RIP Stephen Hawking
-
@50ft-trad said:
Steven's passing is indeed a great loss to the nation and to science. I lack both the intellect and indeed the prejudice to judge his mind and his theories, but he is, was, and will remain, a highly regarded theoretical physicist, accomplished author, and father of three.It is sad to see that some people feel compelled to mark his passing with derogatory comments. I am in no position nor feel no need to pass judgement on him, but would like to express my thanks for his work and dedication despite his life adversity. If nothing else he was a great inspiration that one can still achieve great thing when faced with debilitating life challenges.
Thank you, Steven, and may you rest in peace.
+1
RIP Mr. Hawking!

-
@50ft-trad said:
Without turning this into a religious debate, which has no place on this forum, one does not need belief in a deity to have morality. I did not know Stephen personally, so I will make no judgement on his.Stephen's passing is indeed a great loss to the nation and to science. I lack both the intellect and indeed the prejudice to judge his mind and his theories, but he is, was, and will remain, a highly regarded theoretical physicist, accomplished author, and father of three.
It is sad to see that some people feel compelled to mark his passing with derogatory comments. I am in no position nor feel no need to pass judgement on him, but would like to express my thanks for his work and dedication despite his life adversity. If nothing else he was a great inspiration that one can still achieve great thing when faced with debilitating life challenges.
Thank you, Stephen, and may you rest in peace.
+1
Religion does not have a licence on morality.Spoiler:
"ph"
- FTFY 
-
Is our MTo black armband banner for SH? Or did I miss something else? :(
-
@Huntsman said:
Is our MTo black armband banner for SH? Or did I miss something else? :(MusicMen, aka Bill. :'(
https://forum.multitool.org/index.php?action=profile;u=17231 -
R.I.P. Dr. Hawking.

-
After reading a few comments I feel I need to elucidate my position a bit further.
First of, I have no doubts that he was one of the best physicists. And I know he wrote good books.
The thing I was saying is that it was not due to him being a most special genius of them all. There are a lot of geniuses among the 7.4 billion humans even though there are not many percent wise. What he achieved was not only due to his intelligence but due to hard work and perseverance. Many of those that are smart enough don't do anything approaching what he did because it is hard, takes a long time and there is no way to know if you will succeed when you start. If that (my) view of how things get done diminishes his achievements in anyone's eyes then he or she must have a lot different definition of what is success than I. If that is a nihilistic compared to he did it because he was born to do it then I can't help it. In my eyes my world view hives him a lot more agency than a standard heroic worldview.
As for no one being really important in the great scheme of things (as in stuff gets invented one way or another) see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery
vs
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_theory_of_invention_and_scientific_developmentOr in other words he did not stand on shoulders of giants but on piles of hard working smart people like him. And yes there is a big difference. You are a giant by birth (ok the same goes partially for being smart) but hard work is ones own doing. Again, as I see it there is more agency on the part of the individual in my interpretation compared to the hero theory.
As for the view only he could do it see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries
I would wager that more often than not this is the case. Discoveries and inventions don't happen in a vacuum. The intellectual sitting on the rock and contemplating and then shouting eureka at everyone is simply a false model of reality. In fact important advancements happen as an interplay between before mentioned piles of hard working smart people. And in the process some of them are inevitably wrong despite them being smart and hard working.As for the press not recognising many important scientists we agree.

As for the super heroes, I mentioned them as the extreme of our culture's obsession with heroes. If you find that irrelevant in this debate fine. What you call cynical I call realistic. And if you, once again, find the Wikipedia links useless also fine. I will not send you travelling as you tried sending me. :D
-
@50ft-trad said:
One of the most truly brilliant humans in history. His incredible insight and foresight will forever be remembered. May those who guide the world look back to his acute sense of humanity and morality!
Humanity and morality? It is well-known that he was a recidivist divorcee with a penchant for strip clubs. His philosophy, which denied ab initio the possibility of a creator - though all objective evidence points at the conclusion that every effect (the universe) has a cause equal to or greater than itself - led him to forward the truly kooky notion that nothing created everything - nevermind that he offered no evidence of his thesis. As for his "morality", his worldview denies the possibility of objective morality because philosophical naturalism posits that there is no objective good or bad in the universe. We cannot ascribe morality to someone who denies its existence.
Were it not for his confinement to a wheelchair and his electronic voice, few of us would have ever heard of him. But the greatest, most brilliant genius of our times he was surely not.
Running for cover!Without turning this into a religious debate, which has no place on this forum, one does not need belief in a deity to have morality. I did not know Steven personally, so I will make no judgement on his.
Steven's passing is indeed a great loss to the nation and to science. I lack both the intellect and indeed the prejudice to judge his mind and his theories, but he is, was, and will remain, a highly regarded theoretical physicist, accomplished author, and father of three.
It is sad to see that some people feel compelled to mark his passing with derogatory comments. I am in no position nor feel no need to pass judgement on him, but would like to express my thanks for his work and dedication despite his life adversity. If nothing else he was a great inspiration that one can still achieve great thing when faced with debilitating life challenges.
Thank you, Steven, and may you rest in peace.
+1

-
@lister said:
The thing I was saying is that it was not due to him being a most special genius of them all. There are a lot of geniuses among the 7.4 billion humans even though there are not many percent wise. What he achieved was not only due to his intelligence but due to hard work and perseverance. Many of those that are smart enough don't do anything approaching what he did because it is hard, takes a long time and there is no way to know if you will succeed when you start. If that (my) view of how things get done diminishes his achievements in anyone's eyes then he or she must have a lot different definition of what is success than I. If that is a nihilistic compared to he did it because he was born to do it then I can't help it. In my eyes my world view hives him a lot more agency than a standard heroic worldview.I'm going to be honest here. WHAT? What are you trying to say?
@lister said:
As for no one being really important in the great scheme of things (as in stuff gets invented one way or another) see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery
vs
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heroic_theory_of_invention_and_scientific_developmentOr in other words he did not stand on shoulders of giants but on piles of hard working smart people like him. And yes there is a big difference.
No. That is EXACTLY what the phrase 'standing on the shoulder of giants' MEANS. It is the understanding that your accomplishment is only possible because of all the work from everyone before, only from all of the accumulated knowledge that you essentially get for free from the people who figured out stuff before you. WHO figured it out is not important, only that YOU didn't have to do it. So, the beginning of your work was much farther along due to others' hard work. I think you're caught up on some imagined meaning that is not present in that phrase. It might make more sense to understand that giant here is a metaphor. Let me replace the word giant to clarify. Pyramid. Imagine what it means is that each person who learns something adds a stone to create a base of a pyramid. Someone else uses that stone, places another on top, and only that huge accumulation of knowledge allows the next person to add another stone, and each new person steps one stone higher, seeing just a little further. The 'giant' is not an individual, but an accumulation upon which we stand, and in turn (hopefully) add to ourselves.
@lister said:
As for the view only he could do it see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries
I would wager that more often than not this is the case. Discoveries and inventions don't happen in a vacuum. The intellectual sitting on the rock and contemplating and then shouting eureka at everyone is simply a false model of reality. In fact important advancements happen as an interplay between before mentioned piles of hard working smart people. And in the process some of them are inevitably wrong despite them being smart and hard working.Showing the parallel development happens does NOT show that it happens in ALL cases, or even MOST, only SOME. And SOME is a pretty weak argument. In fact, what you're describing, 'Multiple Discovery' is a hypothesis, stating "most scientific discoveries and inventions are made independently and more or less simultaneously by multiple scientists and inventors." While it's absolutely certain that parallel development DOES happen, even the hypothesis says 'most scientific discoveries', meaning that it ALSO understands that 'heroic theory of invention' MUST happen at least in some instances.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discoveryI said in my FIRST post about this that sure, probably someone would come along and figure out every thing that Hawking figured out EVENTUALLY, but every breakthrough spurs more breakthroughs, and waiting on some is a bottleneck in progress. By the way, I looked up the numbers, and assuming an IQ of 160, there should be about 200,000 people on Earth right now that are that smart. Narrow that down to how many are in the VERY specific field he was in, and I doubt there are even a handful of people who COULD make his discoveries. Given an infinite timeline, sure, someone WOULD. But there is no way of predicting how soon, and it might have been a long time.
@lister said:
As for the press not recognising many important scientists we agree.

@lister said:
I will not send you travelling as you tried sending me. :DI said take it elsewhere, because as an adult, posting 'someone else could have done it' in the eulogy thread of a person is, to me, in EXTREMELY bad taste. Bringing up issues of hero worship in a thread noting the passing of someone who honestly made a difference in the world is MAYBE IN BAD TASTE... RIGHT?
If you disagree, fine, you have a whole forum in which to start a thread called 'Steven Hawking liked strippers, and his discoveries would have been figured out by a colleague anyway', but it's in REALLY SMURFING BAD TASTE to post that in THIS thread. You GET that?
So, if you WISH to smurf on him, PLEASE... seriously... take it ELSEWHERE.
-
I am not smurfing on him. And don't put words of others (strippers) nor yours in my mouth. What I said was there were a few people in position to do what he did sooner or later. But HE was the one to do it sooner. He won the race, he was the best of the best. And he did it on several occasions. And he did it despite his health.
And when you say you don't understand what I wrote, english is not my native language. This is the best I can do. :-\
Also this will be my last post as I do not believe this discussion is going anywhere.
-
@powernoodle said:
It is well-known that he was a recidivist divorcee with a penchant for strip clubs.I did not know, and that fact that I find it so funny probably highlights one of my many character flaws

-
@lister said:
I am not smurfing on him. And don't put words of others (strippers) nor yours in my mouth.Go back and reread the thread. The strippers comment wasn't about you. It was about people taking shots at someone in a eulogy thread, and how it's in bad taste. I didn't even intend to imply that came from you, although in rereading, I see how you walked away with that impression.
-
For everything Stephen Hawking: https://wakelet.com/@StephenHawking
-
I just came to say RIP.

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login