Spirit 30 day Challenge with a few Early- early Birds
-
Nice, love the Crane reflection !

-
Day 2
Adjusted the stopper on my wife's sink.
I love my little edc flashlight, it helped out too.


Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
-
-
Great use Flint

-
Day 04:
The first hint of a concern with the Spirit arose today. Let me explain:
I decided to make a billy can for boiling water in the field from an old tomato can. I tossed the can on the grill yesterday and burnt out the lining. Then boiled some water with a bit of vinegar in the can to get rid of the residue and clean it out. So far, so good.
I used the Spirit's file to clean up the sharp edges of the can where the lid had been cut away.

The file worked well, but left it's own coarse sratches in the metal lip. I cleaned these scratches up with a quick wipe of sandpaper. Nice.
Next, I used the Spirit's punch to bore a hole on either side of the mouth. I drove the reamer through the can from the inside, knowing that I could use the file to clean up and jagged edges formed from 'drilling' out the holes. A small piece of leather supported the can and protected the point of the reamer.

Now here is where the concern is: when I examined the reamer after punching the holes in the can (with a little twist to open them up), I noticed that a small section of the edge of the reamer had been chipped (torn?) off, a few millimeters back from the tip. This is the spot where I twisted the reamer to open the hole in the can. At first I thought the edge had just rolled and used a stone to sharpen the reamer back up, but then I inspected the edge with a jeweler's loop and noticed some clear chipping.
This disappoints me. Drilling a hole in a can is something an awl/reamer/punch should be able to do. For comparison, I dug out my Rebar and did the same test on a similar can. No edge damage at all. I prefer the Spirit's more narrow reamer design, but I have to give the nod to the Rebar that can do the same task without getting torn up. I suspect that Victorinox's steel is too soft here and that the edge just got torn up by the drilling/twisting action. (I tried to get a photo of the edge, but I couldn't master the demands of Macro photography.)
I did end up using the file again to clean the jagged metal edges created by drilling my handle holes. Finally, I used the wire cutters to cut a length of tie wire and then used the pliers to crimp the wire into a bail for the billy can.

So, task accomplished, but I'm now concerned about the strength of the reamer. Might need to find some extra tasks for this tool to attempt.
-
Nix, here's the awl on my old Spirit, dunno if the pic shows it well, but I had the same thing as you describe at first. I didn't sharpen it right away, actually I never have, and this is several years of on and off use. I mostly use it on softer materials, but I do use it on steel too, deburring drilled holes, punching light sheet metal, etc. I have found it develops a 'working edge' over time and stays more or less the same, not as sharp as new, but sharp enough for my purposes. I thought I would be sharpening it regularly too, but never have, I just use it as is.


-
Good pic, twiliter. That's pretty much what mine looked like, just a bit closer to the tip.
I was tempted just to leave the edge alone, but when I first thought it had just 'rolled' I figured I could restore it easily with a stone. I now have it to the point where it will slice an index card or thick paper, but balks at newspaper. For fun, I may see if I can get this thing really sharp. But, I think you are right and that given the pressures of using it like a drill bit, it's likely to get damaged again. Perhaps 'working edge' is good enough.
Still, I think this shows that the steel either needs to be hardened better or be closer to a tool steel.
-
@Nix said:
Good pic, twiliter. That's pretty much what mine looked like, just a bit closer to the tip.I was tempted just to leave the edge alone, but when I first thought it had just 'rolled' I figured I could restore it easily with a stone. I now have it to the point where it will slice an index card or thick paper, but balks at newspaper. For fun, I may see if I can get this thing really sharp. But, I think you are right and that given the pressures of using it like a drill bit, it's likely to get damaged again. Perhaps 'working edge' is good enough.
Still, I think this shows that the steel either needs to be hardened better or be closer to a tool steel.
I'm no expert by any means, but I don't think you'd want a super fine edge on an awl. It will roll and chip very easily that way. It seems that a more obtuse edge would be a better fit?
Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
-
I thought about this too, as I really like having a small controllable blade to work with, and the awl is a likely choice, pics if you do it!

As I carried it more I started using the chisel for a lot of those small blade tasks, but I also use that for rust removal and heavy scraping, so that one does need sharpened once in a while. You're right, the steel could be harder, and I actually bent the large driver slightly and had to do some filing to flatten it. I am not easy on prythingies...

-
@Flint Hills said:
Good pic, twiliter. That's pretty much what mine looked like, just a bit closer to the tip.
I was tempted just to leave the edge alone, but when I first thought it had just 'rolled' I figured I could restore it easily with a stone. I now have it to the point where it will slice an index card or thick paper, but balks at newspaper. For fun, I may see if I can get this thing really sharp. But, I think you are right and that given the pressures of using it like a drill bit, it's likely to get damaged again. Perhaps 'working edge' is good enough.
Still, I think this shows that the steel either needs to be hardened better or be closer to a tool steel.
I'm no expert by any means, but I don't think you'd want a super fine edge on an awl. It will roll and chip very easily that way. It seems that a more obtuse edge would be a better fit?
Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
I like a good sharp edge for leatherwork, but I don't do much of that anymore, a belt hole here and there. It still cuts pretty clean holes in plastic as is.
-
@Flint Hills said:
I'm no expert by any means, but I don't think you'd want a super fine edge on an awl. It will roll and chip very easily that way. It seems that a more obtuse edge would be a better fit?I agree. But there is a difference between a 'fine edge' and an 'obtuse edge'. I have no plans to "thin" the edge. I'm just going to try to make the existing 'obtuse edge' very sharp. Slicing is certainly a function of both edge geometry and sharpness. The awl doesn't--and shouldn't, in my opinion--have slicing geometry. I want that phat, obtuse edge geometry. But even a 90º corner can be made wonderfully sharp with careful honing. That's kinda what I'm going for, but without messing up the factory geometry.

-
@Flint Hills said:
I'm no expert by any means, but I don't think you'd want a super fine edge on an awl. It will roll and chip very easily that way. It seems that a more obtuse edge would be a better fit?
I agree. But there is a difference between a 'fine edge' and an 'obtuse edge'. I have no plans to "thin" the edge. I'm just going to try to make the existing 'obtuse edge' very sharp. Slicing is certainly a function of both edge geometry and sharpness. The awl doesn't--and shouldn't, in my opinion--have slicing geometry. I want that phat, obtuse edge geometry. But even a 90º corner can be made wonderfully sharp with careful honing. That's kinda what I'm going for, but without messing up the factory geometry.

I see what you mean. Carry on!
I like the awl on the Spirit or an Alox and started using it recently as a package opener to keep from getting all the sticky tape goop on my blade. Works well for that but as you say, it needs to be sharp!
Sent from my SM-G930P using Tapatalk
-
I have been carefully avoiding showing this angle of my Spirit here, I am not too proud of the abuse.

BUT
Since Pabloing things has become so trendy I guess I can share. :D

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





