Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
I think it would all come down to calories. One exception would be the dugout canoe because they have a limitation on the size of tree they can take down, Which could bring up another question for all those taking the massive felling axes
-
I worked on the Zambezi river for a while, and I think the only thing worse than making a dugout is actually using it.......
I hope they do a dry & hot environment next......

-
Chihuahuan desert?
-
A dry environment would be interesting. While this show is neat and I enjoy it what we are seeing is what it would look like to just scrape by. There are some initial skills involved but after the first month we are seeing luck, environment, and grit played out. At some point the fishing goes away. We haven't really seen anyone trap much more than mice and fowlers bird. No actual bigger game was trapped or caught. The duck that was caught was a lame duck. I don't remember what else was eaten game wise
. Oh wait, the bothers also got a bird that stupidly walked right into their camp.We've seen some choose the bow and arrows yet no success was had ( on camera ). Starvation after the culling of the initial 10 seems to be where the demise of contestants lies. They seem to battle the cold relatively well. The bothers shelter was crap in their own words. The first really young man ( season 1 ) slept in basically a tarp tent the whole show.
Food is the real killer in these situations. Sure the mind goes for some, injures accounted for some departures, and of course those not really ready to do battle left within a week.
-
Fowler got one bird with a sling shot too. That might be the most anyone has caught with such active means
-
I was just thinking, might be difficult in a dry environment to leave participants in spots with roughly similar resources

Australian Outback?
African Bushveld?
-
Bushveld might be more dangerous due to large predators and other large animals (don't know much about the fauna of that place) plus the venomous reptiles. Outback mostly has those reptiles, crocs and spiders from what I know
-
True, but it's not Naked & Afraid, so hopefully they can get fire and shelter easy enough....
When you are equipped, those nasties can become snacks >:D
Logistics taken into account, what dry area in North America could be used?
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
~Logistics taken into account, what dry area in North America could be used?
Death Valley, any where in Southern California.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
With the lack of rainfall SoCal deserts would be very challenging. Anza-Borrego comes to mind. I'm sure there are some places in Arizona that would qualify as dry ;).
-
Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia have desert landscapes.
Sent from my XT1563 using Tapatalk
-
You'll have to try harder to sell your ideas....


Anza-Borrego
Anza-Borrego Desert State Park is the largest state park in California. Five hundred miles of dirt roads, 12 wilderness areas and many miles of hiking trails ...
Nope.......not remote enough by the looks of it.
Saskatchewan, Alberta and British Columbia have desert landscapes
Actually surprised to hear that

-
Even Croatia has a desert (only 20 hectares though) so not surprising that Canada has a few
-
Season 5 - making the cut is out
-
Nice. I've seen a teaser for the upcoming Alone. Mongolia seems like just the right place. We'll see.
-
DVR'd it last night, will watch it this weekend.
Mongolia will offer the harshest weather extremes if there in fall and early winter months, yet most likely the most balanced landscape with wildlife and vegetation.
Filming, support and emergency logistics will be very challenging for production as Mongolia is remote.
I am looking forward to see how these returning participants will perform and use the experiences learned on prior seasons. Should be very good for editing options and be very educational and entertaining for us arm chair survivor critics.
-
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutions -
@styx said:
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutionsThere are several variables we will likely not know. All are Americans, maybe associated to visa approvals to get staff into Mongolia. Jose IIRC lived in Canada, but held a Spanish citizenship.
The 4 hikers, never had a chance to participate do to their partners tapping out.
Two were removed by medical, for the safety of them.
Others I believe tapped because of family pulls in their minds, of course a baby on the way in season 1, put him in the hole before starting season 1.Just my thoughts...
-
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutionsThere are several variables we will likely not know. All are Americans, maybe associated to visa approvals to get staff into Mongolia. Jose IIRC lived in Canada, but held a Spanish citizenship.
The 4 hikers, never had a chance to participate do to their partners tapping out.
Two were removed by medical, for the safety of them.
Others I believe tapped because of family pulls in their minds, of course a baby on the way in season 1, put him in the hole before starting season 1.Just my thoughts...
Oh you're not wrong. I'm just curious as to how they approached their selection process
-
Found YouTube vids in which each person detailed their ten items. Several have selected a MT (Surge) instead of a knife as part of their 10 items.
Last season with the team concept, each member had a knife, and then ten items total by the team. This year the knife is part the ten item selection.
Interesting selections by them, differences regarding, pan with lid or a POT for cooking, saw and/or axe, knife and/or MT.
All were consistent, a sleeping bag, rated -20 degree F or colder.
Shelter appears to be the most crucial item to establish at camp this season. Fire, water, and food.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login