New Star Wars
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I woke up this morning wondering what the tactical advantage of an AT-AT (Mega cool looking but slow and vulnerable) is over a fast moving and more manouverable vehicle.
Any opinions?
None! They trip and fall over so easily that a regular tank would be better. But then those A-wings are not great either. Seriously, a present day helicopter would be much more efficient. Also noticed how poorly their rockets perform?
You're right! And why didn't the empire just send in Tie Bombers to bomb the shield, or even do it from a Star Destroyer in orbit? The Rebellion would have been better off sending X and Y-Wings to attack the AT-AT's.
I'm so good at these tactics I will apply for Admiral Ackbars job.
I really enjoyed the scenes in 'Force Awakens' when the X-wings are flying over the water. More of that please!
TIE bombers would have been too easy to pick off. And, escort fighters would have been seriously hampered as well in the cross winds and the giant solar collectors on either side. TIE bombers, fighters, interceptors etc were never designed for atmospheric combat.
The X Wings were needed to help cover the escape of the transports- sending them against the AT AT's would have been suicidal for the escaping transports, as the TIE fighters would have been scrambled even if the Star Destroyers were incapacitated by ion blasts.
Y Wings are slow bombers and would have been chewed apart by AT AT's and AT ST's.
Using Star Destroyers from orbit wasn't an option because of the shielding. They may have succeeded if they pounded away for an extended period of time, but that would have given the Rebels a chance to either escape another way or call for reinforcements.
It is very sad that I know all of this well enough to have a logical argument about it....

Def
No, that is the explanation I wanted thanks chief - I made a rookie mistake as well - they were snow speeders on Hoth, not A Wings. I will step down from Admiral Ackbars position and try something easier like being the guy who tightens up the bits on the back of the X-Wing before flight.

-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
[quote author=magentus link=topic=42551.msg1312814#msg1312814 date=1469539094]
I woke up this morning wondering what the tactical advantage of an AT-AT (Mega cool looking but slow and vulnerable) is over a fast moving and more manouverable vehicle.Any opinions?
None! They trip and fall over so easily that a regular tank would be better. But then those A-wings are not great either. Seriously, a present day helicopter would be much more efficient. Also noticed how poorly their rockets perform?
You're right! And why didn't the empire just send in Tie Bombers to bomb the shield, or even do it from a Star Destroyer in orbit? The Rebellion would have been better off sending X and Y-Wings to attack the AT-AT's.
I'm so good at these tactics I will apply for Admiral Ackbars job.
I really enjoyed the scenes in 'Force Awakens' when the X-wings are flying over the water. More of that please!
TIE bombers would have been too easy to pick off. And, escort fighters would have been seriously hampered as well in the cross winds and the giant solar collectors on either side. TIE bombers, fighters, interceptors etc were never designed for atmospheric combat.
The X Wings were needed to help cover the escape of the transports- sending them against the AT AT's would have been suicidal for the escaping transports, as the TIE fighters would have been scrambled even if the Star Destroyers were incapacitated by ion blasts.
Y Wings are slow bombers and would have been chewed apart by AT AT's and AT ST's.
Using Star Destroyers from orbit wasn't an option because of the shielding. They may have succeeded if they pounded away for an extended period of time, but that would have given the Rebels a chance to either escape another way or call for reinforcements.
It is very sad that I know all of this well enough to have a logical argument about it....

Def
No, that is the explanation I wanted thanks chief - I made a rookie mistake as well - they were snow speeders on Hoth, not A Wings. I will step down from Admiral Ackbars position and try something easier like being the guy who tightens up the bits on the back of the X-Wing before flight.

[/quote]Even though they were called snow speeders when the toys came out, they were actually not snow speeders. If they were snow speeders then they shouldn't have had trouble adapting them to the cold. They were simply light assault or recon speeders.
Speeder is a generic term for repulsorlift vehicles in Star Wars. Repulsorlifts are the things that allow various vehicles to float, from landspeeders to speeder bikes. They are generally used in place of wheeled or tracked vehicles since they are more versatile and less moving parts mean less maintenance. In the case of the snow speeders, they didn't so much fly like the X Wings or A Wings etc, as they jumped off uneven terrain and glided around.
As I said, I have immersed myself in the Lore of Star Wars just a bit too much.... :ahhh
Def
-
You know your sad when upon reading that you think "why had that never occurred to me before?". Snow speeders really shouldn't need to be adapted to the cold.

-
Maybe they were designed for use on a planet with hot snow? :ahhh
Def
-
Not to derail this thread (
) but I'm going to hell for derailment anyway so it doesn't really matter any more, but I have been obsessed by this Russian Ekranoplan Ground Effect Vehicle since reading about it in a William Gibson book. It sounds like a precursor to repulsorlift technology and as usual the Russians have gone large with it:There's a bunch of stuff on Youtube as well.
-
Ekranoplans are extremely cool. 8) Not actually practical in that they didn't like poor sea conditions, but definitely cool.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
-
Nice links Gareth

The Russians have come up with some amazing massive vehicles - The Hind - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mil_Mi-24, the 'Hook' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mil_Mi-6 and the Antonov plane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antonov_An-225_Mriya
-
Frankly I think there is some serious potential behind ekranoplans- yeah, they don't like rough seas, but the weather reports these days are amazingly accurate to days in advance. Considering an ekranoplan could cross the Atlantic in 12 hours, weather shouldn't be a bit of an issue. The Pacific might be a different story mind you, but for Australia/China/Japan/Malaysia/Philippines it should also be manageable.
Sure they may not have the same capacity as the current crop of container ships, but a standard container ship takes approximately 1 week to cross the Atlantic (at least from the UK to Halifax, where I used to work), and an ekranoplan could make the trip over and back in one day.
Plus, the ability to go inland some distance (depending on terrain of course) would mean less reliance on coastline for shipyards. Cargo could be brought inland, providing faster delivery to landlocked areas.
It could theoretically revolutionize shipping as we know it if it were to ever be explored.
Def
-
Back to the Star Wars Universe - here are some awesome pics from 'Rogue One' - looks gritty!
http://m.imgur.com/a/DBIlh -
@magentus said:
Back to the Star Wars Universe - here are some awesome pics from 'Rogue One' - looks gritty!
http://m.imgur.com/a/DBIlhDefinitely liking the looks of this. Donnie Yen being in it is definitely a exciting prospect. 8)
-
I hope it is much better than Agents of Shield, the Flash, Gotham, Arrow or Agent Carter. I really have no desire to see a Disnified, watered down version of Star Wars.
Nor a needlessly gritty and dark version like Stargate Universe.
Def
-
New Trailer for Rogue One:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frdj1zb9sMY -
Okay, I have to admit (nearly 20 pages in) that my initial concerns (i.e. "I have a bad feeling about this") were unfounded. It could have all turned out a lot worse. :-)
-
@PTRSAK said:
Okay, I have to admit (nearly 20 pages in) that my initial concerns (i.e. "I have a bad feeling about this") were unfounded. It could have all turned out a lot worse. :-)I'm with you there - I really enjoyed the new one - it had it's weird moments - Chewy walking straight past Leia after Hans death and Chewy being fine with Rei driving the Falcon.
But pretty pretty pretty good as my mentor Larry David would say. -
@magentus said:
New Trailer for Rogue One:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=frdj1zb9sMYStill looking good to me. 8)
-
Chewy walking straight past Leia after Hans death
Yeah that was pretty weird, along with Leia not wanting to go see Luke? (I get she's a busy lady, doing General stuff, but Han just died, and she's just discovered the location of her brother. She couldn't get a day off? Maybe someone in the Resistance should start a union, get some basic workers rights going)
I mean they really wanted the whole leia/rey hugging scene, passing on the legacy etc etc, it was magical, and there was strong female role models everywhere, we all had a great time, but maybe some eye-contact and a chewie growl?
Leia: Hmm, my (Husband? Ex? Baby-daddy?) just went on a dangerous mission.
Oh, here comes his best friend and co-pilot chewie, who I've also had many adventures with, well screw that guy.
Whoop, here comes some 20something girl I've barely met, I'll get my news from her, and hug it out. -
Kenny Baker, actor behind R2-D2, dies
The 3ft 8in actor, who starred in six Star Wars films as well as Time Bandits and Flash Gordon, was 81
the Guardian (www.theguardian.com)
RIP Kenny Baker :(
-
@Whoey said:
https://www.theguardian.com/film/2016/aug/13/kenny-baker-r2-d2-dies-star-warsRIP Kenny Baker :(
Very sad news. :(
-
ANOTHER Rogue One Trailer! :ahhh
Spoiler:

:D
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login




