsman in your life. Assuming he isn't a hardcore MT user or bushcrafter I suppose.
At any rate- good job, Comis!

-
-
-
@WoodsDuck said:
I have to mirror the feelings of many in this thread; I'm glad to have an impartial and reasonably detailed review of the Signal, but it has also further convinced me I don't really want one.
At this price point you could buy the fantastic Surge or a Victorinox MT, which I think have a much higher value.If someone gave me one, I'd probably play around with it while car/cabin camping and enjoy it well enough. And if the price comes down, significantly, it might not be a bad gift for the weekend outdoorsman in your life. Assuming he isn't a hardcore MT user or bushcrafter I suppose.
At any rate- good job, Comis!

Even though my review on Singal is short, but it does conculde that Wave is a better tool.

-
@Aloha007 I hope so too!

@WoodsDuck I have similar sentiment too, but am curious whether LM is playing their cards exactly the way we perceive it? Most 'bushcrafters' might already have those tools anyway, and price wise, it is not motivating enough at this point. So mostly for gifts/beginners? But what got me curious is, if, most bushcrafters/outdoorsmen won't really vote with their wallets, will people think this is a great gift for beginners as well?

@Kampfer Like you have reviewed in the LM subforum, I too think it might be a little too wide of practical use. I have an average hand, and if I were to spread the pliers to grab onto something, my hands could barely contain it to apply good force/torque. And come to think about it, if we were to argue this tool is mostly for 'outdoor/bushcraft' use, then the pliers might be more useful for picking up hot lids or grabbing onto hot pots...
@Sawman haha...I personally am a sucker for this kind of color theme.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login