Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
Very much as I see it.I cannot imagine how difficult it is to get friction fire going in those conditions so I am in no way arm chair quarterbacking nor criticizing.
I have respect for him and the others who are on the show.
I guess looking at these people who are instructors or "experts" I'd expect more. I know the term and title survivalist has been watered way down.
Maybe to bottom line is they are only as proficient as the gear they have. It's not a bad thing at all and probably more than I could do. Its just some would have you believe they could survive for months in the wild.
I believe I heard a cast member say he planned on being out there a year and another for several months
.This is why I hold Matt Graham is high regard. This dude has long term survival on his mind and lives it.
-
In the first season I think Wayne had at least 6 months in mind and Joe had about a year. Maybe it was reversed so don't quote me on it. They didn't fare all to well.
Reality is that I could say I can stay there for the next 10 years, but that would have to include 9 years and 360 days of a cougar chewing on my bones ;)
Maybe the practice what you preach approach would be a good reminder for everyone. And then practice just about everything else what others preach. We've seen it on other shows where one style has an edge but gets complemented by knowledge of other styles (if there are specific styles of survival).
As the next fire mentality goes, I've remembered that at a certain time Dave Canterbury was really going off on it in every video he made.
Another thought if the person with axe problems (not to spoil things) really isn't used to axes, then wouldn't another tool have been a wiser choice? If it's allowed ofc. One can't really expect to take down huge trees, so something like a parang might have worked well.
-
I was cringing so hard when I saw that girl using the axe to split kindling AND HOLDING HER HAND UNDER THE AXE HEAD... and then it slips...

Rule 1 of using sharp things is keep your body parts out of the way of the sharp things.
At least she didnt chop off a finger. Tendons can be repaired, but that would mean shes out if she did that much damage.
-
@styx said:
Another thought if the person with axe problems (not to spoil things) really isn't used to axes, then wouldn't another tool have been a wiser choice? If it's allowed ofc. One can't really expect to take down huge trees, so something like a parang might have worked well.I was thinking the same thing. How useful is an axe if they weren't planning on cutting down huge trees. Especially concerning David Mcintyre (who we know as Colhane on YouTube). He's a machete Guru from his 15 years of teaching in Brazil. He's probably the machete Guru. Even Dave Canterbury sharpens his machetes following Mcintyre's (Colhane's) example. So... why did he bring an axe? Why did any of them.
Most people who live around hard wood forests are probably more familiar with axes than machetes and are comfortable in their ability to use them, and they have to have something to process firewood and construct a shelter so I guess they would bring what they are comfortable with.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVHeKNbRXgc -
I guess it's still the mentality of "whole lotta trees, better bring an axe". But it doesn't make a whole lot of sense from an experience point. While it might look silly McIntyre is an excellent example of use what you're comfortable with and make it work.
For instance a large knife would work too. Sure it would take longer and one would exert himself or herself more but it would work as shown in the video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ow43SFOUUuYAnother option could be a tomahawk. While again not ideal in the conventional sense, I remember there being a guy who made a very nice camp with just a cold steel norse hawk and either a bucksaw or a bowsaw.
http://www.americangrouch.com/2011/12/norse-hawk-camp.htmlThat would round out the tool part of the equation. If allowed by the rules - why simply not go for the best tool you know how to use?
The other part is technique. While axe technique can be discussed at length, a lot of it has to do with better energy transfer. The safety part is rather short since tips apply all around. however people rarely mention the use of a sissy stick or batoning with an axe since it's so much cooler, and might be easier, to swing it. The injury we saw was rather light in comparison to seeing a guy almost split his foot in 2 (won't link to that). And this was a guy who at least on paper was quite proficient in axe use. The lucky part was that it happened at a meet so he was rushed to a hospital -
@Syph007 said:
I was cringing so hard when I saw that girl using the axe to split kindling AND HOLDING HER HAND UNDER THE AXE HEAD... and then it slips...
Rule 1 of using sharp things is keep your body parts out of the way of the sharp things.
At least she didnt chop off a finger. Tendons can be repaired, but that would mean shes out if she did that much damage.
I just watch the episode last night and thought the same thing. I wonder why she did not familiarize herself with an axe knowing she was going to take one out there.
Kinda feel sorry for the one guys ferro rod that burned up. Simple mistake that could have been avoided, but being tried and hungry didn't help him any. I thought it was pretty ingenious of him to look at his past recordings to help find it or figure out what happened to it. Hopefully he has been drying some wood out so he can try a friction fire. Though, I bet using that method is nigh impossible in that area. Hell I can't do that method most of the time in good dry conditions. There is a reason why man dropped that method hundreds of not thousands of years ago for banging two rocks to together and later Flint and steel. Speaking of, I am kinda surprised that nobody has made any charred punk wood yet. Mitch from season 1 did that early on and it helped him from using up his ferro rod so much and made making fire easier. But that is assuming this group watched season 1. But alas, we all know what assuming does. It make an ass out of U and me.
Now of coarse it is easy to set in my chair while watching this, and say this or that, I am not there and I am sure I would make some mistakes too and for sure it has be one hell of a mind job, but the using an axe like that...
Anyways, best of luck to them.That's us mobile
-
Not knowing if any has watched the previous show however familiarizing yourself with the tools you will be using seems reasonable. As far as making mistakes that too is reasonable even for the most seasoned individual.
It takes courage to get out there so yes big props to all those who were determined to do so.
Its hard to not come off as critical and I'm trying not to. I am in no position nor am I second guessing what they did out there. As to the people who get paid to do this or who claim to have years of experience I'm just surprised.
Stepping away from this show for a sec, I don't recall Matt Graham even stumble with what to do. I know the situation and show was totally different but man what a deep "tool box" that dude has.
His environment is totally different but he's out for months at a time.
-
That settles it gents, we need to get an MTo representative there. I vote Kirky :D
-
I vote Aloha.
That's us mobile
-
If I had more skills I'd love to give it a go. I've never hunted nor foraged for wild edibles. I'd love to learn and actually that is something I'm trying to learn in my local mountains.
I would seriously have to move to a wetter city for a year too. I live in a desert with next to no rain. My body would go into shock wondering what all that water was

-
LOL!
I would like to give it a go myself. Not sure how well I would do. My goal would be to last 7 days at the least. If I was going for the long haul, I would gain a 100 pounds. That way I would have "extra fuel" and hope they would starve out. LOL!
That's us mobile
-
Sign me up! I may have missed it...but why aren't they knocking some trees down to make a small cabin?
Other than the axe mishap, why didn't that guy use the dead duck for bait?
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
I'd have to gain some weight as well :D. I don't have nearly the reserves to hold me over for a good nights sleep let alone days :rofl:
@JP said:
Sign me up! I may have missed it...but why aren't they knocking some trees down to make a small cabin?Other than the axe mishap, why didn't that guy use the dead duck for bait?
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
Hey good call on the duck :tu: I wondered about the feasibility of a "cabin". One could possibly stack logs on each other wedged between trees in a triangle shape and then place others over the top. Place the tarp over that and they'd be good to go more or less.
EDIT
I found this video
-
I really want to watch this but I can't find a way to here in Australia. I guess they've clamped down on the YT copies. I can't read any of the previous posts for fear of spoilers so I'm a bit bummed. Bloody History Channel blocking internationals from being able to access their content

-
i think sidereel and xfinity might have all episodes that aired thus far so you can watch them
-
@TazzieRob said:
I really want to watch this but I can't find a way to here in Australia.:pm:
-
@TazzieRob said:
I really want to watch this but I can't find a way to here in Australia. I guess they've clamped down on the YT copies. I can't read any of the previous posts for fear of spoilers so I'm a bit bummed. Bloody History Channel blocking internationals from being able to access their content
Primewire.ag is a wonderful source for those of us overseas.
-
I cant believe how little that wound was bleeding. I cut a finger real bad and had a full cup of blood in my other hand in seconds. Must not have been super deep or maybe less arterys in that spot?
-
something doesn't add up. if we go by her bio on the official site, she should have a solid amount of experience with axes
Although Mary Kate was born in South Side, Chicago, she and her family moved to northwest Montana when she was two years old. She spent the next 12 years living off the grid with her parents and three sisters on Government Mountain in Montana. As a kid, she spent countless hours gathering firewood, picking wild huckleberries, cleaning chicken coops, riding horses, building forts, and simply getting lost in the mountains. Years later, she used these skills to become a firefighter for the Tahoe National Forest. It was there that she learned that no matter how physically demanding a challenge might be, her mental toughness can always help her complete a job. Mary Kate currently resides in Homer, Alaska, where she is fitness trainer at the Alaska Training Room and a mother to two beautiful girls: Boden Kate and Greta Tuff. She is eager to challenge herself to survive whatever Vancouver Island has in store, and sees this as the opportunity of a lifetime.
-
So thanks to Zoidberg's dodgy link
I've watched the first two episodes. I think I was cringing more watching the axe incident as they had previewed the outcome and we all knew it was coming. Hope she's healed well by now.
Interesting how little to nothing we have seen of some participants. Whether that just means they aren't doing the best job filming, are surviving just fine and are too boring to watch doing what they are supposed to be doing, and they are focusing on those in most peril and earliest to tap, maybe.
I guess people make the biggest mistakes when they haven't been taught correctly, and or are tired. That environment would be so sapping. One guy said it perfectly, to paraphrase "you can't survive on beauty alone"
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login