Skip to content
Collapse
? [[global:guest]]
Unread Recent
HOME SEARCH PROFILE MESSAGES 0 BOOKMARKS MEMBERS BADGES
Multitool.Org Forum
MultiTool.org • Community Header Space • Watch This Space

SAK combo dilema

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Swiss Army Knights Forum
25 Posts 1 Posters 5.4k Views
  1. Home
  2. Tool Talk
  3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
  4. SAK combo dilema
SAK combo dilema
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • Nick762 Offline
    Nick762
    Posts: 14
    Nick762 Offline
    Nick762
    wrote on last edited by
    #15 Quote Reply

      @50ft-trad said:
      There comes a point when carrying two separate tools is better than one cumbersome one. Personally I like to keep pliers and Phillips duty for the pliers tool rather than a SAK. An IDL T5 or T7 (or similar) might be a game changer for you. In a larger format, a knifeless plier modification might be an option too. The blade is easily removed from a Gerber Octane, and leaves a very slim profile on a deep carry pocket clip.

      Sticking strictly with SAKs, you have essentially described a CT41 without scissors - which won't alter thickness much, and would need to be a modification as it's not a standard model.

      Seriously, check out the T5 and T7, and maybe even some of the Swiss+tech offerings too

      That's a possibility. I do have a set of Screwpop pliers but I was trying to minimise the number of separate widgets I carry around.

      SAKs
      Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
      Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
      Leatherman
      OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
      Spyderco
      UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
      Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

      1 Reply Last reply
      • Nick762 Offline
        Nick762
        Posts: 14
        Nick762 Offline
        Nick762
        wrote on last edited by
        #16 Quote Reply

          Thanks for the input, there's certainly plenty of options there.
          In an ideal world I'd probably just go with a Leatherman or Swisstool type MT but unfortunately the best plier tools all have locking blades, even the new "bladeless" Rebar risks running foul of UK knife laws because it still has a locking saw blade and reamer. The best UK legal plier tool I've found (for my purposes at least) is probably the Leatherman Squirt although it's petite to say the least it has proven itself. As I said above, I'm trying to minimise the number of widgets I carry (if I ever get asked to turn out my pockets it could be embarrassing) and it's not so much the overall weight that's the issue but the handiness of the tool itself - I don't mind two smaller SAKs over one big one but I'd rather minimise duplication. I've been looking for the perfect multitool for years and concluded that it doesn't exist and there will always have to be some compromise along the way. Maybe the CT41 isn't so bad :)

          SAKs
          Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
          Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
          Leatherman
          OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
          Spyderco
          UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
          Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

          1 Reply Last reply
          • Nick762 Offline
            Nick762
            Posts: 14
            Nick762 Offline
            Nick762
            wrote on last edited by
            #17 Quote Reply

              @classicrock said:
              I do love the Deluxe Tinker model. 4 layers and has a pliers. But as you said about the limitation of the backside phillips driver, I feel the same about it.

              Then I found one SAK named Yeoman Mechanic. But it was hard to find. So I made a custom one, with a little help of my friend.
              So it's still a 4 layers SAK, has a pliers and of course inline phillips driver. Well if you want to built a custom one, just add a wood saw.

              That is rather nice but as you say, hard to find. The Master Craftsman is another one I'd like to get my hands on :(

              SAKs
              Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
              Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
              Leatherman
              OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
              Spyderco
              UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
              Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

              1 Reply Last reply
              • Nick762 Offline
                Nick762
                Posts: 14
                Nick762 Offline
                Nick762
                wrote on last edited by
                #18 Quote Reply

                  @twiliter said:
                  I would go with the CT41 and just carry it until you get used to the size. I did this with the SwissChamp and carried one for years. :salute:

                  I've pretty much reached that conclusion, I used to carry my CT39 regularly - what's one or two more layers?
                  Next step is maybe try my own mod but not I'll have to start collecting distressed second handers first. I haven't got the nerve to break up one of mine.

                  SAKs
                  Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
                  Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
                  Leatherman
                  OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
                  Spyderco
                  UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
                  Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  • Oxford_Guy Offline
                    Oxford_Guy
                    Posts: 955
                    Oxford_Guy Offline
                    Oxford_Guy
                    wrote on last edited by Oxford_Guy
                    #19 Quote Reply

                      @Nick762 said:

                      @classicrock said:

                      I do love the Deluxe Tinker model. 4 layers and has a pliers. But as you said about the limitation of the backside phillips driver, I feel the same about it.

                      Then I found one SAK named Yeoman Mechanic. But it was hard to find. So I made a custom one, with a little help of my friend.
                      So it's still a 4 layers SAK, has a pliers and of course inline phillips driver. Well if you want to built a custom one, just add a wood saw.

                      That is rather nice but as you say, hard to find. The Master Craftsman is another one I'd like to get my hands on :(

                      You can buy the Master Craftsman new from Amazon Japan still (with the nice Space Shuttle inlay). I did this a few weeks before Xmas and it arrived at my door in the UK 4 days later. It's 5 layers, but all quite thin ones, so it's not that thick. Every layer has a back tool, which is nice too.

                      Amazon.co.jp

                      favicon

                      (www.amazon.co.jp)

                      "We broke into Mir using a Swiss Army knife. Never leave the planet without one." - Chris Hadfield, Astronaut

                      Merit Badges
                      Minimal SAK Challenge Flashlight Titanium Ignore
                      1 Reply Last reply
                      • Oxford_Guy Offline
                        Oxford_Guy
                        Posts: 955
                        Oxford_Guy Offline
                        Oxford_Guy
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #20 Quote Reply

                          @Nick762 said:
                          Thanks for the input, there's certainly plenty of options there.
                          In an ideal world I'd probably just go with a Leatherman or Swisstool type MT but unfortunately the best plier tools all have locking blades, even the new "bladeless" Rebar risks running foul of UK knife laws because it still has a locking saw blade and reamer. The best UK legal plier tool I've found (for my purposes at least) is probably the Leatherman Squirt although it's petite to say the least it has proven itself. As I said above, I'm trying to minimise the number of widgets I carry (if I ever get asked to turn out my pockets it could be embarrassing) and it's not so much the overall weight that's the issue but the handiness of the tool itself - I don't mind two smaller SAKs over one big one but I'd rather minimise duplication. I've been looking for the perfect multitool for years and concluded that it doesn't exist and there will always have to be some compromise along the way. Maybe the CT41 isn't so bad :)

                          But I did find somewhere selling NOS Leatherman Knifeless Fuses - I bought one myself last year, but they had more - this has no knife, saw or awl, so UK-friendly but does have scissors, metal file, can/bottle opener and Phillips and flat drivers, all of which lock. If interested PM me and I'll send you a link to the shop

                          "We broke into Mir using a Swiss Army knife. Never leave the planet without one." - Chris Hadfield, Astronaut

                          Merit Badges
                          Minimal SAK Challenge Flashlight Titanium Ignore
                          1 Reply Last reply
                          • Brock O Lee Offline
                            Brock O Lee
                            Posts: 643
                            Brock O Lee Offline
                            Brock O Lee
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #21 Quote Reply

                              @eddie1115 said:
                              In practice, though, I usually pair a plier-based MT with a SAK to achieve what you're talking about. Ranger plus LM Skeletool could work, or Explorer paired with any file- and saw-equipped MT (Wave, Rebar, Spirit).

                              This.

                              I also realised that even though I wanted the saw/file/pliers/3d Philips, I rarely need them on person. So I like to carry my favourite 3 layer sak on person (Pioneer X handles most Philips screws just fine), and leave a Rebar in my work/EDC bag that's usually in the vicinity.

                              Hans

                              Merit Badges
                              Hook User Flashlight Axe User Time Lord Level 2 Fire Making Titanium Scale Changer 111mm Collector Level 1 ALOX Colors Level 1 Minimal SAK Challenge 30 Day TWEEN Challenge - 84 and 85mm SAKs Alox Addict Challenge 30 Day Cadet Challenge Hacker
                              1 Reply Last reply
                              • Nick762 Offline
                                Nick762
                                Posts: 14
                                Nick762 Offline
                                Nick762
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #22 Quote Reply

                                  Been carrying my CT41 for a while and it's been surprisingly handy as I did have misgivings about its size. I had another look at my Handyman which is a little more compact, the only problem being the lack of a Phillips.

                                  Here's one possible solution 😀

                                  IMG_4672.JPG

                                  SAKs
                                  Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
                                  Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
                                  Leatherman
                                  OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
                                  Spyderco
                                  UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
                                  Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

                                  1 Reply Last reply
                                  • NorCalJim Offline
                                    NorCalJim
                                    Posts: 1,544
                                    NorCalJim Offline
                                    NorCalJim
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #23 Quote Reply

                                      Before I was finished reading the original post, I was already thinking Victorinox Spirit X. Working around legal restrictions that prevent carrying multi-tools with locking blades does put a crimp in the better options. Although particularly fond of my Spirit X and LM Charge TTI & AL, I find myself spending more time with one of my LM Juice multi-tools (none of which have locking blades). I always have a Vic Explorer in my pocket and have swapped out a Vic Compact with a LM Juice S2 for the other pocket. The pliers are far superior to the Vic fold-out (Tinker Deluxe, Mechanic, Swiss Champ, etc) and it has a set of drivers (using the optional extender, it can use standard 1/4" bits).

                                      Since one of your requirements was a saw, you can opt for the LM Juice CS4 and it would only add an extra ounce. Want the saw, a serrated blade & a file? The LM Juice Pro (retired) and the Juice XE6 add a little more weight to the CS4 but pack more functions. These tools are small, dense and will weigh more that their small size would suggest but the return is a very useful pliers/wire cutters/needle nose.

                                      Another option would be to go with a Cybertool 29, reducing SAK layers to 3 then and use something like a LM Squirt PS4 for scissors and pliers (I would still look at a Juice S2 or C2 for pliers & drivers...the S2 has scissors).

                                      Good luck!

                                      Merit Badges
                                      Chuck Yeager Challenge
                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      • Nick762 Offline
                                        Nick762
                                        Posts: 14
                                        Nick762 Offline
                                        Nick762
                                        wrote on last edited by Nick762
                                        #24 Quote Reply

                                          Had occasion to walk up Tottenham Court Road (for non U.K. readers this is a street in London famed for its cut price electronics shops although they are getting a bit thin on the ground these days due I guess to more internet shopping), happened to glance in the window of a photographic shop and saw this, a Handyman with a Phillips aka the much missed Craftsman! I suspect my enthusiasm may have counted against getting a discount for "old model" but I didn't want to lose this one.

                                          IMG_4701.JPG

                                          SAKs
                                          Wenger Soldier, Pioneer, Pioneer Farmer, Pioneer X, Classic, Cadet
                                          Climber, Mountaineer, Deluxe Tinker, Ranger, Cybertool 39, Cybertool 41, Fieldmaster, Handyman, Explorer, Soldier, Evogrip 18
                                          Leatherman
                                          OHT, Surge, Skeletool, Freestyle, Squirt and Sideclip
                                          Spyderco
                                          UKPK, Urban Lightweight, Squeak, Squeak Ti, PITS, Mantra, Harpy, Tasman Salt, Rescue 79, Assist, Techno, Civilian, Cliptool Serrated, Paramilitary 2, Ti Dog Tag, ARK H1, Bug, Honeybee and Grasshopper
                                          Fallkniven F1, Mora Garberg, Ka-Bar MK 1

                                          1 Reply Last reply

                                          Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.

                                          Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.

                                          With your input, this post could be even better 💗

                                          Register Login

                                          • 1
                                          • 2
                                          1. Home
                                          2. Tool Talk
                                          3. Swiss Army Knights Forum
                                          4. SAK combo dilema
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          COMMUNITY LINKS
                                          EDC-TV SAKWiki GearFeed SAKSelector
                                          Operational Funds

                                          Help us keep the Unworkable working!

                                          Make A Donation
                                          November Goal: $300.00
                                          Due Date: Nov 30
                                          Total Receipts: $0.00
                                          Below Goal: $300.00
                                          0% funded
                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Login or register to search.
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0