New Charge Plus issues
-
These little quality control fails are exactly why I stopped mail ordering, and now buy in a shop where I can handle and examine.
A generous returns policy has become a business model which then tolerates poor quality control.
A generous returns warranty is great. But I'd rather see quality control first.
-
I just checked 3 or 4 of my Leatherman Tools (the ones I have nearby while sitting behind the PC) and guess what, they all have the plier scraping against the bit ...
The reason why I've never noticed this before seems to be that it's something that (mostly) happens when you pay close attention to closing the tool.
I mean, when I close the tool fast like I would during real use, I feel nothing, maybe the plier is still slightly scraping the bit, but if so, it happens very smooth and unnoticeable. But when I close the tool very slow, one handle at a time, leaving the side with the bit for last, putting the plierhead in the handle and then close up the tool real slow, I can see it scraping very hard, right up to the point that I have to apply extra force because the tip of the plierhead gets stuck on the edge of the bit.
Just checked what happens when you close the other handle last and very slow, and it scrapes the tools on the other side as well, but it's not so noticeable since the tools on the other side don't have the "edge" that the bit has, and they are all stainless, so you don't see the scraping line as good as on the black bit.
All of this on a tool that I use on a daily base, and on which I never noticed something wrong.
So I wonder; if you just close the tool like you would during real use, without paying attention to the plierhead sliding inside the handle and the scraping and all that, is it still noticeable enough to be a problem ? please, don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there isn't a problem on your Charge, but since I can't handle your tool the second best thing I could do was check some of mine, and this is what I noticed on them.
P.S.: I just checked one of my Spirits and guess what, the plierhead also scrapes while closing the handles, but ... Since the Spirit has outside opening tools the smart Vic engineers put in a slope for the plierhead to slide on until it is fully closed.
-
Maybe just enjoy the Charge for now. And, if th scraping causes mechanical issues, then send it in again. But, with that said, I think will be fine. :)
And as far as fit and finish Charge vs. Spirit goes, my Spirit handles are misaligned pretty bad, but it doesn't affect on its' usage. Little things that don't affect performance are a part of MT life. It is said that LM sends more tools out with scraping pliers these days, but all seven of my PSTs(from bqck in the day) have marks on the pliers where they scrape. I can live with that.
Enjoy it and just ignore the tiny things.

-
I have over 20 Charges, all the way to 2004 first production but not a Plus yet. Not a single one of my Charge has liner lock play problem. I am amazed that they Leatherman were able to hold such tight tolerance with pressing machines. I do not have play problem when swapping genuine blades either, only with after-markets made by TTC. Blade scrapping inside of the scales is a common problem inherent to the design itself. The liner lock has to be perfect within microns for the end tip of the blade to be perfectly centered.
I think with machines getting more advanced, cost of production being driven down, and prices being ever jacked up, quality is sacrificed. Sorry to hear about your problems, as I do love the Charge platform.
-
I just checked my Charge ALX BO and will check the other charges I have. The ALX as most, if not all, my tools favors one side to close. The plier head only very slightly, I repeat, very slightly rubs when closing. I had to close with my ear next to the tool. The saw rubs when closing and is both audible and felt. The main blade has very slight up and down movement.
My Swisstool plier rubs very slightly. All tools have very slight movement when opened in the locked position. Mind you its only noticeable when pushing the tools.
My Skeletool CXs main blade is rock solid.
I checked my Sprirt and no plier rub at all and all tools rock solid. I believe the uneven handles was addressed by Victorionx as "its part of the design". I could be wrong on that
.I'll take a look in a moment at the rest of my Charges. Mine are all going to be the oder versions Ti, AL, SLV, TTi but I'll check.
-
My new Surge has the same problem the pliers rub on
the handles and this really shows up on the BO pliers ??? -
When you guys are talking about the plier rubbing you mean against the side of the handle right?
Because my Wave + (and my Spirit) don't have that either, I was talking about the plier tip on the inside tools (see my loooong post above ;)).
-
@Wspeed said:
My new Surge has the same problem the pliers rub on
the handles and this really shows up on the BO pliers ???My stainless Surge has the same problem real bad, but since it's a user I don't really care...
My BO Surge on the other hand is not a user, but I haven't opened and closed it enough to have rub markings on the plier head (that is if he should rub in the first place).
-
Charge SLV. Plier head rub. None. Blade play. No. Serrated. None. File rub. Yes. Saw rub. Very slightly.
Charge ALX. Plier head rub. Very slightly near the pivot. Blade play. None. Serrated. very slightly. File rub. yes. Saw rub. No.
Charge Ti, Plier head rub. None. Blade play. No. Serrated. No. File rub. yes. Saw rub. No.
Charge AL. Plier head rub. Yes near pivot. Blade play. None. Serrated. None. File rub. None. Saw rub. Very Slightly.
I'll check my TTi later as its in my vehicle.
I've highlighted my ALX BO earlier.
Hope this helps.

-
Sorry OCD peeps. 
-
@Aloha007 said:
Charge SLV. Plier head rub. None. Blade play. No. Serrated. None. File rub. Yes. Saw rub. Very slightly.Charge ALX. Plier head rub. Very slightly near the pivot. Blade play. None. Serrated. very slightly. File rub. yes. Saw rub. No.
Charge Ti, Plier head rub. None. Blade play. No. Serrated. No. File rub. yes. Saw rub. No.
Charge AL. Plier head rub. Yes near pivot. Blade play. None. Serrated. None. File rub. None. Saw rub. Very Slightly.
I'll check my TTi later as its in my vehicle.
I've highlighted my ALX BO earlier.
Hope this helps.
It seems like there is still a market for older Charges. I recently bought a Charge plus, but not open the packaging yet. My newest dated Charge before the Plus is a Red Cross Charge, whose file rubs more prevalently than older models. Just wonder when the QC became lax at the factory.
A question, is it possible to put a Charge Plus head (non-CC) on an old Charge TTi?
-
For collectors the older ones will always be collectable, even with the release of the camo charges. Thats my take.
-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
When you guys are talking about the plier rubbing you mean against the side of the handle right?Because my Wave + (and my Spirit) don't have that either, I was talking about the plier tip on the inside tools (see my loooong post above ;)).
For what I've described, YES.
-
@ chrono. "A question, is it possible to put a Charge Plus head (non-CC) on an old Charge TTi?"
I dont see why the pliers wouldn't be interchangeable
. However what others have done is use Rebar plier head prior to the release of the + models. Heck, I would imagine Rebar plier head is on the + models anyway 
-
The uneven handles on many SwissTool Spirits cannot be part of thew design. I got one with noticeably misaligned handles. Then I went to another store, and none of the exact same model had any misalignment. A Victorinox rep here in Israel had said "send it in," but let me know that I may get a blister pack replacement. And the misalignment may be in the new tool. He couldn't open the blister pack. I will admit that the use of the tool is not affected. I kept it.
Victorinox multitools usually have a near-perfection in their fit and finish, and crooked handles bothered me. But I am over it now. A little bit less idealistic. I just wonder what they pay QC engineers to do if they let crooked handles out of the factory in large numbers. Let's face it, much as many of use actually use multitools, they are also tactile and visual mechanical pleasures. Or as some would say, toys (...but sophisticated toys).

Back to the Charge...
-
My 07 TTI and 08 AL are absolutely PERFECT.
Was I just lucky or was QC way better 10 years ago?
-
@Mechanickal said:
My 07 TTI and 08 AL are absolutely PERFECT.Was I just lucky or was QC way better 10 years ago?
Probably

-
@Top-Gear-24 said:
I just checked 3 or 4 of my Leatherman Tools (the ones I have nearby while sitting behind the PC) and guess what, they all have the plier scraping against the bit ...The reason why I've never noticed this before seems to be that it's something that (mostly) happens when you pay close attention to closing the tool.
I mean, when I close the tool fast like I would during real use, I feel nothing, maybe the plier is still slightly scraping the bit, but if so, it happens very smooth and unnoticeable. But when I close the tool very slow, one handle at a time, leaving the side with the bit for last, putting the plierhead in the handle and then close up the tool real slow, I can see it scraping very hard, right up to the point that I have to apply extra force because the tip of the plierhead gets stuck on the edge of the bit.
Just checked what happens when you close the other handle last and very slow, and it scrapes the tools on the other side as well, but it's not so noticeable since the tools on the other side don't have the "edge" that the bit has, and they are all stainless, so you don't see the scraping line as good as on the black bit.
All of this on a tool that I use on a daily base, and on which I never noticed something wrong.
So I wonder; if you just close the tool like you would during real use, without paying attention to the plierhead sliding inside the handle and the scraping and all that, is it still noticeable enough to be a problem ? please, don't get me wrong, I'm not saying there isn't a problem on your Charge, but since I can't handle your tool the second best thing I could do was check some of mine, and this is what I noticed on them.
P.S.: I just checked one of my Spirits and guess what, the plierhead also scrapes while closing the handles, but ... Since the Spirit has outside opening tools the smart Vic engineers put in a slope for the plierhead to slide on until it is fully closed.
Great description of exactly what mine does.
I exchanged the bit over to a fresh (unscraped) side and quickly snapped the tool closed a few times like I didn't have a care in the world. Interestingly the new scrape marks on the bit were much lighter. I closed it slowly again - the plier tip scraped and it gouged significantly harder.
So there you go, it's probably better to just close it up quickly and not overthink it too much. That way the plier tip slips quickly over the bit doing less damage. I have a bit of mechanical sympathy though so I'll close it up in such a way that it won't scrape at all.
@chrono said:
Blade scrapping inside of the scales is a common problem inherent to the design itself. The liner lock has to be perfect within microns for the end tip of the blade to be perfectly centered.Looking closely at it I see what you mean. Knowing this I think I can live with it.
Thanks for your OCD post Aloha007.
The remaining concern then is the liner lock play in the serrated blade and the saw. I feel this is too sloppy for me to ever ignore so I'll return it and ask them to check the replacement Charge before they send it to me. The place I purchased it is in NSW too while I'm in Victoria. The quest for a nice solid Charge Plus continues.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login
