Drawer queens.
-
That you will my very young apprentice :D
-
I have many queens but I do understand your point Ben. SAKs are the the only thing I've collected in my adult life. I guess I got here by accident and the whole act of collecting I still find strange.
I suppose the argument is similar to the collection of art, it has no practical purpose so why own it. I find SAKs to be nice objects in and of themselves. This probably explains why I'm drawn to fancier "pretty" SAKs. :)
Yes I could just enjoy looking at photos but these are very tactile objects and I think they really do need to be held. Along those lines sometimes I will buy a knife and six months down the line sell it, it was nice to appreciate it for a bit, have a play but I don't always feel the need to hang on to every SAK I get.
Perhaps at the end of the day I collect because I'm a bit nuts, I can live with that :D
Neil
-
Sound reasons to me mate :)
-
@NKB said:
...I'm a bit nuts, I can live with that :DNeil
Now I can understand that. :D
The way I see it though, art is what it is - art, and therefore has been "created" to be looked at and displayed. Therefore collecting art is only really doing what it was intended to do. Doing this with SAK's is going against everything they were intended to do IMO.
I suppose I can understand retiring oldies (although that isn't for me) and I can even understand having a spare back-up tool or SAK. But buying something which is new just to never use it and leave it BNIB? Unless it's for investment purposes, I just don't get that.
-
As a recent owner of an XAVT, I guess I better weigh in here. :ahhh
I only get tools I plan on using. The XAVT is the closest to NOT meeting this standard. I never plan to EDC it. However, I do pull it it out for mild duty.
For example, last night, my wife wanted to remove watch batteries from dress watches she isn't wearing currently. The XAVT has a specific blade for this. Although I was nervous at going at expensive watches for the first time with it, the blade worked perfectly.
Oddly enough, I use the barometer and thermometer on it frequently too.

Mostly however, I like it because I like to fiddle with it. :D
On the other hand, I look for opportunities to use the Cybertool 41.

-
-
I think it's just a personality thing mostly. Some people are collectors, some aren't. And then there's me... I would be a collector, but I don't have the cash. :D From what I can tell, the collecting "bug" usually happens for three major reasons... (1)investment purposes, (2)preservation of history, or (3)just plain old fashioned hoarding. :D Anyway, if someone has the collecting bug, they're going to collect what interests them, and it doesn't seem to need to have any practical use related to the original intent of the object (stamp collecting, anyone?).
-
@Mr. Whippy said:
As a recent owner of an XAVT, I guess I better weigh in here. :ahhhI only get tools I plan on using. The XAVT is the closest to NOT meeting this standard. I never plan to EDC it. However, I do pull it it out for mild duty.
For example, last night, my wife wanted to remove watch batteries from dress watches she isn't wearing currently. The XAVT has a specific blade for this. Although I was nervous at going at expensive watches for the first time with it, the blade worked perfectly.
Oddly enough, I use the barometer and thermometer on it frequently too.

Mostly however, I like it because I like to fiddle with it. :D
On the other hand, I look for opportunities to use the Cybertool 41.

So even your least used tool still gets used. :)

-
The only shelf queen I have is a Made in the USA Micra. I don't use it because I have another Micra that I use and the USA marked ones aren't being made any more.
-
The only drawer queens I have are my old SAK Soldiers and a Strider SMF.
-
@pocketgecko said:
The only drawer queens I have are my old SAK Soldiers and a Strider SMF.Have you ever used the Strider?
-
No, it was one of those foolish purchases. I wanted one, broke down after a year and finally got it, and the darn thing cost so much I am afraid to scratch it. It will probably end up being sold in the near future. I dont mind having some drawer queens that are for my collection but a good knife that just sits there isnt my thing.
-
@pocketgecko said:
No, it was one of those foolish purchases. I wanted one, broke down after a year and finally got it, and the darn thing cost so much I am afraid to scratch it. It will probably end up being sold in the near future. I dont mind having some drawer queens that are for my collection but a good knife that just sits there isnt my thing.But now you've got it, don't you just get a craving to use it.

I know if I'd wanted one for a year and then finally got it, it be desparate to give it a good test. :)
-
I have shelf queens and users.. I have tools for my collection and I buy duplicates to actually use.. Very sick, I know!
-
No, it was one of those foolish purchases. I wanted one, broke down after a year and finally got it, and the darn thing cost so much I am afraid to scratch it. It will probably end up being sold in the near future. I dont mind having some drawer queens that are for my collection but a good knife that just sits there isnt my thing.
But now you've got it, don't you just get a craving to use it.

I know if I'd wanted one for a year and then finally got it, it be desparate to give it a good test. :)
Oh, no doubt. I just cant get past the whole "I paid XX for this thing and now I am going to start wearing on it?". Like I said, just a poor choice on my part. It is one hella knife though. Very well made and very light.
-
Related topic:
In addition to the collector argument versus the user argument, how do you all feel about tools that show use as having character?
Provided they are not broken or nonfunctional in any way, does a well used, well cared for, and care worn tool have more value to you than a new in box oldie?
If say your grandfather or father or whatever gave you the option of inheriting the vintage knife/tool of your dreams, would you want one he had carried and used for decades, or the one he kept in a box untouched for you for decades?
-
In addition to the collector argument versus the user argument, how do you all feel about tools that show use as having character?
Provided they are not broken or nonfunctional in any way, does a well used, well cared for, and care worn tool have more value to you than a new in box oldie?
If say your grandfather or father or whatever gave you the option of inheriting the vintage knife/tool of your dreams, would you want one he had carried and used for decades, or the one he kept in a box untouched for you for decades?
A used tool is far more interesting to me. I like the character marks.
Apart from being a tight git :D, I will always buy used as I simply prefer them.
-
No question, a used tool with character is more appealing to me.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
