firearms
-
I have to say, I prefer the revolver over the auto.
It is not due to the mechanic, but I like the precision of a revolver for that reason. Not so many moving parts. IMO the SA revolvers are repeating guns, so they are not that picky on ammunition like a semi-auto pistol.
The less moving parts... the better.
But I´m much more a rifleguy. Not that big fan of handguns either. Maybe a nice 686 someday... in some time...
Just my .02 Cent on this topic.
-
Their is one major reason I prefer a revolver over a semi auto. Reliability. I am in no way saying semi auto's are not reliable, but some are and some are not. Same goes for revolvers, but over the years I have had countless jams, failure to fires, stove piping, magazine not seated, ect. I have never had a failure to fire in a revolver. Never had a jam. Never had any problem with any revolver I have ever owned when referring to failure to function or fire. I also love that if you were in a serious situation and the cartridge was a dud there is no need to do a failure drill (forgot the name) to figure out whats wrong. If its a DA just pull the trigger again. If SA then cock and fire again. Simple is always the best in my opinion. Many less things to go wrong. I also do not like to carry in the front waistband (barrel is 1" from you "family jewels" with a round in the chamber on a semi. I know there are many safety features, but the fact is their is a loaded gun pointed at your junk and if a accident did happen your manhood would be blown away and most likely off. I do not fear this with revolvers. Carrying a semi without one in the chamber is not a option and could get you killed.
-
@ColoSwiss said:
Revolver vs. Auto?
I like 'em both!
I didn't want to start ish but here was a post not long ago saying revolvers were obsolete ( I may be wrong how it was phrased ). I disagreed and thought there were plenty of folk who still loved them. I like them and if I was a gun owner I'd certainly have one or 3
. -
Revolver vs. Auto?

I like 'em both!
I didn't want to start ish but here was a post not long ago saying revolvers were obsolete ( I may be wrong how it was phrased ). I disagreed and thought there were plenty of folk who still loved them. I like them and if I was a gun owner I'd certainly have one or 3
.Obsolete?!
Let me shoot the naysayer with an obsolete Model 19 .357 and you tell me how obsolete it is.
-
I love me some revolver. The revolver has never taken a back seat to an auto with me. A nice blue Smith is a beauty to behold. :)
Dan if you ever get a chance to fire a .500 Linebaugh with full house loads please do so. It a real exciting experience you wont soon forget. I think you may have found a handgun and round with enough recoil. :D Just thinking of firing one of those dinosaur slayers again almost makes my hand hurt. Getting soft in my old age. :D I dont even load my 45 Ruger Bisley very hot any more. I can push 310 to 340 gr SWC or LBT bullets around 1200 out of a 4 3/4" barrel with a healthy dose of H-110. But find my hand much preferrs the 1000 fps range much better.
-
I like both. I think since the advent of the wondernines in the 80's there are many autos that are über reliable. I've never seen a Glock, Beretta, CZ, HK, (non-Umarex) Walther or high end 1911 jam for any reason. I've seen a used Sig 357 jam once when dirty after a few magazines. I've also seen a 38 snub revolver fall apart when some part of the cylinder became unscrewed but also not until it had fired a cylinder full and was opened to reload.
I've seen bad ammo cause problems with both. Regarding the revolver high primers or thick rims can cause the cylinder to lock up.
There's no getting around the fact that autos hold more bullets.
I'm getting a Guncrafter with extra parts that will fire 9mm, 38 Super, and 9x23 Winchester.
-
I like both but shoot a 1911 much better.
Here's an unrelated ammo test pic of the Kit Gun just because....
-
Hmm, people saying revolvers are more reliable need to shoot them a lot more under pressure and in more varied conditions.
When a revolver jams you tend to need tools to get it going again.
Loading and unloading can introduce some serious jams if not done right. -
@shark_za said:
Hmm, people saying revolvers are more reliable need to shoot them a lot more under pressure and in more varied conditions.
When a revolver jams you tend to need tools to get it going again.
Loading and unloading can introduce some serious jams if not done right.I have personally never had ANY revolver I own jam or misfire. I have misfires or a jam frequently with semi's. The situation I am referring to has nothing to do with a reload so that is not even on the radar. In your "normal" situation where a CCW weapon is used (revo or semi) I have almost never seen a reload. I actually cannot recall a single event where a reload was done in such a situation. I have also never jammed a revolver reloading it in my entire life and i'm not just talking standard range time.
-
-
I like both but shoot a 1911 much better.
Here's an unrelated ammo test pic of the Kit Gun just because....
Excuse my ignorance,but why is it a Kit Gun?
It was a small light revolver you could throw in your kit bag for camping, fishing etc.
Ah! Thank you

I did wonder if it was a self build(I've seen self build black powder pistols before)
-
I am glad you asked...as I was wondering about that as well.
-
Thx CS!

:D -
My Dad had a S&W .22LR Kit Gun at one time; probably the first pistol I shot. He was darn good with it; saw him nail copperheads and cottonmouths with it on numerous occasions.
His Marlin 39 was probably the first rifle I shot.
-
@captain spaulding said:
Hmm, people saying revolvers are more reliable need to shoot them a lot more under pressure and in more varied conditions.
When a revolver jams you tend to need tools to get it going again.
Loading and unloading can introduce some serious jams if not done right.I have personally never had ANY revolver I own jam or misfire. I have misfires or a jam frequently with semi's. The situation I am referring to has nothing to do with a reload so that is not even on the radar. In your "normal" situation where a CCW weapon is used (revo or semi) I have almost never seen a reload. I actually cannot recall a single event where a reload was done in such a situation. I have also never jammed a revolver reloading it in my entire life and i'm not just talking standard range time.
Cappy I was and still am of a mind that a good revolver stoked with quality ammo wi go bang every time you pull the trigger.
That said I did have a second hand Smith Model 19 I was never able to get running right. Ended up returning it. Just put this out there in the interest of completeness I guess.
-
I have been shooting revolvers for over 20 years and love them but the reality where I live is multiple armed attackers so capacity and reloads are very important.
Not counting on a reload in a shootout is very short sighted; in sport shooting I have had a case slip back and fall under the ejector star, more than once, this is not easy to fix.
Unfired powder and grime also gets under the star making the revolver impossible to close.
Once a bullet pulled itself loose on recoil and bound up the cylinder. Not a tap rack fix.When a revolver goes wrong you need another gun. An auto can get back to shooting quite quickly.
-
@shark_za said:
I have been shooting revolvers for over 20 years and love them but the reality where I live is multiple armed attackers so capacity and reloads are very important.Not counting on a reload in a shootout is very short sighted; in sport shooting I have had a case slip back and fall under the ejector star, more than once, this is not easy to fix.
Unfired powder and grime also gets under the star making the revolver impossible to close.
Once a bullet pulled itself loose on recoil and bound up the cylinder. Not a tap rack fix.When a revolver goes wrong you need another gun. An auto can get back to shooting quite quickly.
Obviously in your scenario with multiple attackers a auto is a much better option no one is saying it isn't. What I am saying is for 99% of concealed carriers in the USA a single magazine or cylinder will almost always be enough. I agree you should ALWAYS anticipate a reload and have a speed clip or extra magazine or two at the ready, but for the 99% of people that carry everyday and never use their gun the reliability of a revolver outweighs the potential problems with a semi. Obviously you are bias towards semi's since multiple attackers is a possibility and reloads are almost guaranteed if the situation arouse. Most people do not have the same needs as you. Not to say one should not be prepared for such a situation, but its not a priority for the average guy carrying a gun.
Just to address one thing you mentioned about getting a auto back into action quickly. Yes sometimes a auto can be brought back with the standard tap and rack drill, but I have had a auto slip the barrel during recoil and jam the slide in the open position. The gun had to be taken to a gunsmith just to get the slide and barrel free. So not all autos can magically be fixed with a tap and rack. Also what happens if there is a cracked case and the case expands during ignition trapping itself in the barrel? This has happened to me as well. No amount of taping and racking will solve this. If this happened in a revolver just pull the trigger again and your good. What about a ejector failure. Not a ejection failure, but what if your ejector breaks? The gun is useless. There is arguments for both sides.
I am in no way saying you are wrong. If I was you I would carry a semi with two extra mags and a backup gun on top of that. Its all about specific needs and wants in a carry gun. Just my opinion.
-
Dan if you ever get a chance to fire a .500 Linebaugh with full house loads please do so. It a real exciting experience you wont soon forget. I think you may have found a handgun and round with enough recoil.
It is funny you should say that. I am now being gently prodded by a recoil fanatic fan of mine to buy a S&W500. The revolver is around 1200 dollars. I was thinking a little here and there on layaway and it should be mine in a few months. However, when I asked how much a box of 500 S&W magnums were, I was told 80 bucks for 20. That comes out to 4 dollars a round! Yeah, I left the gun exactly where it laid in the display case. Yikes!
As for me, I like both revolvers and semi-automatics.
-
Four dollars a round!
I could not afford to have guns as a hobby in Canada.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login