The Dremel (or clone ) Owners Club
-
I've always wanted that one to replace my clones. But as you said they are expensive! A dremel 4000 kit came up for half the price of the proxxon, so I ended up going with it instead, although I can't say it's actually any better made than the cheaper clones. ::)
well in Italy the difference in price between the dremel and the proxxon is not that much, with dremel you get some extra accessory for a similar price so it wasn't
that much more expensive. also there's a cheaper proxxon model as well.the dremel has several accessories (so many!) that proxxon doesn't have and on which they won't fit, but I thought I'd prefer quality material over them ;)
If they were similar in price I would go with proxxon assuming it actually has less shaft runout, the dremel attachments are mostly gimmick, I don't think I've ever used them and probably won't in the future.
-
@Aloha007 said:
Added another Dremel to my tools today. I got this one for $7 as it was missing all the accessories and the front cap. It works fine and my other dremel has complementary parts so I should be good to go. I'll check the brushes at another time but when tested it ran fine thru all speeds.I believe this is the model I have, and it's an awesome tool. I couldn't do without it. Nice score!
-
I currently own a 'clone' and it gets a lot of use. Planning to upgrade to the real thing this year sometime.
-
@mr626 said:
I currently own a 'clone' and it gets a lot of use. Planning to upgrade to the real thing this year sometime.Honestly unless your clone is a really cheap one, I wouldn't. My $40 clone works about as well as my dremel 4000 "upgrade". The latter has constant speed controller, which is nice, but that's about it. The most important part, shaft runout is about the same on both.
-
I currently own a 'clone' and it gets a lot of use. Planning to upgrade to the real thing this year sometime.
Honestly unless your clone is a really cheap one, I wouldn't. My $40 clone works about as well as my dremel 4000 "upgrade". The latter has constant speed controller, which is nice, but that's about it. The most important part, shaft runout is about the same on both.
Thanks for the advice, but mine is a 'really cheap' one. It really will be an upgrade.
-
I might as well jump in head first for my first post.
Been part of this club for a while know. My first rotary tool was a Black and Decker Wizard VP940 (Cordless, used the versapak batteries), which I used for 2 or 3 years before it croaked.
My second rotary tool was/is a cheapo Harbor Freight single speed that I bought about 10 or so years ago, it still works and I still use it on occasion (most recently the other day to do some engraving in some stones since I have more diamond tipped engraving bits that are 3/32" shafts and my newer rotary tool doesn't have a collet that will hold them yet).
The newer one I just got back in October, also from Harbor Freight. This one is a variable speed rotary tool and can accept attachments such as a flex shaft, the Dremel Plunge Router attachment, the Dremel Blade sharpener attachments,, etc... I have the flex shaft, and the mini saw attachment along with router bits on the top of my to buy list so I can build the table saw/router/shaper over on instructables. I have the improvised safety guard from instuctables along with a bunch of the bottle cap cutting blades (to cut plastic rods and plastic model sprues for use in miniature wargaming kitbashes). I have also made a number of abrasive buffing wheels from some green scouring pads.
I plan on getting the Harbor Freight Cordless Variable Speed Rotary Tool in addition to the two tools I already have. Thisb one will be mainly used when I am not at home or near a power outlet.
Will try to get pics posted as soon as I can.
-
I nearly destroyed my Dremel a while back trying to get a tool out of the chuck. I wrenched on it for 15 minutes and even got the pliers out to hold the bottom down. Turns out I was tightening not loosening.
I have no idea why I did this as I have never been so idiotic about something like that. It still works, but is acting strange. I don't trust it to hold a bit properly. I'm such a idiot. 
-
@captain spaulding said:
I nearly destroyed my Dremel a while back trying to get a tool out of the chuck. I wrenched on it for 15 minutes and even got the pliers out to hold the bottom down. Turns out I was tightening not loosening.Ouch, was it the keyless chuck or the stock collet and collet nut? Only experience I have right now is with the collet and collet nut, though I do have the keyless chuck (along with the flex shaft, mini saw, extra bits for engraving, carving and grinding etc...) on my rotary tool items get with tax returns list, the cordless rotary tool might be thrown on that list (bonus is the one from Harbor Freight I am looking at comes with a flex shaft, so if I order one I will have two, one for each tool).
Just need to find someone I know who has the tools for wood working since I have the Shopnotes Plans for the Rotary Tool Cabinet (Issue 124) and the Rotary Tool Storage Case (issue 67). I just don't know yet what one I would want to build, probably the cabinet, though I would be probably putting a handle on it like the storage case so I could take it on the go. If I leave out the dust box on the bottom, the space where it slides in looks like it is a bit larger then the Table Saw/Router/Shaper table (will hence forth call it the 3-in-1 table for ease of typing) that I grabbed the plans for off of Instructable (which if reading the plans correctly you can using only a rotary tool, a screwdriver and a hobby/x-acto knife, if you have the place where you purchase the wood cut it to size), if this is the case and I do built the cabinet, the dustbox space will be for the 3-in-1 table (the side extension will probably be stored elsewhere if I do use the dust box slot as for 3-in-1 table.
-
as promised the pics of my rotary tools, had to retake them as the originals where 5+MB each.
The first pic is of the old single speed rotary tool from Harbor Freight, this was about about 12 years ago (2003 or so), and still runs, though after dropping it on a hard floor it is a little louder now. Currently this is the tool I use for engraving since all my engraving bits are 3/32" shafts, and the collets for this won't fit into the newer rotary tool as they have a larger outer diameter then the newer tools collets.
The second pic is of the newer rotary tool, also from Harbor Freight, this one as previously mentioned was purchased Oct. 2015. This is one while it does have two engraving bits that came with it, is used for cutting sanding, buffing and polishing. Have used this to cut a padlock that had the key break off in it off of a trailer, cutting parts of of pewter gaming miniatures for kitbashing into new poses, sharpening my hunting/survival knife's blade, sharpening a hand ax and a machete, polishing some old silver, and trimming the nails of my parents dogs. Whats nice about this tool is it can accept the Dremel attachments like the router base, flex shaft, blade sharpening guides, etc...
The third pic is of some homemade items for the new rotary tool, the instructions were found over on Instructables. They are bottle cap cutting wheels (using these for cutting balsa wood, plastic rods and plastic model sprues for use in wargame scenery building/kitbashing) and a cutting shield for use with the actual store bought cut-off wheels. I also have a bunch of abrasive buffing wheels made out of the green Scotch Bright scouring pads.



-
Since my Brothers Dremel 3000 has a stripped Shaft Lock pin (along with the lock holes on the shaft having grooved going from each hole from the shaft lock pin gouging them), I currently have all his accessories, and his Multi-purpose Cutting attachment.
Tried the Multi-Purpose Cutting attachment on my Chicago Electric Variable Speed Rotary Tool, to confirm that I can use Dremel attachments on the Rotary Tool without any problems, it fits perfectly. This is good news since I ordered the Dremel Lawnmower, Garden Tool and Chainsaw Sharpening Kit (Dremel item/model #A679-02) along with a Flex Shaft (non-Dremel flex shaft).
I also took the two collets I have for the Single Speed rotary tool I have and using the variable Speed rotary tool with the sanding drum and a sanding band, I have ground the outside diameter of the shaft of the two collets down enough for them to fit into the variable speed rotary tool (they still work in the single speed , which will now be used as an emergency backup rotary tool). So i know have the 1/8th in collet and the 1/16th in collet that came with the variable speed tool, along with the 3/32" collet and the 1/32" collet from the single speed tool that I can use in the variable speed tool (which means I can now use all the diamond tipped engraving cutters that have a 3/32" shaft that I have in the variable speed tool).
Also including pics, one of the Multi-Purpose Cutter attachment on the variable speed tool and one of my handiwork on the two collets from the single speed tool.


-
I start to have so much dremel spare parts for my clone that easy to move to dremel some day. Diamond disc is cheap one though.

-
@temo said:
I start to have so much dremel spare parts for my clone that easy to move to dremel some day. Diamond disc is cheap one though.
While nice, Dremels to me are over priced, especially when the clones do the same job and perform just the same (in some cases they can perform better). Same goes for the accessories, when buying the Dremel brand ones you are paying for the name, it doesnt matter if the sanding bands are Dremel or a no name 3rd party, they perform the same (even if you use a couple 3rd party bands for every 1 Dremel band I still view it as a better option financially as you can get 100 3rd party bands for roughly $10 where the Dremel bands are about $8 for 6 bands). Same goes for other consumables such as cutting discs, sanding discs, felt polishing wheels, etc... Right now I have coming from China an order of 60 sanding bands with drum mandrels (they are 80 grit. 20 are 1/2", 20 are 3/8" and 20 are 1/4" along with 1 drum mandrel for each band size) that I payed $2.55 on the way (along with a flex shaft) and when my tax return comes in I will be ordering additional rotary tool accessories, such as polishing wheels, a couple accessory sets (such as a 216pcs set that includes 4 spare collets and a spare combination wrench tool, and a 90pcs felt polishing wheel kit that has a selection of 1' wheels. 1/2" wheels, points, mandrels, and polishing compound).
On another not I did discover that while Harbor Freight doesnt offer replacement carbon motor brushes I can use the Dremel 90930-04 Carbon Motor Brushes (the ones used in the Dremel 3000) in my Rotary Tool. Discovered this when I had my brothers Dremel 3000 apart to see what parts he would need to replace, and decided to compare the motor brushes, as they looked to be the same size (other then the height due to wear from usage) put both of his tools brushes into my tool to see if they would work.
-
My take is that Dremel does make better accessories but as Eldorf notes they are a bit to expensive. Surprisingly the Proxxon accessories are cheaper than the Dremel here but I haven't tried them (Proxxon seems like quality tools though). I got a bunch of accessories with my Dremel and the holder for the sanding drums is far better then the clones (and works with off-brand drums, might be a way ). Another way is to make your own drums, that way you could use whatever grit you want and get higher quality cheaper, guides are out there.
Another trick I saw for removing larger volumes of metal was to use multiple cutting wheels at the same time, just stick three on and supposedly they hold up better and wont break as easily and wear slower.
Right now I have a Dremel 300 after my cheap clone bit the dust (metal dust shorted it). If this one breaks one day I'll probably go Proxxon since I'm hearing lot's of good about them.
-
Agree. Dremel is a brand and costs more then some not brand products. Again some cheaper ones don't always inform max rpm etc. Can be as good as dremel in use or some are worse. And agree as well that dremel has a good selection of accessories. So you could build quite compact workshop if not having room for bigger tools.
-
@temo said:
Again some cheaper ones don't always inform max rpm etc. Can be as good as dremel in use or some are worse.For the non-Dremel accessories, I use the recommended Dremel speeds, that can be found in thier user manuals (the different spped tables can also be found at the links provided in this blog post http://blueroofdesigns.com/2015/11/30/dremel-speeds-artists/ in addition to this post she has some great posts for tips on working with different materials and what the variosu accessories are)
-
Tx. Yes was just thinking that there are similar accessories for drills as well which have less rpm. So don't know is ot ok to run example 30k speed if stone has max 15k. Btw did run to one test while googled around:
Anyway my machine did cost maybe 20-30€ and still going 'strong'. Most accessories I have broken that tool had with it
-
I love my black & decker RTX. Variable speed up to 30000rpm I believe, and the collet holds everything ive needed so far. I mainly use it for chainsaw sharpening. Went back and forth between this and the dremel 3k, so far im happy[emoji106]
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I own a Dremel and a Craftsman rotary tool. I like both.
-
@temo said:
http://www.popularmechanics.com/home/tools/reviews/g1255/can-anyone-top-the-dremel-6-rotary-tools-tested/?Sweet Chicago Electric Variable Speed Rotary Tool scored the same as the Black and Decker RTX, 4 Stars, plus out of the lot it is also the least expensive.
The Craftsman 32690 (which got 3 1/2 stars) looks a lot like the Dremel 3000, which makes me wonder if it is actually a rebranded Dremel, I know I have read a couple times that the Craftman power tools are just rebranded/rebadged tools made by other manufacturers under contract.
-
When I got the mail today I had a package sitting there in the mailbox. It was a flex shaft and some sanding bands (they are 60 bands, 20 bands and one drum mandrel of each size- 1/4", 3/8" and 1/2" 80grit bands along with) that I ordered (the projected delivery date was Feb 20-Mar6 since it was coming from China). Total order was about $10, $7.79 for the flex shaft and $2.55 for the 60 sanding bands w/mandrels.
Of course have pics:
Pic 1- Flex Shaft in my Rotary Tools case
Pic 2 Flex Shaft attached to Rotary Tool
Pic 3 Flex Shaft end with a Diamond engraving bit showing how to lock the shaft in place for changing the bits
Pic 4 Sanding Bands and Drum Mandrels (right now have the sanding bands nested in larger bands, so there's a 1/4" band in a 3/8" band which is in a 1/2 in band)



Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login