Been doing some work in the Wiki
-
Hi all
One of the reasons I signed up to MTO was to offer to do a bit of tidying on SAK Wiki, which I've found to be a fascinating read while thinking about what I want in my next SAK. As a part of that research I pulled down all of the Victorinox 84mm and 91mm knife pages, and found a few things that complicated my efforts to clearly understand which knifes had which tools that offered which functions. For example, the can opener tool seems to be described in all these ways:
-
Can Opener
-
Can Opener - Bottle Opener - Screwdriver - Wire Stripper
-
Can Opener - includes small screwdriver tip
-
Can Opener - includes small-slotted screwdriver that also works with Phillips drive
-
Can Opener includes small-slotted screw-driver that works with Phillips screws also
-
Can Opener - includes small-slotted screw-driver tip that works with Phillips also.
-
Can Opener - Screwdriver
-
Can Opener include Screwdriver tip
-
Can Opener w/small screw-driver
-
Can Opener with Screwdriver Tip
-
Can Opener with small screwdriver
-
Can Opener with small screwdriver 3 mm
-
Can Opener with small screwdriver tip
-
Can Opener/Screwdriver
-
Can Opener/Small Screwdriver Tip
-
Can Opener/small-slotted screw-driver that works with Phillips also
-
Can-Opener w/ screwdriver
What I thought might be nice is to tidy up all of the entries so that they and more consistent, and also use that new streamlined list to refresh SAK Selector with equivalent information. Using the knife-to-tool data that has been gather in the reverse direction could also build a tool-to-knife section on each tool page. Finally, the tables of which knife has which features on the Layer N pages could possibly be updated to show all tool combinations, or similar.
Thoughts and guidance welcome. I haven't register yet >:D.
-
-
-
@Little Tinker said:
Hi all
One of the reasons I signed up to MTO was to offer to do a bit of tidying on SAK Wiki, which I've found to be a fascinating read while thinking about what I want in my next SAK. As a part of that research I pulled down all of the Victorinox 84mm and 91mm knife pages, and found a few things that complicated my efforts to clearly understand which knifes had which tools that offered which functions. For example, the can opener tool seems to be described in all these ways:
.......... long inconsistent list !! ........
What I thought might be nice is to tidy up all of the entries so that they and more consistent, and also use that new streamlined list to refresh SAK Selector with equivalent information. Using the knife-to-tool data that has been gather in the reverse direction could also build a tool-to-knife section on each tool page. Finally, the tables of which knife has which features on the Layer N pages could possibly be updated to show all tool combinations, or similar.
Thoughts and guidance welcome. I haven't register yet >:D.Hey Little Tinker (nice name BTW!!),
Welcome to the forum and thanks for the offer of help
That can opener list is amazing - And funny - I guess the result of multiple authors over a long time, and a tool with several functions- As you may know - for these items there is a hyperlink underneath and some display text which the author can edit
For those in the know, I guess it is pretty obvious what the tool is - But for someone unfamiliar - these sorts of inconsistencies are confusing - It sounds like a lot of work to clean up - Is there a clever automated way to do that? or is it just grunt.
(BTW you sound even more OCD than me!!)
The tool to knife and knife to tool links would be great too.
Detron on this forum created a spreadsheet like that and as you say there is the Selector..I am just a novice editor (as you can tell) - But maybe enki or one of the other Wiki-meisters will be along soon!!

@enki_ck said:
Red arrow marks the spot
WIKI editor:
.......
WYSIWYG editor:
.........Enki - Thanks for the piccies - I was going to ask for that
As I suspected - or hoped!! (I did not think I was that blind or dumb) - we must have different authorisations - As no little pencil for me
Here is what my editor screen looks like..
- As you may know - for these items there is a hyperlink underneath and some display text which the author can edit
-
I'm here but I shoud be sleeping, it's past 2am here and I work in the morning.

The work threw the years was done by a few authors, and in spells of a few years, mostly not parallel with other authors. Red Ramage pioneered the whole thing and most of the original pages are his. Then came Stressmaster5000, then ICanFixThat and then I and basilio who did a lot for the Wenger pages. That's the ones who worked for longer periods of time, there are still many people who contributed to it, like Andy T. and many ones that were never even members of MTO.
That's why you notice as many different kinds if code as the software changed, some code no longer worked, new commands were added and everybody tried something new to battle the code. Even the code I did isn't consistent threw the years.

There is a batch edit option we did use prior to the call for help and new editors but it can't be used in all the cases. I'm not even sure where it is as those were always done by whoey. I broke the wiki once or twice so I'd rather not mess with that end of it.
I tried to fix part of it with the how to I posted some time ago to fix the main window on all the pages and make them uniform.
We could probably do a batch edit on the tools too as it only has to change out the letters after the ((tool|... to something we agree on. We just have to agree on some list and forward it to whoey.
One problem however that I see is that although most of the tool descriptions are for the same tool, just worded differently, there are still tool variations that are described in the text after the tool and that would get lost by such a batch edit. For instance the scissors on some Angler SAKs come to mind, those with the fishing led crimpers.
(Too much text for typing on the phone and in bed, sorry for the spelling)
I'll address the sakselektor question when I'm a bit more awake.

-
Probably the reason for it. Yeah, I'm an admin there so have a few more permissions available. I'm not sure if anyone even uses the WYSIWYG editor. I'll talk to Whoey to have it disabled if he can, so as to only have the wiki editor available.
-
@Huntsman said:
Hey Little Tinker (nice name BTW!!),
Welcome to the forum and thanks for the offer of helpThanks for the welcome. The name has multiple meanings of course, happens to reflect parts of my character (as a friend noted "If it ain't broke we can still fix it" :D), and my erstwhile vintage Tinker Small is one of my favourite SAKs ;). My first planned mod is also Tinker related ;)...
@Huntsman said:
That can opener list is amazing - And funny - I guess the result of multiple authors over a long time, and a tool with several functions- As you may know - for these items there is a hyperlink underneath and some display text which the author can edit
For those in the know, I guess it is pretty obvious what the tool is - But for someone unfamiliar - these sorts of inconsistencies are confusing - It sounds like a lot of work to clean up - Is there a clever automated way to do that? or is it just grunt.
The tool to knife and knife to tool links would be great too.
Detron on this forum created a spreadsheet like that and as you say there is the Selector..
I am just a novice editor (as you can tell) - But maybe enki or one of the other Wiki-meisters will be along soon!!

I'm intending that a lot of the edits should be automated, otherwise my enthusiasm could be dented. I'm not expecting that to be too hard, but we'll see...
On reflection although those various rendition of the same information got a bit in the way of me digesting all the tool layer info into Excel (because I had to flatten them out) it won't be such a practical problem once I can see the raw Wiki source, so probably best to focus on new additions than tidying up perfectly usable current info. My current ideas are:
- Knife page (eg Tinker Small
Leave for now, except maybe rejig thinks like key-ring to be a consistent scale or layer tool. I need to be strong on this :P... - Tool page (eg Phillips Screwdriver Back Tool: Provide link to knives that have the tool, with indication of how many layers that knife has to give you a sense of whether it's likely to be what you're after.
- Size / layer pages (eg Victorinox 91mm 3 layer
Expand table to have a column for each differentiating layer / back tool (probably not scale tools - too much noise)
And of course use similar info to refresh the Selector and give dynamic lookup / search as well as simple perusal of that static info.
You could be right :o...
- As you may know - for these items there is a hyperlink underneath and some display text which the author can edit
-
I registered on SAKWiki, so just need editing rights set up to start trialling some of the above.
-
-
To get track of my own edits:
Lately I totally revamped the Wenger Nature Series page (that I think still needs to be ironed out by someone else)
Which implied also updating the Wenger V.I.P related section.Though most of the edits I done were to correct typo or add infos or a picture here and there like Updating Alox color-palette, Adding Huntsman 3.3713 variation (Ecoline Nylon scales), ...
Is there a page dedicated to scale materials?* Or maybe the color-palette could do that too*
That's the first thing we see about a SAK (even more if you don't have it in hand)
-
@Little Tinker said:
My current ideas are:- Tool page (eg Phillips Screwdriver Back Tool: Provide link to knives that have the tool, with indication of how many layers that knife has to give you a sense of whether it's likely to be what you're after.
- Size / layer pages (eg Victorinox 91mm 3 layer
Expand table to have a column for each differentiating layer / back tool (probably not scale tools - too much noise)
Early examples of the above can be seen at:
-
Pliers tool page: I think this looks OK, but maybe a better table title than "Related Knives". And positioning, taking into consideration that there could also be a Wenger table.
-
Victorinox 91mm 3 layer: Default table magic looking too big in narrow-ish browser window, and will be worse on knives with more layers and / or when back tools are included. Maybe break table into "Common" tools and "SpeSmurfpillst"? I left out Scale Tools for a similar reason. Do they warrant a table? Will start to make page big though... Also thinking of switching "Y" to "L" or "B" to indicate Layer or Back tool location.
BTW, there a couple of gremlins where I parsed the current Wiki data and keyring is listed as a layer tool on just a couple of knives (I think of it as a scale tool), CyberTool and Champion pages have multiple tool config lists, etc. They'l get fixed as the underlying data is nudged into shape.
-
-
I'm thinking of using TikiWiki's PluginInclude capability to build a pair of master page of all the new tables and then pull in the right table for each tool or knife.
Has that been tried elsewhere in the Wiki with success or failure?
-
@Huntsman said:
As I suspected - or hoped!! (I did not think I was that blind or dumb) - we must have different authorisations - As no little pencil for me
Here is what my editor screen looks like..
I landed in the WYSIWYG editor when creating a page ??? :-[. No icons to get out for me either :ahhh, but in the TikiWiki documentation I discovered that adding "&wysiwyg=n" to the edit URL takes you into the 'pure' Wiki code
. -
-
cool

Time to give Whoey a reminder again. >:D He's busy with some real world stuff
-
was out of town actually, but WYSIWYG editor is disabled now.
-
-
@Little Tinker said:
I'm thinking of using TikiWiki's PluginInclude capability to build a pair of master page of all the new tables and then pull in the right table for each tool or knife.Has that been tried elsewhere in the Wiki with success or failure?
I've now used that approach to add a knife-tool matrix to each of the Victorinox 91mm 1/2/3/4/5/6+ Layer Model pages. I'll add them to the 84mm model pages when time permits. The INCLUDE line on each of those pages takes the relevant snippet from this 'master' page, which can be quickly regenerated from the core database behind the data I downloaded / parsed, which in turn I ought to be able to be able to maintain by re-downloading the knife data as it is updated.
I think a bit of work to ensure the tables don't get too wide could still be useful. I'm unsure whether the Core and Other tool tables on (say) 5-layer page works as well as intended. Plus its always hard to pre-guess what everyone else is seeing and whether it is legible or not. I don't have a web authoring test suite to use...
A future edit would be to remove the original table, but that would take out the (sparse?) width and weight info as well as the corkscrew / Phillips in the 'lite' matrix. Should that be kept in the new matrices?
Thoughts and inputs welcomed.
-
You know, we need editors for the Multitool Encyclopedia too

What kind of work is needed, exactly?
Mostly we need new articles written, and proofreading of current articles. There is a link to the "How To" page for the wiki in my signature, and if you want to make edits and make new pages, I can send you the passcode needed to register.
Amusingly enough, the MTwiki actually benefited from being neglected for so long, and even with a very small group of editors, cleaning up the old code was quick and painless. The SAKwiki is still being cleaned up, despite having much more enthusiasm and support.
-
Hi Little Tinker
Well you have certainly been doing some BIG Tinkering.
The tool matrices are a great idea - although the 5 layer page seems to show the 3 layer models - Maybe this is still WIP??
I like the updated front back designation .....
One slight bug/issue - The tool table when I see it overlaps the brand, layer, size keys/links down the right hand side of the page.....Edit - I also love the Related Knives section in the Tools pages
I have a couple of suggestions on the tables.
- To save width how about bringing in a two or three letter code for each of the tools - You know the sort of thing: MB, SB, CO, SD, A, CS, KR for instance for a Spartan - We could store the key somewhere in a link or even put it on each page, or update the tool page with the abbreviations ??
- Again to save width, and given that just about every SAK has the Spartan tool set - How about missing out those tools from the table and just putting a note where there is a variation (eg for Compacts)? - So there would be one column for the Spartan toolset - And that column would be blank for all knives that contained the Spartan tool set - Then there would be a note number in that column - For instance Note 1 for a Automobile would say the Spartan small blade is replaced by the Technicians screwdriver - Not sure how well that would work - Might get a bit messy ....... ???
- I see you put all the tools in alphabetical order - But how about a more SAK centric logical order with the most common tools starting with the Spartan toolset first (assuming we don't remove this!
as per suggestion 2) and listing all the tools in the Swisschamp next - Then the less common tools - So the order would be something like:
MB, SB, CO, SD, A, CS, KR, Tp, Tw, Sc, WS, MF, FS, Ph, MG, Pl - followed by all the more unusual tools grouping similar tool together eg PB, MB(S), MB(PS), EB etc etc ??? ???
Edit - It all seems like a lot of work for you - although I get the impression you are pretty good at this type of stuff - So hopefully can make it a bit easier
Anyway -** respect and thanks **

And I have been doing my own Tinkering - So here is a summary:
-
Reworded the Spartan introductory paragraph
-
Re structured the Champion tool section - to clearly show similarities and differences between the 6 and 7 layer versions
-
Updated the history of the Champion Plus
-
Added some references to the 111mm 2 layer models back to the 91mm models
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
:-[