New Ghostbusters
-
-
@magentus said:
Why should non male, non white people have to grow up without seeing positive role models on their screens?They don't. The world of media, entertainment, politics and sports is replete with every flavor of humanity. More important, though, I would contend that rather than counting genders and colors, we should judge people by the content of their character. When we engage in the counting game, we have already lost.
And back to my thesis, Ghostbusters is just a dumb - though hopefully entertaining - movie, with no social significance.
I'm organizing a Ghost Lives Matter movement. Until ghostly apparitions are portrayed as positive role models on the big screen, and proportionately represented with Oscar nominations, a vigorous campaign on social media will ensue. The "B" word ("busters") is an antiquated, anti-apparitional term from the past which should soon find its rightful place on the dung heap of history. Ghosts are people too. In fact, they are the most ethereal and vulnerable among us, and they deserve to be treated with dignity and respect. Transparent is the new black.
-
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?
@powernoodle said:
And back to my thesis, Ghostbusters is just a dumb - though hopefully entertaining - movie, with no social significance.This may well be the case with Ghostbusters. Other films/shows can have different impact on how people view themselves, others, reality. Senator J.McCarthy knew that...
-
-
@firiki said:
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?Honestly, I think it would have been a great success as a game too... What made that game great was the way you could move without complicated steering, IMO it was a milestone for 3D games in the way Prince of Persia was for 2D (and that one also got a movie adaptation).
-
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?
Honestly, I think it would have been a great success as a game too... What made that game great was the way you could move without complicated steering, IMO it was a milestone for 3D games in the way Prince of Persia was for 2D (and that one also got a movie adaptation).
Agreed, Tom Raider opened up new worlds in gaming but I still think Lara played a part too.
-
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?
Ahem: Indiana Jones, Alan Quartermaine, Jack Colton (Romancing the Stone), The Librarian, Nate Drake (Uncharted), George Stobbart (Broken Sword)

Sorry, I'm not following you?
They are all "male Lara Crofts"... Tomb-raiding, jumping, adventuring, puzzle-solving characters...
-
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?
Ahem: Indiana Jones, Alan Quartermaine, Jack Colton (Romancing the Stone), The Librarian, Nate Drake (Uncharted), George Stobbart (Broken Sword)

Sorry, I'm not following you?
They are all "male Lara Crofts"... Tomb-raiding, jumping, adventuring, puzzle-solving characters...
Precisely why I think Lara Croft was a notable exception; the game would have been a success anyway for the reasons Etherealicer mentioned but didn't she offer that little extra something?
-
And Sydney Fox was another female Lara Croft.
The point was why would you turn Lara Croft to male or have Indiana Jones to be male... if the character was established some way.
My favourites are the sequels which added other-sex additional characters: Broken Sword 2-5 added Nico and the Librarians added Eve and Cassandra without genderbending the original character...
-
[quote author=firiki link=topic=65094.msg1238468#msg1238468 date=1457523064]
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?Ahem: Indiana Jones, Alan Quartermaine, Jack Colton (Romancing the Stone), The Librarian, Nate Drake (Uncharted), George Stobbart (Broken Sword)

Sorry, I'm not following you?
They are all "male Lara Crofts"... Tomb-raiding, jumping, adventuring, puzzle-solving characters...
Precisely why I think Lara Croft was a notable exception; the game would have been a success anyway for the reasons Etherealicer mentioned but didn't she offer that little extra something?
[/quote]Not back then... I mean he was quite triangular, if she hugs a smaller person she decapitates him...
-
[quote author=Corwyn link=topic=65094.msg1238521#msg1238521 date=1457527766]
[quote author=firiki link=topic=65094.msg1238468#msg1238468 date=1457523064]
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?Ahem: Indiana Jones, Alan Quartermaine, Jack Colton (Romancing the Stone), The Librarian, Nate Drake (Uncharted), George Stobbart (Broken Sword)

Sorry, I'm not following you?
They are all "male Lara Crofts"... Tomb-raiding, jumping, adventuring, puzzle-solving characters...
Precisely why I think Lara Croft was a notable exception; the game would have been a success anyway for the reasons Etherealicer mentioned but didn't she offer that little extra something?
[/quote]Not back then... I mean he was quite triangular, if she hugs a smaller person she decapitates him...
[/quote]:D True but I should think that was a minor detail back then. Her soft voice and the tender emotions she aroused made her lovable to men, is how I see it. Women also liked her as she was a strong character, according to the one female gamer I've ever met.
-
I'd say Lara Croft is a perfectly good role model for women, strong, smart, independent etc etc. I'm not so certain that, having only watched the trailer mind you, that I can say the same of the female Ghostbusters. So far they look like buffoons to me, and I'm not sure anyone, male or female, should look at that and think "yeah, I want to be like one of them". The original male Ghostbuster on the other hand were cool. A little geeky perhaps, but not ridiculous.
I will say that I do think there is a huge gender bias in cinema and that far more strong female leading roles are needed, not just tacked onto a male lead, but heading up the film in their own right. Also they need to go to someone other than just Angelina Jolie and Scarlett Johansson to star.
-
Hmm. I wonder, if Lara Croft were Larry Croft, would the appeal still be the same?
Ahem: Indiana Jones, Alan Quartermaine, Jack Colton (Romancing the Stone), The Librarian, Nate Drake (Uncharted), George Stobbart (Broken Sword)

Sorry, I'm not following you?
They are all "male Lara Crofts"... Tomb-raiding, jumping, adventuring, puzzle-solving characters...
Oook? Ook oookkk Oook! Eeek eeekk!
Oook

-
@Corwyn said:
And Sydney Fox was another female Lara Croft.The point was why would you turn Lara Croft to male or have Indiana Jones to be male... if the character was established some way.
My favourites are the sequels which added other-sex additional characters: Broken Sword 2-5 added Nico and the Librarians added Eve and Cassandra without genderbending the original character...
Sydney Fox came after Lara ;) I liked that show.
In some cases I can see how a gender swap could make sense (for example a strong male character made female could show that not all strong women are bitches but rather they do what they must in a man's world -I feel they're often viewed this way) but in the case at hand with Ghostbusters I feel such a swap probably doesn't add much.
I mean the old Ghostbusters are great, this new one seems like milking old merchandise 'cause we've run out of fresh ideas, 'cause everybody is doin' it, 'cause nostalgia might lure some people in -hey, I know, let's make these new Ghostbusters female, just 'cause, yeah why not, that'd be fun... Still, I have to actually see the film to form an opinion.
Gareth sums up my thoughts nicely (thank you
) and I agree with you, Corwyn, that adding opposite sex characters is fine. I like good duets :) -
@Gareth said:
I'd say Lara Croft is a perfectly good role model for women, strong, smart, independent etc etc. I'm not so certain that, having only watched the trailer mind you, that I can say the same of the female Ghostbusters. So far they look like buffoons to me, and I'm not sure anyone, male or female, should look at that and think "yeah, I want to be like one of them". The original male Ghostbuster on the other hand were cool. A little geeky perhaps, but not ridiculous.I will say that I do think there is a huge gender bias in cinema and that far more strong female leading roles are needed, not just tacked onto a male lead, but heading up the film in their own right. Also they need to go to someone other than just Angelina Jolie and Scarlett Johansson to star.
I like Gina Carano in Haywire and "In the Blood" (not so much in Deadpool, that kind of combat did not suit her).
There are many more Michelle Rodrigues, Milla Jovovich, Kate Beckinsale...
Personally, I always felt that women are not so popular in action movies because they do not commit like men do (meaning there are very few women who actually choose a career as action lady). You go watch a Jason Staham movie you are going to get action go watch a Keira Knigthly movie and you might get Pirates of the Caribbean or
AbominationAtonement, Fantasy, Drama, Action, Romance... -
I'd say Lara Croft is a perfectly good role model for women, strong, smart, independent etc etc. I'm not so certain that, having only watched the trailer mind you, that I can say the same of the female Ghostbusters. So far they look like buffoons to me, and I'm not sure anyone, male or female, should look at that and think "yeah, I want to be like one of them". The original male Ghostbuster on the other hand were cool. A little geeky perhaps, but not ridiculous.
I will say that I do think there is a huge gender bias in cinema and that far more strong female leading roles are needed, not just tacked onto a male lead, but heading up the film in their own right. Also they need to go to someone other than just Angelina Jolie and Scarlett Johansson to star.
I like Gina Carano in Haywire and "In the Blood" (not so much in Deadpool, that kind of combat did not suit her).
There are many more Michelle Rodrigues, Milla Jovovich, Kate Beckinsale.
Personally, I always felt that women are not so popular in action movies because they do not commit like men do (meaning there are very few women who actually choose a career as action lady). You go watch a Jason Staham movie you are going to get action go watch a Keira Knigthly movie and you might get Priates of the Carribean or
AbominationAtonement, Fantasy, Drama, Action, Romance...Run Lola Run is a perfect example of a great action movie starring a woman. In fact it's a near enough perfect film!
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

