Sheffield 12020
-
I bought a Sheffield 12020 on eBay for a song, and it just arrived today. It's been used and abused a bit. Dropped repeatedly. One of the handles isn't entirely square anymore. It's a large tool, and seems robust and well made. The pliers open very wide, and can handle bigger tasks than most. Not comfortable to use on a garden hose, but for other pliering tasks it seems pretty decent. It's finnicky to close, just like the Schrade ST5E. The Schrade has higher quality tools IMO, especially that bit driver. That said, the tools in this Schrade aren't bad at all. They're ALL locking tools, which is nice. The clip point blade in mine appears to still have the factory edge, and it's still sharp enough to cut receipt paper, as is the small sheepsfoot blade. The wood saw is one of the better saws I've used, making a nice wide kerf and not getting stuck at all. It is rather short, though. The file is aggressive and three-sided, and is made from actual file material. The serrated blade makes very short work of paracord. The gasket scraper is a nice touch, not many tools have that. The shining star is the phillips driver. Big and beefy and robust and very well-formed. However, THREE different flat head drivers seems like a bit much to me. I'd rather have had some other tool in there. A second phillips or something.
The tool quality isn't really the issue at hand, to be honest. The tools are quality enough. It's that they're all difficult to extract, and difficult to unlock. You have to half-open another tool to unlock one that is fully extended, and this isn't a highly precisely machined system. Some of the tools require siginficant force to unlock, even though another tool next to them is pushing the lock bar away. The happens on both the tweaked and untweaked sides, so it's not due to existing damage. The tool just feels CLUNKY. Not precise and refined in the least.
The handles aren't that comfortable to put force onto. For general use they're fine, the tools are flat enough to make it not hard on the palm and fingers, but once you start bearing down it's downright painful. There's also significant handle flex when really bearing down.
The wire cutter portion intrudes into the center gripping oval, which is not ideal. The cutter itself works really well on zip ties and hard wire, but not so great on soft wire. It can't even fit 12ga stranded wire in the cutter, much less Romex. It can't cut 24ga or 16ga with thick insulation. It does make short work of hard fencing wire though. Snips right through wire coat hangers with ease.
It folds up more compactly than the Schrade, so that's nice. The pliers open a bit more than the Schrade, so that's also nice. The handles unfortunately also open really wide, so where I could barely get purchase on a garden hose with the schrade, and can get slightly more purchase with the Sheffield, the Schrade I could do that one-handed, and the Sheffield I need two hands to use it on a garden hose.
Overall I give these a tentative "Meh". If you snag one for under $20 you're doing alright. But I wouldn't get excited over it even at the $20 mark.
Charles.




-
Oh yeah, the tool load:
Side 1:
Serrated blade
Small flat driver
Phillips driver
Another small flat driver
Yet another (larger) flat driver.
Big three-sided metal fileSide 2:
Clip-point blade
Can opener
Very short awl with bottle opener
Gasket scraper
Short sheepsfoot blade
Wood sawCharles.
-
Thank you for posting this one, Charles! Found one on ebay for $19.99 shipped. Should be at my house next week.
I know these slip plier tools aren't all that effective(as you have described), but they sure look awesome, from a collector's standpoint. :)
-
I do need to mention, the Phillips driver on this Sheffield, though short, is one of the best drivers I’ve ever seen on a multitool.
Charles.
-
@ChopperCharles said:
I do need to mention, the Phillips driver on this Sheffield, though short, is one of the best drivers I’ve ever seen on a multitool.Charles.
Thanks for sharing.

Awl on the bottle opener? Nice touch.
Is the Phillips square shank? If so, is the thickness 5mm? -
The driver itself is 6mm in diameter, and very well formed. Looks exactly like a screwdriver head on any of the quality screwdrivers I have. The tang is 4mm wide. It appears the driver was formed first, and the rest of the tool machined down to 4mm thick afterwards. But I'm not sure on that. The driver is 5.4cm long from end to end.
Charles.
-
@gerleatherberman said:
Thank you for posting this one, Charles! Found one on ebay for $19.99 shipped. Should be at my house next week.I know these slip plier tools aren't all that effective(as you have described), but they sure look awesome, from a collector's standpoint. :)
Good to see my enabling skills are still working
( I mentioned the 12020 recently so I'm taking credit for these two purchases) ;)
:D -
Thank you for the info, Charles!

I feel pretty good about my purchase of one now.
Gergozedobe,
Your enabling is legendary :D
Thank you for posting about your 12020!
-
Slipjoint pliers is not something you see everyday in a MT so that makes it a great feature to me

-
Thanks, Poncho!

The Sheffield will be my second slip-joint MT. They are really neat. :)
If you'll read some of Charles' experience with them, you'll see they are somewhat useful, but not as much as one would assume. :-\
-
My copy is bent as well. The handles are not nearly as robust as the Schrade ST5E. One of my handles has gone trapezoidal, and the other is twisted and out of plane. Seller refunded purchase price but not his exorbitant shipping cost :/ Ah well. All the tools still work and the pliers work too, it's just been used hard in the past. It's also not particularly comfortable to put pressure on... but man, when I compare the tools inside this thing to the tools inside a cheap multitool, there's no contest. The tools in this thing are extremely well-made.
Charles.
-
The one I ordered say "lightly used"
We'll see. I bought a "near mint" LM Pulse once. Took 6hrs to get it "acceptable". I had to peen the pliers, file thr teeth into shape, shift the cutters and sharpen them
Beat the barrel pins out and wire wheeled rust off of everything.
-
I've had the same or similar experiences time and again. With the plier tools, I've bought one in particular that I really wanted, and when it arrived it looked like it had been run over. ALL of the rivets popped, side plates and bent, big gaps between the liners, etc. Then again, I've also bought tools sold as "used condition with scratches and marks" and got the item and it was damn near perfect. My Marlboro-branded Victorinox Troubleshooter was like that. It had one chip out of the scale, but was otherwise immaculate and looked like it had never been used. Not a mark on the blades, not a one on the liners. I put blue Plus scales on it and have been using it nearly every day since. Likewise, I bought a factory second Utica/Kutmaster lockback. Brass ends and wood handle, big clip point blade. Basically a hunting knife, It had some discoloration on the brass. That was it. IT'S BRASS. It's supposed to tarnish!
Charles.
-
Very true. I'll try and remember that sometimes the item is way better than described. The Grappler I bought was sold as used with box, but the tool still had factory oil on it. :)
-
Thank you for posting this one, Charles! Found one on ebay for $19.99 shipped. Should be at my house next week.
I know these slip plier tools aren't all that effective(as you have described), but they sure look awesome, from a collector's standpoint. :)
Good to see my enabling skills are still working
( I mentioned the 12020 recently so I'm taking credit for these two purchases) ;)
:D
-
Vise, hammer, bending, and general ducking around and I’ve got my 12020 back in more or less okay condition. It closes correctly and isn’t noticeably tweaked. But I’d have to disassemble it to fix the lock and slight trapezoidal shape to one of the handles. And I don’t think the those are bolts. I think they’re pins or rivets. Can’t turn them with any pliers, and can’t really get much purchase on them with anything.
Good enough for now, but the lock doesn’t work on one side now. Ah well. It only cost me shipping.
Charles.
-
Charles,
When mine arrives, I'll see if my Leatherman wrenches work on it, and report back!
I'll try some heat on the pivits too, in case there is some really hard dried loctite in there.
-
I was curious whether the Phillips could fit a Ganzo bit kit adapter.
Will you use it once everything is fixed? -
It really can’t do what I was hoping it would do. So I’m not sure. The hard wire cutter is excellent, it’s probably worth keeping around for that reason if no other. But I haven’t decided yet.
As for the bit driver adapter, I have one and I just tested it. It will not work. The driver is too large for the adapter to fit over.
Charles.
-
Maybe a shelf queen then. It's certainly interesting. And probably rare? I haven't seen it posted before.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login