Shootout- Leatherman Skeletool vs SOG Reactor
-
I had a couple of cuts after my Spyderco Endura's lock failed (two or three times). I was seriously annoyed and wrote to Spyderco: "your back-lock fails!". This was in 1997. They wrote back and told me I was wrong. What the smurf?!? I had the Band-Aid bill to prove it!
A few years later they came out with the "Boye Detent" and I felt vindicated. Since then, though, I've never had a lock fail. And I ain't kind to my knives.
So, I'm not dismissing your concerns, but I don't have the same experience that you do. I'm quite confident in most (99%) of my locking knives and far, far more confident in my locking knives than I am in my slippies. Of course, my concern about the safety of my slip joints may make me more cautious when using them, and that might be a safety advantage.

(Hey, nice arguing with you, Trad!)
-
@Nix said:
I had a couple of cuts after my Spyderco Endura's lock failed (two or three times). I was seriously annoyed and wrote to Spyderco: "your back-lock fails!". This was in 1997. They wrote back and told me I was wrong. What the smurf?!? I had the Band-Aid bill to prove it!A few years later they came out with the "Boye Detent" and I felt vindicated. Since then, though, I've never had a lock fail. And I ain't kind to my knives.
So, I'm not dismissing your concerns, but I don't have the same experience that you do. I'm quite confident in most (99%) of my locking knives and far, far more confident in my locking knives than I am in my slippies. Of course, my concern about the safety of my slip joints may make me more cautious when using them, and that might be a safety advantage.

(Hey, nice arguing with you, Trad!)
Oh, it's not the lock failing that's drawn blood here. It's the having to put your fingers in the path of the blade to unlock it.
I've never had a lock fail, because I never use it so that the lock is needed - or in other words, I use it like a slipjoint. If I ever do anything that warrants a lock, it's time for a different tool. If there are no other tools, i'll modify the usage so the lock isn't loaded (such as a pinch hold on the blade itself). Cutting through something where the blade might jam? Raise the handle first, so you're rolling the knife out.
Every lock knife cut that I've had has been from closing the blade, either one handed, or two handed while my attention has been elsewhere. One hand closing is way more important to me than one hand opening (though it's nice to have both), and I can safely one handed close a slippy with less chance of a cut than I can a blade that locks but doesn't need to :D
I've also had near misses purely due to unfamiliarity. I was using a 111mm Vic once, and totally forgot the blade locked. I went to close it as if it was a slippy, and just pushed the blade out of my hand, and it landed point down. Luckily, I managed to get my foot out of the way in time.
When I tell people that I consider slippies to be safer than locking blades, they tend to look at me as if my head buttons up the back. That level of confusion that they have in that moment, is the exact same confusion that I have when someone says a locking blade is safer. Seriously! I genuinely do not understand how anyone is "safely" using a folding knife, in such a way that the lock is needed? That means the blade is under force the wrong way. :ahhh Even when making piercing cuts, I always make sure the forces are going the right way, pushing the blade open. Unless I'm missing something, that means no lock needed.

No arguing. Just a friendly exchange of different perspectives

-
No arguing. Just a friendly exchange of different perspectives.
Smurf it all, Trad! Let's fight!
Here is how I recall my Endura failing and cutting me (this may all be a lie, but I think it's true.): I was trying to cut through a thick branch. I made a Herculean cut with exuberance. A real Conan-the-Barbarian kind of cut. As the blade passed through the branch, all the force of the cut was dissipated. The blade then had a large amount of momentum. That momentum was translated into angular velocity focused around the pivot point. With my knuckle actuating the lock--at least in part--the blade was released to rotate around the pivot point and whack my fingers. Whack 'em with the sharp bit. FAIL.
And this is the safety concern. A force applied to a blade correctly pushes the blade into the 'open' position. But once that force doesn't have an "opposite and equal" force applied by the medium being cut, funny things happen. Inertia and the forces of deceleration come into play. And then close that razor sharp edge on yer fingers. For that reason, a lock offers--in my over-confident opinion--a margin of safety against the inertial forces at play when an open blade is being rapidly decelerated. Baseball players are known to break baseball bats by rapidly checking their swings to avoid a strike. I'm not claiming to have the wrists of an MLB batter, but the principle is the same. A lock doesn't prevent disaster, but it's better than no safety mechanism at all.

-
I've never had that. Not even with my softest backsprung non-locking knives. I've never tried to flick any of them closed though, so I don't know how unfeasable that would be in my usage....
goes and gets one to try
Nope. Won't do it!
but then, I don't have any particularly large folders.@Nix said:
A lock doesn't prevent disaster, but it's better than no safety mechanism at all.
Unless it makes it LESS safe than a simple backspring, which appears to be my experience...
There's an odd (and often misunderstood) quirk with British knife law. A locking blade isn't illegal - it's just in the same legal category as a fixed blade. Therefore, you need a valid reason to carry a fixed blade, in order to carry a locking folder.... in which case, you might as well carry the fixed blade :D
We're back to lock not needed (well, here anyway).
-
@50ft-trad said:
I find the "insight" into SOG's sudden interest in quality improvements, to be disappointingly overdue. For four (or is it five) years now, they have been cementing their position as a company who cares very little about quality. Interested in design concepts, maybe, and in profit margins, but not in refining the concepts, ensuring that concepts are properly realised in the manufacturing stages, making sure that the products are indeed of useable tool quality, or giving a crap about their reputation in the marketplace.If SOG are listening, and I hope they are, they need to understand and be prepared to accept that even if every single tool they sold from today onwards, was of the quality that they should have been for the last few years, this is going to be a slow recovery of customer trust. They have pumped many disappointing tools out for several years, and that kind of reputation damage doesn't get swept under the carpet quickly. They now need to consistently put TOOLS on the market, instead of novelty "dad gifts". Not just one or two, but the whole line, and make sure each and every current product, and every subsequent new release, can be carried and USED in real life applications with full confidence. Even then, it may take five years of high quality tools, to start undoing the damage from five years of defects, misinformation, and sloppily built overpriced gadgets. There's no quick fix, fellers - but you've only yourselves to blame. Good luck in your recovery.
Unfortunately I have to agree here. Nowdays when I see a new release by SOG, instead of getting interested, I immediately think about things like </topic/40498
Knowing that a company can put out stuff like that for sale can really shake one's confidence in said company. Like you said, I think it would take a few years of flawless work to restore confidence, at least for me. A Seal Pup Elite is still on my bucket list though... -
@MaverickMCS said:
Unfortunately I have to agree here. Nowdays when I see a new release by SOG, instead of getting interested, I immediately think about things like </topic/40498
Knowing that a company can put out stuff like that for sale can really shake one's confidence in said company. Like you said, I think it would take a few years of flawless work to restore confidence, at least for me. A Seal Pup Elite is still on my bucket list though...Thanks for the link.
-
How many SOG stamps can you find on that multi? Someone in SOG designing dept must really love graffiti.
-
They do like their branding, that's for sure!
Def
-
I agree about the disadvantages of the Leathermans flat bits, but if I were to allow my Leatherman fan boy side to shine through. I would say that it was decent of them to have the bit extender take the normal shape bits as well as the flat bits, and the flat bits do take up less space.
To split hairs even further, the flat bits probably use less steel to make and preserve our natural resources just a little bit.
Get it? See what I just did there? Little “bit”. Ba dum dum!!!
-
If you want to add in accessories.....

For the same price (or less) as the fancy Leatherman bit extender you can probably get a multi piece bit set with a variety of bit types and lengths that fit natively in the SOG without the need for an adaptor. :P
Def
-
Ok ok I give up👍
-
It's not an argument- if you like the Skeletool better, by all means, feel free to explain why. That's what a forum is all about!
No one needs to take my ramblings as the Gospel- different things are more important to different people, which is why there are so many different (and successful!) models out there.
Believe it or not, I am more interested in generating discussion (that's how forums survive) than I am about promoting one tool over another.
The day my opinion carries any more weight than anyone else's is the day this stops being a forum and starts being an againstum.
Def
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login





