I did it- I broke down and bought a Charge
-
..in case it wasn't obvious I was just teasing you Def.
Well tough- it's too late to call off the sniper now! :P
Def
-
With those scissors and the diamond file I think the old PST II was one of LM's best tools. If only the implements locked, we'd be set!
Def
-
I'll have to agree with Def a little here, the settup in the xti model doesn't work for me. But I see it as a good option for someone who needs multiple screwdrivers and doesn't carry the sheath (i dont carry the sheath, but the Ti setup still works for me).
About the steel on the serrated blade, I actually would be disapointed if they changed it to a "fancy" steel. If I need to do something that might dull the blade badly, I like to do it on a blade that I know I can resharpen. I once tried to cut of a blown tire off the rim by the side of the road. After sawing at it with my serrated knife (KF4 actually) I realized I was trying to cut through some thick steel cables that would have dulled any knife! I looked at my edge and it was completely folded over.
But when I got home a few minutes on the sharpmaker made it good as new. I don't think s30v would have served me that well in that situation, so I like the options.About the file scraping: well... I guess they can't catch everything. Mine does the same thing and it annoyed me at the begining but I'm almost over it by now. Almost. ;) I posted a few of my thoughts over on LM's QC on this thread: /topic/1117
And lastly about the Titanium handles, I agree that there's not that big of a technical advantege. I personally really like the look and feel of the Charge models. I like the "full scale" as opposed to the partial on on the waves. If you tried to make the same design out of steel, it certainly would add some weight compared to the wave models. I'm actually not much of a "ti" guy, but I do enjoy it's use here. (notice I said "enjoy" not need, so I'm not really disagreeing with Def at all :) )
-
Fancy trash. Get rid of it and buy a core. It's the only tool that really works.
-
For cripes sake! I go to work in the morning, everything's fine. I come home from work in the evening, and this whole place is in an uproar because somebody is dissin' the Charge!

Seriously though, I have to agree with Def on one thing; the price they are asking for the Charge models is too high. Other than that, it's a premium tool. The size of the handles and pliers fit me perfectly, and no other multitool has a one-hand-opening knife blade setup that can compare.
The Ti arrangement happens to work better for me than the XTi, but that's just me. I can see where some folks would really like the twin bit holders. Personally, I need the scissors instead. I'm thinking the majority of Charge buyers do too, that's why Leatherman went with the arrangement they did on the new TTi.
I must admit, I've never used (or had an occasion to use) a cutting/gutting hook like the XTi has. I suppose it is there "just in case" a person ever needs it, like so many other functions on a multitool. I have used the removable pocket clip on many occasions, and the removable lanyard ring twice. Both work well. And if you need a more secure lanyard attachment, don't forget that the Charge has a "hidden" one in the end of one handle.
And the titanium? Yah, it's mostly for show, but it has some function as well. Pick up a New Wave some day and compare. Same size tools, but like NeitherExtreme said, the titanium has a much better look and feel and grip about it. Worth it in my opinion.
-
Hidden Lanyard ring? I forgot all about that!
It didn't take me long to locate it, but it did take me a moment to figure out how to get it out! No longer will the world have to look in two places for squirrels and provolone cheese!
Def
-
So let me get this straight- the XTi duplicates the bit holder and the lanyard ring, then has a pocket clip and a sheath and no one sees the redundancy on this thing?
I think it's a decent tool- very comfortable size and grip (unless you grab the wrong side and have the pocket clip on) and I also like the broader blade than the Wave, but I think that the tool compliment could have been better thought out. It almost strikes me as something that the design team was going over budget on and finished it up in a hurry because the presentation was in an hour...
Def
-
@Defender said:
So let me get this straight- the XTi duplicates the bit holder and the lanyard ring, then has a pocket clip and a sheath and no one sees the redundancy on this thing?
DefI (and some others) hate carrying a sheath. But, if you're willing to carry the sheath, then you are 100 percent, without a doubt, and most certainly... correct. IMHO of course ;)
-
I dunno- opinions like that could get you in some serious trouble around here!
Def
-
@Defender said:
So let me get this straight- the XTi duplicates the bit holder and the lanyard ring, then has a pocket clip and a sheath and no one sees the redundancy on this thing?I think it's a decent tool- very comfortable size and grip (unless you grab the wrong side and have the pocket clip on) and I also like the broader blade than the Wave, but I think that the tool compliment could have been better thought out. It almost strikes me as something that the design team was going over budget on and finished it up in a hurry because the presentation was in an hour...
Def
I think redundancy is a good thing when speaking of carry options. I use sheaths maybe 10% of the time but would use a pocket clip 100% of the time if one was offered on more multi-tools. Being that the design for the Charge/New Wave series pocket clip system is unobtrusive and adds no weight to the tool I think it's a excellent set-up and actually compliments the sheath. There a no extra screws, no extra visible holes and the clip can be put on and taken off with no tools and stored in the sheath.
-
I think redundancy is a good thing when speaking of carry options
I agree- that's why I carry a SAK and a multi most of the time! But if you lose, misplace or break your tool and it's your backup, then you are without that too.
I am not arguing about the pocket clip design, and to be honest, I like the fact that Leatherman chose to include it so folks could decide for themselves rather than making folks have to buy it separately. It's a well designed, functional clip and that's a good thing.
The problem is with the number of redundancies when it could have been made more versatile by adding different tools. I would have preferred some kind of in-tool carry method for extra bits other than a second driver. If the scales were made a little thicker for example, then extra bits could be carried in cutouts in the handle similar to the way some of the LM knives are set up. Then the extra bits would be handy and you'd have the extra space on the inside for something like scissors.
Def
-
ok my thoughts on all of this....
The clip is a wonderfull idea, the ability to remove to put it on it's great, sometimes I feel like using a sheath and sometimes I don't. I even bought an extra clip cause the first month I had my wave I broke the clip off the tool. The titanium I do think is just for a cool factor since not much is scarificed in the weight dept, the only thing it contributes is adding texture to the surface of the too enabling you to get a better grip. It's sad that both blades are not 154/s30v but the plain edge is designed to be your main blade and the other to accompany it. So the main blade is going to hold an edge longer. Redundancy of tools, I like having the two drivers, keeps me from carying a bit kit around, although I do need one. The Xti is a great tool, but like with all tools, they have thier shortcommings. Leatherman is constantly changing and innovating the models that are released to the market. Some of thier ideas are good ones, some not so good (Flair anyone?) So if something isn't perfect everyone blames it on QC, I agree some QC differs from tool to tool but no one is perfect, take a look at Def's Sideclip to see an example of that! If anything was that much of a problem, something would have been done about it a long time ago, with recalls or such. In short, we all love what comes out of Leatherman and everyone is entitled to thier own opinion, Def has his and I have my own, he and I disagree on alot of things, that is why we work together. Without this we wouldn't get to see the two sides of the coin and help make this place better all the time.
sigh No too is perfect, and until one comes along.....flaws will be found and complaints will be filed (no pun intened). Until then enjoy what good things are produced by industry.
David
-
I must admit, I've never used (or had an occasion to use) a cutting/gutting hook like the XTi has. I suppose it is there "just in case" a person ever needs it, like so many other functions on a multitool. I have used the removable pocket clip on many occasions, and the removable lanyard ring twice. Both work well. And if you need a more secure lanyard attachment, don't forget that the Charge has a "hidden" one in the end of one handle.
Does nobody use the cutting hook to open boxes or envelopes at work? Its excellent for that, its probably the most used tool on my Charge, plus it saves the razor edge I got from the factory on my main blade, cant wait to try it out on a fish this Summer aswell.
-
As a matter of fact I do, the gutting hook on the charge is real good for opening boxes and cutting stuff like the plastic ties the put on little kids toys, just stick the hook in there and pull. It's funny, designed to gut animals and we find another use O0
David
-
Have to agree with you Def , I've owned two charges and both had to be replaced due to faults . I found them hard to sharpen and not just because of the harder 154cm blade ( I have other high end steel knives ) , the angle on the serrated blade is way off the sharpmaker angles so out the window went quick sharpening .The little post inside the handles that the pliers slide on when folding away gets bent easily :( The bits are hard to find when you drop them in a puddle in the dark because your trying to change them around to get the right driver .The tape measure isnt up to much . The scissors arent bad but I hit a staple once and they were never the same again :( I found the titanium slabs slid about when you pushed them from side to side :o No awl , no chisel/scraper , no prybar . The only things I liked was the option to carry interchangable hex bits and the nylon sheath made great horizontal carry .
I guess this came as no surprise to you guys ;DDunc
-
It's sad that both blades are not 154/s30v but the plain edge is designed to be your main blade and the other to accompany it. So the main blade is going to hold an edge longer.
To be honest, I would think serrations would last longer in a harder steel like 154CM, and since serrations are such a pain to sharpen, I think it should be the one that is designed to last longer between sharpenings. Additionally, any blade that is difficult to maintain or sharpen is really not a good tool at all. If I wanted a super dense steel that could cut steel mooring line and the odd locomotive then I'd get a dedicated knife for that. Multitool blades are for the guys who work, and having to spend time maintaining tools takes away from the time you have to work.
Don't believe me? Look at your other tools. Chances are, you have some screwdrivers, socket wrenches, pliers, wire cutters and a hacksaw stuffed away in a box somewhere in the basement or under the back porch. They may look like hell with grease and rust spots on them, but they are there, waiting for the next time you need them. They don't need much maintenance, and you probably use them hard and put them away wet, and never worry yourself about them. Admittedly, they are a far sight cheaper than your multitool ($20 for a hammer? Are you nuts?!) but they put up with anything. That's what a multitool is to me.
I appreciate the fact that you and I disagree so much on tools Dave! Like you said, many of the reviews done on the main site (like yours for this very Charge model- http://multitool.org/content/view/58/67/ ) are all based in opinion. It's nice to have a difference of opinions, and I don't think you and I ever agreed on anything in the past! Certainly not when it comes to multitools!
Of course I am going to go through the rest of the reviews you wrote now and avoid anything that you were overly positive with! :P
Def
-
Seems like there has been a huge amount of debate about the Leatherman bit holders, both here and on other forums. Some folks love 'em, some folks hate 'em. Maybe because I work in manufacturing, I tend to sympathize with the Leatherman engineers on this one.
Think about it; they were handed a challenge to give multitool users the ability to work on a large (and getting larger every year!) variety of fasteners. Not just phillips and flathead, but also standard hex, Robertson, Torx, etc. Millions of guys buy and use Leatherman tools, and they want to use them on all different sorts of fasteners.
The only solution was a compromise. Either one or two bit drivers on the tool itself, flattened so both driver and bits take up minimal space.
But of course, like any compromise engineered for everyone, it is not the perfect arrangement for anyone. Some folks prefer longer, dedicated flathead and phillips drivers. We've even seen some mods here on MTorg to that effect. But why didn't Leatherman do the long dedicated drivers themselves? Because then the guys who need to work on the wide variety of sizes of hex, Torx, and Robertson fasteners would have been left out in the cold.
Bottom line, the bit drivers aren't ideal for everyone, but they are a good compromise for a company that has millions of customers.
-
Good point. I will concede that you do indeed have a point and make it well.
However, in the case of Robertsons, that's a pretty limited market, and Canadians are used to buying those separately. Trust me- I know that one first hand!
Also, a multitool is about versatility- that's the point of multiple tools. Otherwise it would be the Leatherman Hammer and Nail Company rather than Leatherman Tool Group. Deliberate duplication of identical tools flies in the face of versatility.
Def
-
I've been carrying the Charge XTi for a few days now and I have a few more observations about it:
1- It is very comfortable to hold and use as pliers.
2- I use the serrated blade more than the plain blade, but I'd still rather have the guthook turned around. I'd also like the serrated blade (if any) made out of a nice hard wonder steel so the teeth wouldn't need to be sharpened as often.
3- I haven't used any of the bit drivers yet, but I have lamented at the lack of scissors.
4- I don't mind the pocket clip after all. While I'd still prefer sheath carry in most situations, there are a few instances where the clip is handy. Especially considering I have to fight the Charge to get it in and out of the sheath, but that will likely change with more use.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
