New SOG (2017) - Initial thoughts
-
Just a slight aside here- the issue you have with the redundant drivers on the PowerGrab is exactly the complaint I had about the so called "premium" Leatherman Charge XTi that I paid full Canadian retail price of $145 for because everyone talked about how wonderful it was. So wonderful, and yet with an unnecessary duplication of features, to say nothing of the various flatheads.
Maybe since it was Leatherman and they can do no wrong, it's ok when they do it, but a double standard when someone else tries it.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Just a slight aside here- the issue you have with the redundant drivers on the PowerGrab is exactly the complaint I had about the so called "premium" Leatherman Charge XTi that I paid full Canadian retail price of $145 for because everyone talked about how wonderful it was. So wonderful, and yet with an unnecessary duplication of features, to say nothing of the various flatheads.Maybe since it was Leatherman and they can do no wrong, it's ok when they do it, but a double standard when someone else tries it.
Def
Slight but very poignant difference there. The ALX can hold and retain two bits (four drivers) at the same time, increasing the scope of the tool without carrying peripherals. The PowerFail can only use one bit on one driver at any time, and cannot retain any of them.
Therefore there is a legitimate design reasoning behind the ALX design, which is absent on the SOG.
-
Grant, I hope you realise that you just made me defend a Leatherman design principle

:D
-
Looking at the Q3 in closer detail, the rounded tool on the left arm as pictured may be the "chisel" as referred to in the supporting text. Due to the profile of this tool, and the fact that there is no obvious locks, I am going to assume that this tool is ground on the side, and will therefore almost be like a kind of whittling knife.
As all the above comments, this is just speculative guess work, but if correct, I can imagine that being quite a handy little tool in this configuration.
-
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, right? I enjoyed your initial thoughts on the new designs. I am quite a SOG fan and I will quickly share some thoughts of my own.
Baton tools - I have more reservations about these tools than any of the other offerings. The one with the pen is interesting, the one with knife less so, and the two pliers based batons I don't like based on how ugly they are - yes, shallow :P
The Syncs - I like them. The bigger one is my fav, because more tools. They look unique, too
PowerAcess - really excited about this one. We have got a PPP replacement, at the expense of the PPP, I just hope it can live up to that legacy. I am bummed that it has apparently lost the ability to accept the interchangeable tools. I'd like to see it with scissors. Maybe a future variation? But all outside access, the pliers head driver, and a pocket clip? Wins. Solidity of construction is going to be the make/break factor. I sort of wish name was PPP2.0
PowerGrab - I am interested in this one as well, but my love of the PL may prevent me from purchasing... Initially :D I agree with your assessment about the configuration of the inboard vs outboard tools. Scissors should have been out, serrated should have been in. I don;t mind the 1/4" adapter, but a new implement would have been better - 3D #2 phillips being the first thing to come to mind. My concern with the PG? Is this going to eventually replace the PL? They need to offer some variations if that is the long term plan.
Micro Tool Clip - I have one. I like it. I agree that the phillips is a fail.
Overall, I am really excited about SOG this year. And last year. And the year previous. They are really killing it lately. As I mentioned with PA, the solid-ness of these tools is the key factor. The quality needs to be up to PL, SP, PPP standards and not on PowerDuo level. SOG went a different direction than I would have, offering a bunch of new models. I would have made adjustments to the existing product lines and called them 2.0 or 3.0 as applicable. But I like the Reactor a lot. So clearly blazing new trails has paid off recently for them.
-
Thanks for your input, rdub
Nice to get the input of a long term SOG fan. I had no intentions of this thread being "one sided", and always value your comments
Differences of opinion and perspective are important and highly informative.Good call on the pocket clip on the PowerAccess which is something that I overlooked. I've only noticed it in the text and not in any pictures. Hopefully the clip is at the plier end, as these SOGs do tend to swing open quite easily (or at least their predecessors did)
-
.... also, is it me, or is the plier head more similar in profile to the rather nicer Paladin PT510 plier head? Overall, I think the tool has the potential to be superior to the PPP in many ways. I also agree that putting their standard scissors on here would be a nice touch, especially on a knifeless variant
-
@50ft-trad said:
Grant, I hope you realise that you just made me defend a Leatherman design principle
:D
At least SOG can use standard bits.
:P
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
@50ft-trad said:
Grant, I hope you realise that you just made me defend a Leatherman design principle

:D
At least SOG can use standard bits.
:P
Def
.... without peripherals at one end, whereas they can both use standard bits but only with the use of peripheral components at the other end ;)
-
Q4 looks interesting. At one point I did look bit driver mt. But to be honest I have not found usable one. LM bits are good solution if you think about bits in edc (I do not carry all bit options so don't mind even bits are not normal size). This Q4 seems like ok solution. Again bits and tool can be quite large edc. And again like estimated pliers look light duty. Again I prefer fixed flat and philips. Flat I use other then screw tasks as well (prybar etc). But seems this can be smaller then example wave with one slide of bits or spirit plus. So looks fine but depends how handy carry solution is.
So agree that bit driver with one bit is not a great solution. And to carry example 12 bits is same then having extra sak in carry. Again there are quite small ratchet and bit sets you can carry on belt. So LM could do as well Q4 like solution for own bits, example for MT about juice S2 size + room for 5 double bits, that I could edc.
But surely nice try for this area at least.
-
MOre pics and info of the 2017 products are available on SOG website!!!
-
@temo said:
Q4 looks interesting. At one point I did look bit driver mt. But to be honest I have not found usable one. LM bits are good solution if you think about bits in edc (I do not carry all bit options so don't mind even bits are not normal size). This Q4 seems like ok solution. Again bits and tool can be quite large edc. And again like estimated pliers look light duty. Again I prefer fixed flat and philips. Flat I use other then screw tasks as well (prybar etc). But seems this can be smaller then example wave with one slide of bits or spirit plus. So looks fine but depends how handy carry solution is.So agree that bit driver with one bit is not a great solution. And to carry example 12 bits is same then having extra sak in carry. Again there are quite small ratchet and bit sets you can carry on belt. So LM could do as well Q4 like solution for own bits, example for MT about juice S2 size + room for 5 double bits, that I could edc.
But surely nice try for this area at least.
The length of the Q4 is listed as 5.8" (about 147mm) but it's not clear if this is closed, or with/without a driver bit in position. It is possible that this tool might have Juice sized pliers. We can't be certain until somebody buys one and posts size comparison pictures
-
Yes quite long but slim, again bit set brings some size and weight (assume seperate but packs up as pounch was listed). Nice to see more later :)
-
@rdub934 said:
MOre pics and info of the 2017 products are available on SOG website!!!:2tu:
Additional observations:
I do like the way that the back end of the plier head on the PA and PG "fills" the gaps on the gear teeth, minimising the "gears of madness" effect on earlier tools. I'm not quite sure why they have made them hollow though :think:
The pocket clip on the PA is on the correct end for sure, but seems that the tool will be riding quite high in the pocket. Obviously we don't know how big the hands are of whoever is holding the tool, but it does seen a decent "urban pocket tool" size. In order words, not too large for general off work carry
-
-
Thankfully, I was wrong about the Q2 handles.....

-
Despite the battering I gave the PowerGrab earlier, I do need to pour a little more praise on it for the size efficiency of the knife blades.
On the PowerLock, the implements (including knife blades) all appear rather diminutive in comparison with the size of the overall tool. This is because they all carry the same size tools as found on the PPP. The PowerGrab to it's credit, carries knife blades relative to the size of the tool

This is a very significant improvement over the older models, and also means there is a goodly amount of blade which is not impeded by the thumb stud on deep cutting chores.
On this pic, you can also see the plier casting behind the gearing, as eluded to earlier, minimising any discomfort in hand from the gear teeth. There is certainly SOME thought that has gone into these new format tools, but I still think putting the serrated blade and scissors on the "wrong" arms, and the inclusion of old style bit driver stump to be very sloppy and poorly considered.
-
There does seem to be a fair amount of variation in the location and width of the backlock notches across the range of implements. This may affect rigidity of lock up.

Attaching pics is such a PITA on a phone

Also notice the long backsprings (no "rocker" locks) and the quirky release thingummy jobbies.....


I'm not quite sure what to make of those to be honest.....
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login

Anything you disagree on? And any clue what that weird rounded tool is supposed to be on the left arm of the Q3?




