Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
-
I own both tools and I have to say I will be interested to see how your score falls out.
Personally I like and use the Skeletool a whole lot more than the Reactor. The Reactor may be lighter but you feel it in the quality of the tool when you use it hard. I also don't mind the longer length of the Skeletool since it is thinner than the Reactor and in my experience being thinner is far more important to its carry comfort than length.
-
I have a Skele and was thinking about getting the SOG. I'm looking forward to your results.

-
Skele seems to win over Reactor every time, in every review and discussion I've seen :P
absolutely not dismissing your comparison, boss, but I found this VS. video from Gideonstactical (a YouTube reviewer with similar thoughts to mine, and opinions I trust and agree with) almost two years ago and that took the decision for me

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=140kSvBhWzI
afterwards 90% of reviewers agreed in one or another way with it,
and I bet your views won't be much different
-
@ThePeacent said:
Skele seems to win over Reactor every time, in every review and discussion I've seen :Pabsolutely not dismissing your comparison, boss, but I found this VS. video from Gideonstactical (a YouTube reviewer with similar thoughts to mine, and opinions I trust and agree with) almost two years ago and that took the decision for me

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=140kSvBhWzI
afterwards 90% of reviewers agreed in one or another way with it,
and I bet your views won't be much different
Well then I guess we can just pack up the whole site and be on our way then, as that YouTube guy has it covered! Thanks for being a part of the place everyone, don't let the door hit you in the arse on the way out, and last one out, please turn off the lights!
But, since I already wrote all of this, I might as well post it anyway..... you know, like as if we had our own site with our own way of doing things and our own minds, independent of an internet full of bandwagon-jumpers and fanboys....

Part 2- Blade

The blades on each tool are roughly the same size, and both feature liner locks and one handed opening accessibility. The blade on the SOG is a plain edge, while the Skeletool is available either partially serrated or as a plain edge, depending on the model.

As tested, and at the cheaper end of the range is the partially serrated blade- if you want the plain edge blade you need to spend more money or try to find a first generation Skeletool, in which the cheaper ones had plain edge blades and the more expensive CX had the serrated edge.

Either way, moving up to the more expensive CX model will also get you 154cm steel in the blade, versus the black coated 420 stainless found in the Reactor. The cheaper standard Skeletool does not list a blade steel but appears to be some derivative of either a 440 or 420 type steel. As someone who doesn’t worry myself much about steel snobs, I have used both Skeletools and Reactors quite extensively and I don’t find a significant difference between the steels themselves.

Where these is a difference is in accessibility- while both blades are easy to access, the Reactor blade is assisted opening, and allows for lightning quick opening. There are some folks that like this feature and some that don’t, but it provides at least a slight advantage over the Skeletool blade.

Further, there is a well documented complaint about the Skeletool blade- it’s too short. If you look in the blade slot there is ample room for additional blade, and in fact a larger blade mod was done by MTO member Evil10 some time ago. Given that this blade could have been longer, one has to wonder why Leatherman opted not to give the user as much blade as they could.
SOG gets this point, but only marginally.
SCORE- SOG 2, Leatherman 1
Def
-
Assisted blade = prohibited to import it down under. :-
Sorry SOG, but being blacklisted and having my tool confiscated is not my priority at the moment. -
Very interesting
Can't wait to read more
-
Rooting for the Skeletool.
-
I've got a plain-edge Skeletool. At first I was a bit underwhelmed by it's simplicity, it seems heavy for it's limited tool set. A Juice S2 has more tools and weighs less. But the Skeletool has grown on me over time. It's my only multitool with a pocket clip. And I like being able to tailor the 2-D drivers for a specific (anticipated) task. Overall a nice bit of kit.
Never handled a Reactor, so I'm curious about the shootout results. I'm one of those who don't prefer assisted opening, but I'm keeping an open mind here.

-
Oh, that's interesting. Can't wait for part 3 Def

-
good thoughts.
I also don't care for A/O blades, and SOG in particular seems to be very bad doing those (compared to Kershaw, BM, Gerber...), also most non knife people think they are automatics so they are a in a grey area in legal aspects and lawful use.
here in EU most police would put it under the automatic category, thus making it illegal :Pyou also have the durability issue (spring breaking or wearing out) and the fact that most assisted blades don't work well (they have no detent to hold them closed) once the spring is removed. I don't know if it is the case with the Reactor. Also I remember that the linerlock was rather flimsy and weak looking?

as for the Skele, just a wild guess here but maybe they made it with a 2.6 inch blade to make it legal almost everywhere?

many cities, states and places in the US prohibit 3 inch blades that you can open with one hand, such as Chicago.that is also 6.6cm, and many places on Europe limit blade length to 7cm, for instance the UK limit 7.5 cm (3 inches) but only for two handed opening blades. In other countries limit is only 7cm, not considering the opening method)

-
And it strikes me as being a fairly useful blade size/shape. Not going to dress out an Elk with it, but for EDC-type tasks, it seems a reasonable length. About the same size as a 91mm Victorinox.
-
@OldBoy2016 said:
Rooting for the Skeletool.I'm also rooting for the Skele. I'm pretty sure it would make my ideal EDC, but its damn hard to find a seller with decent shipping when I have the money for it (never found)...
-
Part 3- Pliers

After the blade the most prominent function is the pliers, and let’s face it, this one seems like an open and shut case (pun sadly intended) given SOG’s compound leverage. Just for the fun of it though, let’s break it down and see what we really have.

The heads themselves are very similar, with the Reactor’s being slightly stouter than the slender Skeletool’s more pointed needlenose. In fact, the Skeletool has slightly more reach than the Reactor.

As you can see from the photos, it’s pretty minor and I don’t see it being point-worthy so let’s dig a little deeper and notice that the SOG head has more surface area on the cutters. Good cutters are important when you have SOG’s Compound Leverage driving those teeth together, so again it seems like SOG has this one.
But, there’s a twist- SOG’s Compound Leverage isn’t without it’s drawbacks too. For example, while the SOG plier head may open further than the Skeletool’s, the handles have to be much farther apart to allow it, and they are basically nonfunctional in that configuration.
Compact tools such as these are also favored by people with smaller hands and having handles that open too wide limits their usefulness significantly.

This having been said, the Compound Leverage does allow you to use it with the plier handles folded over the head as well as opposite the head in a normal plier position, and that has come in handy on some jobs where clearance was an issue.
Additionally, my father is somewhat past his prime and he loves his SOG pliers because the compound leverage offsets the arthritis in his hands very well, and that alone deserves a point. I could keep poking at this, but in the end we all know this point is going to the Reactor, so let’s just cut to the chase.
SCORE- SOG 3, Leatherman 1
Def
-
Very interesting

To me they are both very handy looking pliers
But I do like the SOG compound leverage idea
-
I never handled a SOG, but this looks great to me.

-
How durable are the SOG pliers?
Those little gears are ingenious....but they seem....frail?
Maybe I'm just too rough on my stuff. :-[
-
Great review!

I like the compound leverage of Reactor but the assisted opening is a con very big to me.
Could it be possible to disassist the SOG Reactor??
Thanks Mr Lamontagne ;)
-
How far can the Reactor jaws open one-handed?

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





