Who would win?
-
My boss sent me a text message about a month ago to see what I thought, since he and his 8 year old son had reached an impasse. His theory was that Starfleet Engineers could beam aboard the Death Star and blow it up from the inside, or that the greater speed and maneuverability of the Enterprise would allow it to win.
His son said, and I tend to agree, that one shot from the main gun on the Death Star would obliterate the Enterprise, and that no one on the Death Star would even feel the bump. Starfleet engineers are pretty well useless against a thousand stormtroopers filling a hallway with hard light, and with numerous bays stocked with thousands of TIE fighters, I really don't see the Enterprise even getting close.
Since the Star Trek thread brought many of the geeks out of the closet, I thought I'd see what everyone here had to say!
Def
-
They don't call it the "Death Star" for nothing. It gets my vote.

-
Yeah but if Skywalker can drop a 'bomb" in a ventalation shaft no bigger than 2 meters Capt. Kirk could do it 8)
-
Kirk doesn't have the Force to guide him... and I doubt you'd get the Enterprise into the trench on the Death Star!
Def
-
I doubt that Capt. Kirk would have the "Force" with him. Anyways at least not the kind of force he would need to defeat Darth Vader and the Death Star. :D
-
Come on Kirk has got an inside girl. she drops the sheilds he slips in un noticed blamo. Or they pick up a klingon ship use the cloaking device and knock the force right out of them. Yes I know they would have to uncloak before firing but by that time its to late
-
Lots of gun towers on the surface of the Death Star....
And I think a green chick would be noticed on the Death Star!
Def
-
@RaptorMan said:
Come on Kirk has got an inside girl. she drops the sheilds he slips in un noticed blamo. Or they pick up a klingon ship use the cloaking device and knock the force right out of them. Yes I know they would have to uncloak before firing but by that time its to lateI do not remember seeing any females on the Death Star other than the Princess. Somehow I feel Darth Vader has gotten past the point of needing female companionship. Now there might be some stormtroopers that need that kind of entertainment. Anybody ever hear this short mp3 about stormtroopers?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lOnTtsL-tCM
I have this in .mp3 for a long time now but here is a youtube version.
-
All the women were in the kitchen
-
Death Star...I'll compare it to a battleship versus a PT boat.
-
. I think we need to look at the facts guys ::) :D :D. X2 Death Stars X2 mass space junk . How many times has the Enterprise been obliterated ( I know a few ::) :D ) ? The Enterprise was designed by Leatherman , Victorinox & some consultancy from SOG :D :D. The Death Star designed by Gerber on a bad day, looks impressive= think Suspension & Flik , but so many design flaws . The Enterprise's service history countless victories , Death Star was it one planet ? = no contest Star Fleet has the runs on the board.I feel like a right geek now :D :D :DThis reminds me , was it the original Clerks movie that the main characters discussed the morality of blowing up the partially completed Death Star.The issue being the Empire to complete the project would have had to use innocent independent contractors/tradesmen , just trying to make a living. Very funny. :D :D
-
Why are you guys even debating this? The issue has already been settled:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNxhrPaaCA4
(Very well done video I might add)

-
Cookies rock

-
I went with the Enterprise... Those photon torpedoes could get things cooking. :D By the way, did the Death Star have shields?
-
Death star no question. Comparing the two is like saying who would win a fight, a cat or a tiger. :D
-
@NeitherExtreme said:
I went with the Enterprise... Those photon torpedoes could get things cooking. :D By the way, did the Death Star have shields?Yeah Death Star had shields but for some reason it kept getting blown up.
I go with Yoda yeah I think that should have been an option :D
but I did vote for the Enterprise
-
It depends on which side has Mike Ditka.
-
Don't forget starfleet went up against the borg and their cubes and beat them, the puny death star is no challenge.

-
Death star ***WILL ***win.

-
Deathstar no question, as despite the power of the Enterprise (what one A,B,C,D,E?) it would never get close enough to cause any major damage, and as for beeming across, well Stormtrooper's may suck as soldiers (they really do) but they'd have weight of numbers on there side.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login