Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutions -
@styx said:
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutionsThere are several variables we will likely not know. All are Americans, maybe associated to visa approvals to get staff into Mongolia. Jose IIRC lived in Canada, but held a Spanish citizenship.
The 4 hikers, never had a chance to participate do to their partners tapping out.
Two were removed by medical, for the safety of them.
Others I believe tapped because of family pulls in their minds, of course a baby on the way in season 1, put him in the hole before starting season 1.Just my thoughts...
-
I'm wondering if they will come out with how the participants were chosen. we've got 4 runners up from previous seasons, Sam being the only person from season 1.
I for one am a bit surprised that they didn't get (be it manage to or even contact) Jose who was third on season 2 and had some really interesting solutionsThere are several variables we will likely not know. All are Americans, maybe associated to visa approvals to get staff into Mongolia. Jose IIRC lived in Canada, but held a Spanish citizenship.
The 4 hikers, never had a chance to participate do to their partners tapping out.
Two were removed by medical, for the safety of them.
Others I believe tapped because of family pulls in their minds, of course a baby on the way in season 1, put him in the hole before starting season 1.Just my thoughts...
Oh you're not wrong. I'm just curious as to how they approached their selection process
-
Found YouTube vids in which each person detailed their ten items. Several have selected a MT (Surge) instead of a knife as part of their 10 items.
Last season with the team concept, each member had a knife, and then ten items total by the team. This year the knife is part the ten item selection.
Interesting selections by them, differences regarding, pan with lid or a POT for cooking, saw and/or axe, knife and/or MT.
All were consistent, a sleeping bag, rated -20 degree F or colder.
Shelter appears to be the most crucial item to establish at camp this season. Fire, water, and food.
-
a lot bows & arrows, fishing line and hooks and trap wire too. I might make a list of the items so we can have some statistic going on. as far as MTs the ones taken were LM Wave, LM Charge TTi, LM Rebar and LM Supertool 300 (Sam has publicly stated that he had a Surge but it bent before they left so he took a Supertool)
info on the knives and tools (you can check out the comments to see what the contestants said)
http://www.thetruthaboutknives.com/2018/05/the-knives-of-historys-alone-season-5/ -
this is it. 2 of the 2 quart pots are dutch own style ones. and due to excel not cooperating the sleeping bags are missing a minus in front of the number

-
oh and by the numbers
sleeping bag - 10
knife - 8
saw - 9
ferro rod - 10
fishing line and hooks -9
trapping wire - 8
axe - 6
emergency rations #1 - 9
emergency rations #2 - 2
2 quart pot - 8
canteen - 2
paracord - 4
bow and arrows - 7
gill net - 2
multitool - 4
1,5 quart pot - 1 (it looks like the lid is a frying pan)
frying pan - 1 -
great job!

-
thanks. apparently I have some efficiency in me when I want to
-

Well done, I think they pulled the show back from the brink, back to ALONE and I think a brilliant move to bring in experienced people.
........I hope that means more episodes!


-
hopefully you're right. I'm interested in seeking how the saws perform given the hyped up winter conditions and that we have multiple Silky saws which are said to be fragile, a folding bow saw that one of the contestants previously had 1 issue with (Larry in season 2), generic bow saws and a construction saw.
if y'all don't want to go through the process of looking for the issue, in a youtube video about the items taken Larry said that the handle swole up due to the moisture and taking the saw apart and putting it back together would have been insanely difficult so he just left it put together -
I wonder if they were told to take bows.....

-
could be that a lot thought having a bow would play well with larger game and the fact that Mongolian people are famous for their archery
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I wonder if they were told to take bows.....
Bows and a quiver with a set number of arrows apparently was on the "10 Item List". Also, with the different terrain, wildlife in a variety of sizes are to be more available and may even be accessible. Yet from the orientation show, fishing and trapping (snares) might be the best option for protein.
-
Was just thinking, having never fired anything resembling a proper bow, I wouldn't take it.....
The I thought of a slingbow........that would be my choice!
I would have a chance of hitting something and it would be a viable defense inside a shelter.
-
if memory serves me, you're quite handy. there are designs for PVC bows that would suit just about any fancy so you can work on shooting a bow :D
-
I'm pretty excited to see the season. I like the location and concept this time. There are some strong competition this time out as some have proved themselves already. It'll be neat to see Jesse and Brad tackle what Mongolia throws at them since they didn't get the chance in their seasons.
Britt at 42 lasted 35 days. I thought he did well in his time out. I'm sure he comes into this adventure stronger and evermore capable.
Niclole at 48 lasted 57 days. What can I say about her, she knows her stuff. If I recall she tapped only cause she missed her children. She's going to be tough as nails with her strong skill set and knowledge.
Jesse at 32, has not been tested on Alone. Unfortunately his brother suffered a fall so they had to tap out. He's a retired Green Beret so we know he's tough. I'm really excited to see how he does.
Randy at 31 lasted 21 days. Randy lost his ferro rod last time which really sucked. I can't wait to see how lessons learned from his past experience on the show benefit him. He teaches this stuff so he has the skill and knowledge. I enjoyed watching him last time.
Carleigh at 30 lasted 86 days. Seriously this woman is a beast ( meant with all due respect ). I really enjoyed watching her. I really hope we see a woman win this season and she has a real shot. She said herself that she didn't hit her wall last time out. I really think she was willing to leave everything out there. She's tough as nails and has the skill to back it up plus the experience.
Sam at 25 lasted 55 days. Sam has a terrific personality. Who can forget him howling with the wolves. That was the best. His shelter was not the best yet he seemed to get along fine. I sure hope we get to see everything he has to offer out there. I think he's a tough guy and should do very well.
Dave lasted 73 days. If he hadn't rationed his food as he did last time on, who knows what the outcome would have been. He's got skill and since the last show he's probably got quite the plan for success. I like his attitude a lot. He's a real contender IMO.
Brad at 24 was not tested yet on Alone. I remember the look on his face when the producers told him his brother tapped. This guy is ready and has been since his episode. I can't wait to see how he does.
Larry at 47 lasted 64 days. Larry has seen his limit. I really feel he can push past that point and make a run to the end. At 64 days out he was one heck of a contestant. I'm sure we'll get a lot of bleeping and rants which I thought was good entertainment.
Brooke at 46 lasted 49 day with husband. She was part of a team but no less awesome in her own right. Having to be out solo this time will be interesting to watch. She has a strong skill set and knowledge. I am excited to see her compete this season.
I got all ages and survival days from Alone site.
-
episode 1 airs tomorrow. the special had a low viewership (under a million)
-
Thats too bad. I guess I can see how some viewers bore with the same basic premise. The mental and emotional struggle that happens as well the inner dialogue each person must be having is what I appreciate. Sure the survival part and what each takes to effect survival is always interesting. How each goes about their process and develops a routine is also interesting. I'm sure many of us play out how we'd perform in the scenarios captured. Its a fun exercise while I sit at home warm usually eating a meal
. -
@styx said:
episode 1 airs tomorrow. the special had a low viewership (under a million)I found it only because I DVR "Swamp People" and saw the listing, as far as I remeber only the actual show starting 6/14 was promoted, not the special introduction show. The likely million viewers were either lucky or part of History's email list.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login