Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

Victorinox Quality?

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
30 Posts 1 Posters 5.4k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
  4. Victorinox Quality?
Victorinox Quality?
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • sergemaster Offline
    sergemaster
    Posts: 1,058
    sergemaster Offline
    sergemaster
    wrote on last edited by
    #19 Quote Reply

      Amici,
      I would agree.. For those of you who recall "my case against the corkscrew" regarding the despised "nick" that occurs on both the liner and back side of the cellidor scale from the placement and use of corkscrew on SAKS which utilize this tool. well this doesn't appear to be an issue at all on this vintage tool since again, both tools and scales seem to be made from a different and tougher standard.

      Cheers,
      Serge

      'I will NOT be threatened by a walking Meatloaf!!' - D. Kessler

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Steinar Offline
        Steinar
        Posts: 3,435
        Steinar Offline
        Steinar
        wrote on last edited by Steinar
        #20 Quote Reply

          Lighter does not mean lower quality. A cell phone from “cheap toy plastic” would be strong and light, but would never sell (for a high price). Put the same electronics in some brittle, heavy cover, and it will sell like hotcakes. A fully digital amplifier hardly weighs anything, but will according to any oscilloscope do just as good a jobs as the heavy monster from the 1970s. (Hi-fi enthusiasts who can hear the choice of metal in the cables will of course always prefer the analog one.)

          We do know the liners now are less polished, which really does not affect usability. We know the cellidor plates which now are hollow, were massive. But: All the objective measures I know of are either of small consequence or purely cosmetic.

          As for blades being harder to sharpen could simply mean the abrasive resistance of the chosen alloy and hardening process now is higher. Which in most cases is associated with higher quality.

          I simply do not know whether the knives we all love were manufactured to a higher standard before, but most of what I see boils either down to heavy is better or older is better. I understand the production of SAKs is extremely cost sensitive, since it is a mass product, and most, if not all, the changes I have alluded to here were probably motivated by cost, I'm just not sure it has any tangible consequences (at least not for me). Everybody hates the thinner tang, but nobody has posted a case where that caused a problem (where the old tang would have saved the day). And the only catastrophic tool failure posted here which was a real surprise I can remember right now (I am sure I will be reminded of others soon), was when the reamer on a 1891 replica Soldier broke right off. Being big and heavy did not help it...

          So, to re-iterate, I am not saying the knives now are just as good (or not), I am just protesting the reflex of associating weight and polish with quality. It may be a correlation, but it is certainly not an implication.

          1 Reply Last reply
          • MacGyver Offline
            MacGyver
            Posts: 1,550
            MacGyver Offline
            MacGyver
            wrote on last edited by MacGyver
            #21 Quote Reply

              @Steinar said:
              Lighter does not mean lower quality. A cell phone from “cheap toy plastic” would be strong and light, but would never sell (for a high price). Put the same electronics in some brittle, heavy cover, and it will sell like hotcakes. A fully digital amplifier hardly weighs anything, but will according to any oscilloscope do just as good a jobs as the heavy monster from the 1970s. (Hi-fi enthusiasts who can hear the choice of metal in the cables will of course always prefer the analog one.)

              We do know the liners now are less polished, which really does not affect usability. We know the cellidor plates which now are hollow, were massive. But: All the objective measures I know of are either of small consequence or purely cosmetic.

              As for blades being harder to sharpen could simply mean the abrasive resistance of the chosen alloy and hardening process now is higher. Which in most cases is associated with higher quality.

              I simply do not know whether the knives we all love were manufactured to a higher standard before, but most of what I see boils either down to heavy is better or older is better. I understand the production of SAKs is extremely cost sensitive, since it is a mass product, and most, if not all, the changes I have alluded to here were probably motivated by cost, I'm just not sure it has any tangible consequences (at least not for me). Everybody hates the thinner tang, but nobody has posted a case where that caused a problem (where the old tang would have saved the day). And the only catastrophic tool failure posted here which was a real surprise I can remember right now (I am sure I will be reminded of others soon), was when the reamer on a 1891 replica Soldier broke right off. Being big and heavy did not help it...

              So, to re-iterate, I am not saying the knives now are just as good (or not), I am just protesting the reflex of associating weight and polish with quality. It may be a correlation, but it is certainly not an implication.

              Mate, i don't think that anyone implyed that "Lighter mean's lower quality" just in it self...
              First, and a bit off topic about audio, while i'm not exactly a hi-fi enthusiast i am guitar player (among many other instruments too) and while weight of a guitar amp means nothing, the difference in sound character and more importantly feel is still miles ahead on vintage tube amps than on it's digital equivalent's, no matter what the oscilloscope says. It can only measure sound waves not "sound character" or "feel". And yes i can tell the diference between the two, even between two different quality guitar cables for that matter... ;)

              About the new vs old Vic's, i know it's not just because it's lighter or heavier that meens it has better or worse quality. I certainly do know my metalurgy, however i don't know the specifics about the steel baing used now or 30 years ago, neigther do i know the specifics of the hardening process of both. As i stated the old ones just "feel" more solid and overal of more refined quality and craft to me. Yes little atention to small details won't afect usability at all, but nevertheless you will notice it when its gone, or at least if the high standards of detail, while still high, has lowered a bit. There are a lot of factors that contribute to the defenition of "quality" not just funtional and practical ones; attention to detail, finishing, etc..., all contributes the the final overall quality of a product.
              What's not important for some, may have some importance to others.
              As for the the thinner tang vs the older one, funtionaly dosen't make any difference but visualy i just like the older better. I even like the crossbow there, i know it's just cosmetic but my first one had it and it just gives it a more refined "classic" look to me.

              BTW, just on a side note about finishing details of recents Vic's, i've bought about 6 or 7 Vic's this year and in all the ones with the back awl there was metal shavings still attached to the edge of the awl from the grinding process. One pass with a paper towel got rid of those, no problem, but point is that some years ago something like that would have never left the factory. Not to mention light scratches on the tools sometimes, micro dings on the blade, awl or can opener's edges and other detail stuff like that.
              The last time i bought a lot of sak's before this year (around 2008/2009 maybe) i saw none of those issues in probably 10 or more knives.
              Even in a recent informal conversation at my country's Vic rep (that handles destribution for the stores) they told me there where some recent changes in policy in the company and that it wasn´t quite the same Victorinox like the old days any more. They said, and i quote: ""unfortunatly some of the newer guys in mannagement there are growing sharper teeth... (as in "sharks after profit")""

              "Another Day...; a whole n'other set of fresh possibilities..." - MacGyver (S1E19 - "Slow Death")

              1 Reply Last reply
              • JamesJ Offline
                JamesJ
                Posts: 1,044
                JamesJ Offline
                JamesJ
                wrote on last edited by
                #22 Quote Reply

                  The main difference for me is the thicker blade on model before (approx) 2005. Usually these are the blades with a crossbow stamp, and blades with less text and no crossbow are thinner, and there is a spacer built into the outer liner to make up for the width. However I have Tinker with thebolder crossbow stamp that has the thinner blade, probably made during a transitional year.

                  There's a different feel to the snap. Im not claiming the blade is actuallt stronger and perhaps thinner actually is less likely to snap sonce it can bend more...but in terms of feel, I prefer thicker. I also prefer the screw scissors. Again there was a transitional period where screw scissors had the spring groove and hook on the back side. Without the hook, the backspring is different and I believe there's more metal there (no cutout for the hook) so it's going to have a heavier feel and smoother look on the back.

                  I prefer somethings old for style, like the fluted CS, thicker blade, metal inlays instead of printed logos..and in other cases I prefer newer, like the pliers with crimper, stainless aggressive version-4 of the metal file. These don't all exist in one knife so...custom mods it is.

                  One thing that really feels cheap to me is on 84mm knives that, due to the included layers, only require 3 of the 4 pins. These seem to be a little more flexible and less sturdy. Could always just add the 4th pin.

                  -JJL
                  instagram: jamesjlarue (warning, lots of cat pics along with the SAKs)

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • MacGyver Offline
                    MacGyver
                    Posts: 1,550
                    MacGyver Offline
                    MacGyver
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #23 Quote Reply

                      @JamesJ said:
                      One thing that really feels cheap to me is on 84mm knives that, due to the included layers, only require 3 of the 4 pins. These seem to be a little more flexible and less sturdy. Could always just add the 4th pin.

                      Humm, i'm not sure i understand what you meen there by only using 3 pins... What 84mm models are you refering to? The ones with no back tools?

                      "Another Day...; a whole n'other set of fresh possibilities..." - MacGyver (S1E19 - "Slow Death")

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • tosh Offline
                        tosh
                        Posts: 3,181
                        tosh Offline
                        tosh
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #24 Quote Reply

                          Interesting topic, thanks for bringing it up.

                          I think I too know what you refer to with your old vs new SAK

                          Like many here I too have a few that span the decades of production and relate to what you say.

                          We know the scales have changed, no doubt the production process is far more accurate today than in the past which in itself leads to the rise of carelessness from human intervention.

                          The "feel" you speak off will undoubtably be a very personal thing, during the ten years you owned it, your thumb will no doubt have rested in a certain spot time after time, they way you cut things, the pressure you apply could easily have distorted/twisted the chassis so that the knife fits your hands better. I know from working with hand tools, namely planes and chisels that these individual traits that we unwittingly use daily, do infact shape the tool personally. We only realise this when we ask to borrow someone's else's identical tool or we replace one. The tool never feels familiar at first...it just feels different.

                          I don't claim to know it all, but what I do know is right.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • Inlaw Biker Offline
                            Inlaw Biker
                            Posts: 14
                            Inlaw Biker Offline
                            Inlaw Biker
                            wrote on last edited by Inlaw Biker
                            #25 Quote Reply

                              @Inlaw Biker said:
                              Alright my first post, glad I found this forum. I hope this is not too offensive a question to start off but ...

                              Following up on the original post, I was just confused. Now that I've received the Climber and done some research I understand a little better. Just wanted to clear things up.

                              My Camper II with Nylon scales really confused me. I didn't realize there were two scale types available, as was kindly pointed out. My new Climber is Cellidor and it feels much better to me than the Nylon (which my kids have lost now anyway). Different from the old Climber yes but still just fine. It's definitely less weight but it still feels good. Anyway I guess it goes without saying I prefer Cellidor to Nylon.

                              However, now I have a new problem. The knife I received is pretty scuffed up somehow, it looks like maybe it was used, or went through some kind of tumble in shipment. There are two significant wear spots and lots of tiny micro-scratches like you'd expect to see in a knife that's been in some pockets.

                              Since it's also bigger than I want for everyday after all, I think I'll exchange it for the Tourist model. It seems to be the best balance of size and function for me. Actually I would love an Alox Cadet but, like I said I really need the corkscrew.

                              Also I researched my old (1990's?) SAK which in fact was called a Deluxe Climber. It's the same as the Climber but with pliers. I always disliked the pliers and never used the hook that I recall, but I love the two-blade models. I use the small blade as much as the big one.

                              So is the "new" knife better than the old? Who can say really, maybe in 10 years I'll know for sure. It doesn't feel "cheap" at all, except that actually these knives are not all that expensive considering what you get.

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • MacGyver Offline
                                MacGyver
                                Posts: 1,550
                                MacGyver Offline
                                MacGyver
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #26 Quote Reply

                                  @Inlaw Biker said:

                                  @Inlaw Biker said:

                                  Alright my first post, glad I found this forum. I hope this is not too offensive a question to start off but ...

                                  Following up on the original post, I was just confused. Now that I've received the Climber and done some research I understand a little better. Just wanted to clear things up.

                                  My Camper II with Nylon scales really confused me. I didn't realize there were two scale types available, as was kindly pointed out. My new Climber is Cellidor and it feels much better to me than the Nylon (which my kids have lost now anyway). Different from the old Climber yes but still just fine. It's definitely less weight but it still feels good. Anyway I guess it goes without saying I prefer Cellidor to Nylon.

                                  However, now I have a new problem. The knife I received is pretty scuffed up somehow, it looks like maybe it was used, or went through some kind of tumble in shipment. There are two significant wear spots and lots of tiny micro-scratches like you'd expect to see in a knife that's been in some pockets.

                                  Since it's also bigger than I want for everyday after all, I think I'll exchange it for the Tourist model. It seems to be the best balance of size and function for me. Actually I would love an Alox Cadet but, like I said I really need the corkscrew.

                                  Also I researched my old (1990's?) SAK which in fact was called a Deluxe Climber. It's the same as the Climber but with pliers. I always disliked the pliers and never used the hook that I recall, but I love the two-blade models. I use the small blade as much as the big one.

                                  So is the "new" knife better than the old? Who can say really, maybe in 10 years I'll know for sure. It doesn't feel "cheap" at all, except that actually these knives are not all that expensive considering what you get.

                                  Hi, sorry you are having trouble with your new climber. Did you bought it online or order from a store?
                                  The Sak's on store displays sometimes have a few micro scratches from being moved around, but it's very minor so I dont bother much.
                                  I've noticed however that Vic seems to have changed the type of cellidor recently (4 or 5 years) some of the newer scales on some of my latest sak's seem to have a deeper darker shade of red, and seem more prone to micro scratches and get a patina faster too. I have at least one Tinker with both scales like that, and my current edc tinker has the "older" front scale witch have no patina yet and the "newer" back scale that already has more patina and scratches, not to mention all the other stuff I've already said on earlier posts. So they are dropping the ball a bit on the detail quality. Such inconsistency would never happened 10 years ago for example. :(

                                  "Another Day...; a whole n'other set of fresh possibilities..." - MacGyver (S1E19 - "Slow Death")

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • Inlaw Biker Offline
                                    Inlaw Biker
                                    Posts: 14
                                    Inlaw Biker Offline
                                    Inlaw Biker
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #27 Quote Reply

                                      @MacGyver said:
                                      Hi, sorry you are having trouble with your new climber. Did you bought it online or order from a store?
                                      The Sak's on store displays sometimes have a few micro scratches from being moved around, but it's very minor so I dont bother much.

                                      I got it from Amazon so no problem with the return. On both sides of the knife there were serious rub marks in a concentrated spots, where the knife lays flat. It was in a cardboard box with no padding which I assume is standard. All I can think is, maybe it was damaged in shipment. Maybe placed near an engine where it endured a lot of vibration for days and days? I have bought and sold a bit of camera gear so I know how to grade equipment, I'd call it 'very good' condition out of the box, rather than 'like new' or 'excellent.' Maybe I'm being picky but anyway...

                                      Greg

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • Aloha Offline
                                        Aloha
                                        Global Moderators
                                        Posts: 31,235
                                        Aloha Offline
                                        Aloha
                                        Global Moderators
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #28 Quote Reply

                                          Micro scratches can be removed quite easily. Its always nice however to be the one who puts those scratches in however.

                                          I have found jewelry polish or even very high grit sand paper to work wonders on Cellidor. I've even used knife stropping compound to highly polish Cellidor.

                                          Esse Quam Videri

                                          Merit Badges
                                          One Piece Collector Japanese PST Juice Collector Level 1 Reviewer Camping Fire Making Flashlight Outdoor Cook BO Tools Level 3 Santa Traditional Folder Challenge Pen Challenge
                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          • Sazabi Offline
                                            Sazabi
                                            Posts: 6,397
                                            Sazabi Offline
                                            Sazabi
                                            wrote on last edited by
                                            #29 Quote Reply

                                              That's no different than almost all of my alox knives, when purchased new, in box, from a couple different retailers, have incomplete annodization along the backsprings; it rubs off, presumably, from the trays they are shipping in. If they still used the older felt box inserts, I doubt that would be an issue.

                                              1 Reply Last reply

                                              Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                              Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                              With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                              Register Login

                                              • 1
                                              • 2
                                              1. Home
                                              2. Tool Talk
                                              3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
                                              4. Victorinox Quality?
                                              Reply
                                              • Reply as topic
                                              Log in to reply
                                              COMMUNITY LINKS
                                              EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                              Operational Funds

                                              Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                              Make A Donation
                                              November Goal: $300.00
                                              Due Date: Nov 30
                                              Total Receipts: $0.00
                                              Below Goal: $300.00
                                              0% funded
                                              • Login

                                              • Don't have an account? Register

                                              • Login or register to search.
                                              • First post
                                                Last post
                                              0