Anyone watch the tv show Alone? [SPOILERS!]
-
Can I change channel quickly?
Started watching Naked & Afraid XL season 4.....
Very real except that somebody's within hailing distance....with cameras.
The hardship is real however, walking barefoot is bad enough!
I'm sure the people keeping watch are armed, but to have lion and hyena that close...trying to breach the shelters.
@Alan K. said:
[ Speaking of defense against predators I wonder why no one has made a spear yet.Walking stick/spear combo would be one of the first things I make....
-
I've also wondered why a spear hasn't been made. I'd feel better with some distance while I attempt to use my bear spray.
Good to see Dave as successfull as he's been. He's a good guy not wanting to hurt those animals. I totally got what he was saying and how he was feeling. He's taking some great shots and hitting the target. I hope the next kill is quick so he can feel better.
Brooke. She was such a good fisherwoman with her husband. Not sure whats going on with her. She's got to get into gear soon the season is changing. Come on Brooke, I want to see you pull fish out like you did before.
Sam. This young mans attitude is so refreshing. He's got quite a shelter going on. Glad to see he's not going to try to wing it with a tarp shelter.
Jesse. Well darn. I really felt like he was checking out emotionally from last episode. That darn fish getting away was a total let down. Resorting to eating the pine tree was desperate even from his view.
Britts attitude continues to be so great. Catching all those fish was wonderful to see. Go Britt. His shetler looks great too. Freaking bears are close to camp tho. I'd like to see him work other food resources and be successful. I'm sure he would too. He has such a great attitude.
Larry. Dude is hilarious. He's a real character. Man I was scared when he hit the deck. Glad he wasn't hurt and recovered quickly. I'm also glad he recognized what may have been going on. Now he can make the needed adjustments. I do wish he'd fish more after the initial catch. I know he's anxious to eat.
Good episode. I did miss the dude with the log cabin. I always forget his name.
-
They're not managing to store much food, and it looks like the winter is coming.
I don't know how one guy can figure out the fishing and the others struggle, the river seems to be full of trout and grayling, classic targets for fly fishing.........and "fly" fishing is exactly what's working....
-
maybe they aren't experienced at fly fishing.
I was surprised to see the last one go. And ofc Larry is having a fight with mice
Also...
-
I learnt fly fishing an absolute vacuum, literally a handful of people in my whole country that's even tried it, very few that actively practiced it.....
US and EU........difficult to believe an outdoorsy person doesn't even know the concept

Anyway.......funny to see that the guy catching enough fish craves meat anyway......more likely fat?
Dave......I think it was the previous episode, but when he started crying about the squirrel I found that a bit much.......
I don't understand how you can be that hungry and still come up with BS like that, I would assume that's when survival mode kicks in and BS goes out the window....
-
honestly, I've never fly fished or even met someone who has locally. but then again, I'm more of a hobo because "rods are just too complex to carry" so that might explain it
we have a saying here that basically says that fish isn't real meat. so it could be that he is used to more red meat
-
It is very frustrating to watch a contestant exit because of the loneliness and color of the tarp. She did indicate that she was starving, indicating she was not gathering any fish or protein via her bow, yet her filming that was shared did not indicate she was trying that much.
I thought Larry might tap due to his mice population he is hosting, yet there is a source of meat(!).
Sam has not been featured, yet the snippets would show he is struggling.
Britt and Randy's attitudes are good and shelter's are adequate. Both smoking fish.
Dave's break down over the squirrel I thought was because it did not die on first shot, and it suffered, which I thought was strange, then he did it again shooting a grouse, yet set there and watched a mouse walk into the trap be killed. Come up you are trying to survive, I quess the editors luv it.
Done to five, able guys, just depends on what nature provides for them and maybe location, location and location is the true key to success.
-
So, you are a perfect example - do you know and understand the concept of fly fishing, even if you've never done it?
For the best part of my life A River Runs Through It was my only exposure to fly fishing, there was no internet, no magazines on the subject. We drowned worms under floats but that's it.....
@styx said:
we have a saying here that basically says that fish isn't real meat.We don't say it we just believe it

I like seafood more than fish in general, even if I'm in the mood for fish I have a mental block against ordering it in a restaurant.
-
not really. i know there is a lot of motion and that tying flies is something everyone takes pride in because theirs is the best
@LoopCutter said:
It is very frustrating to watch a contestant exit because of the loneliness and color of the tarp. She did indicate that she was starving, indicating she was not gathering any fish or protein via her bow, yet her filming that was shared did not indicate she was trying that much.I thought Larry might tap due to his mice population he is hosting, yet there is a source of meat(!).
Sam has not been featured, yet the snippets would show he is struggling.
Britt and Randy's attitudes are good and shelter's are adequate. Both smoking fish.
Dave's break down over the squirrel I thought was because it did not die on first shot, and it suffered, which I thought was strange, then he did it again shooting a grouse, yet set there and watched a mouse walk into the trap be killed. Come up you are trying to survive, I quess the editors luv it.
Done to five, able guys, just depends on what nature provides for them and maybe location, location and location is the true key to success.
could be the editing. but if you're hungry, tired, it isn't hard to imagine smaller things pushing us over the edge
when it comes to Sam, I got no idea. he struggled in season 1, broke down a few times and still had a good run.
breaking down over an energy source, well i sort of get it but also don't. i'm not heartless but things like that don't bother me. to be fair squirrels and grouse are a lot cuter than mice -
Not surprised Brooke tapped out. She was out there nearly a month. We didn't see her do so well with fishing like her last time on the show. I wonder if she was out to prove something to herself? I mean she was out last time with her husband. She had quite a positive attitude possibly due to the company. She was successful fishing up to a point. Then hunger took her out. I still applaud her. I liked her a lot.
Randys shelter is more of a home. Quite impressive. He seems to be doing well and has a much different attitude this time. Its great to see him doing well at this point.
Larry, man this guy is a crack up. Those darn mice again
. He has got to try not to let them get into his head, although seems last time its what drove him. Find a way to trap them and eat them. He's seriously a trip.Dave is quite a shot with that bow. He reminds me of Matt Graham. He has no hesitation to hunt he just wants a clean kill. I understand that. I respect that. Honestly, I admire it. Having a moment when you shot an animal yet not killed it straight away is not a big deal. Him setting up that mouse trap in his shelter was awesome to see. He has a nice little meal with very little effort. Larry should do the same thing.
The snippet we saw of Sam showed him struggling with food. I hope he figures it out soon. I'd love to know what he's doing to get food. -
-
the last episode really shows that ideas can't be judged as good or bad but rather by their quality. the execution is what makes them good or bad. and I'm talking about the nets here
-
Sam seems to be really struggling. I'm wondering what his plans were for protein knowing winter will be brutal
.Britt is chugging along. I sure hope he continues to hang in there. His attitude is really noticeably more positive this go around.
Larry and those mice
. Larry and the wind
.Randys shelter is really something. His idea for smoking fish is neat. He's in a nice groove and I do hope he continues.
Dave not wanting to hurt the animals is understandable. I hope he gets a deer. That would be a game changer for sure.
-
I hope Dave doesn't fall from that stand. And next time I want to see Larry win against the wind as he did against the mice
-
Larry's landing net was well built, it functioned and he was so proud of it, and the fact he did it there. The most positive that editing has presented him on both seasons.
Britt will be in trouble if it colder and fish no longer bite, or he can not gather bait (grasshoppers).
Sam does not appear to be thinking of proper solutions for proper results. The gill net required 10 pound rocks to hold in place. A throw net about 20' across may help if he waited out into the river and tossed into a edy.
If Larry can kill a deer, that would be awesome, his newly made spear thrower looks neat, (can not remember what it is called at the moment)
Randy appears to have it together, if he stays in the moments mentally, he could outlast awl.
-
The word you were looking for is atlatl
-
^ Yep, that is the name of the tool he carved, Atlatl. I do not recall ever seeing one before, let ALONE, hearing of one.

-
@LoopCutter said:
^ Yep, that is the name of the tool he carved, Atlatl. I do not recall ever seeing one before, let ALONE, hearing of one.

Matt Graham that was in the later season of Dual Survival uses it a lot, something I still want to try, but we don't have obliging plants/trees here.
I was expecting a bit more from this season, if I can be perfectly honest I'm finding one of my favourite shows boring

-
well it is going slow a bit. maybe there is simply so much to show?
-
The "action" is a bit slow. I still enjoy the mental aspect even if we arent hearing about everything they are going though. At this point with winter creeping in we should really begin to see who has the "fitness" to remain.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login