Fasting........
-
Didn't see it.
But good one! -
I just lost 120 pounds!
8) 8)Spoiler:
I broke up wityh my girlfriend...

I thought you used Euros there, not pounds...
Maybe his gf weighed 120 pounds?
Which means she was quite in shape...not if she was under 150cm tall
-
I just lost 120 pounds!
8) 8)Spoiler:
I broke up wityh my girlfriend...

I thought you used Euros there, not pounds...
Maybe his gf weighed 120 pounds?
Which means she was quite in shape...not if she was under 150cm tall
stole my words :D
-
@ThePeacent said:
Protein is the second slowest digesting nutrient (very close to fat) and often considered the most sating, but its relative price is the highest and high-protein diets are proven to be expensive *and *toxic in the long term :ahhhIn fact there is no animal in the world that basically feeds on protein (even the meat eaters, big carnivores and wild predators, they feed mostly on fatty meat pieces and big chunks of non-muscle tissue), they either prefer carbohydrates (herbivores and many others, omnivores too) or fat (big cats and felines, fish, birds) to comprise most of their caloric intake ;)
That may be a bit too general.
Most wild animals are relatively lean. And many predators don't get to eat much fatty protein. It is true that most predators will preferentially eat organ meats, which do have a higher fat content, and frequently, a high nutrient content. Predators will often eat partially digested plant-based foods from the stomach and intestines of prey animals. So, they do get some carbohydrate that way.
But, there are humans, e.g. Inuit, who eat primarily protein and fat. Very little carbohydrate at all. And are very healthy....until they start eating a 'Western Diet' with lots of carbs.
Many people have demonstrated that it is possible to live quite nicely on just meat. Meat with some fat content. I'm not aware of anything that suggests pure protein becomes 'toxic' over time. A lack of essential fatty acids leads to nutritional deficiencies, but a high protein diet is not inherently problematic.
The early studies that led some people to think that protein might cause kidney issues came from force feeding rabbit high protein diets. Well, rabbits aren't designed to eat protein, and feeding rabbits an unnatural diet proved to be a problem.
But for humans, an all meat diet is not a problem as long as there is enough fat in the diet to meet nutritional requirements. The term "Rabbit Starvation" is an example of an all-meat diet that is so low in fatty acids that nutritional requirements aren't met.
Humans require 'essential' amino acids (proteins) and fatty acids (fats), but there is no carbohydrate requirement.
-
When the time comes, I will start the thread (possibly tomorrow evening or Monday morning as we have people for all places and countries) but I thought this would be an appropriate first post for it, and an introduction to any newcomers to the subject. It's long winded, but if you want to go through it, here it is:

Spoiler:
OK, so here we have it. If anyone wants to join, at any point, you're welcome here and feel free to post about your experience(s) with fasting, as well as any doubts or thoughts you have about it, questions, ideas, or personal accounts or from others.
Keep it respectful, please. 
And,<u> this is not medical advice</u>, any reasonings as to "why this happens" or "how do you explain this" can be asked and you'll be pointed out to where to do your own research, read on the subject, or you'll get your answer here ;)
The basics, of what you can and cannot do would be very simple:
You can:
- Eat during the scheduled hours of the day that correspond to your fasting method- Drink non-caloric drinks during the fasting hours, that is water, sparkly water, plain black coffee, tea [green, black, or white], and flavored water (with lemon drops, for instance) but not using any caloric add-on (sugar, cream, milk, alcohol, honey, etc. all these are out, only non-caloric sweeteners are allowed if you need the drink flavored or sweetened)

- Furthermore, you must drink more because fasting naturally depleted your body fluids and causes greater water loss than any other "diet" or way of eating, but we won't get into why that happens here, ask if necessary

- Exercise, work, play sports, do your hobbies and normal life. ;)
You can't:
Spoiler:
- Eat snacks, appetizers, binge eat (but you can binge watch TV or binge surf Mt.Org!
) or drink juices, cappuccinos, nectars, smoothies, milk, alcohol or any caloric beverage during the fasting hours
- Eat or take in calories after or before your pre-scheduled eating windows

- Overdo it, if you feel bad (not just hungry, a bit bad tempered or somewhat light headed) or notice any issues stop it immediately and have common sense when feeling your own body's signals and feelings

- Start fasting if you have a serious medical condition mostly related to diet (diabetes, hypotension, etc.). Consult your GP or doctor before starting fasting, or if you think it could negatively affect your health or interfere with your medication(s)

any medication, pills, or substances you must ingest will have to be ingested during the eating periods, as many meds today contain glucose, dextrose, and other caloric substances which usually comprise most of the medicine's weight (cough syrup, gastric pills, etc.) :ahhh
Below, a brief approach to the most common (But not all) fasting methods that people use today:
Spoiler:
- IF: (intermittent Fasting) includes any fasting that follows a regular pattern of eating and non-eating hours that is repeated throughout the week, month or another time frame, for instance eat 6 hrs a day, stop eating during 18 hrs and then start eating again, the religious Ramadan would be a very common practiced type of IF (fasting from sun to sun, eating before the first sunlight and start eating again after the last ray of sunlight)
-
ADF: (Alternate Day Fasting) is eating one day of the week, then not eating the whole next day, then eating again the third day, and fasting the entire fourth day and so on, in whatever order you choose (for instance eat on Sunday but not Monday, then eat on Tuesday etc. or viceversa)
-
2/7: That is fasting two days every week, no matter when, be it two days in a row (ex: not eating on Monday and Tuesday) or more commonly not eating on two different days of the week
-
Prolonged fast: This is not eating for more than 48 hours straight, for example eating on Monday at 8AM and then fasting until 13PM of Wednesday. 72hrs or more fasting is included here. Even though people rarely fast for more than 48hrs, some do it for political beliefs, religious practices, health problems or other issues, but these kind of fasts generally require of close medical supervision and a controlled environment
One should never attempt this long of a fast without previous planning, medical advice, and preferably previous experience to fasting. :o
Finally, some common things people feel and experience when fasting:
The* not so pretty: *
Spoiler:
-
The first times and days are the harder, but if you're in good health your body adapts quickly and it becomes a non-issue. Like everything, it takes practice to be fully comfortable with it. You might feel weak or tired because of the loss of liquid (drink, drink!!) and electrolytes in the blood that come with the liquid loss [Na, K, Ca, Mn, Cu] (drink electrolyte drinks or do them at home with lemon, salts, etc., put salt in your food, etc.) :ahhh
-
Hunger *always *comes in waves (it's the body's hormonal system functioning, the same in everybody), the idea is to ignore or overcome these waves with will power, distracting yourself or doing other stuff (keeping yourself busy) until it goes away. It *will *go away, and the more time you are at this the longer the time will be between them, and the lesser their effect and disturbance on you. The first 48 hrs are the worst, always.
-
All of the above will be harder if you suffer from Diabetes or Pre-Diabetes or take certain medications that affect hormones (or have other ailments/diseases that cause hormonal abnormalities). If so, it is of prime importance that you talk to your doctor before attempting any fasting at all :ahhh

-
The first days or weeks you'll probably be more bad tempered, susceptible and angry when you feel hunger, but this is also related to hormones (hunger = alert, due to our animal roots) and will even out or disappear after a while of fasting and getting used to it. Your self control will eventually become much better, stronger and can help you out in other aspects of life

The somewhat pretty:
Spoiler:
with some time into fasting and practicing with this method,-
You will notice that your glucose levels (and insulin release, blood sugar spikes, etc.) improve with fasting and your hunger levels will be lower after a while, and the hunger "waves" or pangs will be reduced or will disappear, hard to believe *until *you experience it
-
You will lose weight, **if **you compliment the fasting with a proper diet (that is, not eating junk food in your eating windows, :D and learning to listen to your *real *hunger and body signals, not start eating just the minute you "can" and eat for 6 hours straight to engorge yourself until you're full, to "compensate" for all what you haven't eaten
) and keep active, walking, working, etc. You **can **gain weight with fasting, too :o -
You will be better at knowing when your body asks for food, and when you are just experiencing a hunger pang, cravings or desire to eat. If you're hungry but go for a walk, drink some water or engage in an activity and 15 mins later you are not consumed by a raving hunger, then you didn't really need to it back then when you thought you did
). Thus you will be more proficient at regulating when, what ,where and *why *do you eat, without needing to run for a doughnut or interrupt what you are doing to eat something, be it work, a hobby or a fun trip 
-
Your blood lipids (cholesterol, fatty acids, etc.) will improve especially if your diet is a proper, nutritious one during the time that you are eating. Your mood will even out as you learn to cope with hunger, which will be lesser and more controllable as you progress, and you'll feel more energetic and active if you get the proper food at the proper time, and combine it with controlled non eating periods
Final notes,
- if you fast, drink a lot!! Keep hydrated
and electrolytes are also key, sodium, potassium, etc. - if you take meds or have medical conditions, ask your doctore before any of this!!

- if you fast, you must take special care of your diet and what you eat when you do eat. Nourish yourself with real food!

- if you fast, and you feel bad or are experiencing trouble or signs of it (blackouts, fainting, weird body movement, etc.) stop instantly and talk to our doctor!!!
- **Normal **things are feeling light, strongly tempered, hungry, a bit weak (the first times), pain in the stomach ??? (that's not real pain, but hunger signals, intense ones though :D) or even tired at times until you get used, but NOT normal is feeling ill, in pain, have crampings, or having extreme reactions (vomiting, diarrhea, etc.)

So, after this long winded post, if you feel like it, welcome to this thread and join whenever you want or when you've answered your questions and want to give it a try!

- Drink non-caloric drinks during the fasting hours, that is water, sparkly water, plain black coffee, tea [green, black, or white], and flavored water (with lemon drops, for instance) but not using any caloric add-on (sugar, cream, milk, alcohol, honey, etc. all these are out, only non-caloric sweeteners are allowed if you need the drink flavored or sweetened)
-
So you're going to start a fasting thread? I'm in!
-
I thought this was the fasting thread....

-
Protein is the second slowest digesting nutrient (very close to fat) and often considered the most sating, but its relative price is the highest and high-protein diets are proven to be expensive *and *toxic in the long term :ahhh
In fact there is no animal in the world that basically feeds on protein (even the meat eaters, big carnivores and wild predators, they feed mostly on fatty meat pieces and big chunks of non-muscle tissue), they either prefer carbohydrates (herbivores and many others, omnivores too) or fat (big cats and felines, fish, birds) to comprise most of their caloric intake ;)
That may be a bit too general.
Most wild animals are relatively lean. And many predators don't get to eat much fatty protein. It is true that most predators will preferentially eat organ meats, which do have a higher fat content, and frequently, a high nutrient content. Predators will often eat partially digested plant-based foods from the stomach and intestines of prey animals. So, they do get some carbohydrate that way.
But, there are humans, e.g. Inuit, who eat primarily protein and fat. Very little carbohydrate at all. And are very healthy....until they start eating a 'Western Diet' with lots of carbs.
Many people have demonstrated that it is possible to live quite nicely on just meat. Meat with some fat content. I'm not aware of anything that suggests pure protein becomes 'toxic' over time. A lack of essential fatty acids leads to nutritional deficiencies, but a high protein diet is not inherently problematic.
The early studies that led some people to think that protein might cause kidney issues came from force feeding rabbit high protein diets. Well, rabbits aren't designed to eat protein, and feeding rabbits an unnatural diet proved to be a problem.
But for humans, an all meat diet is not a problem as long as there is enough fat in the diet to meet nutritional requirements. The term "Rabbit Starvation" is an example of an all-meat diet that is so low in fatty acids that nutritional requirements aren't met.
Humans require 'essential' amino acids (proteins) and fatty acids (fats), but there is no carbohydrate requirement.
all very true and valid points.

For the Inuit diet and a carb-free (or almost) way of eating I really recommend reading "Why We Get Fat, And What to do About It" and "The Big Fat Surprise" to address **exactly **those points
Also reading on Vilhjalmur Stefansson and his experiments after meeting the Inuit raises interesting points and considerations regarding western Diet vs meat based diet 
And not contradictiomg your explanaton in any way, it is very true that:
**a-**Protein exclusive diets were tried on the inappropriate animals (mainly vegetarian ones) and the results *cannot *apply to human beings
b- If a high protein (or protein exclusive) diet can be considered toxic/dangerous to the human being is because of the lack of other nutrients, not because of protein itself or a inherent substance/component in the amino acids or as a result of their breakdown in the digestive systemThat of course would also apply to a 100% carb or 100% fat diet not complemented with other minerals, micronutrients, vitamins etc. but realistically speaking it's impossible for any person to thrive and live on that kind diet, thus resulting in a toxic diet in any of the previous scenarios :ahhh
Carbs are the *least *important macronutrient as practically all they provide is energy,
proteins have the amino-acids and fats with their fatty acids are vital to dissolve and absorb many vitamins, and contain lots of minerals and other key substances. The only strongly beneficial nutrients related or present in carbohydrate rich foods are fiber, vitamins and minerals (mostly from plants and non refined grains) which sadly are lacking in most modern western diets, which only have refined, nutrient poor carbs
So I don't see if or where are we contradicting ourselves in what has been posted,
but yes there's many misinformation spread all across the world and much bad has been done and said in the education and advertising of the American Diet and Nutrition in general in the last century 
but I fail to see what does that have to do with fasting more than it has to do with proper nutrition, a subject for another (or **many **other) threads ???
-
yes we got a bit carried away, :D thus why I said in the post just above and answering to Nix's very interesting points:
"*So I don't see if or where are we contradicting ourselves in what has been posted,
but yes there's many misinformation spread all across the world and much bad has been done and said in the education and advertising of the American Diet and Nutrition in general in the last century 
but I fail to see what does that have to do with fasting more than it has to do with proper nutrition, a subject for another (or many other) threads ???"*
-
Well said, El P.

-
I can vouch for the part where it states that the waves of hunger get less intense and less common.
When I couldn't eat for a few weeks, the first 3-4 days were the hardest regarding hunger.
-
so please help me figure this out - you said 18-6 right? i usually get to the gym around 18:30 to 19:00 and don't get back home before 21:00. this will all change for the next month since I'll be going to a different gym, but that is still the best outlier.
if I cap off the eating window at 22:00 that means it starts at 16:00, which means going through almost the entire day on a coffee or 2 and water. this is a bit concerning since I get up around 7, work 'till 17:00
if I say end the eating window at 20:00, it would start at 14:00 which is great (since that is about the time I eat lunch at work anyway), however it would also mean that after the gym there is no meal and logistically a bit more concerning managing to put all the meals while i'm at work (i squat 3 times a week and if i eat something in the hour before it tends to lead to wanting to hurl, especially if it is a max effort or around 90% squat which also means I've got a belt on tight)To give a few figures, I should be eating a baseline of 2000 kcal to be in a caloric deficit plus what ever I spend on cardio (walking to and from work, to and from the gym). Gym days that means 880 extra kcal, off days that means 440 extra kcal. Again, for the next month all days will be calculated as off days since that temporary gym is close to my work.
That would bean hitting 2400kcal a day, breaking it down to 3 meals would be 800kcal which is oddly difficult when you're trying to eat clean (no sugar, carbs from potatoes, rice, vegetables and fruit, using leaner meats).
I have a feeling that this will result in me being one of those guys that packs a mini fridge to work and eats every 2 hours like a baby -
@styx said:
so please help me figure this out - 1you said 18-6 right? I usually get to the gym around 18:30 to 19:00 and don't get back home before 21:00. this will all change for the next month since I'll be going to a different gym, but that is still the best outlier.if I cap off the eating window at 22:00 that means it starts at 16:00, which means going through almost the entire day on a coffee or 2 and water. this is a bit concerning since I get up around 7, work 'till 17:00
if I say end the eating window at 20:00, it would start at 14:00 which is great2 (since that is about the time I eat lunch at work anyway), however it would also mean that after the gym there is no meal and logistically 3a bit more concerning managing to put all the meals while i'm at work (i squat 3 times a week and if i eat something in the hour before it tends to lead to wanting to hurl, especially if it is a max effort or around 90% squat which also means I've got a belt on tight)To give a few figures, I should be eating a baseline of 42000 kcal to be in a caloric deficit plus what ever I spend on cardio (walking to and from work, to and from the gym). Gym days that means 880 extra kcal, off days that means 440 extra kcal. Again, for the next month all days will be calculated as off days since that temporary gym is close to my work.
That would bean hitting 52400kcal a day, breaking it down to 3 meals would be 800kcal 6which is oddly difficult when you're trying to eat clean (no sugar, carbs from potatoes, rice, vegetables and fruit, using leaner meats).
I have a feeling that this will result in me being one of those guys that packs a mini fridge to work and 7eats every 2 hours like a babylet's split the answer to address different bolded parts, in order

1- I didn't *say *anything about *your * ideal personal approach to fasting, 18/6 is as valid as is 16/8, 20/4 or other methods. I personally do 18/6 most days (stop eating at 9PM, eating lunch at around 15 next day). You do as you wish, or can

2- That's up to you, some people can't have breakfast, some others need something to eat as soon as they get up, many people have dinner at 6 or 7PM (including several EU countries), etc. If you usually skip breakfast like me, and your first meal is lunch, then the easier it is to tick to this. You have to mold it to your preferential eating hours, or do ADF (alternate day fasting)
3- I, and many millions of people, do not eat while at work, or have jobs/job sites/environments where it is harder to find a break for eating. I advise you to consider not eating at all during your work hours to improve your efficiency and save time, but I do not know what, where or when do you work ??? or what does your job demand of you

4- Calories are totally independent of fasting, one can eat 3500kcal/day on a fasting diet, or 1800kcal/day on a 5 meal a day plan :ahhh
5- No need to do that, I personally eat 2600-2800 kcal/day on two meals, and one snack in between (15-16PM and 20-21PM) if I feel like it. Also, I guess you're following that diet and meal distribution due to your workout and exercise, and the intention to build muscle
but it can be easily modified to be efficient while fitting into a fasting plan 
6- I don't really agree with that.
Even in a muscle building diet you can combine the proper carb/protein/fat ratios in every meal (be it 2 or 3 meals a day or more) to reach 800kcal, less or more calories too, in a clean, natural way. The hardest part is not what foods to pick, but rather the logistics of transport, eating, and varying the diert enough while working, walking and going to the gym.Planning is the key here.
And also, fat is the densest food calorie wise (9Kcal/gram vs 4kcal/gram for protein and carbs) so adding it to your meals would make them more compact, easier to transport, and smaller so they interfere less with exercise (non fulll stomachs, bloating, gas, indigestion, etc.) and your logistics.Finally, maybe the best diet to compliment a fasting approach is a ketogenic or low carb one, where fat is king and carbs (especially easily digested ones like rice, potato, etc.) are not welcome, because of their immediate absorption, blood sugar spiking and other issues

just food for thought (pun intended) :D
7- that would be the end result the furthest from a proper, well planned fasting diet, but I am not anyone to tell you how, what, where and when to eat :ahhh, the fasting approach *might *not be for you, or at least not *at this time * :P if you find it so challenging and hard to pull off. Friendly advice here, nothing else! I will try to help you the best I can, otr at least offer you other points of view

-
Actually I had a very hard time eating clean and reaching a specific caloric goal. A big part of that is the lack of availability or ridiculously high cost of some foods that would help out without putting in horrid amounts of the not so good micronutrients. It is one of the reasons why even trying keto for myself for instance is a really bad idea since most of my pay would go on food.
I think I'll give it a go in the 16-8 format from 14:00 to 22:00 as that will give me enough options put those calories in (yes, I'm very concerned about yo-yoing and going too fast)
-
@styx said:
Actually I had a very hard time eating clean and reaching a specific caloric goal. A big part of that is the lack of availability or ridiculously high cost of some foods that would help out without putting in horrid amounts of the not so good micronutrients. It is one of the reasons why even trying keto for myself for instance is a really bad idea since most of my pay would go on food.I already spend as much on food as a small family.
I beat myself up about this at times, but the only option is eating less, not to start shoveling garbage......my body doesn't let me get away with that.I had an active weekend but I ate too much yesterday......paying for that today.

-
yea that is problematic at best
-
@ThePeacent said:
3- I, and many millions of people, do not eat while at work, or have jobs/job sites/environments where it is harder to find a break for eating. I advise you to consider not eating at all during your work hours to improve your efficiency and save time, but I do not know what, where or when do you work ??? or what does your job demand of you
Even disregarding those that are in effect slaves, I know the truth of what you're saying.....but I can't do it.
Closest I came was when I smoked 40 a (good) day.......
-
I just lost 120 pounds!
8) 8)Spoiler:
I broke up wityh my girlfriend...

I thought you used Euros there, not pounds...
She was British.

Spoiler:
Seems Brexit came early for me...

-
I just lost 120 pounds!
8) 8)Spoiler:
I broke up wityh my girlfriend...

I thought you used Euros there, not pounds...
Maybe his gf weighed 120 pounds?
Which means she was quite in shape...not if she was under 150cm tall
Of course she was in shape!

Spoiler:
Round is a shape, you know?!

Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login