Need help finding a new work tool...
-
@ThundahBeagle said:
Dutch! Sync!I like what you have done with the Surge. You have made it...perfect.
Thanks, although my activities were purely mental at this stage. Transforming that into realtiy is becoming rather attractive, though

-
I think the only other production tool (maybe just discontinued) with all those features in one is the Gerber MP1 (by putting a PH driver bit on the exchanger)?
/topic/47327
-
@ThePeacent said:
I think the only other production tool (maybe just discontinued) with all those features in one is the Gerber MP1 (by putting a PH driver bit on the exchanger)?/topic/47327
I seriously considered the MP1 too but read too many reports of the tools being weak. Also no file on the MP1.
-
I think the only other production tool (maybe just discontinued) with all those features in one is the Gerber MP1 (by putting a PH driver bit on the exchanger)?
/topic/47327
I seriously considered the MP1 too but read too many reports of the tools being weak. Also no file on the MP1.
Despite being a fan of (some) Gerbers, I cannot recommend any which are outboard with the Saf-T-Lock system. Too many times I have found that with one implement deployed, the lock bar does not return back fully to the "home" position, leaving other tools in that handle to flop out a bit. This is not an issue withb the inboard configurations (MP 400, MP600, Diesel), and I didn't suffer it on the MP700s either, but the Strata and Fit both suffered from this. If a driver was deployed for example, a sharp tool (knife) could fall from the handle enough to risk injury. This is one of the reasons that I personally would not consider the MP1 / Shift
Have you tried a Swisstool? It doesn't have OHO, but neither does your beloved ST300
-
@50ft-trad said:
I think the only other production tool (maybe just discontinued) with all those features in one is the Gerber MP1 (by putting a PH driver bit on the exchanger)?
/topic/47327
I seriously considered the MP1 too but read too many reports of the tools being weak. Also no file on the MP1.
Despite being a fan of (some) Gerbers, I cannot recommend any which are outboard with the Saf-T-Lock system. Too many times I have found that with one implement deployed, the lock bar does not return back fully to the "home" position, leaving other tools in that handle to flop out a bit. This is not an issue withb the inboard configurations (MP 400, MP600, Diesel), and I didn't suffer it on the MP700s either, but the Strata and Fit both suffered from this. If a driver was deployed for example, a sharp tool (knife) could fall from the handle enough to risk injury. This is one of the reasons that I personally would not consider the MP1 / Shift
Have you tried a Swisstool? It doesn't have OHO, but neither does your beloved ST300
I do have both a Swisstool and a Spirit. I think they both are excellent tools and I carry them frequently when I'm not at work. The only issue I have with them is it's tough for me to get the tools out. My nails are often cut very short which makes accessing the tools a little tricky. Fine for home but a pain when on the job. I can get at the ST300 tools even with leather gloves on.
-
@50ft-trad said:
I think the only other production tool (maybe just discontinued) with all those features in one is the Gerber MP1 (by putting a PH driver bit on the exchanger)?
/topic/47327
I seriously considered the MP1 too but read too many reports of the tools being weak. Also no file on the MP1.
Despite being a fan of (some) Gerbers, I cannot recommend any which are outboard with the Saf-T-Lock system. Too many times I have found that with one implement deployed, the lock bar does not return back fully to the "home" position, leaving other tools in that handle to flop out a bit. This is not an issue withb the inboard configurations (MP 400, MP600, Diesel), and I didn't suffer it on the MP700s either, but the Strata and Fit both suffered from this. If a driver was deployed for example, a sharp tool (knife) could fall from the handle enough to risk injury. This is one of the reasons that I personally would not consider the MP1 / Shift
Have you tried a Swisstool? It doesn't have OHO, but neither does your beloved ST300
I do have both a Swisstool and a Spirit. I think they both are excellent tools and I carry them frequently when I'm not at work. The only issue I have with them is it's tough for me to get the tools out. My nails are often cut very short which makes accessing the tools a little tricky. Fine for home but a pain when on the job. I can get at the ST300 tools even with leather gloves on.

-
Dutch! Sync!
I like what you have done with the Surge. You have made it...perfect.
Thanks, although my activities were purely mental at this stage. Transforming that into realtiy is becoming rather attractive, though

You lose the ability to attach a Bit Extender HOWEVER if you attach a Removable Bit Driver to the Phillips you get the same result.

@clown said:
I don't suppose you recall what washer you used? I don't have any extra parts laying around and will have resource one from somewhere.No idea sorry. It may have been one of Zoidberg's spares.
-
Dutch! Sync!
I like what you have done with the Surge. You have made it...perfect.
Thanks, although my activities were purely mental at this stage. Transforming that into realtiy is becoming rather attractive, though

You lose the ability to attach a Bit Extender HOWEVER if you attach a Removable Bit Driver to the Phillips you get the same result.

Correct, thanks. I see my Surge as my 'tank' tool, i.e. sturdy and ready for whatever the world might throw at it, which tends to kind of 'limit' it to non-exchanger-type tools (yeah I know, there's the saw/file blade exchanger too) and that's why I can dig swapping the bit driver for the Phillips head. I happen to have a ST 300 Phillips head and a suitable removable bit driver (as a nod to flexibility) lying around unused... hmmm...
Sent on my SM-G930F with Tapatalk
-

Just pointing that out as some people LOVE their Bit Extenders. :)
-
Just pointing that out as some people LOVE their Bit Extenders. :)
Right :D. I do too, on certain tools, such as my ST 300 VX where I specifically added it - that is a bit closer to my normal carry for civilised urban environments where OHO is frowned upon, such as in Germany, and where I value the flexibility that the incorporated bit extender brings. But I'm sufficiently aware of mechanics to know that it, and the 2D bits, are not as strong as a dedicated Phillips head. Which is one more reason for starting to think it might be better placed on my Surge.
Edit: I feel as if I am starting to attribute distinct personalities to my tools. Sure sign of advanced affliction with the MTo virus, I fear...

Edit2: Clown's question is a valid one though - where did you source your washers? I could adapt M5 ones but better to have the right size from the get go.
Sent on my SM-G930F with Tapatalk
-
Dutch! Sync!
I like what you have done with the Surge. You have made it...perfect.
Thanks, although my activities were purely mental at this stage. Transforming that into realtiy is becoming rather attractive, though

You lose the ability to attach a Bit Extender HOWEVER if you attach a Removable Bit Driver to the Phillips you get the same result.

@clown said:
I don't suppose you recall what washer you used? I don't have any extra parts laying around and will have resource one from somewhere.No idea sorry. It may have been one of Zoidberg's spares.
Sorry to drop in with an off subject question but sense you mentioned the removable bit driver dose any one know if it will worh with the Swisstool phillips?
That is a Surge mod I may consider.
I realy like how that came out and with the removable driver it would work great. Even as is the Surge is a great tool with some plusses over my prefered Swisstool. :o Yes I did admit the Swisstool could be improved. Ouch! That was hard. 
-
the removable bit driver dose any one know if it will worh with the Swisstool phillips?
Douglas,
Funny, I'd never tried that...
The LM removable driver sort of fits but doesn't go far enough over the Swisstool Phillips to be of practical use, about 7 mm or 1/4 " at most. It would fall off quickly. The curve on the inside of the Phillips is the culprit, at least on mine.

Sent on my SM-G930F with Tapatalk
-
Dutch! Sync!
I like what you have done with the Surge. You have made it...perfect.
Thanks, although my activities were purely mental at this stage. Transforming that into realtiy is becoming rather attractive, though

You lose the ability to attach a Bit Extender HOWEVER if you attach a Removable Bit Driver to the Phillips you get the same result.

Correct, thanks. I see my Surge as my 'tank' tool, i.e. sturdy and ready for whatever the world might throw at it, which tends to kind of 'limit' it to non-exchanger-type tools (yeah I know, there's the saw/file blade exchanger too) and that's why I can dig swapping the bit driver for the Phillips head. I happen to have a ST 300 Phillips head and a suitable removable bit driver (as a nod to flexibility) lying around unused... hmmm...
Sent on my SM-G930F with Tapatalk
Sorry for hijacking the thread, but this is kind of related.

Thinking a little bit further along the lines of the Surge as no-frills Sherman tank type tool, one could also consider:
- doing away with the scissors. Although the Surge ones happen to be among the best LM has ever designed, the question arises whether one needs these (as OHO?) on a rugged no-frills tool, to the detriment of...
- a fixed saw and file...? The exchanger is pretty good on the new Surge, but the moves to swap the blades do remain a bit fiddly, and you need to carry one separately from the tool. Also, as a OHO tool, the OH aspect of it might be somewhat diluted by the need for swapping the blade if the wrong one happens to be on it...
Now, by what I thought of so far as pure coincidence but is turning out to be, dare I say it, destiny, I have lying around one each of the ST 300's saw and file blades from the VX mod...

-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
Thinking a little bit further along the lines of the Surge as no-frills Sherman tank type tool, one could also consider:- doing away with the scissors. Although the Surge ones happen to be among the best LM has ever designed, the question arises whether one needs these (as OHO?) on a rugged no-frills tool, to the detriment of...
- a fixed saw and file...?
Interesting idea.
I'm sure many people will disagree with you!
I hear what you are saying about the saw. I like to have a saw on a multitool although I will take something with a decent one like a Wenger Ranger if there is a possibility it will be needed (eg: hiking, which I will not use my Surge for).
An advantage of the removeable file is touching up the Surge's own blades.As much as I love a dedicated saw, I like the Surge scissors too much to replace them for one.
-
Thinking a little bit further along the lines of the Surge as no-frills Sherman tank type tool, one could also consider:
- doing away with the scissors. Although the Surge ones happen to be among the best LM has ever designed, the question arises whether one needs these (as OHO?) on a rugged no-frills tool, to the detriment of...
- a fixed saw and file...?
Interesting idea.
I'm sure many people will disagree with you!
I hear what you are saying about the saw. I like to have a saw on a multitool although I will take something with a decent one like a Wenger Ranger if there is a possibility it will be needed (eg: hiking, which I will not use my Surge for).
An advantage of the removeable file is touching up the Surge's own blades.As much as I love a dedicated saw, I like the Surge scissors too much to replace them for one.

Hmm, yes, that is where we might differ - I'd take the Surge hiking (nature trails etc.), no problem, as that is where the OHO aspect is least likely to attract the undue attention of the law over here. And that's where enhancing OHO and ruggedizing (even more) might be advantageous. (When hiking I'd also carry a separate tool with scissors (Minichamp/Squirt upwards) or a separate pair of scissors (as part of a small FAK). Don't need OHO scissors when hiking).I think I might give it a try. It is a reversible mod, after all.
I agree about the Surge scissors, though, they rock.

-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
I think I might give it a try. It is a reversible mod, after all.... I thought, until I realised that I'd have to make liner lock faces on the 300's saw and file...
not ready to go down that one-way street yet.But I might do the Phillips.
-
@Dutch_Tooler said:
But I might do the Phillips.DO IT!!!

-
It's definitely on the shortlist :D
Sent on my SM-G930F with Tapatalk
-
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login


