The Orville
-
@Lynn LeFey said:
@lister said:
But space operas (is that what you call this genre?) just don't work for me anymore.I would say, no. Star Trek and series LIKE Star Trek are not Space Opera.
Space Opera could generally be thought of as High Fantasy with the superficial trappings of Science Fiction. Meaning, Daring Heroes on a quest to vanquish a great enemy, usually with a strong romantic thread as well. The only thing separating something like Lord of the Rings and Star Wars are the external trappings. Instead of mystical elven blades, you have light sabers. Instead of Sauron, you have the Emperor. In BOTH cases, you have the wise old wizard guiding the new young hero.
Star Trek, The Orville, and the like are something different. As Gene Roddenbury put it, Star Trek was 'Wagon Train to the Stars'. It's about exploring possible ideas, with aliens standing in for the social issues in question. It's not a Wagnarian Opera with starships, in other words. It's a forward looking, speculative, or frequently currently relevant look at what humanity is or might become.
Very different beasts in my opinion.
But if you're sick of them, you're sick of them, regardless of what the genre is called.
I looked up space opera on wikipedia and they list star trek as an example. But definitions are not that important. It is not like I don't like fantasy.
What puts me off in star trek is all the technobabble. And all the humanoid aliens. I mean, obviously our body shape works well for a technological species. But It can't be the only viable option? And the universal translator. And the unofficial motto of the show: One small shag for a man, one giant gang bang for humanity. I mean, why do all aliens have boobs? Off all primates only humans have those. I think that off all animals we are the only ones that have them when not lactating. :D
I like borgs. I would prefer them if they were not slow zombie kind of a zombie but a fast one but still they are a terrifying opponents.

I think my problem is I burned out my ability to enjoy most narratives by first reading to many books and later on listening to to many audio books. I mean I read 3 to 4 books a week when in high school and by now listened to well over a year worth of audio books (that is an actual year of time spent listening). I find it hard now to find anything that still holds my interest. :ahhh
Terry Pratchett's disc world books are a good example of how to get around that kind of a readers block. Read books that make fun of things that you grew tired of and you can enjoy them all over form a different perspective... :D
-
@lister said:
I mean, why do all aliens have boobs? Off all primates only humans have those. I think that off all animals we are the only ones that have them when not lactating. :DSo now we finally get to the important point, what really matters here for you

1- Breasts
2- Mammary glands
3- Boobs
4- The story line -
I'm not sure how to say this subtly, but Wikipedia is actually capable of being incorrect. And in this case, is. Or, at least, when 'Space Opera' was defined, it would be. If people are taking 'Space Opera' to mean 'any sci-fi show that isn't absolute hard sci-fi', well... then... not much i can do about shifting definitions. I assume 'The Expanse' would still fall outside their definition.
All (or most) aliens in different sci-fi series mostly look human for a very real-world reason... budgetary constraints. Light facial prosthetics can be done within reason. Masks or helmets (for instance with Issac on Orville or Twiki from Buck Roger) are easy. The more fully articulated suits, like C3PO become greatly more complex on television schedules. Occasionally puppets or muppets have been used, like Yoda, Rygel and Pilot from Farscape, There was an attempt, and huge failure of a puppet character on Babylon 5, named 'N'Grath'. He looked fine on camera, but the puppet kept failing and the character was written out of the show.
Outside of practical effects, there's the possibility of CGI, but on TV budgets, they're still iffy, although Yaphit from Orville is CGI. The problem is that cgi looks fake. Yaphit only kind of works because he's kind of supposed to look 'fake'.
Same as with humanoid aliens, the universal translator is simply a matter of budget. TV shows (most, anyway) don't have time or budget to develop a number of new languages, then train the bit-part actors to properly pronounce them. The exception here is 'Game of Thrones', which has 2 fictional languages used frequently, Dothraki and Valyrian. And like the exception to the rule, it's also allowed because it has an exceptionally high budget. I suppose we also occasionally hear untranslated Klingon on Star Trek, and we've probably heard untranslated Krill on Orville, although I'm not 100% sure on that (I watch Orville on Friday nights with friends, and am usually at least 3 beers into the evening by then, rendering perfect recollection questionable. :D)
As CGI continues to improve, we should see more very non-human characters in fantasy and sci-fi shows. As for universal translators... sorry, I'd prefer them over reading the translation at the bottom of the screen just so some show makers can feel clever, and a handful of disgruntled fans can find some other nit-pick.
-
Ok, so you don't trust wikipedia, how about this:
http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/SpaceOpera
But as I said, definition is not that important. The fact remains that most science in the show can easily be replaced with magic. And yet they pretend that it is all about science and engineering. I know a bit about both and I simply can't see it that way. And it is not that I don't like magic or universes with weird rules as I said before. It really destroys any chance that I could suspend my disbelief.
Anyway it is pointless to argue about it. You like it, I don't, though I did as a kid. I bet I could find a few shows that I like and you don't. No show is going to be liked by all. :D
-
This show is awesome. Makes up for the actual new trek sucking (IMO) and is the best new trek style show in ages. :D
-
I like borgs. I would prefer them if they were not slow zombie kind of a zombie but a fast one but still they are a terrifying opponents.

Fast borg? The entire federation would be assimilated and series would end in two episodes. :D
Yes, but those two episodes would be really fun.
The borg battle part of ST voyager was my favorite part. :D
-
Fast Borg would be a possibility, and I am surprised it never happened. Since they adapt so quickly to everything else you'd think an increase in speed would be on their To Do list.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
Fast Borg would be a possibility, and I am surprised it never happened. Since they adapt so quickly to everything else you'd think an increase in speed would be on their To Do list.Def
Here is an idea I could get behind: Fast Borg. Add sabre toothed tiger like Borgs as hunters and their teeth in place of the wrist tentacles of the normal Borg drones. They still adapt to energy weapons so throw in some good old fashioned slug throwers in to a mix to see how they adapt to those. They must still have some plans for say Car Gustav recoilless rifles, tungsten slug shotguns and whatnot to replicate in those fancy 3D printers. Stori goes along the lines of humans getting their asses kicked all the way to Borg winning and lots of horror, suffering and despair along the way. Who says that humans must always win? Oh and make use of 3D space and don't have all the space ships aligned in paralel planes!

:D
-
Wasn't the last episode great? A big up-yours aimed where it belongs followed by a message of hope for the future........hope positively festive seasony!


-
i'm a few episodes behind, but when the guy says "now entering glory hole" was hiliarious
-
quite watchable, not original, but entertaining.
The 2nd in commands' fake pectorals look really weird to me though... I keep thinking of the famous Madonna (singer) uniform
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



