Modding a SAK 111
-
I think that the internal notch in liner 2 and 3 is to let the slightly bulbous Philips driver sit without interference. I can't think why it's there in liner 5 too, though, It can't be to reduce costs through parts commonality as it's thinner than the others and has no lock slot. It's a unique piece. And why the right hand liner is so thin is beyond me.
-
@Don Pablo said:
The stamped contouring is required because A, not all tools are same thickness, and/or B, it stops the tools rubbing in the wrong places.
What do you keep in your pocket? :ahhhIt's all perfectly normal stuff in my pockets. Some people have questioned the mini crowbar but it seems perfectly normal to me..............
-
Anyway, I think that I'll stop trying to second guess this stuff and just keep the layers in stock order as much as possible.
I'm thinking of removing the blade and moving either the saw or nail file down to replace it. I can't decide whether to keep the slide lock or remove it. But the pivot area of those tools is slightly different to that of the blade so I may need to reshape the base to make the lock work if I decide to keep it.
-
Got it finished.
I moved the saw blade into the knife blade position in the end, for no good reason really. It could just as easily have been the nail file. It was an arbitrary decision.
I was going to reprofile the pivot area of the saw blade so that the lock still worked but in the end I decided against it, for two reasons. Firstly, it worked fine as a slip joint with zero work. Secondly, I was worried that I would have to take so much material off the joint that I would lose tension in it and the corkscrew. So, no lock.
I have temporarily put the old scales back but with the spring removed from the button. The button rattles a bit but it fills the hole.
Longer term I'll get new scales without the button. Does anyone know if the linerlock scales will work?
-
Nice job

As to liners, I've been giving them a lot of thought recently too. There's commonality, and minimising stock inventory and press tooling, but also to balancing of weight, strength, and material costs.
I haven't studied this, so what I'm about to say may be totally wrong, but I've been thinking through how I would go about choosing shape and thickness, if I was designing them myself.
Wider layers, potentially have greater unsupported pin lengths, and may require a more substantial liner flanking them. Likewise, a layer with a tool that would be subject to torque (driver, and possibly pliers) might need more support to prevent the two halves of the knife from crabbing in your hand as you twist it. A thinner layer which doesn't need a twisting action, such as a file or saw, might be fine with a thinner liner, unless its neighbour is one of the wider or torque prone layers.
Again, with the torque in mind, I think a slimmer build such as a Yeoman, might be more rigid and need less robust liners than for example a Swisschamp with the same driver, as there's less leverage from the axis of the driver, to the outer edge of the scale.
As I say, this is all purely speculative.
-
It was subjective, but I did think that the thicker liners seemed way stiffer than the thin ones; way more than I would have expected from the extra 0.3mm thickess.
-
@dvd8n said:
It was subjective, but I did think that the thicker liners seemed way stiffer than the thin ones; way more than I would have expected from the extra 0.3mm thickess.That 0.3mm is only a 43% increase in thickness, but it equates to just over double the section modulus of the 0.7mmm piece (that axis gets squared in the calculation) - so basically, double the rigidity if the rest of the dimensions are the same

-
Take a look at the 91mm liners. The thickest ones are those next to the pliers and cybertool layers - these are for tool clearance as much as added strength. The ones next to the philips are a little thinner, and the rest are thinner still. The liners on a Cadet are only 0.4mm thick (I think) but are made from nickel silver which is stiffer and stronger than brass.
-
Victorinox are obviously putting a lot more thought into the design of the liners than I thought. But the fact that the first thing that I had to do on disassembly is hammer one of them flat shows that they are not always right.
Then it struck me. I had a look at a 91mm knife; specifically the pivot area. In most places the liners overhang the tool pivots by about 1.5mm. The biggest was 2mm; a few of them were actually flush. On my 111mm a 6mm overhang is normal. I guess it gives extra support when the tools are open but on the other hand it's not surprising that I'm managing to bend the thinner liners.
To be honest it's not really a big problem; the knife has lived in my pocket daily for ten years with minimal damage. But, on the whole I'd have gone for the thicker liners throughout and accepted the tiny weight penalty.
(By the way, if you look really hard at the bottom of the black 111mm, you can still see a small gap between the liner and the scale where I did not quite get it flat. I'll tweak it slightly with pliers when I put new scales on it.)
-
Eeeeeew, that 91mm needs a clean when you look at it close, doesn't it?

-
So say you had an Outrider, could you add the plier's AND move the other end tools around or whatever to also add in the mag lens?
-
Well I'm far from being an expert, but I'll have a go at answering.
If you have access to the parts of the layer containing the pliers then I don't see why you couldn't add them to the Outrider. If you don't then you'd need to buy a parts donor. The cheapest would be a Hercules, so why not just carry that?
The magnifying glass is interesting as I'd thought about it as it's the one tool that I really miss from my 91mm. This is the grey plastic magnifier. I really didn't want to strip it from my 91mm, but if I did I'd be struggling to find a spot to put it in on the 111mm. The layer that the magnifier is on is a thick one at 2.7mm so I don't think that it would be happy on the bottle/can opener layer. The closest in thickness is the scissor layer; I'd need to lose the scissors and maybe the philips too as I don't know if the glass would sit with the screwdriver. It definitely wouldn't nestle with the scissors.
I don't know how happy you'd be to lose the scissors; I wouldn't as it's probably the tool that I use the most.
-
Actually it's just occurred to me that the Wenger magnifier is steel and may be slimmer. I'd like to have a go at mounting that, but not enough to buy one of the models that have them to strip it out for parts. They aren't the cheap models ::)
-
I'm in a moral dilemma now.
I remembered that my father in law had a swiss army knife; I had a look and blow me if it wasn't a Wenger with the steel magnifier.
It looks like it's 2.5mm thick so would swap in to a saw or file layer quite nicely, assuming the pivots are compatible.
Now, it's not strictly my knife; I guess that it's strictly my wife's.
My wife's away for the weekend; I could take the layer out when she's away and she'd never know. But women are funny and sentimental about these things. Life's hard when you have no moral compass. >:D
-
NO!
:DBetter to try making the Vic magnifier thinner (not sure if possible) or getting another Wenger.
-
Definitely don’t chop the Wenger, just get one off of the bay and save yourself the lonely nights on the sofa. As far as more ideas on your build, if you use a liner lock model than there are no underside tools on the blade layer and the corkscrew is on the saw layer. You can remove the blade layer and include the other tools from the other build. If you keep the newer bottle opener you may be able to lose your pribar too. The downside is they used different pivot sizes, so the old tools may have to be drilled out. But you would have scales that don’t rattle.
-
@Simyo said:
Definitely don’t chop the Wenger, just get one off of the bay and save yourself the lonely nights on the sofa. As far as more ideas on your build, if you use a liner lock model than there are no underside tools on the blade layer and the corkscrew is on the saw layer. You can remove the blade layer and include the other tools from the other build. If you keep the newer bottle opener you may be able to lose your pribar too. The downside is they used different pivot sizes, so the old tools may have to be drilled out. But you would have scales that don’t rattle.Just noticed this reply. The problem is, being in the UK, ebay refuse to sell knives because of bad publicity from a consumer affairs TV program. So getting cheap raw materials means visiting car boot sales or junk shops. But you are probably right; I'll keep my eye open for a cheap Wenger.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login



