Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
The neat thing about Fowlers win is he didn't bring a "survival" knife. He brought a Spirit and that shovel. Yes he had a axe and saw but I found it pretty neat and totally against what many profess is their go to when outdoors. Dave Canterbury for a while now as I'm many other have talked about how important an axe is outdoors. This is the go to for processing wood.
Being "fatter" I'm sure helped a bit too. He lost 70lbs overall and was still within what their medical team deemed ok to continue.
-
So I'm not fat, I'm just ready to survive
-
-
Even though I'm not familiar or comfortable using an axe, I can understand long term why you would want it.
On YT School of Self Reliance and Survival Russia there were recent videos about the advantages of a saw over an axe, both very convincing.
I guess it all depends on where you are, but I would find it very difficult to depend on a MT rather than a knife.
Had an interesting conversation with my cousin who is more a farm boy. He was very impressed with my shaving sharp Council tool, but pointed out there is a reason for the more obtuse (I think that's the right use of the word?) edge on locally used axes - very hard woods in general.
-
@Aloha007 said:
The neat thing about Fowlers win is he didn't bring a "survival" knife. He brought a Spirit and that shovel. Yes he had a axe and saw but I found it pretty neat and totally against what many profess is their go to when outdoors. Dave Canterbury for a while now as I'm many other have talked about how important an axe is outdoors. This is the go to for processing wood.Being "fatter" I'm sure helped a bit too. He lost 70lbs overall and was still within what their medical team deemed ok to continue.
I think the fact he carried an odd setup of tools but did make/ do so much, is one of the reasons why I was pulling for him to win it. I sure most "YouTube survivalist" would scoff at him and call him a hack bc he didn't carry a dedicated knife. Just goes to show that there is no secret formula to success in survival.
-
I'm glad he won I was just really pulling for one of the women to take it this year. Poor guy had to leave his family on the side of the road to make it to the airport to Patagonia. What a way to begin his journey.
I say yay for homesteaders and hurrah for guys like him who are do it yourselfers. Taking nothing away from the "survivalist" and those who had specialized skills. He didn't bring any food rations. Part of the 10 items can include food rations and from what I read he felt his tools were more important. The only item he brought that was IMO questionable was his sling shot. His shovel turned out to be quite a good tool out there. With the sharpened edge it was more like a hatchet/shovel/knife.
-
The shovel just proves that being familiar with your tools is a more important thing than simply owning the latest and greatest.
I can see the point behind the slingshot since it can take small game and is easier to carry around on a scout or water trip than a bow.
-
Knowing the capabilities of your tools and being able to actually use your tools seems simple enough. We've seen some accidents now on this show with participants. Its unfortunate however knowing how to properly use a tool and how to properly keep you safe from your tools is also very important. Accidents happen I understand this but it a great reminder.
-
It's not just that. If you're used to something like a Mora which is thin and then upgrade to shall we say a Becker BK-7, it still is a knife but not one that performs in the same way
-
@styx said:
It's not just that. If you're used to something like a Mora which is thin and then upgrade to shall we say a Becker BK-7, it still is a knife but not one that performs in the same way
I wonder how many participants actually have felling axe experience? Seems like they instinctively take gear they think they'll need. I wonder how many actually bring gear they've used on a regular basis?
-
It's not just that. If you're used to something like a Mora which is thin and then upgrade to shall we say a Becker BK-7, it still is a knife but not one that performs in the same way

I wonder how many participants actually have felling axe experience? Seems like they instinctively take gear they think they'll need. I wonder how many actually bring gear they've used on a regular basis?
I believe you're right about them bringing what they think they will need, or what they think they should have because it is expected of them, even if they have little or no experience with tools such as a felling axe. I'm not very comfortable with an axe myself and would rather have a good saw for hard woods and a machete for softer woods.
-
I'm sure they know what the previous participants 10 items were and working off the list they are given it makes sense. I have no experience with a large axe. I also have zero experience with a bow. Those items would not be brought by me.
I don't think even with a month or two I'd not be comfortable enough to choose either.
-
Well if you chopped for 6 hours a day, every day for a month, I'd wager you'd be fine
-
I agree^^
You will be an expert axe swinger after a short while. Safety first....And as demonstrated this season always walk with it in its scabbard/sheath.
As for the bow, I am in beginner lessons and you will be shooting in minutes, relatively confident in close range shots landing in the "neighbourhood" of where you are aiming within hours....and besides, when will you ever have so much time to practice other than when on this show?
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
Sign me up for a location without poisonous animals....Or ticks.
Doesn't New Zealand have herds of wild cattle and feral goats?
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
Considering everything, I'd be willing to take on a lion with a few dozen ticks on for $50 at this point
As for axe use, have you seen the cord wood axe challenge?
-
lol, nope haven't seen cordwood challenge
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
So where can I sign up to get a vacation from the idiots around me? Those cougars and bears on the show somehow seem more agreeable
-
Did you have a tough day at work?
I want to be hired by the State of Texas to hunt the Wild Hog professionally.
I don't fully understand the hog problem though. Why wouldn't all of the ranchers that are having problems get organized and begin a eradication program to reduce the population on their range?
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
Yup, tough day at work. And then found out that someone cost me 30k, so the day got a bit tougher
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login