Who would win?
-
Deathstar no question, as despite the power of the Enterprise (what one A,B,C,D,E?) it would never get close enough to cause any major damage, and as for beeming across, well Stormtrooper's may suck as soldiers (they really do) but they'd have weight of numbers on there side.
-
Enterprise! They'd find a way! :D
-
they can always just beam a torpedo into the right place and BOOM no more death star

-
IMO the Death Star is like one of them "super guns" the germans used during the war, a very good punch but poor maneuverability
and easy target.The Enterprise has powerful shields (which stopped the romulans super weapon by backing up ::) ) and uses warp drive for battle
maneuvers. All Kirk would have to do is stay outta the way of the main gun on the D.S. and slowly chip away to the chewy center!and don't forget the Tribble factor, Kirk could beam some over and all you'd have is one great big "headless" hamster ball, rolling
around the galaxy! :D -
IMOHO, the Federation can destroy the deathstar but the Empire would conquer the Federation. One thing the Federation don't have is a strong army which the Empire have with their storm troopers and don't forget Darth Vader.
-
Logically (yeh I know maybe not the best thing to apply) the Enterprise hasn't a chance. The weakness in the Death Star's defence is in small fighters not larger craft. The Death Star destroys several rebel ships at the end of Return of the Jedi. If the Death Star's main gun can destroy planets what chance has the Enterprises' shields? They seem to fall down if a Ferengi farts in the wrong direction. ;)
-
@Gareth UK said:
If the Death Star's main gun can destroy planets what chance has the Enterprises' shields? They seem to fall down if a Ferengi farts in the wrong direction. ;)Yes the Death Star's main gun is awesome, but you have the big trouble of getting it to point in the right direction. A Death Star isn't the most maneuverable piece of equipment!! The Enterprise could quite easily stay out of the line of fire. However you do have the problem of the mound of Tie Fighters and point defence weapons :ahhh Assuming they could penetrate the Enterprises sheilds it would be bye bye Enterprise! But if it was just the Enterprise against the main gun of the Death Star the Enterprise would win hands down 8)
-
And even though the Death Star might have Darth Vader, don't forget that the Enterprise can always "remodulate the frequency" or "reverse the polarity" and save the day!! :ahhh
-
With James Tiberius Kirk at the helm the Enterprise can achieve ANYTHING

-
Enterprise all the way!!! The Empire is nothing butt brut force and sending massive amounts of troops dead on. Can compare their tactics you used during 18th & 19th century, you know, the armies stands face to face and shoot at each otter till someone looses.
Enterprise and Federation/Starfleet on the other hand is smart and cunning. They use there brains and have captains that is not afraid that an admiral will kill them if they FUBAR, hey, lets just face it, Kirk aren’t afraid of no one.
-
Death star. ;)
-
@Gareth UK said:
If the Death Star's main gun can destroy planets what chance has the Enterprises' shields?Even the old Enterprise has faced planet killers several times, and won; "Dooms Day Machine" (planet eating cornucopia) and "Balance of Terror" (first time they see the Romulan's new toy), not counting the B,C,D,E ships!

-
Well the question is "Could the Enterprise destroy the Death Star?" Possibly, however, they may possibly be destroyed too. Does the Enterprise even have defenses against the hordes of Tie Fighters, Bombers and Interceptors that would be involved too?
Of course this begs the bigger question, what happens in a war between the Federation and the Galactic Empire.
Let's think about this.
The REAL power of the Empire is in its Star Destroyers and Super Star Destroyers, the Death Star is primarily a terror weapon. There's no way in hell a Federation star ship could even come close to even hurting a run of the mill Star Destroyer. It's slower, has less guns, is almost 1/3 the size and carries no small one man fighting ships. And the Empire has tens of thousands of them. They have more warships than the Federation has planets.
-
OK, so here is an interesting scenario;
A Star Destroyer is more than five times longer than Kirk's Enterprise (and two-and-a-half times longer than Picard's Enterprise). So if size is anything to go by, the Enterprise stands little chance in a frontal assault.
However, the Federation has more advanced technology in some respects-- notably, transporter technology-- and if the Enterprise crew can draw upon their much more extensive mission experience, the situation is much more hopeful. For example: Kirk, Spock, and McCoy inject themselves with hefty doses of kironide, the chemical that gives psychokinetic powers (Plato's Stepchildren), then transport directly to the bridge of the Star Destroyer to confront Darth Vader on an equal telekinetic footing. They stun Vader with phasers set on wide dispersion (so he can't block them with his light saber), then take him back to the Enterprise. Before he wakes up they use the transporter to split Vader into his good and evil halves (The Enemy Within). The evil Vader is kept under sedation while the good one tells them everything they need to know to overthrow the Empire. Then the Enterprise uses a slingshot orbit around the nearest sun in order to go back in time (The Voyage Home, et al.) and prevent the fall of the Old Republic. The End.
Taken from here;
http://rjmason.com/ramblings/starTrekVsStarWars.htmlI still think Vader would death strangle Kirk while on screen.

-
Nice scenario but highly dependent on luck. 20000 Star Destroyers overwhelming Federation Space is a lot less dependent on luck.
-
I repeat for those that obviously did not hear me:

ahem...cough cough...
"With James Tiberius Kirk at the helm the Enterprise can achieve ANYTHING
" -
the Death Star was made as a "fear weapon" not a true battleship.
also the Empire is a space bully, only going after weak, unsuspecting,
antiquated opponents.while the Federation has battled countless war hungry foes,
in many dimensions, time zones, and often vastly superior!

-
SCENE: Space
The Enterprise sits stationary in space.
The Death Star dwarfs the small vessel.SCENE: Enterprise Bridge
Spock: "The object appears to be a man-made construct.
It is roughly the size of a small moon.
They do have some primitive technology."
Kirk: "We should beam over and investigate.
Sulu: "What about the prime directive, Captain?"
Kirk: "The what?"
Sulu (under breath): "Idiot."
Kirk: "Ok, all of you bridge crew... except you Uhura...
get ready to beam over."
Uhura (under breath): "Chauvinist pig."On the way to the transporter room, Kirk stops off at the RedShirt
holding pen and selects one unlucky RedShirt to accompany the brigde
crew onto the small metal planetoid.SCENE: Death Star Hallway
Six forms materialize. Captain Kirk, Mr. Spock, Mr. Sulu, Mr. Chekov,
Bones and the RedShirt appear, phasers out and ready. Closeup on Redshirt's
face reveals beads of sweat on his forehead. Eight Stormtroopers round
the corner.ST#1: "There are the intruders. Blast 'em!"
All eight Stormtroopers open fire. All eight hit the RedShirt.
The Enterprise's bridge crew return fire, obliterating the Stormtroopers.Kirk: "That wasn't so tough. My shirt didn't even get ripped."
Bones (kneeling over RedShirt's body): "He's dead, Jim."
Kirk: "Who?"
Bones: "Ensign... whatsizname? The RedShirt."
Kirk: "Oh! Him! Yeah, well... we have more."A doorway at the end of the hall slides open. The omnimous form of
Darth Vader fills the doorway. He is flanked by two Stormtroopers.Kirk (to crew): "Oh good! Another bad guy!"
Kirk (to Vader): "We come in peace!"
Kirk (to crew): "Phasers on kill!"The Enterprise's bridge crew open fire, concentrating on Vader.
Vader raises his hand and dissipates the energy of the phaser beams.Spock: "Our phasers seem to have no effect on him, Captain."
Kirk: "We'll just have to take him out in hand to hand. Use your nerve pinch."Spock advances on Vader, makes it about three feet then turns to Kirk.
Spock (strained voice): "Captain, I am experiencing a bizarre lack of oxygen.
I believe this entity is..."Spock keels over. Kirk has one of his infamous melodramatic moments,
yelling something unintelligible. Kirk charges Vader. There is a
brilliant red-white flash visual effect accompanied by a snap-hiss sound effect.
Kirk falls down, in two entirely separate directions, then dissolves.
His shirt is ripped, but it's too late to save him. Closeup on each of
the Enterprise's bridge crew exchanging amazed looks.
(Sulu doesn't look entirely displeased.)Sulu (into communicator): "Scotty, beam us up!"
Sulu (to no-one in particular): "I've always wanted to say that."The remaining bridge crew dematerialize. Vader kicks Kirks clothes on his
way back to the Death Star's command room.SCENE: Enterprise Bridge
The bridge crew race to their positions. Sulu assumes command and sits
in the comfy chair.SCENE: Death Star Command Room
Grand Moff Tarkin stands looking thoughtfully at a large display screen.
Vader stands nearby.Tarkin (to DS gunnery crew): "You may fire when ready."
Gunnery crew members start pulling levers and pushing buttons.
SCENE: Enterprise bridge
Chekov: "They zeem to be powering up zome zort of energy veapon!"SCENE: Death Star Innards
Two precariously placed, unlucky DS crew members cower as a brilliant
beam of energy streaks past them down a long tunnel.SCENE: Enterprise bridge
Sulu (yelling): "SHIELDS!"SCENE: Space
Several small beams of energy fuse into one really big one. The beam
strikes the Enterprise. Nifty explosion visual effect.SCENE: DS Command Center
Tarkin <to Vader>: "Well that wasn't so tough."
Vader: "We lost eight Stormtroopers."
Tarkin: "Well, we have more."FADE OUT.
This is funny.....................
-
fantastic Sir! 
-
"With James Tiberius Kirk at the helm the Enterprise can achieve ANYTHING
Pfft. What's he gonna do, screw Darth Vader to death?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login