Wool as an outer layer
-
I love them! They look stylish, have pockets for days, and they're warm. They're virgin wool so they can feel a little scratchy. Below about 20 degrees F, you might need to start adding layers under it.
https://www.filson.comSent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I've been seeing a bit of uprise in the line of thought that wool is a great outer layer for hiking, backpacking and other outdoor activities even in rain, snow and sleet.
While I understand that wet wool still keeps it's insulation value, tests have shown that it still acts like a wet piece of clothing when it comes to windchill. And I can personally attest to that.
So am I missing something with this wool outer craze?Yes, you're missing something...and it's in your own post. wool as an OUTER layer.
If it's your outer player then it's not directly against your skin. If your middle layer is windproof, it will block the windchill.
I lived in Alaska for 32 years and wore either a Filson Mackinaw Cruiser or a Filson Double Mackinaw Cruiser (pictured) for a couple decades worth of winters without a problem. Both are virgin wool.


I still have my Double mackie even though I live in Texas now. It's just too nice a coat to part with.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
so basically a windproof mid layer under the wool outer. why does that sound reversed somehow?
Maybe you're envisioning a thin wool jacket? The Filson coats I wore were made of 24oz. and 26oz. virgin wool. They were definitely made to be your outer layer. You'd have a hard time fitting something over one. You might be able fit a very oversized raincoat or poncho over one, I suppose.
Wool is durable and retains its thermal properties even when damp so if your under layer blocks the wind from your skin, a heavy wool coat will still keep you warm. At least in my experience.
The downside, in my experience, is that wool can be rather heavy; whereas, Gortex isn't. You can imagine a coat made of 24oz. per square yard fabric isn't lightweight.Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Could be that I'm also thinking about something more loosely woven.
So how did you layer the things under it? For some reason a windproof layer to me is a bright colored windshirt and that is tripping me up very much -
I've heard of those Filson jackets. Really great looking and from your account sounds like a wonderful article of clothing.
-
@50ft-trad said:
An interesting point has been touched on here. These days, we fixate upon getting the kit to suit our routine (first world problem), whereas in the old days, you adapted the routine to suit the kit available. We survived a good few millennia without synthetic materials, but it is almost deemed defeatist these days to have to compromise your routine in any way to accommodate kit limitations ....
Chalk that up to how much we're bombarded by advertisements. Most magazines are nothing more than disguised press releases to get you buy the next better thing.
-
@Tired_Yeti said:
Wool is durable and retains its thermal properties even when damp so if your under layer blocks the wind from your skin, a heavy wool coat will still keep you warm. At least in my experience.
The downside, in my experience, is that wool can be rather heavy; whereas, Gortex isn't. You can imagine a coat made of 24oz. per square yard fabric isn't lightweight.Yup. Back before synthetics, your only options were wool, fur, or waxed cotton, and they're all heavy compared to today's technologies. When you think about it, the lightweight down jackets we now see everywhere are a relatively modern invention (by Eddie Bauer in the 1940s). To get that level of warmth back in the day, you'd probably have to pile on two jackets.
-
They had matching pyjamas....
On the subject of buying the latest biggest and best gear....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZAtzN_ScKXY -
When you take into consideration that we also have a lot of approaches and discussions within those approaches, no wonder it gets to confusion through over analyzing things.
In the ultra light community you've got guys like Andrew Skurka and Chris Townsend who are well known, respectable and knowledgeable. The two of them have very different opinions on windshirts for instance.
Then you can add guys like Ross from Woodtrekker or Piotr Ma who aren't household names but fit in some area between lightweight backpacking and other outdoor, more traditional, activities for lack of a better description that add up weight. Again a lot of differences in weight and approach.
On topof that you have a lot of strong traditional communities like the bushcraft community that have their approach. Actually the garment that led to my initial confusion if the Lester river Boreal shirt -
@styx said:
When you take into consideration that we also have a lot of approaches and discussions within those approaches, no wonder it gets to confusion through over analyzing things.In the ultra light community you've got guys like Andrew Skurka and Chris Townsend who are well known, respectable and knowledgeable. The two of them have very different opinions on windshirts for instance.
Then you can add guys like Ross from Woodtrekker or Piotr Ma who aren't household names but fit in some area between lightweight backpacking and other outdoor, more traditional, activities for lack of a better description that add up weight. Again a lot of differences in weight and approach.
On topof that you have a lot of strong traditional communities like the bushcraft community that have their approach. Actually the garment that led to my initial confusion if the Lester river Boreal shirtSeems whomever you tend to feel more akin to in terms of philosophies is the direction one will head. When one is peeling off labels from food tins to save weight (
) then certain material make sense. Certainly the traditionalist will tend to favor natural materials. Then you have everyone in between.I seem to be in the middle somewhere. I do love my wool. I go to my local resell shops and scour the isles to find wool. I have got some decent pieces. Since it doesn't rain a whole lot in SoCal let alone snow ( ;) ) I can get away with nearly any material. I do not want or like to have my outer layer wet tho which is why I'll choose a breathable outer layer with a wool mid layer.
-
I think something can be learned from all approaches and a mix of them can give just about anyone the right answer for that individual
-
@styx said:
I think something can be learned from all approaches and a mix of them can give just about anyone the right answer for that individualYes I very much agree. We do know there are those who are slaves to traditions and those who need the next new material. I like technology as much as the next guy and also respect what has worked. The link I attached in one of my posts showed some wonderful advances in wool and how water and wind resistant/prof it has become. I'm all for this type of advance especially when keeping the integrity of the wool.
-
ARISE!!!! :ahhh
We had a bit of a cold spell this week, had to get out some warm clothes that had been packed away for a few weeks already.....
One of those was a wool sweater I got when I was 17, 1992 I think, critical point being that was in the middle of my growth spurt, so the sweater/jersey still fits....
I wore it regularly to work up until about 5 years ago, when it got relegated to about the house clothing.
That's a quarter century of service with some life left.

The main reason why Fleece has replaced wool in my wardrobe is price and quality, one went up and the other down.......no prizes for guessing which

-
so it felt like seeing an old friend after years of mischief?
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
