What's your latest SAK?
-
@WolfyW said:
Bought my wife this "used, new condition" Vic Compact off the big auction site. It looks mint. Not a mark on the tools or scales. She rarely has pockets, but I figured the variety of tools in a narrow package would be very useful to her in her purse.I see it has the crossbow stamp on the main blade tang, no nail file on the back of the hook. Scissor is rivot, not screw.
Comparing the thickness of the main blade to my brand new Tinker, the Compact blade is thicker at the tang. Stronger.
Did Victorinox lessen the strength of the blades and parts while doing away with the crossbow??? Just curious.
Nice knife.
If you're interested its one of the Taiwan series, Sun Moon Lake.
-
Bought my wife this "used, new condition" Vic Compact off the big auction site. It looks mint. Not a mark on the tools or scales. She rarely has pockets, but I figured the variety of tools in a narrow package would be very useful to her in her purse.
I see it has the crossbow stamp on the main blade tang, no nail file on the back of the hook. Scissor is rivot, not screw.
Comparing the thickness of the main blade to my brand new Tinker, the Compact blade is thicker at the tang. Stronger.
Did Victorinox lessen the strength of the blades and parts while doing away with the crossbow??? Just curious.
Nice knife.
If you're interested its one of the Taiwan series, Sun Moon Lake.Thanks for that information! Very interested in knowing that and anything else. And nice collection you have there

-
@WolfyW said:
Bought my wife this "used, new condition" Vic Compact off the big auction site. It looks mint. Not a mark on the tools or scales. She rarely has pockets, but I figured the variety of tools in a narrow package would be very useful to her in her purse.I see it has the crossbow stamp on the main blade tang, no nail file on the back of the hook. Scissor is rivot, not screw.
Comparing the thickness of the main blade to my brand new Tinker, the Compact blade is thicker at the tang. Stronger.
Did Victorinox lessen the strength of the blades and parts while doing away with the crossbow??? Just curious.
I can't speak to the science but it is evident that the base of the tang on the crossbow (Rostfrei) stamp is slightly thicker than the current blade.
Here's one of my older Climbers vs New Compact


-
There is no difference in thickness between the old vs new main blades. The only thing slightly thinner now is the tang. It makes no difference to the overall strength of the blade. If you look carefully at both you'll see that on the old one the tang was thicker than the start of the blade on one side, this means that when produced the blade blank was thicker than the current one, that means more metal was removed ( wasted) when grinding the blade to it's final thickness, multiply that by some millions and you'll get the point. This way there is less material going to waste.
-
@MacGyver said:
There is no difference in thickness between the old vs new main blades. The only thing slightly thinner now is the tang. It makes no difference to the overall strength of the blade. If you look carefully at both you'll see that on the old one the tang was thicker than the start of the blade on one side, this means that when produced the blade blank was thicker than the current one, that means more metal was removed ( wasted) when grinding the blade to it's final thickness, multiply that by some millions and you'll get the point. This way there is less material going to waste.I'll add that I have one SAK which has the crossbow tang stamp but it's thinner and has the spacer on the outer liner. It's an oddball. I prefer the snap feel and perceived sturdiness of the thicker tang personally, though I realize it isnt actually stronger.

-
My latest SAK is this mod, which is described in detail here:
/topic/70512
-
8) -
@MacGyver said:
There is no difference in thickness between the old vs new main blades. The only thing slightly thinner now is the tang. It makes no difference to the overall strength of the blade. If you look carefully at both you'll see that on the old one the tang was thicker than the start of the blade on one side, this means that when produced the blade blank was thicker than the current one, that means more metal was removed ( wasted) when grinding the blade to it's final thickness, multiply that by some millions and you'll get the point. This way there is less material going to waste.Makes sense.
-
@MacGyver said:
There is no difference in thickness between the old vs new main blades. The only thing slightly thinner now is the tang. It makes no difference to the overall strength of the blade. If you look carefully at both you'll see that on the old one the tang was thicker than the start of the blade on one side, this means that when produced the blade blank was thicker than the current one, that means more metal was removed ( wasted) when grinding the blade to it's final thickness, multiply that by some millions and you'll get the point. This way there is less material going to waste.Thanks for the info!

-
Technician (one of two I bought recently, this one will be a user, but I want to get Victorinox to replace the main blade, the tools are fine, though, the other one is still on it's way to me from the US and is NIB, for the collection):

-
@Oxford_Guy said:
Technician (one of two I bought recently, this one will be a user, but I want to get Victorinox to replace the main blade, the tools are fine, though, the other one is still on it's way to me from the US and is NIB, for the collection):

-
@Oxford_Guy said:
Technician (one of two I bought recently, this one will be a user, but I want to get Victorinox to replace the main blade, the tools are fine, though, the other one is still on it's way to me from the US and is NIB, for the collection):
+1

-
Sweet score OG... If it's going to be a user, I'd say just polish the blades and re-sharpen them...

This was my first attempt at polishing/removing scratches... The pic doesn't show it well, but the blade had heavy scratches around the blade tip area...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Looks good to me!

@jaya_man said:
Sweet score OG... If it's going to be a user, I'd say just polish the blades and re-sharpen them...
This was my first attempt at polishing/removing scratches... The pic doesn't show it well, but the blade had heavy scratches around the blade tip area...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
My new MacGyver Season 1 Episode 1-3 SAK!!! My newest family member, fresh from the bath. This is a pre-80' w/ square Philips, and this particular one has no T&T.
Not sure if Mac was using a rounded or square Philips but I know for sure it was definitely not El Corkscrew.




-
@El Corkscrew said:
Looks good to me!
Sweet score OG... If it's going to be a user, I'd say just polish the blades and re-sharpen them...

This was my first attempt at polishing/removing scratches... The pic doesn't show it well, but the blade had heavy scratches around the blade tip area...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
My new MacGyver Season 1 Episode 1-3 SAK!!! My newest family member, fresh from the bath. This is a pre-80' w/ square Philips, and this particular one has no T&T.
Not sure if Mac was using a rounded or square Philips but I know for sure it was definitely not El Corkscrew.
Nice Tinker mate

As far as i can tell Mac never used a square Philips one, it was split round Philips ones.
On Ep1 it was a regular Tinker, no keyring, and I think it had t&t.
Up until The Thief of Budapest it was the Tinker small, no keyring, and t&t removed.But it's almost impossible to keep track of all the sak's used on the whole 7 season's, he would use more than one model on many episodes. I think they just had a big prop drawer of them and just grab a random one for the shot, unless they needed a specific tool of course :D.
As we all know, 80% of the time it was 2 layer 91/84mm sak's sometimes the Executive. The other 20% was 3 or 4 layers.
As RDA stated on an interview he always carry one in his pocket on the set, even when it wasn't written into the shot. He said he probably destroyed like 100 of them or more through the whole show
For those who remember the Three For the Road episode on season 2, on the scene that he is cutting the stuffing out of the Cadilac's back seat, he said they repeated that shot 3 or 4 times and on one of them he stabbed the seat but was holding the sak in reverse so when he started to cut the blade closed on his little finger... Ouch...
-
Stay Glow Rambler

-
@El Corkscrew said:
Looks good to me!

Sweet score OG... If it's going to be a user, I'd say just polish the blades and re-sharpen them...

This was my first attempt at polishing/removing scratches... The pic doesn't show it well, but the blade had heavy scratches around the blade tip area...
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
My new MacGyver Season 1 Episode 1-3 SAK!!! My newest family member, fresh from the bath. This is a pre-80' w/ square Philips, and this particular one has no T&T.
Not sure if Mac was using a rounded or square Philips but I know for sure it was definitely not El Corkscrew.
Nice Tinker mate

As far as i can tell Mac never used a square Philips one, it was split round Philips ones.
On Ep1 it was a regular Tinker, no keyring, and I think it had t&t.
Up until The Thief of Budapest it was the Tinker small, no keyring, and t&t removed.But it's almost impossible to keep track of all the sak's used on the whole 7 season's, he would use more than one model on many episodes. I think they just had a big prop drawer of them and just grab a random one for the shot, unless they needed a specific tool of course :D.
As we all know, 80% of the time it was 2 layer 91/84mm sak's sometimes the Executive. The other 20% was 3 or 4 layers.
As RDA stated on an interview he always carry one in his pocket on the set, even when it wasn't written into the shot. He said he probably destroyed like 100 of them or more through the whole show
For those who remember the Three For the Road episode on season 2, on the scene that he is cutting the stuffing out of the Cadilac's back seat, he said they repeated that shot 3 or 4 times and on one of them he stabbed the seat but was holding the sak in reverse so when he started to cut the blade closed on his little finger... Ouch...
Thanks comrade! I do remember Three for the Road... I believe I recall seeing a camping logo on 3 layer SAK he is sporting in one of the shots. Just did a quick check on episode one and it in the does not have the T&T.

-
Amici,
Here is my newest entry, a recently acquired and very vintage Swiss Champ with brand spanking new Yellow plus scales..Cheers,
Serge
-
There is no difference in thickness between the old vs new main blades. The only thing slightly thinner now is the tang. It makes no difference to the overall strength of the blade. If you look carefully at both you'll see that on the old one the tang was thicker than the start of the blade on one side, this means that when produced the blade blank was thicker than the current one, that means more metal was removed ( wasted) when grinding the blade to it's final thickness, multiply that by some millions and you'll get the point. This way there is less material going to waste.
I'll add that I have one SAK which has the crossbow tang stamp but it's thinner and has the spacer on the outer liner. It's an oddball. I prefer the snap feel and perceived sturdiness of the thicker tang personally, though I realize it isnt actually stronger.
Ditto
Cool oddball!

-
Harvester - gray with black shield
#16 of 50
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login