firearms
-
@SAK Guy said:
Everybody knows Glocks are great but why did they have pull out tired old arguments to run down a great, timeless American design in order to justify their standardization on pistols and calibers.
IMO of course.
Rant off.....
As a 1911 and Glock owner, my opinion is different. I agree with many of their arguments about the 1911 and, though it is a great design, I wouldn't call it "timeless". There are modern designs that have proven simpler in operation, manufacture and are more reliable.
However, I agree with you that those arguments should not be used solely for standardization, if that's what they're doing.
-
Many of the M1911's "issues" have to do with tuning and tightening the action. It's a combat pistol at its core, not a match one. Pick up a GI spec M1911a1 and shake it. It'll rattle. Those loose tolerences are intentionally built into the weapon to keep it running while dirty in combat conditions......
-
@jerseydevil said:
Many of the M1911's "issues" have to do with tuning and tightening the action. It's a combat pistol at its core, not a match one. Pick up a GI spec M1911a1 and shake it. It'll rattle. Those loose tolerences are intentionally built into the weapon to keep it running while dirty in combat conditions......Absolutely. That goes for any firearm. Put a round in the chamber of a Glock 19 and see how tight it fits. Regardless of how tight it is, I personally have not experienced any 1911 that was on the order of reliability of a Glock. Has there been a lot of tightening of the action in military issue 1911s that would cause them to have these complaints?
Tightening can be done to an extent and maintain reliability. Compare a Glock to a Springfield XD-M.
-
Everybody knows Glocks are great but why did they have pull out tired old arguments to run down a great, timeless American design in order to justify their standardization on pistols and calibers.

IMO of course.
Rant off.....
As a 1911 and Glock owner, my opinion is different. I agree with many of their arguments about the 1911 and, though it is a great design, I wouldn't call it "timeless". There are many modern designs that have proven simpler in operation, manufacture and are more reliable.
However, I agree with you that those arguments should not be used solely for standardization, if that's what they're doing.
I understand completely Terry.
Glocks are fantastic and probably exactly what any modern military needs but why, if 1911's were so flawed, didn't they address it back in 2012? I think the 1911's were just fine so they wanted another one but now in a time of continuing shrinking budgets, the pressure to standardize is even greater. Different caliber, different mags and holsters, different training for two completely differently operational designs etc. The 19's were proven, cheaper, held more rounds already in use, was already green lighted for MARSOC optional carry and in federal pipeline for use by other SF groups. I think someone way up high looked at the numbers, said "standardize" and make it look like we weren't complete idiots back in 2012.... What I'm miffed about is them blaming the design that they wanted, used since the 1990's, and replaced with a "better" model but now it's total crap. In 40 + years of travel/carry, recreational use/competition, I can count 1911 stoppages on one hand and all were due to either poor quality handloads, worn out WWII mags or repairs/mods made by previous owners. But I've only shot 25,000 rounds or so through them.And an essentially unchanged design from 1906 fits the "timeless" descriptor in my short sighted, highly biased, crotchety old book of adjectives!

-
Many of the M1911's "issues" have to do with tuning and tightening the action. It's a combat pistol at its core, not a match one. Pick up a GI spec M1911a1 and shake it. It'll rattle. Those loose tolerences are intentionally built into the weapon to keep it running while dirty in combat conditions......
Absolutely. That goes for any firearm. Put a round in the chamber of a Glock 19 and see how tight it fits. Regardless of how tight it is, I personally have not experienced any 1911 that was on the order of reliability of a Glock. Has there been a lot of tightening of the action in military issue 1911s that would cause them to have these complaints?
Tightening can be done to an extent and maintain reliability. Compare a Glock to a Springfield XD-M.
There's not much that can be done to a glock, I mean taking it apart and there's only a few parts like the spring and release pin, which can be replaced if changing over to a laser.
JR -
Many of the M1911's "issues" have to do with tuning and tightening the action. It's a combat pistol at its core, not a match one. Pick up a GI spec M1911a1 and shake it. It'll rattle. Those loose tolerences are intentionally built into the weapon to keep it running while dirty in combat conditions......
Absolutely. That goes for any firearm. Put a round in the chamber of a Glock 19 and see how tight it fits. Regardless of how tight it is, I personally have not experienced any 1911 that was on the order of reliability of a Glock. Has there been a lot of tightening of the action in military issue 1911s that would cause them to have these complaints?
Tightening can be done to an extent and maintain reliability. Compare a Glock to a Springfield XD-M.
Also, those new Marine pistols had cerakoted feed ramps/slides /rails which caused problems....this same issue has cropped up on cerakoted glocks from Lipseys (so I've read) until they've been shot in and those contact points have smoothed out or polished out by owners/smiths..
-
Many of the M1911's "issues" have to do with tuning and tightening the action. It's a combat pistol at its core, not a match one. Pick up a GI spec M1911a1 and shake it. It'll rattle. Those loose tolerences are intentionally built into the weapon to keep it running while dirty in combat conditions......
Absolutely. That goes for any firearm. Put a round in the chamber of a Glock 19 and see how tight it fits. Regardless of how tight it is, I personally have not experienced any 1911 that was on the order of reliability of a Glock. Has there been a lot of tightening of the action in military issue 1911s that would cause them to have these complaints?
Tightening can be done to an extent and maintain reliability. Compare a Glock to a Springfield XD-M.
I have a buddy who is a 1911 guy and he loves his Springfield XD! The grip angle is the same as a 1911 so if I get a polymer framed pistol, it will probably be one of those or an HK.
The Glock has a steeper grip angle and doesn't point as naturally for me. -
@SAK Guy said:
I have a buddy who is a 1911 guy and he loves his Springfield XD! The grip angle is the same as a 1911 so if I get a polymer framed pistol, it will probably be one of those or an HK.
The Glock has a steeper grip angle and doesn't point as naturally for me.I absolutely love my XD-M, but I also have no issue with Glock's grip angle. I always index, so they both point naturally for me, but I feel that I can lock my wrist more effectively with Glock's angle. All in all I prefer Glock over XD simply because, though the XD is a direct Glock rip-off, for some reason Springfield unnecessarily decided to make it more complex than a Glock. It simply doesn't need a grip safety and a striker status indicator.
I'll refrain from saying anything else about the 1911, as you obviously have more experience there than I even if you are highly-biased and crotchety. :P :D
-
I have a buddy who is a 1911 guy and he loves his Springfield XD! The grip angle is the same as a 1911 so if I get a polymer framed pistol, it will probably be one of those or an HK.
The Glock has a steeper grip angle and doesn't point as naturally for me.I absolutely love my XD-M, but I also have no issue with Glock's grip angle. I always index, so they both point naturally for me, but I feel that I can lock my wrist more effectively with Glock's angle. All in all I prefer Glock over XD simply because, though the XD is a direct Glock rip-off, for some reason Springfield unnecessarily decided to make it more complex than a Glock. It simply doesn't need a grip safety and a striker status indicator.
I'll refrain from saying anything else about the 1911, as you obviously have more experience there than I even if you are highly-biased and crotchety. :P :D
I think that Glock angle was intentional as it effectively lets you lean into the pistol and control recoil/rapid fire. Like everything else on the Glock it was well thought out and innovative! Used to do a lot of quick presentation drills and with the 1911, I could point shoot center mass hits out to about 15 yards. Trying those drills with a buddy's 17 resulted in me pointing about two feet over the target at the same distance. Could probably get used to one if I owned one to shoot a lot. -
The Chip McCormick Power Mag functioned flawlessly with hardball late yesterday afternoon . This skunk was coming right up on the front porch and eating cat food. My Mom became afraid to go outside after about 4pm and having cats and small dogs, the rabies risk was real so I had to do something.
Been watching him for several days and he usually stayed where there was no safe shot and then quickly disappeared. But yesterday, he changed his routine just long enough for me to get out the door and line up a shot as he was leaving. The .45 was close by (no time to drag out and load the .22 rifle) and the mags functioned flawlessly. He was moving away fast at about 14 yards. Took a couple of shots. Probably the first time in nearly 3 years that I had shot the 1911. Was glad to see it's like riding a bike for me.
I walked further down the porch and took a pic.
-
I suspect hitting a skunk with a .45 means it's definitely not getting up again. :D
-
.45s work great for vermin control.

-
Got myself a Mosin Nagant M44 recently.
What a fine rifle. It has the Nr. 11 stamped on it. This means it was made in Poland at the Radom facility. And a mighty fine gun.
But some jerk used to fire corrosive ammo out of it. The barrel got some rust and pitting. I used to clean it hard. But there was still rust.Then I had enough. Put the gun, went to the range and did dome firing.
Nice feeling so far. The best surprise was the target at 100 metres. The target picture was great. All in a circle of about 10 cm diameter.
I was a little off center, about 30 cm to left. But in a great circle of 10 cm at 10-shot-group.I used non-corrosive ammo. With 180grs FMJ by S&B, Pretty heavy bullets and a wonderful recoil.
At the end of the day, the barrel was clean and no more rust inside the barrel.
So I finally I tried to adjust the front sight. But it sat tight. Well... that concerned me and I did some research online.
Got myself a front-sight-adjustment (in Germany it is called Kornschieber).Need to get on the range soon and do some more testing.
But still... my favorite is my WWII K98k. With its new barrel and a mighty fine recoil and a target picture at 10 metres.
-
Great!!!! 
-
@ColoSwiss said:
.45s work great for vermin control.

-
@Humppa said:
Got myself a Mosin Nagant M44 recently.What a fine rifle. It has the Nr. 11 stamped on it. This means it was made in Poland at the Radom facility. And a mighty fine gun.
But some jerk used to fire corrosive ammo out of it. The barrel got some rust and pitting. I used to clean it hard. But there was still rust.Then I had enough. Put the gun, went to the range and did dome firing.
Nice feeling so far. The best surprise was the target at 100 metres. The target picture was great. All in a circle of about 10 cm diameter.
I was a little off center, about 30 cm to left. But in a great circle of 10 cm at 10-shot-group.I used non-corrosive ammo. With 180grs FMJ by S&B, Pretty heavy bullets and a wonderful recoil.
At the end of the day, the barrel was clean and no more rust inside the barrel.
So I finally I tried to adjust the front sight. But it sat tight. Well... that concerned me and I did some research online.
Got myself a front-sight-adjustment (in Germany it is called Kornschieber).Need to get on the range soon and do some more testing.
But still... my favorite is my WWII K98k. With its new barrel and a mighty fine recoil and a target picture at 10 metres.
Awesome!!!!!! You have some fine rifles Andi!!! 
-
Oh, I did something fiscally unsound.
I just put a 100 down on a Glock 17. $400, and it's very clean, three mags, the - disconnector and Glock's extended slide release. My G19 has been wanting a big brother for a while.
-
@ironraven said:
Oh, I did something fiscally unsound.I just put a 100 down on a Glock 17. $400, and it's very clean, three mags, the - disconnector and Glock's extended slide release. My G19 has been wanting a big brother for a while.
Sounds great!!!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
