Firearms...the original multi tool?
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I don't see modern firearms as multitools, mostly because they really only do one thing, and that is accelerating a scrap of lead to supersonic speeds and ejecting them out one end. That is a pretty singular function, although as you pointed out, that function can have multiple applications, from offense, to defense to putting food on the table. Those don't seem like functions to me, even though they are widely varied.I myself am an appreciator of things that go bang, and I am not against having firearms discussions here. I enjoy firearms, I enjoy shooting them and I have a few myself, which are documented in other threads here.
The problem we see (thankfully very occasionally) is the RTKBA discussions as this is a very international forum, and people forget that there's a whole planet full of people with very different cultures and opinions regarding firearms, and their use, and occasionally people forget to respect that.
Personally, if there was a CCW available in Canada I would get it, although I likely wouldn't carry a firearm as part of my EDC, partially because there's really very little reason for it in Canada, and partially because I don't want that level of responsibility at all times. I would have it so that I could decide when I wanted to have it, and when I needed it, and maybe keep one locked in the car, but not on my person.
I recall a story from a friend of mine in Michigan who has a CCW that really drives the responsibility issue home, and it wasn't even him that was the problem. He was in a mall and some kids were chasing each other about in a store. Invariably one tripped and fell, and, as people do, he reached out to try and grab something to keep him from falling. Unfortunately what he grabbed was the handle of my friend's pistol under his shirt. Now, we can argue till the cows come home over whether it was his fault for letting the kids get that close, or the parent's fault for not minding their kids etc, but regardless of who is to blame for what, that could have been a very bad situation, where "fault" is very little comfort. My friend immediately checked the securing of his weapon and made sure the kid was ok, as the kid had turned almost completely white when he realized what had happened. This friend, BTW, is a Sheriff, and not just some gun toting lunatic who just liked to carry firearms in public, and this could have happened just as easily to a uniformed officer carrying openly.
Still, that's probably the biggest reason I wouldn't choose to EDC a pistol, at least not all the time. When I felt it necessary or desirable I absolutely would though- I have been on a few jobs in my time where I am pretty sure I'd have been more comfortable with some instant backup. There was this one evening where I was going out to the outskirts of an industrial park, right along a vast wooded area to cost some people a lot of money, time and effort.... and I was the only one going.... :ahhh
In Canada there are not many situations where one would require a firearm for personal defense, although one such [urlhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moncton_shooting]incident happened a few years ago in a city called Moncton[/url]. Some idiot walked up to a police cruiser parked on the street and killed two police officers as they sat there. By the time he was caught the next day he had shot three more, killing a third and wounding two others. The worst part of it was that the shooter was hiding in yards, and people were taking pictures of him and tweeting them. If any one of those people had a firearm handy when they saw him, they could have either covered him from a bedroom window until police arrived, or, if necessary, put a much needed hole in him.
But thankfully those situations are rare, and that's why I don't feel like I need to carry a pistol everywhere, I think I would just like to make my own choice. :D
Def
Any quality holster will prevent the trigger from being pulled in the situation that you described. If you are worried about the gun falling out, they make active retention holsters that need a thumb snap or button push to unholster. It is indeed a huge responsibility though and not for everyone. I choose to carry where legal, but respect the decision of those who choose otherwise.
-
Not going to comment much except to say I find myself carrying more & more as our country seems to be going headlong into a state of anarchy ..............I haz a sad..........

-
I am well aware of the various holsters and retention methods, and am trained in firearm retention. It was part of my intensive security and close quarters combat training I got when I worked for a nuclear and medical research and development company back in the late 90's. The Uncle Mike's triple retention holster was the cream of the crop back then, and I am sure that the designs have only gotten better since then. The cool thing was, we trained full contact (blue guns of course) with people that could identify the holster and knew how to draw the firearm from it, so we learned never to rely on built in retention.
Man those days were a lot of fun... and they hurt like hell, but it was worth it! That was also where I started working with dogs and a lot of other fun toys.
One incident I was involved in had me riding on the outside of a transport truck as it was heading towards the highway. The driver had threatened to run me over, and had attacked me with a tire iron long before the police could arrive. The funny thing is, one might immediately think about going straight to a firearm, but it would have been the last thing on my mind in that situation. Mind you, I am a lot older now, and not in nearly the shape I was in then, so maybe I might consider it nowadays instead of going toe to toe with a guy much larger than me, who was swinging a steel pipe over his head! :ahhh
I remember around that time spending a lot of time working with all manner of close quarters combat stuff, from knives to various batons (PR-24 side handle, Rapid Rotation baton, ASP, Winchester expandable baton) to tazers and stun guns, pepper spray... ,the list goes on. We also did firearms training, although at the time we did not carry firearms on duty, although that was in the works, and we did have long guns (specifically shotguns) available for emergency use. We also spent a lot of time reviewing tactical situations ad training films, and we often did knife on gun training, which really drove home how important it is to rely on yourself more than your firearm. A film by Calibre Press called Surviving Edged Weapons shows actual testing and situation recreations of police officers that have encountered situations where they were faced with knife weilding assailants, and let me tell you, more often than not the officer did not are well.
Transitioning that concept to civilian use was really quite fascinating, since it points out that most situations in which your firearm is going to be beneficial to you are the kinds of situations in which the threat is far enough away that you are able to avoid it entirely.
For example, the LA County Sheriff's office has established that in order to safely counter a knife with a gun, the officer requires a minimum of 21 feet of distance, and, even in that situation, the officer must be running backwards in an arc. Only then do they have the necessary time to draw, aim and fire two rounds, center of mass.
The Mythbusters tested this theory and came to a similar conclusion.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
A police officer usually will not have the option of using that 21 feet to turn and run like hell, while a civilian does, and let me tell you, that is a much better plan than trying to get into a gun battle with someone intending to cause you harm. At 21 feet you should be able to recognize the potential threat and cross the street, get in your car or just turn around and walk the other way.
This is not a comment meant to discourage CCW. Just the opposite in fact- I would encourage anyone to take proper training and get their CCW if available. While it doesn't make the news terribly often, there are tens f thousands of hours of footage from gas stations and convenience stores that show how someone with a CCW can make a big difference. I just think that people need training to know when and where is appropriate to use a firearm, and, more importantly, when not to.
Def
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
I am well aware of the various holsters and retention methods, and am trained in firearm retention. It was part of my intensive security and close quarters combat training I got when I worked for a nuclear and medical research and development company back in the late 90's. The Uncle Mike's triple retention holster was the cream of the crop back then, and I am sure that the designs have only gotten better since then. The cool thing was, we trained full contact (blue guns of course) with people that could identify the holster and knew how to draw the firearm from it, so we learned never to rely on built in retention.Man those days were a lot of fun... and they hurt like hell, but it was worth it! That was also where I started working with dogs and a lot of other fun toys.
One incident I was involved in had me riding on the outside of a transport truck as it was heading towards the highway. The driver had threatened to run me over, and had attacked me with a tire iron long before the police could arrive. The funny thing is, one might immediately think about going straight to a firearm, but it would have been the last thing on my mind in that situation. Mind you, I am a lot older now, and not in nearly the shape I was in then, so maybe I might consider it nowadays instead of going toe to toe with a guy much larger than me, who was swinging a steel pipe over his head! :ahhh
I remember around that time spending a lot of time working with all manner of close quarters combat stuff, from knives to various batons (PR-24 side handle, Rapid Rotation baton, ASP, Winchester expandable baton) to tazers and stun guns, pepper spray... ,the list goes on. We also did firearms training, although at the time we did not carry firearms on duty, although that was in the works, and we did have long guns (specifically shotguns) available for emergency use. We also spent a lot of time reviewing tactical situations ad training films, and we often did knife on gun training, which really drove home how important it is to rely on yourself more than your firearm. A film by Calibre Press called Surviving Edged Weapons shows actual testing and situation recreations of police officers that have encountered situations where they were faced with knife weilding assailants, and let me tell you, more often than not the officer did not are well.
Transitioning that concept to civilian use was really quite fascinating, since it points out that most situations in which your firearm is going to be beneficial to you are the kinds of situations in which the threat is far enough away that you are able to avoid it entirely.
For example, the LA County Sheriff's office has established that in order to safely counter a knife with a gun, the officer requires a minimum of 21 feet of distance, and, even in that situation, the officer must be running backwards in an arc. Only then do they have the necessary time to draw, aim and fire two rounds, center of mass.
The Mythbusters tested this theory and came to a similar conclusion.
- YouTube
Auf YouTube findest du die angesagtesten Videos und Tracks. Außerdem kannst du eigene Inhalte hochladen und mit Freunden oder gleich der ganzen Welt teilen.
(www.youtube.com)
A police officer usually will not have the option of using that 21 feet to turn and run like hell, while a civilian does, and let me tell you, that is a much better plan than trying to get into a gun battle with someone intending to cause you harm. At 21 feet you should be able to recognize the potential threat and cross the street, get in your car or just turn around and walk the other way.
This is not a comment meant to discourage CCW. Just the opposite in fact- I would encourage anyone to take proper training and get their CCW if available. While it doesn't make the news terribly often, there are tens f thousands of hours of footage from gas stations and convenience stores that show how someone with a CCW can make a big difference. I just think that people need training to know when and where is appropriate to use a firearm, and, more importantly, when not to.
Def
I bet you have some pretty cool stories from your training and experiences. I have certainly read all of the 21 feet studies and things like that. I still choose to carry because every situation is it’s own animal, and I am not willing to trust statistics with my life. Also, I would rather be wounded once before getting out of the situation than killed. On your comment about training, I think mental training is just as important as physical training. People that carry need to take the responsibility upon themselves not only to remain proficient in handling their firearm, but to walk themselves through what could happen mentally. Think about when would and would not constitute the use of a firearm.Think about the emotional toll after the fact. Many people are great with the mechanics and are not prepared for the mental aspect. Also, keep your gun clean. Dont let it fill itself with dust. Today’s firearms are incredibly reliable but don’t take your chances walking around with half a pound of gun and two pounds of pocket lint. Yes I like pocket carry. Many people hate it, but it does away with the 21 feet rule if you see a possible threat ahead of time. Just put your hand in your pocket. It cuts your draw time significantly.
-
@gdoolittle said:
Not going to comment much except to say I find myself carrying more & more as our country seems to be going headlong into a state of anarchy ..............I haz a sad..........

What is your carry piece?

Either a Browning hipower if expecting trouble, or a Star M43 . Both in open carry mode, not CCW. If I really expect trouble I am likely to also have a Hipoint 995 carbine in sling mode.
-
@Grant Lamontagne said:
For example, the LA County Sheriff's office has established that in order to safely counter a knife with a gun, the officer requires a minimum of 21 feet of distance, and, even in that situation, the officer must be running backwards in an arc. Only then do they have the necessary time to draw, aim and fire two rounds, center of mass.[...]This is commonly referred to as the Tueller Drill
Although I think the main point is to train drawing, reading and shooting quickly while under pressure. -
G-Dizzle, you are absolutely correct. Training, both mental and physical are absolute necessities, and absolutely you should carry one. You never know when it will come in handy. To me, it isn't about whether or not people should carry, it's about how people should have the choice available to them as to whether or not they carry.
Sadly my generation wears our pants too tightly to be able to draw anything from a pocket fast enough to be useful, even if we have half a mile instead of 21 feet! :ahhh
Def
-
Thanks to everyone for their replies. There are obviously some strong feelings here about carrying a firearm. Train Safety and Safely Train.
-
The thing that makes MT.o so great(multinational and every social class) also makes it a very opinionated place. I generally steer away from posting about firearms, but a couple of times a year I do security at my work for these big store-wide sales. I carry my Bersa Thunder 380 on those days and post it with my EDC for the day. :)
I do wish some would keep in mind that firearms discussions aren't against the rules on MT.o and it never hurts to just go on to the next thread, instead of posting something that will derail a civilized firearm conversation.
We know guns are dangerous. We know a lot of people have a lot of disdain for them. And we know there are good reasons for the two aforementioned statements. But, we may occasionally like to discuss firearms. Guns are part of life and part of the culture where I was born and raised/live. That is also true of many members here. :) -
As a Scandinavian I don't have much experience with handguns, but I have used some at a shooting range and that is a lot of fun. But I have to say that it's a good thing we don't have to feel the need to carry a gun for safety/feeling safe.
I have read somewhere that Norway is in the the top 3-5 in weapons per person, it's mostly hunting rifles and shotguns and not weapons for home protection and self protection.
And ad much as I would like to start hunting, I can't really do it because I like the animals alive in their natural habitat much more, and think it's awful that humans have exterminated 70% of all animals on earth the last 60 years.But shooting targets are so much fun!
Sent fra min FRD-L09 via Tapatalk
-
Really more of an old timey thing but here are a couple of my favorite firearm multitools. The photos are off the interwebs but I will probably never own an example of either of these. First, a French boarding axe pistol, and second, the famous Sharps carbine with coffee grinder built into the stock. They were a soldier's best friend but real ones are exceptionally rare now.


-
I stand corrected. What interesting guns.
-
Yeah, man. What in the name of off-brand-MTs is up with the coffee grinder stock. I get the idea, but I don't think it is a good idea. The boarding axe pistol I can dig.

-
@Alan K.

-
@gerleatherberman said:
The thing that makes MT.o so great(multinational and every social class) also makes it a very opinionated place. I generally steer away from posting about firearms, but a couple of times a year I do security at my work for these big store-wide sales. I carry my Bersa Thunder 380 on those days and post it with my EDC for the day. :)I do wish some would keep in mind that firearms discussions aren't against the rules on MT.o and it never hurts to just go on to the next thread, instead of posting something that will derail a civilized firearm conversation.
We know guns are dangerous. We know a lot of people have a lot of disdain for them. And we know there are good reasons for the two aforementioned statements. But, we may occasionally like to discuss firearms. Guns are part of life and part of the culture where I was born and raised/live. That is also true of many members here. :)Discussing firearms is not against the rules here, but the political discussions that often follow along are. Also, when you consider that, to some folks, firearms and RTKBA is also pretty much a religion, that is also considered taboo here.
As long as discussions remain civil though, I am glad to let even political and/or religious discussions going. Unfortunately, even here at MTO these types of discussions usually end up going south, and not in a good way, and it often ends up with people who were friends the day before absolutely hating each other, and that is not the MTO way.
It is encouraged on many other forums because this kind of conflict breeds higher post counts, which results in more $$ for the forum, and more forum related merchandise for sale as guys will try to outdo each other by trying to be the bigger superfan, but frankly I am just not interested in the c*ck swinging that goes along with it. I understand it, and I get it, and occasionally I get tempted to open a "No Hold Barred" subforum here that members have to request entry to- a place where we turn off the swear filter and let people have their say openly and honestly, but the reality is that it is not going to be left in there, and it will spill over into the rest of MTO and ruin the pleasant vibe. Because of that, I doubt it will ever happen. If folks really want to argue, other forums, Twitter and Facebook are all free to use.
I like guns. They are fun to (responsibly) play with, and the mechanical aspects of them are fascinating. I don't like them because they make me feel safe in my own home- I have really big dogs for that. I don't like them because they make me feel like a man, because I have Jeeps for that. :P
I like them because they are fun, and, when handled responsibly (like Jeeps and dogs and internet forums!) they are a joy for everyone around them. Sure they aren't for everyone, and that's ok too. It takes all kinds to make the world go round!
Def
-
Def,
Thanks and well said as usual. It is hard for me to convey how much I appreciate the fact that you try so hard to keep the peace around here. I have, in the past, been on sites that had "all things go sub-forums", and as you said, the animosity ALWAYS spills over to the rest of the site, where unsuspecting members are left wondering why people seem to be at each other's throats.
-tangent-
As far as RTKBA, it is irrelevant in any discussions about the actual firearms. And bringing it up isn't changing any minds. That horse is already dead. /tangent -
Well said Grant. For the record, I am in RTKBA shall not be infringed camp, yet i think that we just had a good conversation about guns. I think many people that believe what I do get a bad rep from just a few people that are overly confrontational 24/7.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register Login







