Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
Here are the Bios and items each chose to take.
http://www.history.com/shows/alone/cast -
thought one was a wave and one was a surge. well the Surge might have an advantage since the file can be taken off and used to touch up it's own blade
-
I wonder if they came here for ideas
. Be neat if they did and would check in and let us know. -
Cool! Larry Roberts is in it. Hope he makes it pretty far.
That's us mobile
-
got extra info on the man?
-
I see from their lists several are taking foods. I would also considering the first few day the last thing I'd want to deal with is hunger. Getting that shelter squared away and a fire are going to be essential as we saw.
-
@Aloha007 said:
I see from their lists several are taking foods. I would also considering the first few day the last thing I'd want to deal with is hunger. Getting that shelter squared away and a fire are going to be essential as we saw.well they do have the advantage of knowing what to expect to some degree since the first season has been out for a while.
got extra info on the man?
Just a small time you tuber. You see him and Justin Wolfe do some vids together.
That's us mobile
outside of Alan last season, i wasn't aware of the other yt guys so no wonder i don't know him
-
WOW what a 1st day. I won't spoil it for those who haven't yet seen the episode.
Holy smurf is all I can say, it's not quite what I would have expected.
-
Forgot it was on, must fine and watch now. :ahhh
-
Thanks for the heads-up!

I assume they only air the show once it's over and done with?
Can you imagine if a few guys just keep going :D -
i could imagine it but it was somewhat crazy that last year a few contestants said they were getting ready for 6 months and even a year but the winner was decided in 56 days. should make us all wonder how much we overestimate ourselves. although the validity argument can be made because of a limit on gear choices and weight limit of that same gear (no need to take it into account since one will be predominantly sedentary)
-
Limited gear plus environment greatly reduce ones overall endurance to last. I'd imagine in that environment even a rifle would have not been much help
.I've never hunted but I also wonder even under more ideal weather conditions what hunting would be like?
Alan ( winner from last year ) appeared to fare decently. Keep in mind he is a very large man 6'6 and must have "required" a lot more calories than a smaller man.
I am still surprised how spooked some are regarding predators. I guess those who go out in the wild with firearms feel better if they run across one.
Not comparing naked and afraid necessarily but they last 21 days with next to nothing. I wonder what if any is "scripted" on that show. We know a camera crew follows those survivalist however I cannot imagine any help is given.
The weather is a huge factor for the cast of Alone tho its still very much a metal challenge as well.
-
With naked and afraid, I think the big factor is that they have an immediate safety net. So while they are required to last 21 days it is also a limited number of days
-
I've been thinking about something. The contestants step off the boat on the morning of the first day and they're fresh, full of energy and enthusiasm, and their bellies are full. How come none of them immediately commenced to cutting down small trees to build a sturdier shelter or cut themselves a sharpened pole to use as a defensive weapon? It's what I would have done as soon as I had determined my shelter location.
-
getting overwhelmed and thinking about other resources like water?
-
I think they all have solid plans but when they hit the beach and see the boat leaving they get a big EFFING reality check.
Now the emotions come flooding in and once any shred of doubt comes in panic sets in.
Most people in their day to day lives don't live in panic. The voices within telling them what they NEED to do vs what they had envisioned caused more confusion for some.
The dude who wasted all that energy to see if he could find a better site, the lady who failed to secure her tarp so as not to wet her down bag. These simple stupid mistakes cost big time. Just like last year when they guy lost his ferro rod and tapped. How about the guy last year who drank the water and then later that night started having visions.
This group had the "benefit" of watching last years mistakes and successes. You would think they would know to get a shelter up and get fire going. Next on the list is find water and set up some sort of "security".
I've got nothing but respect for these folks but in some cases I too wonder WTF.
-
it goes like shower arguments vs actual arguments with people. we all know what to say, have the perfect responses and could be defined by most of the positive superlatives when going over things in our head. but when we actually need to have a discussion, it's not necessarily that it all comes out. and even if it does, it often looks and sounds incomprehensible as opposed to the original idea.
I do wonder if there is a way of preparing oneself for the mental aspect of that reality check.
-
@styx said:
it goes like shower arguments vs actual arguments with people. we all know what to say, have the perfect responses and could be defined by most of the positive superlatives when going over things in our head. but when we actually need to have a discussion, it's not necessarily that it all comes out. and even if it does, it often looks and sounds incomprehensible as opposed to the original idea.I do wonder if there is a way of preparing oneself for the mental aspect of that reality check.
Yes I do believe there are ways to emotionally and mentally prepare. Life and ones experience would play a part as well. Depending on how each has dealt with those life's situations are important. I think early on when the reality has struck it not so much about skill per se. What hits them in the face are emotions and their natural inclinations toward them, in a way emotions have memory.
Stressful situations may have some curl up while others coil up. Think fetal position vs snake ready to strike. Its kinda like the fight or flight mentality when faced with threats. The difference is the threat is part imagined and part reality. The imagined is where we see those began to get really worked up. The deep recesses of our mind is a scary place.
Mentally many have relied on others to fill in where needed, the soldiers are well skilled and trained yet they have other skilled and trained colleagues watching their backsides.
The survivalist while also skilled and trained rarely place themselves in situations where they are testing their skills to this level of even close.
Taking nothing away from anyone of these people at all mind you. The guy who tapped out said it himself. A survivalist would truly only know how good his/her skill was after they have survived a circumstance.
Emotions are a rollercoaster so for these folks such high highs followed by low lows in short spans of time has got to be brutal.
The fascination for me is not so much how they survive its more the emotional and mental hurdles they overcome.
We saw this played out with Alan. His conversations to me were interesting to hear and watch unfold. He seemed to get stronger IMO mentally as the day wore on. The young man also went thru similar mental and emotional battles. He seemed to ebb and flow emotionally more than Alan. I enjoyed watching the dude who built the yurt go thru his rollercoaster and working it out at times. He as we saw ultimately came to the conclusion he had accomplished all he came to do.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login