New SOG (2017) - Initial thoughts
-
PowerGrab:
What the smurf were they thinking here?
This might be more than one post. In fact, I'm going to break off here and go get a coffee before I try to tackle this one..... -
OK, I've got myself a coffee, so lets take a look at the SOG
ClusterSmurfPowerGrab
What a sloppy sloppy lazy unthinking half arsed piece of design work. Let's tick off a few positives first before we launch our full on assault though. Pliers look good. Nice and strong, soft and hard wire cutters, compound leverage, again this affects handle splay, but thems the breaks. OHO plain edged blade, compatibility with traditional SOG components, and metal saw included on the file.
OK, arse kicking time. You may notice that this tool has BOTH the traditional bit driver adapter "stump", AND the magnetic bit driver on the back of the plier head. There is only one simple reason for including both hex bit driver features on one tool. Laziness! They ran out of off the shelf tools and ideas for what to fill the handle with. Simple as that!
The only other reason to include a second feature is if the first feature is crap - so which is it SOG? Which of these two features is so crap that you have to include the other one? Just give us one and make sure it works! Are we supposed to have not noticed, or are we supposed to think you can tighten one screw with one end and simultaneously think we can loosen another screw with identical screw pitch length at the same time. Why not give us a full thickness 3D #2 Phillips? Chisel blade? Pry tool? Tyre depth gauge? Hex bit storage? Jigsaw blade attachment? Even a lanyard loop makes more sense here. Make an effort for smurfs sake!!!!!

OK, so moving on ..... deep breaths
This tool has one "inboard" arm, and one "outboard" arm. This gives SOG the option of fitting each arm with the tool which gives optimum orientation in use. However, once again, they opt to royally smurf it up instead!

Remember my comments earlier about blunt nosed serrated blades? I mentioned that these are one of the few tools which benefit from an "inboard" configuration, but Some Oblivious Gonad (note the initials) chose to mount it on the outboard arm. They got the OHO plain edged blade on the correct arm, so 1/2 point awarded for putting 50% of the knife blades in the right place.....
.... and then there's the scissors.....
..... these scissors are NOT the greatest on the market. In fact they are one of the worst that are offered in multitools (where's Lynn when you need her?). One of the many aspects about these scissors that makes them crap, is that they are upside down on the tool. They had off the end of the handles with the moving arm pointing over the opposing handle. The reason for this is that essentially, these scissors are outboard design scissors that SOG kept mounting in an inboard configuration....
.... but wait...
..... here's a tool with both inboard and outboard arms....
..... and.......


They want 120 beer vouchers for this shambles?
This isn't a Friday afternoon special, the shift where you really aren't paying attention because you want to go home, grab a shower, and head straight out for a weekend of full on partying. This is worse than that! This is day after the Christmas party material! You know you're probably going to get the sack anyway for dipping your smurf in your bosses wife's glass of Bollinger, and sang loudly "dip your balls, in someone's Bolli, fallallallallaargh fallallaargh.... BARF!!!" - instant 18" pavement pizza.
You reckon you've got nothing to lose, so you screw up the design on purpose as a parting shot in case they sack you, knowing you can correct the design later if you keep your job. However, the next morning, you get told you can keep your job as it was a one-off, providing you don't screw up anything else for the next 6 months, but you need to get the PowerGrab design submitted immediately as they've planned a January release....
And so the SOG ClusterSmurf was born
-
Finally there's the Micro Tool Clip. Third time of attempting it, and the Phillips is still unusable.
Nuff said!
-
In the interests of full disclosure, for those who don't already know. I am one of the customers that SOG lost due to them having a significant decline in quality of design and manufacture over recent years. I have however tried to approach this appraisal as neutrally as I can, and keep this objective. Any apparant bias against the brand is purely coincidental, and due to the fact I'll happily take the piss out of anyone and everything, given an adequate opportunity

-
The end!
-
Your turn

-
Where have you all gone?
Was it something I said?

-
If any moderators are bored and fancy a little job...
:D ... Kampfer posted up some piccies in a seperate thread of catalogue captures for each of these tools, and it would be really useful to get one of the appropriate pic posted at the beginning of each "review" post, so people can relate picture to words.It was a problem for me to do this, as I'm just working off a phone. Hopefully one of you can assist.
Yes, I know it's a smurfty request, but thanks in advance anyway :P

-
Just a slight aside here- the issue you have with the redundant drivers on the PowerGrab is exactly the complaint I had about the so called "premium" Leatherman Charge XTi that I paid full Canadian retail price of $145 for because everyone talked about how wonderful it was. So wonderful, and yet with an unnecessary duplication of features, to say nothing of the various flatheads.
Maybe since it was Leatherman and they can do no wrong, it's ok when they do it, but a double standard when someone else tries it.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Just a slight aside here- the issue you have with the redundant drivers on the PowerGrab is exactly the complaint I had about the so called "premium" Leatherman Charge XTi that I paid full Canadian retail price of $145 for because everyone talked about how wonderful it was. So wonderful, and yet with an unnecessary duplication of features, to say nothing of the various flatheads.Maybe since it was Leatherman and they can do no wrong, it's ok when they do it, but a double standard when someone else tries it.
Def
Slight but very poignant difference there. The ALX can hold and retain two bits (four drivers) at the same time, increasing the scope of the tool without carrying peripherals. The PowerFail can only use one bit on one driver at any time, and cannot retain any of them.
Therefore there is a legitimate design reasoning behind the ALX design, which is absent on the SOG.
-
Grant, I hope you realise that you just made me defend a Leatherman design principle

:D
-
Looking at the Q3 in closer detail, the rounded tool on the left arm as pictured may be the "chisel" as referred to in the supporting text. Due to the profile of this tool, and the fact that there is no obvious locks, I am going to assume that this tool is ground on the side, and will therefore almost be like a kind of whittling knife.
As all the above comments, this is just speculative guess work, but if correct, I can imagine that being quite a handy little tool in this configuration.
-
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, right? I enjoyed your initial thoughts on the new designs. I am quite a SOG fan and I will quickly share some thoughts of my own.
Baton tools - I have more reservations about these tools than any of the other offerings. The one with the pen is interesting, the one with knife less so, and the two pliers based batons I don't like based on how ugly they are - yes, shallow :P
The Syncs - I like them. The bigger one is my fav, because more tools. They look unique, too
PowerAcess - really excited about this one. We have got a PPP replacement, at the expense of the PPP, I just hope it can live up to that legacy. I am bummed that it has apparently lost the ability to accept the interchangeable tools. I'd like to see it with scissors. Maybe a future variation? But all outside access, the pliers head driver, and a pocket clip? Wins. Solidity of construction is going to be the make/break factor. I sort of wish name was PPP2.0
PowerGrab - I am interested in this one as well, but my love of the PL may prevent me from purchasing... Initially :D I agree with your assessment about the configuration of the inboard vs outboard tools. Scissors should have been out, serrated should have been in. I don;t mind the 1/4" adapter, but a new implement would have been better - 3D #2 phillips being the first thing to come to mind. My concern with the PG? Is this going to eventually replace the PL? They need to offer some variations if that is the long term plan.
Micro Tool Clip - I have one. I like it. I agree that the phillips is a fail.
Overall, I am really excited about SOG this year. And last year. And the year previous. They are really killing it lately. As I mentioned with PA, the solid-ness of these tools is the key factor. The quality needs to be up to PL, SP, PPP standards and not on PowerDuo level. SOG went a different direction than I would have, offering a bunch of new models. I would have made adjustments to the existing product lines and called them 2.0 or 3.0 as applicable. But I like the Reactor a lot. So clearly blazing new trails has paid off recently for them.
-
Thanks for your input, rdub
Nice to get the input of a long term SOG fan. I had no intentions of this thread being "one sided", and always value your comments
Differences of opinion and perspective are important and highly informative.Good call on the pocket clip on the PowerAccess which is something that I overlooked. I've only noticed it in the text and not in any pictures. Hopefully the clip is at the plier end, as these SOGs do tend to swing open quite easily (or at least their predecessors did)
-
.... also, is it me, or is the plier head more similar in profile to the rather nicer Paladin PT510 plier head? Overall, I think the tool has the potential to be superior to the PPP in many ways. I also agree that putting their standard scissors on here would be a nice touch, especially on a knifeless variant
-
@50ft-trad said:
Grant, I hope you realise that you just made me defend a Leatherman design principle
:D
At least SOG can use standard bits.
:P
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


Anything you disagree on? And any clue what that weird rounded tool is supposed to be on the left arm of the Q3?


