Firearms...the original multi tool?
-
I don't think that topics about potentially contentious issues are guaranteed to descend into chaos if we all behave like grown ups. There's already a long running thread about firearms that seems to be relatively well-behaved over here: /topic/53984
-
There used to be a subforum on hunting or guns ? here, a few years ago, but it was stopped as it was not very busy, then and the threads were moven into other subforums.
As pointed out, there are a few related threads on guns, air rifles, pistols etc.
-
Thanks for the link (info) to the firearms thread. I thought I had searched well enough before asking the question. Obviously not. Again, THANKS for the info.
-
No worries. We're not too hung up on having only one thread for stuff, but I figured it contained the kind of thing you'd be interested in.

-
My grandfather once told me that they didn't have cars and bikes, but they were exactly the same as young men pimping their horse carts.

For him a rifle was a tool, but I have no doubt he had pride in his weapons and a general appreciation for a well made firearm.
Most of us these days might go hunting occasionally, some might carry for self defense, but the vast majority don't need that tool regularly anymore.
I like that (FALSE) story that due to everybody being armed the Wild West was a civilized place
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I like that (FALSE) story that due to everybody being armed the Wild West was a civilized placeThe 'Wild West' was not a civilized place, but the time frame, societal views and leniency towards 'offenses' were entirely different than what today's politically correct society tolerates. If you think about one trip, just one, to WalMart....how many offenses would you see that would have ended up with a youngster getting their butts whipped or someone shot for talking to another in such a rude or offensive fashion?
-
I don't see modern firearms as multitools, mostly because they really only do one thing, and that is accelerating a scrap of lead to supersonic speeds and ejecting them out one end. That is a pretty singular function, although as you pointed out, that function can have multiple applications, from offense, to defense to putting food on the table. Those don't seem like functions to me, even though they are widely varied.
I myself am an appreciator of things that go bang, and I am not against having firearms discussions here. I enjoy firearms, I enjoy shooting them and I have a few myself, which are documented in other threads here.
The problem we see (thankfully very occasionally) is the RTKBA discussions as this is a very international forum, and people forget that there's a whole planet full of people with very different cultures and opinions regarding firearms, and their use, and occasionally people forget to respect that.
Personally, if there was a CCW available in Canada I would get it, although I likely wouldn't carry a firearm as part of my EDC, partially because there's really very little reason for it in Canada, and partially because I don't want that level of responsibility at all times. I would have it so that I could decide when I wanted to have it, and when I needed it, and maybe keep one locked in the car, but not on my person.
I recall a story from a friend of mine in Michigan who has a CCW that really drives the responsibility issue home, and it wasn't even him that was the problem. He was in a mall and some kids were chasing each other about in a store. Invariably one tripped and fell, and, as people do, he reached out to try and grab something to keep him from falling. Unfortunately what he grabbed was the handle of my friend's pistol under his shirt. Now, we can argue till the cows come home over whether it was his fault for letting the kids get that close, or the parent's fault for not minding their kids etc, but regardless of who is to blame for what, that could have been a very bad situation, where "fault" is very little comfort. My friend immediately checked the securing of his weapon and made sure the kid was ok, as the kid had turned almost completely white when he realized what had happened. This friend, BTW, is a Sheriff, and not just some gun toting lunatic who just liked to carry firearms in public, and this could have happened just as easily to a uniformed officer carrying openly.
Still, that's probably the biggest reason I wouldn't choose to EDC a pistol, at least not all the time. When I felt it necessary or desirable I absolutely would though- I have been on a few jobs in my time where I am pretty sure I'd have been more comfortable with some instant backup. There was this one evening where I was going out to the outskirts of an industrial park, right along a vast wooded area to cost some people a lot of money, time and effort.... and I was the only one going.... :ahhh
In Canada there are not many situations where one would require a firearm for personal defense, although one such [urlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moncton_shooting]incident happened a few years ago in a city called Moncton[/url]. Some idiot walked up to a police cruiser parked on the street and killed two police officers as they sat there. By the time he was caught the next day he had shot three more, killing a third and wounding two others. The worst part of it was that the shooter was hiding in yards, and people were taking pictures of him and tweeting them. If any one of those people had a firearm handy when they saw him, they could have either covered him from a bedroom window until police arrived, or, if necessary, put a much needed hole in him.
But thankfully those situations are rare, and that's why I don't feel like I need to carry a pistol everywhere, I think I would just like to make my own choice. :D
Def
-
Are modern firearms sturdy enough to hammer stuff with?
-
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I like that (FALSE) story that due to everybody being armed the Wild West was a civilized place
The 'Wild West' was not a civilized place, but the time frame, societal views and leniency towards 'offenses' were entirely different than what today's politically correct society tolerates. If you think about one trip, just one, to WalMart....how many offenses would you see that would have ended up with a youngster getting their butts whipped or someone shot for talking to another in such a rude or offensive fashion?
It's not only the youngsters that deserve a butt whipping these days ... ;)
Anyway, I can say that, if it was easier to own/carry a firearm over here I would probably own only half of my current multitool collection, and instead have a couple of firearms.
But I don't consider firearms as being multitools. Just as I don't consider my car to be a multitool, even though I can use it to transport people and goods, use it as a shelter or sleeping place, use it as an attack or defense weapon, and so on ...
As always, this is just my own humble opinion ;).
-
@Don Pablo said:
Are modern firearms sturdy enough to hammer stuff with?I guess it is a matter of which ones.

I am not too keen to test this on my antique shotgun ot Bersa Thunder. :ahhh
@Gerhard Gerber said:
I like that (FALSE) story that due to everybody being armed the Wild West was a civilized place
The 'Wild West' was not a civilized place, but the time frame, societal views and leniency towards 'offenses' were entirely different than what today's politically correct society tolerates. If you think about one trip, just one, to WalMart....how many offenses would you see that would have ended up with a youngster getting their butts whipped or someone shot for talking to another in such a rude or offensive fashion?
I must agree that Wal-Mart can be likened to the Wild West, but minus the repercussions for nasty behavior. Particularly the Wal-Marts in more densely populated areas. And black-friday can be compared to a one-day gold-rush. :ahhh
Though, I bet you could have gotten a sales associate to open the Sporting Goods department showcases in the Wild-West(if they would have had Walmarts). :ahhh
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I don't see modern firearms as multitools, mostly because they really only do one thing, and that is accelerating a scrap of lead to supersonic speeds and ejecting them out one end. That is a pretty singular function, although as you pointed out, that function can have multiple applications, from offense, to defense to putting food on the table. Those don't seem like functions to me, even though they are widely varied.I myself am an appreciator of things that go bang, and I am not against having firearms discussions here. I enjoy firearms, I enjoy shooting them and I have a few myself, which are documented in other threads here.
The problem we see (thankfully very occasionally) is the RTKBA discussions as this is a very international forum, and people forget that there's a whole planet full of people with very different cultures and opinions regarding firearms, and their use, and occasionally people forget to respect that.
Personally, if there was a CCW available in Canada I would get it, although I likely wouldn't carry a firearm as part of my EDC, partially because there's really very little reason for it in Canada, and partially because I don't want that level of responsibility at all times. I would have it so that I could decide when I wanted to have it, and when I needed it, and maybe keep one locked in the car, but not on my person.
I recall a story from a friend of mine in Michigan who has a CCW that really drives the responsibility issue home, and it wasn't even him that was the problem. He was in a mall and some kids were chasing each other about in a store. Invariably one tripped and fell, and, as people do, he reached out to try and grab something to keep him from falling. Unfortunately what he grabbed was the handle of my friend's pistol under his shirt. Now, we can argue till the cows come home over whether it was his fault for letting the kids get that close, or the parent's fault for not minding their kids etc, but regardless of who is to blame for what, that could have been a very bad situation, where "fault" is very little comfort. My friend immediately checked the securing of his weapon and made sure the kid was ok, as the kid had turned almost completely white when he realized what had happened. This friend, BTW, is a Sheriff, and not just some gun toting lunatic who just liked to carry firearms in public, and this could have happened just as easily to a uniformed officer carrying openly.
Still, that's probably the biggest reason I wouldn't choose to EDC a pistol, at least not all the time. When I felt it necessary or desirable I absolutely would though- I have been on a few jobs in my time where I am pretty sure I'd have been more comfortable with some instant backup. There was this one evening where I was going out to the outskirts of an industrial park, right along a vast wooded area to cost some people a lot of money, time and effort.... and I was the only one going.... :ahhh
In Canada there are not many situations where one would require a firearm for personal defense, although one such [urlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moncton_shooting]incident happened a few years ago in a city called Moncton[/url]. Some idiot walked up to a police cruiser parked on the street and killed two police officers as they sat there. By the time he was caught the next day he had shot three more, killing a third and wounding two others. The worst part of it was that the shooter was hiding in yards, and people were taking pictures of him and tweeting them. If any one of those people had a firearm handy when they saw him, they could have either covered him from a bedroom window until police arrived, or, if necessary, put a much needed hole in him.
But thankfully those situations are rare, and that's why I don't feel like I need to carry a pistol everywhere, I think I would just like to make my own choice. :D
Def
Beautifully said, Def! :)
It does seem that firearms are more like multi-funtion devices more than multitools, since they aren't built with the intention of being used as tools. Much like cars, watches and flashlights I guess. :)
-
I am not seeing a firearm as a multi tool in the way we generally use the term
. Using a fire arm as a hammer seem irresponsible even in days past. I am not knowledgable about guns so excuse my ignorance. Were guns made to use the stock to hammer? Improvised MT
.A gun is made and designed to shoot. To my thinking thats all it really does, again

-
It’s like prying with a blade!
Only a few blades are designed for prying. -
I don't now, Homer managed to use his to turn out lights, turn off the TV and open bottles. That sounds pretty multi-functional to me.
:D
Def
-
@Don Pablo said:
It’s like prying with a blade!
Only a few blades are designed for prying.And while it can be done and is, a blade that is successfully used to pry would to my thinking not be counted as a MT.
I've used my Swisstool and Wave as a hammer
but in no way do I count hammer a feature.If attaching a bayonet to a rifle makes a rifle a MT then a grenade launcher added
. -
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I don't now, Homer managed to use his to turn out lights, turn off the TV and open bottles. That sounds pretty multi-functional to me.:D
Def
:D
-
@Don Pablo said:
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I don't now, Homer managed to use his to turn out lights, turn off the TV and open bottles. That sounds pretty multi-functional to me.
:D
Def
But could be use it to turn on the lights, tv and close bottles? :D
Yes, by pointing it (fire arm ) at whoever was in the room and asking nicely

-
I have to admit I´m guilty of a little joking and trolling about firearms here on MTo. I found it´s best not to be too provocative.
I don´t like handguns, but appreciate a good hunting rifle. Unfortunately, getting the licenses to carry one and go hunting with it would cost me more than my entire knife collection. And I would have to buy a rifle too of course. I don´t think it´s going to happen.
I agree with Def on the multitool thing. I like the story about guns as multitools, but I guess for most people today a gun is for firing bullets.
PS The ancient Romans had multitools so a firearm can´t be the original. There are pics somewhere on MTo.
-
Of course they are multi-tools. They shoot and are beautiful. That is enough functions for me.

A .357 revolver is one of the most versatile firearms that there are. It can shoot anything from bear loads to snake shot without jamming. You can load it with bunny farts or dragons breath. It can be used for hunting, survival, self defense, etc. the long double action trigger pull is extremely safe, but you can pull the hammer back for a trigger that is light enough to make shooting a breeze. I could go on for quite a while about revolvers, about guns in general actually.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login






