Braided wire cutting.
-
@Vidar said:
I actually tried looking for some bicycle or lawnmover control wire to try varius pliers. Those sized wires seem quite appropriate for normal daily life tasks, and should reasonably be within expected range of a good plier?Typically though, when you need something it is nowhere to be found. When you don't it is in your face wherever you go.
(I'm planning to mount an expedition later to some uncharted territories not frequented by man since last millenium. There are rumours among the natives that sound like sightings of an old lawnmover. I might also come back with some new species).
Cogs turning in head...
<a href="http://cool-smileys.com//smiley-with-a-light-bulb-above-his-head" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer"><img src="http://www.cool-smileys.com/images/58.gif" alt="banner" style="max-width: 100%; height: auto;" /></a>
I understand!

17 years is a lot of time.
Not sure about the new species bit though.

-
Removed - duplicate reply
-
I have been on an laborious expedition. I climbed, jumped a few low obstacles, and ducked once, before I indeed located the well preserved remains of a last century lawn mover. As luck would have it there was a note next to the carcass stating that it would donate any useble organs or parts to worthy causes like machinery in need, science or bizarre experiments.
I chose a control wire of galvanized steel. That seemed like a normal non-industrial everyday thing to cut and repair. I've lined up some pliers and a selection of multi-tools for testing. It is raining heavily outside right now though, so I plan to wait that out as I don't want to fill any inside areas with lots of tiny metal splinters. (Although I'm sure I would clean them out over time by getting them stuck in my feet and hands... Where is that magnetic cleaner when I could actually use one? I can feel another expedition coming up at some point).
What I can say already though is that a Knipex bolt end cutting plier cuts such a wire with great ease indeed. So easy in fact that I'm surprised if any other plier fails - actually I might even try some tough scissors just for the smurf of it.
-
The rubbish Leatherman Super Tool 300 cutting 1/16" (1.6mm) braided wire, both uncoated and nylon coated.
https://youtu.be/Dh_d-H-USoo
The rubbish Leatherman Rebar cut so well on occasion that it shot some wire sections across the vanity even without a dedicated stranded wire cutter. -
I have a pair of Klein cable cutters, use them for heavy gauge stranded electrical wire. I'm not sure how thick those brake cables are, but these would most likely do the trick. I will post a pic tomorrow, in the mean time here is a stock pic of the tool:

-
Yeah, but where is the bottle opener?!?
-
Hit the bottle with that thing and it should be open..? :D
-
I've been annoyed about this for a while, specifically with bike brake cables. It would have been really nice if a MT like my Charge could do this simple task. Trying it with a Skeletool ruined the wire cutters, dented them badly.
As for the cost vs features, not sure. You could say the same about the scissors deficiencies. Or the file. Etc, etc.We're paying for a whole bunch of tool compromises put together into a single streamlined package. We're paying for the combination not the tools if that makes sense. Could be better tool design choices inside that combination and it could be cheaper. I fully agree. Especially at the Leatherman price points. Not being a USA citizen it does become tedious to pay a premium markup for US build which I do not particularly find reflected in the actual item quality itself, at least not to the extent the price markup might suggest. Referring to my experience in general rather than Leatherman specifically.
-
I've done the tests, but as it turned out to be fairly comprehensive I put them in their own thread - "plier cutting test" - or something like that.
-
@pomsbz said:
I've been annoyed about this for a while, specifically with bike brake cables. It would have been really nice if a MT like my Charge could do this simple task. Trying it with a Skeletool ruined the wire cutters, dented them badly.As for the cost vs features, not sure. You could say the same about the scissors deficiencies. Or the file. Etc, etc.We're paying for a whole bunch of tool compromises put together into a single streamlined package. We're paying for the combination not the tools if that makes sense. Could be better tool design choices inside that combination and it could be cheaper.** I fully agree. Especially at the Leatherman price points. Not being a USA citizen it does become tedious to pay a premium markup for US build which I do not particularly find reflected in the actual item quality itself, at least not to the extent the price markup might suggest**. Referring to my experience in general rather than Leatherman specifically.
Exactly so, almost choked on my lunch earlier...decided to check what amazon are listing the MUT for

£210 bloody quid!!
Leatherman Mut - Military multi-tool with bronze carbon scraper, with a total of 16 built-in tools, made in USA, black finish with a brown Molle holster : Amazon.co.uk: Sports & Outdoors
Leatherman Mut - Military multi-tool with bronze carbon scraper, with a total of 16 built-in tools, made in USA, black finish with a brown Molle holster : Amazon.co.uk: Sports & Outdoors
(www.amazon.co.uk)
An' it don't cut smurfe!!!
-
I've been annoyed about this for a while, specifically with bike brake cables. It would have been really nice if a MT like my Charge could do this simple task. Trying it with a Skeletool ruined the wire cutters, dented them badly.
As for the cost vs features, not sure. You could say the same about the scissors deficiencies. Or the file. Etc, etc.We're paying for a whole bunch of tool compromises put together into a single streamlined package. We're paying for the combination not the tools if that makes sense. Could be better tool design choices inside that combination and it could be cheaper.** I fully agree. Especially at the Leatherman price points. Not being a USA citizen it does become tedious to pay a premium markup for US build which I do not particularly find reflected in the actual item quality itself, at least not to the extent the price markup might suggest**. Referring to my experience in general rather than Leatherman specifically.
Exactly so, almost choked on my lunch earlier...decided to check what amazon are listing the MUT for

£210 bloody quid!!
Leatherman Mut - Military multi-tool with bronze carbon scraper, with a total of 16 built-in tools, made in USA, black finish with a brown Molle holster : Amazon.co.uk: Sports & Outdoors
Leatherman Mut - Military multi-tool with bronze carbon scraper, with a total of 16 built-in tools, made in USA, black finish with a brown Molle holster : Amazon.co.uk: Sports & Outdoors
(www.amazon.co.uk)
An' it don't cut smurfe!!!
I've been thinking this through. A multitool is a collection of compromises. I don't consider a single tool on my Charge AL to be optimal for its intended task. Not one. But. I cannot carry an even slimmed down set of 'non compromised' tools without it being over 3 times the bulk (pliers/cutters/file/screwdriver). So every time I use my Charge I wish I had the proper tool in my hand. But every time I'm using the Charge it's because I don't and wouldn't have had that tool to hand. Because they don't fit in my bag or would not be in my pocket.
That said I believe you mentioned that in the plier cutting test the Victorinox tested far better cutting cable. They also seem to be significantly cheaper. Perhaps that might be a solution for you? Sell out of Leatherman and move to Victorinox. If it works for you, why not? Given the pricing in the UK you should break even. For me the Victorinox had its own set of compromises which didn't fit my needs. Namely OHO blade and no bit driver slot built in.
I'm a photographer. They make zoom lenses which allow you lots of different types of view from a given stand point. The more zoom you get the more you pay usually. The non zoom lenses, even the ones costing 80 quid, will easily outperform the vast majority of these zoom lenses. Even the ones costing a grand. But they can't do all the other stuff. I have a fancy that in whatever field of engineering, whether tools or electronics, you pay more for compromise if that compromise spans more capability than the speSmurfpillst item.
Whether that compromise is worth the cost is usually dependant on the users specific needs and what the competition is offering. Competition is incredibly valuable. Without it innovation stagnates, prices rise and QC drops.
-
@pomsbz said:
I've been thinking this through. A multitool is a collection of compromises. I don't consider a single tool on my Charge AL to be optimal for its intended task. Not one. But. I cannot carry an even slimmed down set of 'non compromised' tools without it being over 3 times the bulk (pliers/cutters/file/screwdriver). So every time I use my Charge I wish I had the proper tool in my hand. But every time I'm using the Charge it's because I don't and wouldn't have had that tool to hand. Because they don't fit in my bag or would not be in my pocket.Agreed.
A multi-tool is basically a trade off between the capabilities of speSmurfpillsts tools versus the portability of the jack-of-all-trades. And often it makes sense to pay extra for that capable portable package.One qualifier though: The compromise must be still be good enough to do the job. If not the multi-tool is effectively worse then nothing as you think you have a tool for the task, but instead it turns out you have just been carrying a dead weight. To me it seems that is often the difference between a good and bad multi-tool, and that difference is worth paying for.
-
Well said pomsbz.
A big part of all this is that decent multitools retail for ridiculous amounts in some places. The ones in the shops here cost three times more than what I managed to buy mine online (shipped from US) for. So we expect a lot if we pay full retail. In fact what I paid even seems too much.
-
I cut the wire in my test with four different LM tools, including the one I had in my pocket that I needed to use at the hardware store to cut the cables off the spools.
Three of those tools each cost less than $50 since I don't buy new.
One came from Pearl Harbor in Hawaii. Another shipped from Naval Station Rota in Cádiz, Spain. I'm an ocean away from one and an ocean and a continent away from the other. I just don't understand the price complaints. -
A Surge retails here for about $250NZD. I bought my Surge from the US for $120NZD including postage, and at that time they were well over $300NZD in store here.
$120NZD is about $90USD at the moment (I can't remember what it was 3 years ago) and I still consider that expensive.
-
$90 is about the most I've paid as well. I consider that expensive too. A 2018 Mercedes-Benz GLS450 starts at $69,550USD. I consider that expensive too. But I don't have to buy either of those products, do I?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login