Any love for the Craftsman?
-
@NorCalJim said:
..Great tool set but why stop at 6 layers? For me, the Explorer gives me the magnifier and inline Philips together with the essentials in a practical carry 4 layer form factor. If pliers are important, then I can easily carry a LM Juice S2 in another pocket for a set of superior pliers. For those planning to carry the Craftsman in a small belt pouch, they could just as easily carry a Swiss Champ or a Spirit X.So love for the Craftsman? Strong like, maybe...and a sample for my collection but my love is reserved for SAKs with magnifiers and inline philips with Explorer at the top for portability, followed closely by the Swiss Champ (yeah, I include the magnifier bunch such as Champion, Yeoman, Woodsman, Passenger, Scientist, etc.)
BTW, no disrespect intended for the Victorinox pliers. I admire this precision tool for what it can do but for all-around tasks requiring pliers, I would look to a LM tool. In my case, with very modest requirements, a Juice is more than sufficient.
I'm not insulting your intelligence, but I just want to point out for the record that piers are OFTEN misunderstood and misused.
Pliers are for pinching, twisting, gripping, and pulling. They are not designed or intended for turning nuts and bolts; although, many of us use them for that (me included sometimes). Wrenches are for nuts and bolts. So when you consider and accept that, the Victorinox pliers are great for their size. They don't have the length of some others and they don't have handles that allow such a tight grip as some, but for most tasks outside of automotive work or heavy duty tasks,they work fine. For my average daily tasks, I have no need for LM sized pliers. I carry the Craftsman EDC and it's been plenty adequate. I have a garage full of tools so if I'm working on a serious project, I just grab tools off the workbench.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Al's logic path for appraising the Craftsman:
-
If I need pliers, I want better than these. This means accompanying it with a pliers based tool
(Action: Ditch pliers layer. Not needed) -
If I'm carrying a pliers based tool, the Phillips on that will offer higher torque and better access
(Action: Corkscrew with mini driver) -
If I'm carrying a pliers based tool, the medium flat driver on that will offer higher torque and better access
(Action: Ignore. Nothing to replace back spring driver with) -
Everything else on there is good and reliable, so I don't needsaw or file on pliers tool
(Action: Greater range of pliers tools can be considered)
Verdict: Buy a Ranger (or a CT41 if you want the additional driver capabilities) and select accompanying pliers tool accordingly

-
-
I'm quite glad they replaced the fish scaler with pliers. Can't remember the last time I had fish with scales.
Honestly, this got me thinking...throughout several threads we all ponder, debate, and lament various tools that seem odd enough that we struggle to find a job for them.
I've come to realize, that really bugs the heck out of me! I want my tools to make sense. I don't want to stare at a fish scaler or an orange peeler or some other oddball tool and try to justify it to myself.
While the Craftsman does not have every SAK tool in it. All the tools in the Craftsman are useful and logical. It makes sense to me!The perpendicular #2 Phillips is plenty useful. I've used it a lot. I truly think far more people fuss about the handle being in the way and not being able to turn the screw than there are people who have actually struggled with this issue.
In my experience so far, pretty much anywhere I can use a short #2, I have been able to use the SAK.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
And another problem with the corkscrew. On the Craftsman, I can open the wood chisel no problem--but with the Champion I recently got, the corkscrew is in the way.
-
Old style.
I'm quite glad they replaced the fish scaler with pliers. Can't remember the last time I had fish with scales.
Honestly, this got me thinking...throughout several threads we all ponder, debate, and lament various tools that seem odd enough that we struggle to find a job for them.
I've come to realize, that really bugs the heck out of me! I want my tools to make sense. I don't want to stare at a fish scaler or an orange peeler or some other oddball tool and try to justify it to myself.
While the Craftsman does not have every SAK tool in it. All the tools in the Craftsman are useful and logical. It makes sense to me!The perpendicular #2 Phillips is plenty useful. I've used it a lot. I truly think far more people fuss about the handle being in the way and not being able to turn the screw than there are people who have actually struggled with this issue.
In my experience so far, pretty much anywhere I can use a short #2, I have been able to use the SAK.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The trouble with the back Philips is the very limited torque that it can take. :-\
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
The trouble with the back Philips is the very limited torque that it can take. :-\While that's true it's relative in my view. My garage tools are lighter duty than an industrial automotive kit. If I am working on something that needs serious torque, I grab a bigger stronger tool.
I view the SAK as what it is:- Convenient for light duty
- An emergency self-rescue tool kit.
I don't consider the SAK--ANY SAK--to be a replacement for individual, dedicated tools.
It's a pocket sized miniature tool kit. I have to manage my expectations.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The Craftsman, Master Craftsman, Handyman and Delemont S557 are my favorite Vic tools, though I would like it if Victorinox came up with a Handyman without scissors and instead the Magnifying glass + inline Philips screwdriver. And of course with the Delemont-line locks for the screwdrivers. Probably I would go nuts with such a model and would buy 10 pieces right away.
In an urban environment I opt for the (Master) Craftsman because of its Philips screwdriver. It still can be pocket carried and in an urban environment there are more screws to fasten than there are bottle to be uncorked. Even for self defense purposes the back Philips can be a formidable effective attachment.
However in any outdoor survival happening I would choose the Handyman because when you're on foot in the woods a corkscrew has much more utility!Recently I bought this 2nd hand Craftsman for only € 10. Is had very abused scales, because it was used as a hammer (who on earth is using pocket knives as hammers??
) All tools were in excellent condition.
So I cleaned it a little bit and put brand new scales on it (only € 1.99). Total costs € 11.99 !!If you ever walked outdoors (and even indoors!) with an outward bent shoe lace hook on your boot, you would be desperate for the pliers!
-
@EMZ said:
The Craftsman, Master Craftsman, Handyman and Delemont S557 are my favorite Vic tools, though I would like it if Victorinox came up with a Handyman without scissors and instead the Magnifying glass + inline Philips screwdriver. And of course with the Delemont-line locks for the screwdrivers. Probably I would go nuts with such a model and would buy 10 pieces right away.In an urban environment I opt for the (Master) Craftsman because of its Philips screwdriver. It still can be pocket carried and in an urban environment there are more screws to fasten than there are bottle to be uncorked. Even for self defense purposes the back Philips can be a formidable effective attachment.
However in any outdoor survival happening I would choose the Handyman because when you're on foot in the woods a corkscrew has much more utility!Recently I bought this 2nd hand Craftsman for only € 10. Is had very abused scales, because it was used as a hammer (who on earth is using pocket knives as hammers??
) All tools were in excellent condition.
So I cleaned it a little bit and put brand new scales on it (only € 1.99). Total costs € 11.99 !!If you ever walked outdoors (and even indoors!) with an outward bent shoe lace hook on your boot, you would be desperate for the pliers!
Where did you get €2 euro scales? :)
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
The Craftsman, Master Craftsman, Handyman and Delemont S557 are my favorite Vic tools, though I would like it if Victorinox came up with a Handyman without scissors and instead the Magnifying glass + inline Philips screwdriver. And of course with the Delemont-line locks for the screwdrivers. Probably I would go nuts with such a model and would buy 10 pieces right away.
In an urban environment I opt for the (Master) Craftsman because of its Philips screwdriver. It still can be pocket carried and in an urban environment there are more screws to fasten than there are bottle to be uncorked. Even for self defense purposes the back Philips can be a formidable effective attachment.
However in any outdoor survival happening I would choose the Handyman because when you're on foot in the woods a corkscrew has much more utility!Recently I bought this 2nd hand Craftsman for only € 10. Is had very abused scales, because it was used as a hammer (who on earth is using pocket knives as hammers??
) All tools were in excellent condition.
So I cleaned it a little bit and put brand new scales on it (only € 1.99). Total costs € 11.99 !!If you ever walked outdoors (and even indoors!) with an outward bent shoe lace hook on your boot, you would be desperate for the pliers!
Where did you get €2 euro scales? :)
That!
Is a good question...
-
91mm and 91mm SwissChamp scales for € 1.99.
58mm scales for € 1.49.
Needle is € 0.15 and cord € 0.50.
You can buy it at: taschenmesser-onlineshop.de
They have great service! -
Ships to the likes of Belgium and Germany, but not UK or Ireland. :(
-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
Ships to the likes of Belgium and Germany, but not UK or Ireland. :(
Really?
Oh boy oh boy!Lol.

-
@Poncho65 said:
If I had one I would talk about it :D They are a great SAK and the older version is the fraternal twin brother to the Ranger
one with corkscrew other with Phillips
I always have a MT with a Phillips driver or at least always have my Gerber Shard so the Phillips thing isn't as big of a deal and that is why I am content with the Ranger I guess 
I think you mean the Master Craftsman?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I was a long time user of the Handyman... It is my very first real SAK. Wish I had the Craftsman then... prefer the phillips over the corks screw... It is a thick sak with 6 layers... So I don't carry it in my person... it stayed in my bag...
The backside phillips came in handy many times... except that it always folded on me during heavy torque action... Pliers was of no help except being an oversized tweezer...
Then I found the Explorer... went to the dark side when I discovered I could make a Yeoman...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
@Tired_Yeti said:
While the Craftsman does not have every SAK tool in it. All the tools in the Craftsman are useful and logical. It makes sense to me!The perpendicular #2 Phillips is plenty useful. I've used it a lot. I truly think far more people fuss about the handle being in the way and not being able to turn the screw than there are people who have actually struggled with this issue.
In my experience so far, pretty much anywhere I can use a short #2, I have been able to use the SAK.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
The Craftsman is a great sak, but not for pocket carry, which is the way i carry all of mine most of the time. That's why i gave it's brother (Handyman) away, didn't use it.
As for the backside Phillips, i stopped trusting it as a reliable all around SD, for nothing more than low/very low torque use, a long time ago. Never had much of a problem with it's actual placement for usage, yes it's not ideal but nothing on a sak is "ideal", that's the whole point, Sak's are not meant to replace tools, it's meant to be something small and light you carry in your pocket that, apart from being a pocket knife, has tools that can help you save the day in a pinch and you have nothing else near suitable available to you, not to be confused with "just something you use when ever you need tools..."

My problem with the backside Phillips actual usage is it's sturdiness and mounting, the driver itself is a great driver, the way it's mounted on the Sak (for the kind of stress it endures during usage) it's not. I bent the pin and liner on my first supertinker just with medium torque taking some screws of the backplate of a desktop PC tower tha wasn't even that tight...

So even if i still love the whole Tinker line, it's not for the Phillips terrible great usage, other than occasional very light torque situations, i just love it be cause it looks good there and it makes the Sak feel and look sleeker

But than again i love the look of the CS equally, so...
:ahhh
:D -
So far, it seems the chief complaint against the Craftsman design is the perpendicular Phillips's inability to tolerate torque. I agree. As I mentioned in another post, I don't consider this SAK as a replacement for a set of dedicated tools.
My argument for the Craftsman is:
- It has a set of recognizable, very useful tools. No unfamiliar or confusing orange peelers or fish scalers or other odd tools. Every tool onboard has familiar applications and are miniature versions of tools commonly used daily. The only tools I'd like to have that aren't in there is the pen and, maybe, the magnifier.
- While the perpendicular Phillips can't take much torque, neither can the corkscrew. In general, the Phillips is more commonly necessary and useful than a corkscrew for most people.
So, yes, that's a small dig against the Handyman...but, that's why I chose the Craftsman.
The corkscrew hates torque

All other comparisons seems to be against either larger SAKs with more layers or smaller SAKs with fewer tools. For this layer count, I don't know of a SAK with a better tool layout.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
It's all subjective, but I'd rather have the inline Phillips(which can take lots of torque) with a useless corkscrew, than the backside Phillips and a layer less.

-
@Tired_Yeti said:
So far, it seems the chief complaint against the Craftsman design is the perpendicular Phillips's inability to tolerate torque. I agree. As I mentioned in another post, I don't consider this SAK as a replacement for a set of dedicated tools.My argument for the Craftsman is:
- It has a set of recognizable, very useful tools. No unfamiliar or confusing orange peelers or fish scalers or other odd tools. Every tool onboard has familiar applications and are miniature versions of tools commonly used daily. The only tools I'd like to have that aren't in there is the pen and, maybe, the magnifier.
- While the perpendicular Phillips can't take much torque, neither can the corkscrew. In general, the Phillips is more commonly necessary and useful than a corkscrew for most people.
So, yes, that's a small dig against the Handyman...but, that's why I chose the Craftsman.
The corkscrew hates torque

All other comparisons seems to be against either larger SAKs with more layers or smaller SAKs with fewer tools. For this layer count, I don't know of a SAK with a better tool layout.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
How did that happen???
Obviously not opening a bottle of wine...
-
@El Corkscrew said:
So far, it seems the chief complaint against the Craftsman design is the perpendicular Phillips's inability to tolerate torque. I agree. As I mentioned in another post, I don't consider this SAK as a replacement for a set of dedicated tools.
My argument for the Craftsman is:
- It has a set of recognizable, very useful tools. No unfamiliar or confusing orange peelers or fish scalers or other odd tools. Every tool onboard has familiar applications and are miniature versions of tools commonly used daily. The only tools I'd like to have that aren't in there is the pen and, maybe, the magnifier.
- While the perpendicular Phillips can't take much torque, neither can the corkscrew. In general, the Phillips is more commonly necessary and useful than a corkscrew for most people.
So, yes, that's a small dig against the Handyman...but, that's why I chose the Craftsman.
The corkscrew hates torque

All other comparisons seems to be against either larger SAKs with more layers or smaller SAKs with fewer tools. For this layer count, I don't know of a SAK with a better tool layout.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
How did that happen???
Obviously not opening a bottle of wine...
Unless the bottle was the wrong way up :P :D
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login