A car is going to Mars (orbit)
-
Probably right.


-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
a bunch of reused rocket boosters landing at the same time like in a sci fi movie.

That is what I'm waiting for.
I think this is just Mr Musk calling dibs on the best parking spot.
The parking fees are going to be astronomical though.

-
Just had a thought.
Mars need global warming. So Musk has the right idea, he's just doing it badly.
-
Don't get me wrong Pabs, I'd be very impressed if they reach Mars' orbit.
Yet every single day we get to hear on the news how we, regular cilvilians, are the cause of global warming and that we should avoid travelling by plane.
This, while world leaders travel by a plane for themselves and we get crammed with 199 other people into an aluminum can.
We should stop eating meat, turn down the heather, sort out our trash etc...
Yet, every now and then they launch a missile that will generate more pollution then a city can in a lifetime.They send a car into space which probably costs more then my house.
Imagine what that funds could do here on earth.
Fix the problems here before venturing further into space. The deepest crevaces in the oceans have not been explore yet since we aren't able to go there, but we already think about visiting other planets.So no, I am not against space travel!
I do think we have different priorities right now. And if SpaceX want to launch a missile, fine, just do something usefull with it.
A bag of sand may sound stupid, but one day you might be able to drop it on Mars and use it to grow crops with...Just my 2c.
So once again Pablo, I'm not against space travel and/or technology.
I AM against a waste of recources while there're still so many problems to be solved here. ;) -
I'm sorry but I find this foolish and irresponsible. The last thing we need to do is in any way stir up any trouble with Mars. Have we learnt nothing from War of the Worlds? They will have developed vaccinations by now!!!!

-
February 6. :ahhh
-
The idea that the launch is a publicity stunt gives me a headache. The car is a stunt, of course, but the launch is simply a high risk, full scale test of the rocket, where nobody in their right minds would send their actual payload. Elon Musk has stated any outcome where they don't damage the launch ramp is a success. (The site is historically important and the only place on US soil to launch manned flights.)
Pablo tried explaining this, but I just wanted to chime in to state I don't believe there is a viable future without space exploration.
Just to put current cost of space travel in perspective: If you found a way to turn lead into gold in low Earth orbit, it would not be cost effective.
-
@Steinar said:
The idea that the launch is a publicity stunt gives me a headache. The car is a stunt, of course, but the launch is simply a high risk, full scale test of the rocket, where nobody in their right minds would send their actual payload. Elon Musk has stated any outcome where they don't damage the launch ramp is a success. (The site is historically important and the only place on US soil to launch manned flights.)Pablo tried explaining this, but I just wanted to chime in to state I don't believe there is a viable future without space exploration.
Just to put current cost of space travel in perspective: If you found a way to turn lead into gold in low Earth orbit, it would not be cost effective.
Thanks for explaining the car bit.

Also, keep in mind that this car cost $100,000 back in 2009, and it has gone through 9 years of use and depreciation. I’m not saying that it’s cheap, but that it costs less than you awl probably think it does. 9 years is a good life for any car.Oh and Steinar, I’m of a similar opinion regarding the necessity of access to space.
If we run out of resources on Earth, we’re sunk or crippled. Helium is an interesting example.The space shuttle was supposed to make access to space cheap and easy, but for various reasons it ended up being practically the most expensive way to launch something into space.

What could have been.....SpaceX have already proven:
-
That it’s possible to land and recover a rocket booster, which is the most expensive part of the rocket (excluding the payload of course)
-
That it’s possible to refurbish and reuse said boosters for much less than the cost of making a new one
-
And that said reused boosters can be just as reliable, even more so, than brand new boosters
-
And that it’s possible for a rocket booster designed to be reused to be profitable if it’s only used once.
-
And that rockets that are not the Saturn V or the Space Shuttle can be cool
-
-
If we run out of resources, it's because we waisted it on launching missiles and building parts that are shot away from our planet...
Imagine what that money, fuel and rare materials could do here on earth...
What if space exploration stopped tomorrow?
We'd all live our lives...
Yet it costs bilions.Again, fix the problems here before venturing out there.
It's like bringing your car to the garage to try and find a sollution for it's fuel consumption while you know there's a water pipe blowing water out on your attic. -
In case you didn’t notice, SpaceXs entire foundation is that they aren’t throwing missiles away, they’re reusing them.

You aren’t thinking large scale enough. :D
We may be able to go all “eco” and everything, but there is a very finite supply of resources on earth.
Take helium, it’s critical as a oolant for medical equipment and such, but we’re running out of it. :ahhh
Helium on Earth is made via the radioactive decay of various elements, in the form of alpha radiation. If fossil fuels are a non- renewable resource, Helium is doubley so.
It’s possible to replace most fossil fuels with alternatives, smurf natural gas is just Methane, and we can make that in abundance if we have a supply of green or nuclear power. But I’m not aware of a viable alternative for helium in medical equipment, but there’s oodles of it elsewhere in the solar system. -
I don´t think space programs are a waste of money. Without them, we would have no cell phones or GPS.
And regarding waste of materials, there are several companies already planning for asteroid belt mining. A good idea because we are certain to deplete the earth sooner or later. Think of the rain forests being cut down so we can grow soy and mine materials for our batteries.
PS Asteroid belt mining on a truely massive scale may cause a redistribution of mass throughout the solar system such that the effects make global warming look loke kiddy stuff.
-
@Ron Who said:
PS Asteroid belt mining on a truely massive scale may cause a redistribution of mass throughout the solar system such that the effects make global warming look loke kiddy stuff.I’m not sure about that, it sounds a bit “out there”. The total mass of the belt is apparently 4% of our moon. And it’s distributed all along the belts orbit.
My take is that it has very little to negligible effect on the other bodies in the solar system, to the point that if you waved a magic wand and made it disappear, nothing would happen.I can see something exciting happening to Jupiter’s(or Saturn’s, etc) moons if you brought the entire asteroid belt there, but I think that we’re clever enough to not do that. ;)
-
One more thing.
You say we can find alternative sources of energy, yet we need to venture out into space in search of Helium because there is no alternative to that?
Sounds like quite a lame excuse
Resources running out require actions to spend them well.
Spending them well doesn't mean "shoot them into space and hope that one day we'll find more then enough up there"
'Cause if you don't fined anything there, you would have pushed everyone deeper down the hole.And keep in mind, oil is not only used for power and propulsion.
It's also a resource for other materials like plastics. -
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ron Who said:
PS Asteroid belt mining on a truely massive scale may cause a redistribution of mass throughout the solar system such that the effects make global warming look loke kiddy stuff.
I can see something exciting happening to Jupiter’s(or Saturn’s, etc) moons** if you brought the entire asteroid belt there, but I think that we’re clever enough to not do that. ;)**
no, of course. Like the Amazon, the Aral sea or the Uyuni Salt Desert, we're well known for stopping at the slightest hint of overexploitation of natural places

-
@Pablo O'Brien said:
@Ron Who said:
PS Asteroid belt mining on a truely massive scale may cause a redistribution of mass throughout the solar system such that the effects make global warming look loke kiddy stuff.
I can see something exciting happening to Jupiter’s(or Saturn’s, etc) moons** if you brought the entire asteroid belt there, but I think that we’re clever enough to not do that. ;)**
no, of course. Like the Amazon, the Aral sea or the Uyuni Salt Desert, we're well known for stopping at the slightest hint of overexploitation of natural places

Spoken like we can move an entire asteroid belt out of greed. :D
-
@Mechanickal said:
One more thing.
You say we can find alternative sources of energy, yet we need to venture out into space in search of Helium because there is no alternative to that?
Sounds like quite a lame excuse
Resources running out require actions to spend them well.
Spending them well doesn't mean "shoot them into space and hope that one day we'll find more then enough up there"
'Cause if you don't fined anything there, you would have pushed everyone deeper down the hole.And keep in mind, oil is not only used for power and propulsion.
It's also a resource for other materials like plastics.The helium was just one example, and heaven knows we have plenty in Jupiter and Saturn. :D
Nevermind it for now.I think that your “waste of resources” argument could be better directed at other, better, things.

Consider, anually, we spend about 100 to 200 billion dollars (my estimate) on space activities. Sounds big right? Well.... that’s the USA, Europe, China, Russia, etc combined. It includes comercial enterprises, which are spending money on space for proft(TV, weather, internet, etc)
As a percentage of the global economy, it’s just a few tenths of a percent, like 0.2%.
But a sizeable part is military related, which brings me to my next point.The annual global military spending is around $1000 billion dollars, mostly by governments not expecting a profit or monetary return on their spending.
That could be very useful if it was spent on other things.
In any case, I’m not saying that your argument is wrong, just that there are other “more useless” things that we should redirect spending from before we look at cutting space spending. Low hanging fruit and all that.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
